Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43320 (KAR)

NANDA AND ORS v. MADIVALAPPA AND ANR

MFA/200129/2018 · 2025-10-17

H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"# $! % &!$! % &!#&' # ! !$$ (') *+ ! !$$ (') * + !"# ! $% ##&% Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' !( $% ##&% " !# ! $% ##&% & !& ! )% * ##&% + " '$)' + , "- ' - & + + )" + * %&%$'%) '&#'%# * + !"& ! ' !( - 3 - " !#) ! $% ##&% !&# ! )% *! ! ##&% ' ."%'%'' / + + )"+ $ %&%$'%) * + 0'& ") &$( 0# % %%% + ! - 4 - ! 1 1 & !1 + 2'%%($'% 30 43567 89 :;6 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 C;6>6?0 + 2'%%'$'% 30 43567 89 :;6 @5?3A?<:0=<76>6@:32<)"24:;62:2>6;3@560@: $ 42> 0;2>: D:;6 @:E 863<F ?FF>36G67 89 :;6 H=7FA6<: ?<7 ?C?>7 7?:67 %&%$'%) B?0067 89 :;6 773:32<?56<32>3G35=7F6,773:32<?5 37?>42> 0;2>: D:;6 >38=<?5E 3< 2'&#'%# 3<@6 :;6 @;?556<F6 30 :2 :;6 0?A6 H=7FA6<: 82:; :;6 ?BB6?50 ?>6 ;6?>7:2F6:;6>?<7@2AA2<H=7FA6<:30B?0067 ' +?@:0 F3G3<F >306 :2 :;6 4353<F 24 :;6 ?BB6?50 8>364590:?:67?>6:;?:2<%&%"'%#?:?82=:%$#%?A C;356 :;6 76@6?067 >H=< 2 ?8=>?2 C?0 B>2@6673<F :2C?>70?553I;67:2H23<;307=:92<;30A2:2>@9@562< 564: 0376 24 :;6 >2?7 C;6< ;6 C?0 B>2@6673<F <6?> ?=8?7 ?: :;?: :3A6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 - 5 - =0I6> " ;6?G9 F2270 G6;3@56 86?>3<F 6F2 '$)' @?A6 4>2A 8?@I 0376 C3:; ;3F; 0B667 3< ? >?0; ?<7 <6F53F6<: A?<<6> ?<7 520: @2<:>25 2G6> :;6 G6;3@56 ?<7 7?0;67 :2 :;6 76@6?067 ?0 ? >60=5: :;6 76@6?067465572C<2<:;6>2?7?<7C;66524:;62446<73<F G6;3@56 B?0067 2G6> :;6 76@6?067 7=6 :2 C;3@; ;6 0=@@=A867:2:;63<H=>3602<:;60B2: " ;6@5?3A?<:043567?B6:3:32<=<76>6@:32<(( 24 :;6 @: 066I3<F @2AB6<0?:32< 42> :;6 76?:; 24 :;6 76@6?067?52<FC3:;3<:6>60: & <06>G3@6240=AA2<0 >60B2<76<:20?<7 ' 36 2C<6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 ?<7 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 ?BB6?>67 :;>2=F; :;63> @2=<065 ?<7 43567 06B?>?:6C>3::6<0:?:6A6<:03<C;3@;:;6?G6>A6<:0A?76 3< :;6 B6:3:32< C6>6 76<367 ;6 ?F6 2@@=B?:32< ?<7 3<@2A624:;676@6?067?>676<367 # <:;68?03024:;6B56?73<F024:;6B?>:360 :;6 5?3A0>38=<?54>?A67:;6300=60?<7:;6>6?4:6>>6@2>767 - 6 - :;66G376<@6;6@5?3A?<:0 3<2>76>:2B>2G6:;63>@?06 6J?A3<67@5?3A?<:2?0?<7?<2:;6>C3:<600?0 ' ?<7 F2: 6J;383:67 72@=A6<:0 <?A659 J :2 J"<86;?5424>60B2<76<:2'<0=>?<@62AB?<9 6J?A3<673:02443@6>?0 ?<7F2:6J;383:6772@=A6<: <?A659 J ;6 5?3A0 >38=<?5 89 :;6 3AB=F<67 H=7FA6<: 3<:6>?53? ;657:;?::;6?@@376<::22IB5?@62< ?@@2=<: 24 0256 <6F53F6<@6 24 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 ?0 ? >60=5: 24 C;3@; :;6 76@6?067 0=0:?3<67 3<H=>360 ?<7 0=@@=A867 :2 :;6 3<H=>360 ;6 >38=<?5 4=>:;6> ;657 :;?: :;6 @5?3A?<:0 ?>6 6<:3:567 :2 ? @2AB6<0?:32<24 0'& ") &$(?52<FC3:;3<:6>60:?::;6 >?:624(KB??<773>6@:67:;63<0=>6>24:;62446<73<F G6;3@56 :2 B?9 @2AB6<0?:32< ?52<F C3:; 3<:6>60: 63<F ?FF>36G67 :;606?BB6?50;?G6866<43567 ( 6?><67@2=<06542>:;6<0=>?<@62AB?<9;?0 @2<:6<767 :;?: ?@@376<: ;?0 2@@=>>67 7=6 :2 :;6 <6F53F6<@6 24 76@6?067 ;3A0654 C;6< ;6 C?0 >373<F :;6 A2:2>@9@562<:;6;3F;C?9 ;6@?A60=776<59:2:;6564: - 7 - 0376 ?<7 :;6>642>6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 C?0 =<?856 :2 @2<:>25 :;6 G6;3@56 ?<7 8?@I C;665 24 :;6 A2:2>@9@56:2=@;67:2:;6G6;3@56?<776@6?067>376>4655 72C< 0=446>673<H=>360?<70=@@=A867:2:;63<H=>360 ? 6@2<759 ;6 @2<:6<767 :;?: 3: 30 G6>9 @56?> 4>2A:;60I6:@;J':;?:7>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56 C?0 B>2@6673<F 2< :;6 564: 0376 24:;6 >2?7 ;6 >376>24 :;6 A2:2>@9@56 C?0 B>2@6673<F 2< :;6 0?A6 73>6@:32< 3< 4>2<:24:;6G6;3@56;6>376>24:;6A2:2>@9@560=776<59 @?A6:2:;6564:0376?<7;6<@6 :;6?@@376<:;?02@@=>>67 ?<7 :;6>642>6 ;6 ?502 @2<:>38=:67 :2 :;6 ?@@376<: ;6 >38=<?5 ;?0 6>>67 3< ;2573<F :;?:7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@5630?52<6<6F53F6<:3<@?=03<F:;6?@@376<: 8 <>60B6@:24L=?<:=A ;6@2<:6<767:;?:6G6< :;2=F; @5?3A?<:0 ;?G6 B>27=@67 0?5?>9 @6>:343@?:6 24 :;6 76@6?067 0:?:3<F :;?: ;6 C?0 6?><3<F 0) ##& B6> A2<:;?0B6>J" :;69;?G6<2:6J?A3<67?=:;2>24:;6 72@=A6<: ?<7 :;69 ;?G6 <2: B>27=@67 ?<9 8?<I 0:?:6A6<: 0;2C3<F :;?: ;6 C?0 F6::3<F :;6 0?5?>9 - 8 - ;6>642>6 :;6A2<:;593<@2A6?006006789:;6>38=<?5?: 0) #&&302<:;6;3F;6>0376 @ ?0:59 ;6 @2<:6<767 :;?: @2<0376>3<F :;6 ?F6 ?<7 ?G2@?:32< 24 :;6 76@6?067 :;6 2G6>?55 @2AB6<0?:32< ?C?>76789:;6>38=<?5302<:;6;3F;6>0376?<7>6L=3>67 :2 86 >67=@67 6<@6 ;6 02=F;: 42> ?552C3<F :;6 ?BB6?5 43567 89 :;6 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 ?<7 730A300?5 24 :;6 ?BB6?54356789:;6@5?3A?<:0 ) 6?><67 @2=<065 42> :;6 @5?3A?<:0 ;?0 >?3067 :;642552C3<F@2=<:6>@2<:6<:32<0! ? +3>0:59 C;6< :;6 76@6?067 C?0 B>2@6673<F 2< ;30A2:2>@9@56 :;67>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56@?A63< ?;3F;0B667 3<>?0;?<7<6F53F6<:A?<<6>?<77?0;67:2 :;6;3<7B2>:32<24:;6A2:2>@9@56=6:2:;63AB?@: ;6 465572C< 0=446>673<H=>360?<70=@@=A867:2:;63<H=>360 2< :;6 0B2: ;6>642>6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 ?52<630>60B2<038563<@?=03<F:;6?@@376<: - 9 - 8 6@2<759 ;6 @2<:6<767 :;?: @5?3A?<:0 ;?G6 6J?A3<67 696C3:<600 36 ' 6 ;?0 @?:6F2>3@?559 0:?:67 :;?: ?@@376<: 2@@=>>67 7=6 :2 <6F53F6<@6 24 :;6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 2 730B>2G6 :;6 0?A6 >60B2<76<: 2' ;?0 <2: 6J?A3<67 :;6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 G6;3@56 G6< B253@6 ;?G6 >6F30:6>67 :;6 + ?F?3<0: :;6 7>3G6>24:;6G6;3@56?<7@;?>F60;66:;?0?502866<43567 ?F?3<0::;67>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@562<0376>3<F?55 :;606 72@=A6<:0 :;6 >38=<?5 ;?0 >3F;:59 ;657 :;?: :;6 7>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56?52<630<6F53F6<:3<@?=03<F :;6?@@376<: @ < >60B6@: 24 L=?<:=A ;6 @2<:6<767 :;?: :;6 76@6?067 C?0 C2>I3<F ?0 ? 6?@;6> 3< ? 6?@;6> 3< ? B>3G?:6 67=@?:32<?53<0:3:=:32<;6@5?3A?<:0;?G6B>27=@67:;6 0?5?>9 @6>:343@?:6 ?0 B6> J" C;3@; 0;2C0 :;?: ;6 C?0 F6::3<F 0) #&&?0;30A2<:;590?5?>9<?773:32<:2 :;?: ;6 C?0 ?502 F3G3<F B>3G?:6 :=3:32<0 :2 :;6 0:=76<:0 ?<7F6::3<FA2<:;59466024 0# %%%=::;6>38=<?5 - 10 - ;?0 @2<0376>67 2<59 0) #&& C;3@; 30 2< :;6 52C6> 0376 7 ?0:59 ;6 ;?0 @2<:6<767 :;?: 3< G36C 24 :;6 H=7FA6<:24:;62<E856B6J2=>:3<:;6@?0624 !>6B2>:673< " #$ 6?@; 24 :;6 @5?3A?<:0 ?>6 6<:3:567 :2 0&% %%% :2C?>70 5200 24 52G6 ?<7 ?446@:32< ?<7 @2<02>:3=A 6<@6 ;6 02=F;: 42> 6<;?<@6A6<: 24 @2AB6<0?:32<89?552C3<F:;6?BB6?54356789:;6@5?3A?<:0 ?<7 730A3003<F :;6 ?BB6?5 43567 89 :;6 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 6?>7 :;6 56?><67 @2=<065 42> :;6 B?>:360 6>=067:;6H=7FA6<:?<7?C?>724:;6>38=<?5 $ ;6@?0624:;6@5?3A?<:030:;?:2<%&%"'%# ?:?82=:%$!#%?A C;6<76@6?067>H=<C?0B>2@6673<F 2<;30A2:2>@9@56:2C?>70?553I;67:2H23<;307=:92< :;6564:037624:;6>2?7 :;67>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56 86?>3<F 6F2'$)'@?A64>2A8?@I0376C3:; ;3F;0B6673<?>?0;?<7<6F53F6<:A?<<6>?<77?0;67:2 - 11 - :;6 ;3<7 B2>:32< 24 :;6 A2:2>@9@56 7=6 :2 C;3@; :;6 76@6?067520:@2<:>252G6>:;6A2:2>@9@56?<7465572C<2< :;6 >2?7 =6 :2 :;6 ?@@376<: ;6 0=0:?3<67 F>36G2=0 3<H=>360?<70=@@=A867:2:;63<H=>360 % <76> :;6 2:2> 6;3@560 @: 3< :;6 @5?3A B6:3:32<8642>6:;65?3A0>38=<?5:;60:?<7?>724B>22430 A=@; 8652C :;?< C;?: 30 >6L=3>67 3< ? @>3A3<?5 @?06 ?0 C655 ?0 3< :;6 @3G35 @?06 2 72=8: 8642>6 :;6 >38=<?5 :;6>6 A=0: 86 02A6 A?:6>3?5 2< :;6 8?030 24 C;3@; :;6 >38=<?5 @?< ?>>3G6 2> 76@376 :;3<F0 <6@600?>9 :2 76@376 42> ?C?>73<F @2AB6<0?:32< 8=: :;6 >38=<?5 30 <2: 6JB6@:67:2:?I62>:2?72B:?<3@6:924?@3G352>@>3A3<?5 @?06 4:6> ?55 3: 30 ? 0=AA?>9 6<L=3>9 ?<7 3: 30 :;6 56F305?:32<42>:;6C654?>624:;62@36:9;6B>2@6673<F0 =<76> :;6 2:2> 6;3@560 @: ?>6 <2: ?I3< :2 :;6 B>2@6673<F0 =<76> @3G35 >=560 6<@6 0:>3@: >=560 24 6G376<@6?>6<2:>6L=3>67:28642552C673<:;30>6F?>7< :;6 @?06 24 ! %& - 12 - '( && >6B2>:67 3< ) * + , -+-$ :;6 2<E856B6J2=>:;?0;657?0;6>63<8652C! ! " # ! $ !# # # !! # # # ! !! # !! ! ! !! % 2 B>2G6 :;6 @?06 @5?3A?<: 2 30 6J?A3<67 ?0 3< ;6> 6G376<@6 ;?0 >63:6>?:67 :;6 0:?:6A6<:0 A?76 3< :;6 @5?3A B6:3:32< ;6 @5?3A?<:0 ;?G6 ?502 6J?A3<67 2<6 696C3:<600 ?0 ' 6 ;?0 @?:6F2>3@?5590:?:67:;?:?@@376<:;?02@@=>>677=6:2>?0; ?<7 <6F53F6<: 7>3G3<F 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@56 ?<7 0:?:67 - 13 - :;?:7>3G6>C?07>3G3<F:;6G6;3@563<?;3F;0B6673<>?0; ?<7 <6F53F6<: A?<<6> ;6 @2AB5?3<: C?0 527F6789 2<6 <35 =A?>?0B6>J';6>6@2>700;2C:;?:;630?502 ?< 696C3:<600 < ;30 @2AB5?3<: ;6 ;?0 0:?:67 :;?: ?@@2>73<F :2 :;6 0:?:67 4?@: :;6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<F G6;3@5630<6F53F6<:3<@?=03<F:;6?@@376<:<:;68?03024 @2AB5?3<:?0B6>J' B253@6;?G6>6F30:6>67:;6+ ?0 B6>J?F?3<0::;67>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@564:6> :;2>2=F; 3<G60:3F?:32< B253@6 ;?G6 43567 @;?>F6 0;66: ?F?3<0::;67>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56G6<:;60I6:@; ;?0866<B>27=@67?:J'?:30G6>9@56?>:;?::;6 C37:; 24 :;6 >2?7 30 "%4: :;6 ?@@376<: ;?0 2@@=>>67 %4: 4>2A:;6564:037624:;6>2?7<B6>=0?524:;60?A6 3:30 G6>9@56?>:;?:7>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@5630<6F53F6<: 3<@?=03<F:;6?@@376<:2730B>2G6:;66G376<@624:;6 @5?3A?<:0 :;6 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 ;?0 <2: ?77=@67 ?<9 6G376<@6 A=@;56007>3G6>24:;62446<73<FG6;3@56 6J@6B: B>27=@3<F 3<0=>?<@6 B253@9 :;69 ;?G6 <2: A?>I67 ?<9 72@=A6<: - 14 - ' 2<0376>3<F :;6 6G376<@6 24 ?<7 ' ?<7 F23<F :;>2=F; @2AB5?3<: J' + J 0I6:@; J'? @;?>F6 0;66: J :;6 >38=<?5 ;?0 >3F;:59@2A6:2:;6@2<@5=032<:;?:?@@376<:;?02@@=>>67 7=6 :2 >?0; ?<7 <6F53F6<: 7>3G3<F 24 :;6 7>3G6> 24 :;6 2446<73<FG6;3@56 " <>60B6@:24L=?<:=A 3<730B=:?859 ?::;6:3A6 24?@@376<: 76@6?067C?0?F67?82=:")96?>06C?0 C2>I3<F ?0 6?@;6> 3< ? B>3G?:6 67=@?:32<?5 3<0:3:=:32< ;6@5?3A?<:0;?G6B>27=@67:;60?5?>9@6>:343@?:6J" 3:30G6>9@56?>:;?:76@6?067C?0F6::3<FA2<:;590?5?>924 0) #&& 6J@6B::;?::;6@5?3A?<:0;?G6<2:B>27=@67 ?<972@=A6<::20;2C:;?:;6C?06?><3<F 0# %%%B6> A2<:; 89 F3G3<F :=3:32< :2 :;6 0:=76<:0 ;6>642>6 :;6 >38=<?5;?0>3F;:59@2<0376>67:;63<@2A624:;676@6?067 ?: 0) "&& ?4:6> 767=@:3<F 0'%% :2C?>70 >2460032<?5?J ;6>38=<?5;?0>3F;:59?7767#%K24 :;6 3<@2A6 24 :;6 76@6?067 :2C?>70 4=:=>6 B>20B6@:0 ?0 B6> :;6 5?C 5?37 72C< 89 :;6 2<E856 B6J 2=>: 3< :;6 - 15 - @?0624& .(,/& %/>6B2>:673<! #,+ +#;6>38=<?5 ;?0>3F;:59767=@:67">724:;63<@2A6:2C?>70B6>02<?5 6JB6<060 ?0 :;6>6 ?>6 :;>66 76B6<76<:0 ?<7 ?BB5367 A=5:3B536> 24 D#E ;=0 :;6 >38=<?5 >646>>3<F :2 :;6 H=7FA6<: 24 :;6 2<E856 =B>6A6 2=>: 3< :;6 @?06 24 ,/(0& ,/ 1 ,&/ %/ 2) * , 3#4 @?06 ?C?>767 0'" ") &$( :2C?>7052002476B6<76<@9 & < ?773:32< :;6 @5?3A?<:0 ?>6 6<:3:567 :2 @2AB6<0?:32<24 0# %%%2<?@@2=<:24D52002460:?:6E ?<7 @2AB6<0?:32< 24 0# %%% 2< ?@@2=<: 24 D4=<6>?5 6JB6<060E5?3A?<:2 C34624:;676@6?067306<:3:567 42>@2AB6<0?:32<24 0&% %%%=<76>:;6;6?7241520024 0B2=0?5 @2<02>:3=A1 5?3A?<: 2' 30 6<:3:567 42> @2AB6<0?:32< 24 0&% %%% :2C?>70 5200 24 B?>6<:?5 @2<02>:3=A?<75?3A?<:2"306<:3:56742>@2AB6<0?:32< 24 0&% %%%:2C?>705200244353?5@2<02>:3=A - 16 - # ;=0 :;6@5?3A?<:0?>66<:3:567:2:;642552C3<F @2AB6<0?:32<! ,-./0123/4/5.6 53.6./2.150 ,4/23/ (0) 2002476B6<76<@9 '" ") &$( +=<6>?56JB6<060 # %%% 2002460:?:6 # %%% 200240B2=0?5 @2<02>:3=A &% %%% 20024B?>6<:?5 @2<02>:3=A &% %%% 200244353?5@2<02>:3=A &% %%% 217 " * ( <:;6>60=5: C6B?00:;642552C3<F! 3 ;6?BB6?54356789:;6<0=>?<@62AB?<9 3<+2'%%($'%30&& 33 ;6 ?BB6?5 43567 89 :;6 @5?3A?<:0 3< + 2'%%'$'%30 0&' - 17 - 333 ;6 H=7FA6<: 24 :;6 5?3A0 >38=<?5 30 A2734367 3G ;6 <0=>?<@6 2AB?<9 30 73>6@:67 :2 76B203: :;6 @2AB6<0?:32< ?A2=<: 24 0 " *?52<FC3:;3<:6>60:M(K B? 4>2A :;6 7?:6 24 4353<F 24 :;6 @5?3A B6:3:32<:355:;67?:624>6?53N?:32< C3:;3<? B6>3272403JC66I04>2A:;67?:624>6@63B: 24@2B924:;30H=7FA6<: G ;6 ?A2=<: 3< 76B203: 3< + 2'%%($'% 30 73>6@:67 :2 86 :>?<0A3::67:2:;6@2<@6><67>38=<?5 !5* ($!) & !5* (#&' #) & 30:2!52!'( !