- 1 - !"# $#%&#& &#" ' ! " # #$ # # " $ % # &'('& ) ) !# "#* # # # #$ + + # # "$ + + # # # ## &&& # # *# + ( && , # + ## ++### ## - * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ./0 123/0/45 627/7/45 /0 8/92: ;< 7.2 627/7/4521' .=0;>5: 61></5? 74 027 >0/:2 7.2 41:21 :>72: &&& 6>002:/51/@/5>9/0A299>524=04( &&;<7.21/5A/6>9 *=:?2+>@/9<4=17>/A.=1"8410.417B7.2+>@/9<4=17C$ & 2>1: 7.2 92>152: A4=5029 841 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521>5:7.292>152:A4=50298417.2120645:257 .2120645:257'D/828/92:>627/7/45=5:212A7/45 &481022E/5?@457.9<@>/5725>5A2480& ' .2123/0/45627/7/4521.212/5D.4D>0120645:257;284127.2 +>@/9<4=177.4=?..>0>662>12:7.14=?../0A4=5029:/: 547 A.4402 74 8/92 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 .2 120645:257 7.212/5 2325 :/: 547 A.4402 74 A1400'2G>@/52 >5: 92>:./023/:25A2.2+>@/9<4=17A450/:21/5?7.223/:25A2 48 >5: 7.2:4A=@2570 614:=A2: >5: 7.2 H=>9/8/A>7/45 48 7.2 120645:257 7.212/5 >0 > 487D>12 5?/5221 .>0 >D>1:2: @>/5725>5A2 48 0 ' 2325 7.4=?. 7.2 @>/5725>5A204=?.7;<7.2D/82D>00& '621@457. - 3 - ??1/232:;<7.20>/:41:21487.2+>@/9<4=177.2123/0/45 627/7/4521 .=0;>5:/0;284127./04=17 2>152:A4=50298417.2123/0/45627/7/4521D4=9: A45725: 7.>7 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 .>0 547 ;225 ?/325 0=88/A/257 466417=5/7< 74 8/92 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 74 A1400'2G>@/52 >5: 74 92>: ./0 23/:25A2 2 8=17.21 A45725:2: 7.>7 2325 7.4=?. 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 /0 > 487D>12 5?/5221 >8721 #' 6>5:2@/A .2 /0 547 .>3/5? F4; >5: .2 /0 1=55/5? > <@ /5 >5>6>17.< 4D5 29>5?>5> 7>72 >5: 547 ?277/5? @=A. /5A4@2 2 8=17.21 0=;@/70 7.>7 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 .>0 74 ;2 ?/325 >5 466417=5/7< 74 8/92 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 >5: A457207 7.2 0>/:627/7/45;<12@>5:/5?7.2@>7721747.2+>@/9<4=17 2>152: A4=5029 841 7.2 120645:257'D/82 D4=9: A45725: 7.>7 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 D.4 >662>12: ;28412 7.2 +>@/9< 4=17 7.14=?. ./0 A4=5029 /5 06/72 48 ?1>57/5? 0=88/A/257 466417=5/7< .2 .>0 547 8/92: 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 >5: .2 .>0 >904 547 A1400'2G>@/52: >5: 547 92>: ./0 23/:25A2 450/:21/5? 7.2 0>@2 7.2 +>@/9< - 4 - 4=17.>01/?.79<>D>1:2:@>/5725>5A2/7.7./0.261><2: 841:/0@/00>9487.2123/0/45627/7/45 ( >3/5?.2>1:7.292>152:A4=502907./04=17.>0 621=02:7.2/@6=?52:41:21>5:7.271/>94=1712A41:0 % .2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 .212/5 D.4 D>0 120645:257 ;28412 7.2 +>@/9< 4=17 .>0 >662>12: 7.14=?. ./0A4=502945&&;284127.2+>@/9<4=1757.>7 :>< 7.2 @>7721 D>0 1282112: 74 A45A/9/>7/45 >5: 7.212>8721 7.2 @>7721 D>0 64072: 45 && &%&& %&& && && >5: && 5 &&4;F2A7/450747.2@>/5627/7/45.>0;2257>E25 >0 547 8/92: >5: 7.2 @>7721 A>@2 74 ;2 >:F4=152: 74 &&& 841 12A41:/5? 7.2 627/7/4521C0 0/:2 23/:25A2 5 &&& 7.2 627/7/4521C0 0/:2 23/:25A2 D>0 92: >5: 7.2 @>7721 .>0 547 ;225 64072: 841 A1400'2G>@/5>7/45 459< 45 7.2?14=5:7.>74;F2A7/450747.2@>/5627/7/45.>0547;225 8/92: .212>8721 7.2 @>7721 .>0 ;225 >:F4=152: 74 (&&& 841 120645:257C0 23/:25A2 >5: 45 7.>7 :>< 7.2 120645:257C023/:25A2.>0;2257>E25>0B/9C>5:7.2+>@/9< - 5 - 4=17.2>1:7.2>1?=@2570457.20>@2:><>5:64072:7.2 @>772184141:210 ) 450/:21/5? 7.2 >;432 >062A70 2325 7.4=?. 0=88/A/257 466417=5/7< D>0 ?/325 74 7.2 120645:257'.=0;>5: 841 8/9/5? 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 ;=7 0=88/A/257 466417=5/7< D>0 547 ?/325 841 ./@ 74 A1400'2G>@/52 >5: 74 92>: 120645:257C00/:223/:25A21400'2G>@/5>7/4548627/7/4521' D/7520020 .>0 74 ;2 6143/:2: 2325 7.4=?. 7.212 /0 54 07>72@257484;F2A7/4508/92:57.2:>7245D./A.7.2A>02 D>064072:841120645:257C023/:25A27.2+>@/9<4=17.>0 7>E25 7.2 120645:257C0 23/:25A2 >0 B/9C 325 7.4=?. 7.2 @>/5725>5A2 A9>/@2: ;< 7.2 D/82 D>0 0& ' 621 @457.7.2+>@/9<4=17.>0>D>1:2:0 '621@457. >945?D/7.A4070487.29/7/?>7/45480 'GA2677.2 07>72@25748>00270>5:9/>;/9/7/205447.21:4A=@2570.>32 ;225614:=A2:;<7.2120645:257'D/82740.4D7.2/5A4@248 7.2.=0;>5: 5:21 7.2 >;432 A/1A=@07>5A20 7.2 @>7721 12H=/120 74 ;2 12@>5:2: 841 >8841:/5? 466417=5/7< 74 7.2 - 6 - 123/0/45627/7/4521.=0;>5:748/9207>72@257484;F2A7/450 74 A1400'2G>@/52 7.2 627/7/4521 >5: .21 D/7520020 >5: 74 92>: 23/:25A2 450/:21/5? 7.2 8>A7 7.>7 7.2 @>/5725>5A2 >D>1:2: ;< 7.2 +>@/9< 4=17 /0 0 ' 621 @457. >0 7.2@>7721/012@>5:2:>0=@480& '621@457./0 41:212:74;26>/:>0/5721/@@>/5725>5A2814@7.2:>7248 627/7/458/92:;284127.2+>@/9<4=177/99/70:/0640>9 53/2D487.2>;4327.284994D/5? "/$ .2123/0/45627/7/45/0>994D2:/5'6>17I "//$ .2 /@6=?52: 41:21 :>72: &&& 6>002:/51/@/5>9/0A299>524=04( &&/0027 >0/:2I "///$ .2@>7721/012@>5:2:747.21/5A/6>9 *=:?2 +>@/9< 4=17 >/A.=1 D/7. > :/12A7/45 74 >8841: >5 466417=5/7< 74 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521' .=0;>5: 74 8/92 07>72@257 48 4;F2A7/450 74 A1400' 2G>@/52 >5: .21 D/7520020 /8 >5< >5:92>: 120645:257C0 0/:2 23/:25A2 D/7. 7.2 84994D/5? A45:/7/450 - 7 - ">$ .2 123/0/45 627/7/4521' .=0;>5:0.>996></5721/@@>/5725>5A248 0& ' 621 @457. 814@ 7.2 :>72 48 627/7/45 "1/@/5>9 /0A299>524=0 4( &&$7/99:/0640>9487.2627/7/45I ";$ .2 123/0/45 627/7/4521' .=0;>5: 0.>99 :2640/7 /5721/@ @>/5725>5A2 >7 7.2 1>72 48 0& ' 621 @457. 814@ 7.2 :>72 48 627/7/45 /2 &&& 7/99 7./0 :>< >5: :2640/7 7.2 0>/: >@4=57 45 41 ;28412 && ;284127.2+>@/9<4=17I "A$ 47. 6>17/20 >12 :/12A72: 74 >662>1 ;28412 7.2 +>@/9< 4=17 45 &&I ":$ ./0 41:21 0.>99 07>5: 1234E2: /8 7.2 123/0/45 627/7/4521 8>/90 74 :2640/7 7.2 0>/: /5721/@ @>/5725>5A2 >0 621 A45:/7/454";$487.2>;43241:21;28412 && >5: .2 /0 9/>;92 74 6>< @>/5725>5A2>D>1:2:;<7.2+>@/9<4=17 3/:241:21:>72:&&&I "2$ .2123/0/45627/7/45210.>998/92 ./007>72@257484;F2A7/45045&& - 8 - >5: A1400'2G>@/52 D/7./5 > D22E 814@7.20>/::>72I "8$ 20645:257'D/82 /0 621@/772: 7492>:.218=17.2123/:25A2/8>5<D/7./5 >D22E7.212>8721I "?$ .2 123/0/45 627/7/4521' .=0;>5: 0.>99 92>: ./0 23/:25A2 D/7./5 7.122 D22E0 814@ && /5A9=:/5? 2G>@/5>7/4548>5<47.21D/752002045./0 ;2.>98I "/3$ .2+>@/9<4=170.>99547;2/589=25A2: ;< 7./0 41:21 48 /5721/@ @>/5725>5A2 /5 > 0=@ 48 0& ' D./92 6>00/5? 41:21 45 7.2 @>/5 627/7/45 () *&#&+ % /07494(