- 1 - !"! #" $$ %% &%' ( !"#$# % & ' (($ !"#$# % & ' (#&' $"$)$ # "$ * # * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + " ,-../01201 345/4 5-6/5 $"$)$ 7-88/5 9: /0234 2;2. <51/ -05 205,-0<4 20 03"$ 30 03# 6,28-77/-.28=2./5 42 -8-;-4-> -4/55: ./-40/5 ?3<08/. 8<9@266/5 -77/-. A-8 9: 7.-2062== 20 8<26 ?,-../01201 345/4 4/>/?6201 -77.2?-6230=346/@734-4:20><0?6230=2./59:7.-2062==208<26=34 7-4626230-058/7-4-6/7388/88230 ( 6 A-8 8<9@266/5 03"$ A-8 =2./5 =34 7-4626230 -05 8/7-4-6/ 7388/88230 3= 7.-2062==B8 $C 8,-4/ 20 " 4/825/062-. 7.368 =34@/5 20 :03#$)# @/-8<4201 # ?4/8 1<06-8 3= 24<7-7<4 ;2..-1/ 205,-0<4 -.<D &E8<26 7437/46:B =34 8,346' -.6/40-62;/ 4/.2/= 3= 7-:@/06 3= 8 " )# F"$G A26, 206/4/86 -6 C 7- 0 7.-206 26 A-8 86-6/5 6,-6 30 $)$#$ 5/=/05-06 ,-5 /H/?<6/5 3206 /;/.37@/06 14//@/06 &EB =34 8,346' =34 5/;/.37@/06 3= 8<26 7437/46: 20 =-;3<43=7.-2062== -05 207<48<-0?/ 3=8-@/ - 3 - 7.-2062== ,-5 5/;/.37/5 .-:3<6 -=6/4 396-20201 -7743;-. =43@ /;/.37@/06<6,3426:-059:20;/86201,<1/-@3<06 6 A-8 86-6/5 -=6/4 ?3@7./6230 5/=/05-06 4/=<8/5 63 /H/?<6/ 0/?/88-4: 53?<@/068 =34 12;201 <7 7.368 63A-458 7.-2062==B8 8,-4/-87/4-254/=<8-.,-5./563=2.2013=8<266A-8 86-6/5 -.301 A26, 7.-206 03# A-8 =2./5 =34 6/@734-4: 20><0?62304/864-202015/=/05-06=43@-.2/0-62017.368=34@/520 8<267437/46: 0)$#$ -=6/45/=/05-06-77/-4/5 -05 /01-1/5 ?3<08/.20 8<26 642-. 3<46 A-87./-8/5 63 14-06 -5G206/42@345/43=6/@734-4:20><0?62304/864-20201-.2/0-6230 3= 7.368 20 8<26 7437/46: /8726/ ,-;201 D03A./51/ 3= 8-25 345/4 5/=/05-06/H/?<6/582H8-./5//58/-.83=2./5742;-6/ ?3@7.-206 -1-2086 7.-2062== -05 6A3 A260/88/8 63 30 #$$ -8/5 30 8-@/ A-8 4/1286/4/5 9: 73.2?/ 30 $($ 7.-2062== -.301 A26, 8-25 A260/88/8 >3206.: =2./5 -77.2?-6230 =34 -062?27-634:9-2. ,/4/-=6/4 -==25-;26 3= 30/ 3= A260/88/8A-8396-20/5<05/4?3/4?2306A-88<9@266/5 8<26 A-8 =2./5 9: 7-:201 ,<1/ ?3<46 =// =34 7436/?62303= 7.-2062==B8 206/4/86208<267437/46:77.2?-6230A-8=2./5=347436/?62303= - 4 - 8-25 206/4/86 5<4201 7/05/0?: 3= 8<26 = 7436/?6230 A/4/ 036 14-06/5 5/=/05-06A-8.2D/.:63=4<864-6/8<269:8/..201-A-: /0624/ 8<26 7437/46: 6 A-8 8<9@266/5 -.301 A26, 8<26-77.2?-6230 ?372/83=-054/?34582052?-62017-:@/068 @-5/=34;-423<8A34D8204/.-6230638<267437/46:A/4/=2./5 1034201 8-@/ -05 9-8/5 30 2@7437/4 4/-830201 642-. 3<46 ,-57-88/52@7<10/5345/4-058-@/?-../5=34206/4=/4/0?/ 3 8<986-062-6/ ?306/06230 6,-6 2@7<10/5 345/4 8<==/4/5=43@7/4;/4826: -66/062303=6,283<46A-854-A063 398/4;-62309:642-.3<466,-6A-8=4-<1,6A26,8<872?230 -826A-88210/5@<?,9/=34/345/43=6/@734-4:-7743;-.=34 =34@-6230 3= .-:3<6 6 A-8 8<9@266/5 20 -98/0?/ 3= -0: 4/I<24/@/06 20 .-A @-05-6201 8210201 3= 30.: -=6/4 -7743;-.3=.-:3<67.-0 8-25398/4;-6230A3<.59/7/4;/48/ F <46,/4 398/4;-62306,-65/=/05-06,-55/;/.37/5 .-:3<6742346314-063=-7743;-.3=.-:3<67.-0@/4/.:309-828 3= 7,36314-7,8 7435<?/5 9: 5/=/05-06 9<6 ?-86201 53<96 20 ?-8/ 3= 7.-2062== 6,-6 ,/ ,-;/ ?3@@/0?/5 5/;/.37@/06 30.: -=6/4 -7743;-. 3= .-:3<6 7.-0 A3<.5 9/ ?3064-52?634: -05 -8 8<?,7/4;/48/ - 5 - ) 6 A-8 =<46,/4 8<9@266/5 7.-2062== ,-5 -88/46/5 -93<67-:@/063=<7//8/0-D,8634205-;-01431/0?: 205,-0<4 A-8 -@30186 7-:@/068 @-5/ 20 7<48<-0?/ 3= -8 5/=/05-06B8 830G20G.-A A-8 30/ 3= 26B8 7-460/48 A-8 036 7437/4.: -774/?2-6/5 0 =-?6 642-. 3<46 -77/-48 63 ,-;/ 743?//5/5 30 A4301 74/@28/ 6,-6 8<?, 7-:@/06 A-8 9: 4205-;-0 143 1/0?: 63 7.-2062== ,<8 6,/4/ A-8 7/4;/48/ -774/?2-62303==-?68 " 6 A-8 =<46,/4 8<9@266/5 398/4;-62308=2052018 9: 642-.3<46A/4/;246<-..:?30?.<82;/-05642-.3<46-77/-4/563 ,-;/ ,/.5 @202 642-. 0 -93;/ 143<058 2@7<10/5 345/4 A-44-06/5206/4=/4/0?/-0583<1,6=34-..3A201-77/-. 0 36,/4 ,-05 42 -:D<@-4 -62. ./-40/5 /0234 3<08/. -77/-4201 =34 42 -,-06/8, -62. ./-40/5 ?3<08/.=345/=/05-06 37738/5-77/-. #$ 6A-88<9@266/5 -77/-.A-8-1-2086528?4/6230-4: 345/47-88/59:642-.3<4630-0-77.2?-6230=2./5<05/4 45/4 JJJJ<./#3=6A-88<9@266/5 30B9./<74/@/3<46 20 - 6 - 4/7346/5 20 ,-5 ,/.5 8?37/ =34 206/4=/4/0?/208<?,345/48A3<.59//H64/@/.:.2@26/5-0563 ?-8/8A,/4/345/42@7<10/58<==/4/5=43@7/4;/4826: ## 6 A-8 8<9@266/5 A,2./ 7-88201 2@7<10/5 345/4 642-. 3<46 ,-5 6-D/0 036/ 3= 42;-. 7./-52018 -05 ?306/062308 =4-@/5 7437/4 732068 =34 ?30825/4-6230 -05 7-88/5 2@7<10/5 345/4-=6/4-882102015/6-2./54/-8308=34=205201830/-?,73206 =4-@/5 # 083=-4-8642-.3<46/06/46-2020153<96-93<6 26A-88<9@266/5 642-.3<46,-56-D/0036/3=0362?/288</59: 7.-2062==635/=/05-067423463=2.2013=8<26-0563A,2?,204/7.: 0362?/ 288</5 9: 5/=/05-06 ?37: 3= A-8 83<1,6 63 9/ =<4028,/5 0 7/4<8-. 3= 6-11/5 7,36314-7,8 8,3A201 7.-2062== =34@201 .-:3<6 @<?, 74234 63 -7743;-. 3= .-:3<6 642-. 3<46 ,-5 /06/46-20/5 53<96 -93<6 42-. 3<46 ,-5 6,/4/-=6/46/86/5/-?,3=7-:@/068?.-2@/563,-;/9//0@-5/ 9: 7.-2062== 20 7<48<-0?/ 3= -05 =3<05 6,/@ 63 9/ <08<986-062-6/534.20D/563-058<267437/46:0.21,63= -93;/ 642-.3<46,-5A/21,/5?24?<@86-0?/8A,/4/207.-2062== 30 30/ ,-05 ,-5 @-5/ -88/462308 -93<6 ,<1/ /H7/0526<4/ - 7 - 20?<44/5207<48<-0?/3=9<6<08<986-062-6/53030/,-05 A,2./ 5/=/05-06 ,-5 7435<?/5 6-11/5 -05 62@/ 86-@7/5 7,36314-7,8 20 8<77346 3= ,28 ?.-2@ 63 ,-;/ 5/;/.37/5 .-:3<6 ,2@8/.= #( ,<8 2@7<10/5 345/4 A-8 9-8/5 30 5</ ?30825/4-6230 3= /0624/ @-6/42-. 30 4/?345 308/I</06.: ?306/06230-93<62@7<10/5345/48<==/4201=43@7/4;/4826:A-8 036/86-9.28,/5-05-88<?, -77/-.A-8.2-9./=34528@288-. # /-45./-40/5?3<08/./02343<08/.-057/4<8/5 2@7<10/5345/4 # 43@-93;/ 732066,-6A3<.54/I<24/?30825/4-6230 28 ! #F 8036/5-93;/ 7.-2062==288//D201638<986-062-6/ ,28?306/06230-93<62@7<10/5345/48<==/4201=43@7/4;/4826: 30 =3<4 528620?6 143<058 2486.: ?-86201 53<96 -93<6 30 143<05 6,-6 26 A-8 74234 63 7-88201 3= 345/4 3= -7743;-. 3= - 8 - .-:3<605//5 642-.3<46,-80364/=/44/563-0:743;282303= .-A @-05-6201 63 9/ /06/4/5 2063 30.: -=6/4 396-20201 -7743;-.3=.-:3<67.-0<6 7/4<8-.3=/0624/2@7<10/5345/4 A3<.5 2052?-6/ 6,-6 8<?, 398/4;-6230 A-8 20 ?306/H6 6,-6 5/;/.37@/06 A34D 30 =2/.5 ?3<.5 9/120 30.: -=6/4 396-20201 -7743;-. 3= .-:3<6 -05 ?.-2@ 9: 7.-2062== 63 ,-;/ <05/46-D/0 5/;/.37@/06A34D207<48<-0?/3=A3<.5-77/-453<96=<. #) 6280/H6.:?306/05/56,-6642-.3<46525036-5376 8-@/ :-45862?D A,2./ -??/76201 5/=/05-06B8 -88/46230 6,-6 8,/ ,-5 =34@/5 .-:3<6 74234 63 -7743;-. 3= .-:3<6 7.-0 3A/;/4 398/4;-6230 9: 642-. 3<46 -93<6 5/=/05-06 -77/-4201 63 ,-;/ <05/46-D/05/;/.37@/06A34D3=.-:3<6/;/07423463-7743;-. 3=.-:3<67.-0289-8/5307,36314-7,87435<?/59:5/=/05-06 -25 7,36314-7,8 -7-46 =43@ 9/201 6-11/5 -4/ -.83 62@/ 86-@7/5 -8/5 30 8-25 @-6/42-. 642-. 3<46 -442;/5 -6 8<?, ?30?.<8230 30B9./ <74/@/ 3<46 20 ?-8/ 3= &8<74-' 4/=/44201 63 268 /-4.2/4 5/?2823020 ! "! 4/7346/5 20 #$% & ,-8 ,/.5 26 A3<.5 036 9/ -7743742-6/=34642-.3<4663,3.5@202642-.-686-1/3=14-063= - 9 - 6/@734-4:20><0?6230,/4/=34/ 26A3<.50369/-7743742-6/63 /H7/?6642-.3<466312;/=2052018-93<6./1-.26:3=5/;/.37@/06 A34D <05/46-D/0 9: 5/=/05-06 30 143<05 6,-6 26 A-8 74234 63 -7743;-.3=.-:3<67.-0 -686-1/3=?30825/4-62303=-77.2?-6230 =346/@734-4:20><0?6230 #" ;/0?306/06230-93<6398/4;-62309:642-.3<4620 7-4- $ 3= 2@7<10/5 345/4 6,-6 <7//8 /0 -D,8 A-8 64-08=/44/5200-@/3=5/=/05-06=43@4205-;-01431/0?: 9/201?3064-4:634/?345 A3<.5036,3.50=-?6 20;/4:8-@/ 7-4-14-7, 642-.3<46036/57.-2062==B8?.-2@6,-68<?,7-:@/06 A-8 @-5/ 9: 7.-2062== 63 4205-;-0 143 1/0?: ,28 A3<.5 2052?-6/6,-6-774/?2-62309:642-.3<46A-8207437/4?306/H6 -05036?3064-4:63@-6/42-.304/?345 # 628-.838//0 A,2./7-882012@7<10/5345/4 642-. 3<46,-8-5;/46/563/-?,2086-0?/3=7.-2062==?.-2@20163,-;/ 87/06@30/:=345/;/.37@/063=.-:3<6-0530/H-@20-6230 26 ?30?.<5/5 8-@/ 63 9/ <0-??/76-9./ 9: -88210201 87/?2=2? 4/-830805//5 743,2926230-1-2086,3.5201@202G642-.-686-1/ 3= ?30825/4-6230 3= -77.2?-6230 =34 6/@734-4: 20><0?6230 A3<.5 - 10 - -.83 -77.: 63 =2052018398/4;-62308 A,2?, -4/ ?30?.<82;/ 20 0-6<4/ $ 0.21,63=-93;/ 26A3<.58<==2?/63?.-42=:6,-6-.. 398/4;-62308 A3<.5 9/ 7<4/.: -05 ?30=20/5 63 206/42@86-1/-05-662@/3=7-88201=20-.><51@/06 642-.3<46 A3<.59/1<25/59:/;25/0?/./55<4201642-. # ,3<1, ./-40/5 ?3<08/. =34 7.-2062== @-5/ =/4;/06 8<9@2882308=347436/?6201206/4/863=7.-2062==20?-8/ 7.-2062== A/4/ 63 8<??//5 20 8<26 30 143<05 6,-6 20 ?-8/ 3= 5/02-. 3= 20><0?6230 /87/?2-..:-8,/?.-2@863,-;/87/06,<1/8<@83= @30/: A,2./ 7-88201 2@7<10/5 345/4 642-. 3<46 ,-8 6/86/5 9-8286,/4/3=-05-674/8/0686-1/5289/.2/;/57.-2062== ,<8 642-. 3<46 ,-8 7-88/5 2@7<10/5 345/4 9: =4-@201 7437/4 732068 =34 ?30825/4-6230 -05 9: -88210201 5/6-2./54/-83080;2/A3=.-A.-2553A09:30B9./<74/@/ 3<46 20 ' ' ()()) * (4/7346/520#$%+$ ?306/062308<41/5A3<.5 036 8<==2?/ =34 A200201 206/4=/4/0?/ -1-2086 2@7<10/5 345/4 - 11 - 36,/46,-063288</524/?62308=34/H7/526/642-.-8-@/-8<4/3= @2621-6201,-458,27?-<8/5637.-2062== ( 3206 =34 ?30825/4-6230 28 -08A/4/5 20 308/I</06.: =3..3A201 2' 77/-. , 9<6 9: ,3.5201 6,-6 398/4;-62308@-5/9:642-.3<4620?3<48/3=268 345/4 A3<.5 9/ 64/-6/5 -8 -05 ?30=20/5 63 206/42@ 86-1/ -05 A,2?, A3<.5 036 920526-662@/3==20-.528738-. 22' 3A/;/4 20 =-?68 -05 ?24?<@86-0?/8 3= ?-8/ 524/?6230 28 288</5 63 642-. 3<46 63 /H7/526/ 528738-.3=8<269:=2H20187/?2=2?62@/.20/=34/-?, 86-1/ 3= 8<26 -05 9: 524/?6201 936, 7-462/8 63 ?337/4-6/ =34 /-4.: 528738-. A26,3<6 8//D201 <00/?/88-4:-5>3<40@/068 *+ &$$ ' " 2863#.3$