Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43317 (KAR)

GURURAJ SHETTY v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/201171/2025 · 2025-08-21

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ % $$ $ & &'() & (( * !"# " ! $ %#% # $ & # & $ %#% ' (& $$) Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $ & & & $ $ $& ! * " & # ! ' (& + " ) !" () "! & ( ) & !# "" & # * , -& - 3 - ( -& ) ./ 0/121234/56 7/248 9::;6/< 36 13 # 24 52=/ 3!# "" 3> 24<.94;5;59?3?2:/ 1912345/8261/5/< >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97?/ ;4</5 /:12346 # 94< * 3> 66/4129? 3==3<212/6 :1 , 0/4<248 34 1./ >2?/ 3> 1./?/954/<<<212349?2@2?;<8/94< 24<.94;5 92:.;5 26152:1 95/ 6//A248 13 B;96. 1./ :52=249? 053://<24862421291/<98924611./= " /95< 52 9126.A;=95 9<A95 ?/954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 94< =1 5912 912? ?/954/< 28. 3;51 3@/54=/41 ?/9</5 >35 1./ 5/6034</416 /5;6/<1./=91/529?6345/:35< # /954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 :341/4</< 1.91 0/121234/5 3 ::;6/< 3 7C 49=/ D ;5;59E 5/62</413>31.949?2??98/94@29?;A92:.;526152:1 261./3F4/53>95;1259</595/192?6.3094<0/121234/5 36" 94< # 95/ 1./ 52@/5 94< F4/5 3> ?355C - 4 - 5/60/:12@/?C ./ 52:/ 0;5:.96/< 7C 0/121234/5 3 F96 7/248 159460351/< 13 9.9596.159 24 1./ ?355C 7/95248 5/8261591234 3 " ! ** F.2:. F96 <52@/4 7C 0/121234/5 3"./?355CF96592</<94<1./:9=/13 7/ 5/8261/5/< 9??/8248 1.91 1./ 52:/ =/941 >35 0;7?2: <261527;1234F967/248:9552/<2??/89??C 1 26 1./ :341/41234 3> 1./ ?/954/< :3;46/? >35 1./0/121234/561.911./5/F9690;7?2:9;:12343>1./52:/ 7C1.//0951=/413>852:;?1;5/960/54312>2:91234<91/< %"" 94< 1./ 52:/ F/28.248 * B;2419?6 F96 0;5:.96/< 7C 34/ 52 9449=;51./009 94< 1./ 692< 52:/ F96 5/?/96/< 7C 1./ >>2:/ 3> 1./ /0;1C 3==266234/5 &9??952 34 #%"" .;6 21 26 1./ :341/41234 3> 1./ ?/954/<:3;46/?>351./0/121234/561.911./610/121234/5 9?63 7/248 1./ 3F4/5 3> 1./ 5/192? 6.30 7C 49=/ 95;12 59</560;5:.96/<1./52:/>53=34/ 9449=;51./0093> 95;1259</5694@294<1./69=/F967/248159460351/< 13 9.9596.159 1 26 :341/4</< 1.91 0/121234/5 3 26 1./ @9?2< ?2:/46/ .3?</5 .9@248 5/8261591234 94< - 5 - 1./5/>35/21:944317/:34:?;</<1.911./0/121234/56.9@/ :3==211/< 94C 3>>/4:/ ::35<248?C ./ 059C6 >35 B;96.2481./:52=249?053://<2486 =15912912??/954/<28.3;51 3@/54=/41?/9</5>351./5/6034</41 191/6;7=2161.91 1./ F/28.198/ 94< </6:5201234 3> 1./ 7986 24 F.2:. 52:/ F967/248159460351/<F/5/43162=2?9594<1./0/121234/56 F/5/431.9@24894C@9?2<<3:;=/416>351594603512481./ 52:/ 1./ 69=/ F96 =/941 >35 0;7?2: <261527;123441./976/4:/3>@9?2<<3:;=/4169:52=249? :96/F965/8261/5/<1./5/>35/6./059C6>35<26=2669?3> 1./0/121234 % 4 @2/F 3> 1./ 52@9? :341/412346 ;58/< 7C 1./ ?/954/<:3;46/?6>35731.1./09512/61./032411.91F3;?< 9526/>35=C:3462</59123426 - 6 - ! " #$%& C946F/5131./973@/0324126241./ >35 1./>3??3F248 * 1 26 1./ :341/41234 3> 1./ 0536/:;1234 1.91 0/121234/5 3" 9::;6/< 3" F96 >3;4< <52@248 1./ ?355C 7/95248 5/8261591234 3 " ! ** F21. % 0?9612: 7986 3> 52:/ F/28.248 A8 /9:. @9?;/< 91 973;1 6*! F21.3;194C@9?2<<3:;=/4161F96>3;4< 1.911./52:/F96=/941>350;7?2:<261527;1234/121234/5 3261./3F4/53>1./52:/0/121234/5 3#261./3F4/5 3> 1./ ?355C 94< 1./5/>35/ :52=249? :96/ F96 5/8261/5/< 9892461 9?? 1./ 1.5// 0/56346 ./ :9=/ 13 7/ 5/8261/5/< 34 *"" ./ 05/6/41 0/121234 :9=/ 13 7/ >2?/< 34 ",*"" 6//A248 B;96.248 3> 1./ :52=249? 053://<24862421291/<98924611./= - 7 - ! 3 9 03241/< B;/5C ?/954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 6;7=211/< 1.91 1./ <3:;=/416 43F 053<;:/< 7/>35/ 1.26 3;51 13 :341/4< 1.91 0/121234/5 3 .9< 0;5:.96/< 52:/ >53= 34/ 9449=;51./009 7/248 1./ .28./61 72<</5130;5:.96/ 52:/ 24 1./ 0;7?2:9;:1234 1.91 F96 ./?< 7C 1./ /0951=/41 3> 33< 94< 2@2? ;00?2/6 F.2:. F96 5/?/96/< >53= 1./ >>2:/ 3> 1./ /0;1C 3==266234/5960/55/?/96/35</5<91/<#%"" F96 431 053<;:/< 7/>35/ 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 /954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 6;7=216 1.91 1./ 0/121234/56 F/5/ 34 792? 3F/@/5 ./ :341/4<6 1.91 1./ 0/121234/56 F/5/ 9>592< 1.91 1./C =9C 7/ 19A/4 2413 :;613<C 7C 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 94< 1./5/>35/ 1./C 4/@/5 900/95/< 7/>35/1./4@/612891248>>2:/5435<2<1./C053<;:/94C <3:;=/41F.2:.2643F053<;:/<7/>35/1.263;51./4 1./ 9;1./412:21C 3> 1./ <3:;=/416 1.91 95/ 053<;:/< 7/>35/ 1.26 3;51 95/ 431 @/52>2/< 7C 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 43 5/?294:/ :3;?< 7/ 0?9:/< 34 6;:. :302/6 3> <3:;=/416 13 9::/01 1./ :341/41234 19A/4 7C 1./ - 8 - 0/121234/56126>351./0/121234/5613900/957/>35/1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 94< 053<;:/ 5/?/@941 <3:;=/416 13 /497?/ 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 13 @/52>C 1./ 9;1./412:21C 3> 1./ <3:;=/416 94< 1./ :341/41234 19A/4 7C 1./ 0/121234/56 , 4832481.53;8.1./>256124>35=9123494<1./ 21=9A/63;19615348 :96/3>9:3842G97?/ 3>>/4:/ 94< ;4</5 6;:. :25:;=6194:/6 21 26 431 9 >21 :96/ >35B;96.2481./:52=249?053://<2486 /954/< :3;46/? >35 1./ 0/121234/56 0?9:/6 5/?294:/ 34 1./ </:26234 3> 1.26 3;51 24 @2</ 35</5 <91/< "*"""13:341/4<1.9124962=2?95:96/1./:52=249? 053://<2486F/5/B;96./<98924611./0/121234/561./5/24 ./5/>35/62=2?9535</526137/0966/<241./05/6/41:96/ 96F/?? 1 5? 3",,% "" - 9 - .9@/834/1.53;8.1./692<35</5:52=249? :96/ 24 52=/ 3#, "" :9=/ 13 7/ 5/8261/5/< <;5248 >2561.9?>3>1./""+1./0/121234/56.9@/900539:./<1./ 3;51 F21. 62=2?95 :341/41234+ 1./ <3:;=/416 F/5/ 053<;:/< 7/>35/ 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 6//A248 1./25 5/?/96/ 7;1 24 6021/ 3> 6;>>2:2/41 300351;421C 1./ 4@/612891248>>2:/5.9<431:3=/3;1F21.94C5/60346/ 4</5 6;:. :25:;=6194:/6 1./ 35</5 :9=/ 13 7/ 0966/< 34"*"""19A2482413:3462</5912341./>9:11.91/@/4 9>1/5?906/3>=35/1.949C/9543249?/0351F96>2?/< 7C 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 35/3@/5 /@/4 F./4 1./ <3:;=/416 5/?2/< 34 7C 1./ 0/121234/56 1./5/24 F/5/ 053<;:/< 7/>35/ 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 1./5/ F96 43 5/60346/>53=.2662</ " &;1 24 1./ 05/6/41 :96/ 96 .9@/ 9?5/9<C 431/< F21.24 <9C6 3> 5/8261591234 3> 1./ 1./ 05/6/41 0/121234 :9=/ 13 7/ >2?/< >35 6//A248 B;96.2483> 1./ :52=249? 053://<2486 <=211/<?C 1./ <3:;=/416 F.2:.95/5/?2/<347C1./0/121234/56F/5/4/@/5053<;:/< - 10 - 7/>35/1./4@/612891248>>2:/513/497?/.2=13@/52>C1./ 9;1./412:21C3>1./69=/4</56;:.:25:;=6194:/69= 3> 1./ 3024234 1.91 1./ 692< </:26234 5/?2/< 34 7C 1./ ?/954/<:3;46/?>351./0/121234/56:944317/1./79626>35 096624862=2?9535</5241./05/6/41:96/ # 1 26 9 @/5C <948/53;6 059:12:/ 1.91 26 7/248 >3??3F/<241./5/:/41096113900539:.1./3;5124@3A248 24./5/41 E;526<2:1234 3> 1.26 3;51 2==/<291/?C 9>1/5 5/8261591234 3> 1./ 96A248 1./ 3;51 13 B;96. 1./ :52=249?053://<2486341./796263>>/F<3:;=/416./ 3;5168/4/59??CF2??431.9@/94C=/:.9426=13@/52>C1./ 9;1./412:21C 3> 1./ <3:;=/416 13 82@/ 9 >24<248 1.91 1./ 0/121234/56.9@/431:3==211/<94C3>>/4:/351.911./5/ 95/ 43 =91/529? 13 053://< 9892461 1./ 0/121234/56 1 26 1./ 05/538912@/ 3> 1./ 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 F.3 26 9;1.352G/< 13 @/52>C 1./ 8/4;24/4/66 94< 9;1./412:21C3>1./<3:;=/4165/?2/<347C1./0/121234/56 <3431 >24< 94C 5/9634>351./0/121234/56 F.3 95/ 1./ 9::;6/< 24 :52=249? :96/6 431 13 900/95 7/>35/ 1./ - 11 - 4@/612891248 >>2:/5 /@/4 9>1/5 371924248 792? 94< 13 053<;:/1./<3:;=/41634F.2:.1./C95/5/?C248136//A >2?248 3> 1./ H&I /0351 35 :?36248 1./ :52=249? :96/ ./5/>35/9=3>1./30242341.919??3F2486;:.0/1212346 6/16979<05/:/</41/4:/9=3>1./30242341.911./ 0/121234/56 95/ 431 /4121?/< >35 1./ 5/?2/> 96 63;8.1 >35 24 1./0/121234 4 @2/F 3> 1./ 973@/ 946F/5 1./ 03241 >35 :3462</591234 24 1./ 94< 053://< 13 0966 1./ >3??3F248 ./:52=249?0/12123426 +) &$$( % & 261 3 ? 3 $