- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) ! " # $%&%'& "$' ( )&)"* % + )&)"*% #%, ""*"%*% "! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ##"'"!# ! # ! # *%$""$%*%" ')%*"- # # # "%"***$ #. !# # # / / 0 $ 1234561237891:5;<=>123:14?<8:;1>=<3@<56561 A235B1; % 6B; 2AA12> B; A31=13314 272B:;5 561 C84791:5 2:42D23442514*%""%*%"B: <')%*"-A2;;14 @E561 3B:?BA2>1:B<3 BFB> 8471 2>2@8327B 61=2?5;<=561?2;12315625<:%"*%%*"-25 2@<85G**295612AA1>>2:52;2A141;53B2:A3<?114B:7 <: 561 3<24 25 5625 5B91 561 3B413 <= 561 9<5<3 ?E?>1 @123B:7 317B;5325B<: <$%$&%'& 3<41 B5 B: 2 6B76 ;A11432;62:4:17>B71:592::132:442;614272B:;5561 - 3 - 2AA1>>2:5815<D6B?661;8;52B:1473B1F<8;B:C83B1;5< 6B; ;6<8>413 239 2:4 6124 1 D2; ;6B=514 5< <F5 <;AB52> 1429 2:4 561312=513 5< 2923144E <;AB52> 2>2@8327B=<35312591:5 :C8314?>2B92:5 915 DB56 2: 2??B41:5 42514 2:4=B>142 ?>2B9A15B5B<:?>2B9B:7?<9A1:;25B<:<= ;"'*****$ 61 3B@8:2> ?<:;B413B:7 1:5B31 92513B2> <:31?<34732:514;G-***$DB56B:5131;525GHA13 2::89=3<95614251<=A15B5B<:5B>>5614251<=312>BI25B<: ) 773B1F14 @E 561 ;2B4 <3413 56B; 2AA12> B; A31=13314 B: D6B?6 B5 B; 92B:>E ?<:51:414 5625 2; A13 <8:4 135B=B?251 2:4 B;?62371 234 B1 J ) 2:4 J ' 61 ;8;52B:14 B:C83B1; 2:4 D2; 249B5514 2; 2: B:A25B1:5=<3 2 A13B<4 <= 51: 42E; J &K 561 4B;2@B>B5E ?135B=B?251 B;;814 @E % 2:4 61 2;;1;;14 561 4B;2@B>B5E '*GGH 5< 561 D6<>1 @<4E 85 561 3B@8:2> ?<:;B41314 561;29125")H1D2;D<3LB:72;2:273B?8>583B;52:4 123:B:7 ;%****$ A13 9<:56 @85 561 3B@8:2> 13314 B: 52LB:7561;29125"%)*$A139<:561271329<8:5; - 4 - 231 732:514 8:413 561 6124; $ <;; <= 91:B5B1; J532 <83B;691:5 2:4 <;; <= :?<91 83B:7 2B4 A 13B<4 2:4 2>;< B15 2:4 551:42:5 62371; 2:4 2B: 2:4 8==13B:715?6131=<3131M81;514=<31:62:?191:52:4 5<2>><D5612AA12> G ; A13 561 <8:4 135B=B?251 561 2AA1>>2:5 ;8;52B:14 B;><?25B<: <= 561 ;6<8>413 DB56 ?<99B:8514 =32?5831<=561689138;D6B?6B;73B1F<8;B::25831 % F13B=B14 <8:4 135B=B?251 2:4 2>;< 561 B;?62371 89923E;A135614B;?62371?23461D2;249B5514<: %"*%%*"- 2:4 4B;?623714 <: %'*%%*"- B1 6<;AB52>BI14 =<3 1B765 42E; 5 B; <@;13F14 5625 3B765 ;6<8>413 A3<JB92> 6124 <= 68913<8; D2; 31A>2?14 DB56 A3<;561;B;2:4=B:2>>E2;;1;;145614B;2@B>B5E25'*GGH5 B; ;525145625B5B;292>8:B514=32?5831<=3B765A3<JB92> 68913<8;DB56B9A>2:5B:;B58613B@8:2>13314B:52LB:7 ")H 4B;2@B>B5E DB56<85 2:E @2;B; 2:4 1F1: "34 <= 561 ;291 2AA3<JB9251 ?<91; 5< %)H 6131=<31 56B; <835 =B:4; 312;<:2@>1 5< 52L1 561 4B;2@B>B5E 2; %)H 61 - 5 - 2AA1>>2:5 915 DB56 2: 2??B41:5 <: %"*%%*"- 2:4 6B; B:?<91 D2; 3B765>E 52L1: 2; "%)*$ 2:4 B5 :114; :< B:513=131:?1 ' :FB1D<=5612@<F1561><;;<==85831123:B:7 D<8>4?<915</ "%)*J"%J"J%)HN)"G')*$ & 613B@8:2>732:5142:29<8:5<=;&G*G$ 8:413 561 6124 K 14B?2> JA1:;1; B5 :114; :< B:513=131:?12;56131B;4B;A851DB5656129<8:5 - <:;B413B:7 561 :25831 <= B:C83E 2:4 A13B<4 <= 6<;AB52>BI25B<: 56B; <835 =B:4; 312;<:2@>1 5< 2D234 ;G****$ 5<D234; A2B: 2:4 ;8==13B:7 ;%)***$ 5<D234; ><;; <= 291:B5B1; 2:4 ;****$ =<3 532:;A<3525B<:1J532:<83B;691:52:42551:42:5?62371; "* 1 9B765 :<562F1 D<3L14 25>12;5 =<3 2A13B<4 <=563119<:56;4815<B:C83B1;;8;52B:14B:5612??B41:5 56131=<31 ><;; <= B:?<91 483B:7 >2B4 8A A13B<4 ?<91; 5< ;-')*$"%)*J! - 6 - "" : 2>> 561 5<52> ?<9A1:;25B<: D<8>4 ?<91; 5< ;'')*$DB56B:5131;5 255613251<= GHA13 2::89 =3<95614251<=A15B5B<:5B>>312>BI25B<: "% 61 2D234 <= ?<9A1:;25B<: A2;;14 @E 561 3B@8:2>B;9<4B=B142;8:413/ *+,- ./0120- "<;;<==85831123:B:7?2A2?B5E )"G')*$ % 2B:2:4;8==13B:7 )****$ <;;<=291:B5B1; %)***$ 14B?2>1JA1:;1; &G**$ )32:;A<3525B<: 1J532 :<83B;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5 ?62371; ****$ G<;;<=123:B:7483B:7561>2B4 8AA13B<4 -')*$ 1+3 445 ??<34B:7>E 561 ?>2B92:5 B; 1:5B5>14 =<3 2 5<52> ?<9A1:;25B<: <=-445 DB56 B:5131;5 25 561 3251 <=GHA132::89=3<95614251<=A15B5B<:5B>>312>BI25B<: 2:4 1:5B5>14 =<3 2: 1:62:?14 ?<9A1:;25B<: <= - 465 " :56131;8>5561=<>><DB:7<3413B;A2;;14/ - 7 - B! 612AA12>B; BB! 61 ?>2B92:5 B; 1:5B5>14 =<3 2 5<52> ?<9A1:;25B<: <= ;'')*$ 2><:7 DB56 B:5131;5255613251<=GHA132::89=3<9561 4251<=A15B5B<:5B>>312>BI25B<: BBB! 61 3B@8:2> 2>3124E 41A<;B514 ;G-***$ 2D23414@E5613B@8:2>56131=<3131;A<:41:5 <% K :;832:?1 <9A2:E B; 4B31?514 5< 41A<;B5 561 1:62:?14 ?<9A1:;25B<: <= ;%'&)*$ DB56 B:5131;5 25 561 3251 <= GH DB56B:<:19<:56=3<95614251<=56B;<3413 BF! : ;8?6 41A<;B5 561 2AA1>>2:5 B; A139B5514 5< DB56432D 561 29<8:5 2><:7 DB56 B:5131;5 2??3814<:B5 -,5 &%!! ( $ B;5</"></G /