Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43333 (KAR)

MAHADEV v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/203295/2023 · 2025-09-23

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $" % %!"" &' !" #$ %$ & " $ !" ' !" !" !" #$ % ( & Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( $ '') ( $ $ *+ $ ,-./-$.0-1234567183,097:70-0-357,.5;,-.19., .3 .135< =-09 ,-.11->.,?45 .94>., 83, 097 ,76:35;75069./7.::7.,7;-5:7,635 ' 97 2.:0-357; (,-0 $70-0-35 -6 8-17; 677>-5< 097 83113=-5<,71-786 .& 3 -6647 . =,-0 38 7,0-3,.,- 3, . ;-,720-35 03 @4.69 097 3,;7, ;.07; "A"''!'' -5 -17 3 "' '!''' 'A) " :.667; BC 097 67235; ,76:35;750 .4093,-0C .6 -117<.1 .5; .,B-0,.,C/-;7557D4,7 B& 3 -6647 . =,-0 38 .5;.E46 ;-,720-5< ,76:35;7506 " 03 03 ,7603,7 097 5.E7 38 097 :70-0-357, -5 ,76:720 38 1.5; -5 C 3'! - 3 - E7.64,-5< ! 2,76 6-04.07; .0 .E.5>7,- -11.<7.14>..5;-60,-20-;., 97:70-0-35./7,E7506.,7.645;7, 0-66.-;09.0097:70-0-357,+68.097,,?45 3.EB.55. =.6 -6647; =-09 . 7,0-8-2.07 38 ,.50 38 .<4/.1- 9-0 45;7, 417 'F 38 .,5.0.>. .5; ,.50 4176 -5 ,76:720 38 1.5; -5 C3'! 'E7.64,-5<!2,766-04.07;.0.E.5>7,--11.<7 .14> .5; -60,-20 -;., /-;7 3,;7, ;.07; !A!A"F)F 0 -6 60.07;09.009709757:40C3EE-66-357,-5-173 "!!" ;.07; 'F!)"F! 2.527117; 097 7,0-8-2.07 38 ,.50 -6647; -5 8./3, 38 097 :70-0-357,+6 8.097, 97 6.E7 =.6 @4760-357; B783,7 09-6 34,0 -5 ($3"A) "F! .5; 097 =,-0 :70-0-35 =.6 .113=7; 097 3,;7, 38 097 7:40C 3EE-66-357,=.6670.6-;7.5;097E.007,=.6,7E.5;7;83, ,72356-;7,.0-35 03 097 .96-1;., -;., /-;7 3,;7, ;.07; ""!"FF97,7.807,097:,3277;-5<6=7,7235;4207;BC097 .96-1;.,.807,931;-5<.6:30-56:720-35.5;:,3277;7;03:.66 .5 3,;7, 35 "A"'"FF 03 ,7<,.50 097 1.5; E7.64,-5< ! 2,76-5C3'! '6-04.07;.0.E.5>7,--11.<7$4,64.5003 0973,;7,38097.96-1;.,0975.E738097:70-0-357,=.6;41C - 4 - ,77507,7;-50977/7547723,;6-5314E56F.5;"'B.67; 35 6422766-35 .6 9-6 8.097, 9.; ;-7; 35 "!"FF" .5; 097,783,7 7887207; E40.0-35 -5 3,E 3"' .5; 097 5.E7 38 097:70-0-357,=.6,7817207;-5097,7/7547,723,;60-11'!"F'! 609-5<66033;0946097:70-0-357,,727-/7;.530-278,3E 097 388-27 38 097 66-60.50 3EE-66-357, B.67; 35 097 17007, -6647; BC 097 834,09 ,76:35;750 ;.07; "!A'!'' 21.-E-5< 09.0 097 3/7,5E750 38 .,5.0.>. /-;7 30-8-2.0-35 ;.07; ')!A"FF" ;721.,7; 097 64B?720 1.5; .6 3,760 .5; 45;7, 720-35 38 097 3,760 20 "FA 7527 097 66-60.50 3EE-66-357,634<9003-5@4-,7.B340097<,.503,;7,E.;7-5 8./3,38097:70-0-357,+68.097,.135<=-093097,<,.5077697 66-60.503EE-66-357,/-;73,;7,;.07;"A"''!''670.6-;7 097 3,;7, 38 ,7<,.50 <<,-7/7; BC 097 6.E7 097 :70-0-357, 8-17; . ,7/-6-35 B783,7 097 7:40C 3EE-66-357, 97 7:40C 3EE-66-357, /-;7 3,;7, ;.07; ''!A'!' ,7?7207; 097 7/-6-35 $70-0-35 4760-35-5< 097 3,;7, 38 097 66-60.50 3EE-66-357,097:70-0-357,-6B783,709-634,0 345671 83, 097 ,76:720-/7 :.,0-76 4,<7; 67/7,.1 2350750-356 - 5 - ,<-5< 67/7,.1 2350750-356 2345671 83, 097 :70-0-357, :1.27;,71-.52735097;72-6-35-5$ -5 (3'!!!'F '!'" ;-6:367; 3835" !"'!'' 97 60.07E750 38 3B?720-356 -6 8-17; BC097 3/7,5E750 ,<-5<67/7,.12350750-3560973/7,5E750:1.27;,71-.52735 09783113=-5<;72-6-356 "& ( G $$ )!F)"! "FFA '& $ G ($%& ")" "FFA $ "'"'"FFA & $ G'!') 7.,; 097 .,<4E7506 .5; :7,467; 097 (,-0 :.:7,6 =-09 2.,7 97 8.206 .,7 6488-2-7501C 6.-; .5; ;3 530 ,7@4-,7 ,7-07,.0-3597-6647,7/31/76.,345;0977D7,2-6738097:3=7, - 6 - BC09766-60.503EE-66-357,-56700-5<.6-;70973,;7,38,7 <,.50 488-27 -0 03 5307 09.0 097 2.52711.0-35 38 .<4/.1- 9-0 =.6670.6-;7BC09-634,00-6:-/30.103530709.0.807,097 ;-6:36.1 38 097 (,-0 $70-0-35 . 6:30 -56:720-35 =.6 235;4207; .5;.53,;7,38,7<,.50=.6E.;735""'"FF0,.5<71C .807,.1.:6738.1E3600=750C834,C7.,6.530-27=.6-6647; .5; :,3277;-5<6 =7,7 -5-0-.07; 783,7 097 66-60.50 3EE-66-357,097.9.6-1;.,:1.27;,71-.52735.30-8-2.0-35 ;.07;')!A"FF"03235075;09.009764B?7201.5;-6.530-8-7; 83,760 1.5; 0 -6 .,<47; 35 B79.18 38 097 3/7,5E750 09.0 . 530-8-2.0-35 45;7, 6720-35 38 097 3,760 20 =.6 -6647; 35 ')!A"FF" <,7.0;7.138.,<4E750-6.;;,7667;.B340720-35 38 0973,7602097>7C.6:720638097.,<4E750.,77D.E-57; 664E-5<097,7-6.530-8-2.0-35097,7-65309-5<35,723,;03 693=09.0097,7-623E:1-.527=-09720-35"38097.,5.0.>. 3,760 20 76:-07 097 530-8-2.0-35 53 .20-35 =.6 0.>75 .5; 097:70-0-357,2350-5476039./7097:,3:7,0C-5@4760-35.6-6 ,7817207;-5097 752709766-60.503EE-66-357,2341; - 7 - 530 9./7 :1.27;,71-.527 35 097 530-8-2.0-35 .5; 670 .6-;7 097 ,7<,.50 3,;7, .807, . 1.:67 38 0=750C834, C7.,6 97 1.= -6 =711 670017; 09.0 097 :3=7, E460 B7 7D7,2-67; =-09-5 . ,7.635.B17 0-E7 5 097 :,76750 2.67 097,7 -6 .5 -53,;-5.07 ;71.C 5 EC /-7= 097 :,3277;-5<6 .,7 217.,1C B.,,7; BC 1.2976E.C/7504,7036.C09.00977/7547.4093,-0-769./7 8.-17;039./7,7<.,;03097,717/.502356-;7,.0-356 34567183,097,76:720-/7:.,0-76:1.27;,71-.52735097 ;72-6-356 ,787,,7; 03 64:,. ;3 530 09-5> 09.0 097 1.= -6 -5 ;34B0.29;72-6-3504,5635-063=58.20697:,767502.67-6 .16307607;-50971-<9038097.83,76.-;;72-6-356 3,097,7.635660.07;.B3/70973,;7,3809766-60.50 3EE-66-357, -6 1-.B17 03 B7 670 .6-;7 223,;-5<1C -0 -6 670 .6-;7 A 97 (,-0 38 7,0-3,.,- -6 3,;7,7; 97 ,;7, ;.07; "A"''!'' :.667; BC 097 66-60.50 3EE-66-357, -5 -17 3 "' '!''' 'A) " /-;7 557D4,7 -6 @4.697; 3567@47501C 097 3,;7, :.667; BC 097 7:40C 3EE-66-357,-6.163670.6-;7 - 8 - ) 76410.501C097(,-0$70-0-35-6 72.467 38 097 ;-6:36.1 38 097 (,-0 $70-0-35 :75;-5< -507,132403,C .::1-2.0-356 -8 .5C .,7 ;-6:367; 38 .5; 097 -507,-E;-,720-35-8.5C60.5;6;-629.,<7; () &%!""' % -603"13')"