- 1 - !" #$ !! %&' ( !"# ! " !# $ !# "$ % & Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !&' ! ( !"( ! !)" ! ( !* +! ! ,(-&. ) !& !% ,$) ,$'&# ! !* +! ! ,(-&. # !$) !% ,$) ,$'&# ! +! ! ,(-&. - "& ,#.... ' !&" - 3 - !% ,$),$"- ! +! ! ,(-&. . !$' !% ,$),&)- !* +! ! ,(-&. %- "$ % &( )' . %% % % #$ % % % * &.-".- ((&".( ** % %* + % % * ! ! / * - 4 - $ !/ * 01 23456271 89:62; 6<<5=1>1? @; A01 *4?<912A B65? ?6A1? &.-".' :6331? =2 8((& 8C ".( @; A01 D16521? 12=85 =>=D *4?<1 62? * % =2?06245 C85 3085A EA01 5=@426DF 063 C=D1? A0=3 6::16D " 5=1CC67A3D16?=2<5=31A8A01C=D=2<8CA0=36::16D651 63C8DD8B3! $ 2 (.(".( 6A 6@84A .#$. :9 A01 ?171631? 0=>6G4965 62? 4G9130 B151 :58711?=2< C589 =2?06245 A8 *6B6D<156 82 A01=5 98A857;7D1 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$),&)- 62? 0=>6G4965 B63 A01 :=DD=82 5=?15 012 A01; 516701? 2165 6D6;;6 69: A01 ?5=>15 8C A01 567A85 62? A56=D15 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 83,$) ,$'&# 62? ,$),$"- D86?1? B=A0 :6??; @6<3 B63 ?5=>=2< A01 A567A85 62? A56=D15 =2 6 5630 62? 21<D=<12A 962215 62? 6::D=1? 34??12@56G1362?3A8::1?=2C582A8CA0198A857;7D1 - 5 - 41 A8 2=<0A 08453 A01 5=?15 8C A01 98A85,7;7D1 ?6301?A8A010=2?,3=?18CA01A567A8562?A56=D152 677842A 8C B0=70 0=>6G4965 343A6=21? <5=1>843 =2H45=1362?347749@1?A8A01=2H45=1382A013:8A & 01 :1A=A=82153 B08 651 A01 D1<6D 51:51312A6A=>13 8C A01?171631?0=>6G4965C=D1?67D6=9:1A=A=8242?15 17A=82))8CA01 8A8510=7D13 7A'--7D6=9=2< 789:1236A=8282677842A8CA01?16A08C0=>6G4965 =2A0136=?586?A56CC=7677=?12A7785?=2<D;:56;3A8 6DD8BA017D6=9:1A=A=82 ( 01 8B215 62? A01 ?5=>15 8C A567A85 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$) ,$'&# 62? A01 ?5=>15 8C 56=D15 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$),$"- 6::1651? A0584<0 A01=5 784231D @4A ?=? 28A C=D1 6 3A6A1912A8C8@H17A=823 ) 3 6<96 12156D 23456271 89:62; =9=A1? C=D1?63A6A1912A8C8@H17A=823?12;=2<A016>15912A3 96?1=2A017D6=9:1A=A=82A=3?12=1?A06AA01A567A85 - 6 - 62?A01A56=D15@165=2<51<=3A56A=828,$) ,$'&# 62?,$),$"- B151 =2>8D>1? =2 A01 677=?12A A =3 782A12?1? A06A 63 :15 A01 789:D6=2A 62? 3:8A :6270626996A01677=?12A8774551?38D1D;?41A8A01 21<D=<127182A01:65A 8CA015=?15 8C A01 98A857;7D1 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$),&)- B08 5=??12 0=398A857;7D1=26563062?21<D=<12A962215A=3 782A12?1?A06AA01?5=>158CA01A567A8562?A56=D15?=? 28A:8331336>6D=?62?1CC17A=>1?5=>=2<D=71271638C A01 ?6A1 8C =27=?12A 1271 01 :56;3 A8 ?=39=33 A01 7D6=9:1A=A=826<6=23AA01=23456271789:62; # 011D=627112156D23456271 89:62; =9=A1?C=D1? 6 3A6A1912A 8C 8@H17A=823 ?12;=2< A01 6>15912A3 96?1=2A017D6=9:1A=A=8262??12=1?A06AA01A56=D15 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$),$"- B63 =23451? B=A0 A01 =23456271 789:62; 01 ?5=>15 8C A01 8CC12?=2< >10=7D1 B63 28A :833133=2< 6 >6D=? 62? 1CC17A=>1 ?5=>=2< D=71271 63 8C A01 ?6A1 8C 677=?12A - 7 - 1271 01 :56;3 A8 ?=39=33 A01 7D69 :1A=A=82 6<6=23A A01=23456271789:62; - 01 5=@426D @631? 82 A01 :D16?=2<3 8C A01 :65A=13 C5691?A0151D1>62A=33413 ' 01 :1A=A=82153 A8 34@3A62A=6A1 A01=5 7631 :1A=A=8215 8 B631I69=21? 63 , 1I69=21? B=A2133 63 ,"62?965G1?)?874912A363I0=@=A3A8) . 2 51@4AA6D A01 =23456271 789:62; 1I69=21? A01=5 8CC=715 63 , 62? ," 62? 965G1? AB8 ?874912A363I0=@=A3,62?," 01 5=@426D 6CA15 633133=2< A01 >15@6D 62? ?874912A65; 1>=?1271 6DD8B1? A01 7D6=9 :1A=A=82 =2 :65A B=A0 783A3 62? 6B65?1? 6 789:1236A=82 8C -))...,B=A0=2A1513A6AA0156A18C'J:1562249 C589A01?6A18C:1A=A=82A=DD516D=36A=82A=301D?A06A 513:82?12A 83 A8 ( @1C851A015=@426D 651H8=2AD; 62? 31>156DD; D=6@D1 A8 :6; A01 789:1236A=82 69842A - 8 - 62??=517A1?@8A0A01=23456271789:62=13A8:6;A01 789:1236A=8269842A=2A0156A=88C(.J1670 " 01 1D=6271 12156D 23456271 89:62; A? 6<<5=1>1? @; A01 36??D=2< 8C D=6@=D=A; 063 C=D1? A0=3 6::16D $ 165? A01 65<4912A3 8C A01 D16521? 784231D C85 A01 :1A=A=82153 62? A01 D16521? 784231D C85 A01 =23456271 789:62; & 16521? 784231D C85 A01 =23456271 789:62; 34@9=A3 A06A A01 5=@426D 8>15D88G1? A01 1>=?1271 82 51785? =1A017065<1,3011AB0=70308B3A06A6@6A1?7065<1 3011A B63 C=D1? 6<6=23A A01 5=?15 8C A01 98A857;7D1 @165=2< 51<=3A56A=82 8,$),&)- 63 677431? 8 ( 011D=627112156D23456271 89:62;=328AD=6@D1 A8 :6; A01 789:1236A=82 A8 A01 :1A=A=82153 @; 6::85A=82=2< D=6@=D=A; A8 A01 1IA12A 8C (.J 62? 8A015 (.J4:82A01A567A8562?A56=D1542=A=1 6<96 - 9 - 12156D 23456271 89:62; A? 01 6D38 34@9=A3 A06A638CA01?6A18C677=?12AA01A56=D15B63=23451? B=A0=A62?28AA01A567A85127182A0131<5842?3 301:56;3A86DD8BA016::16D ) D16521?784231DC85A01:1A=A=8215334@9=A3 A06A A01 6::1DD62A,=23456271 789:62; 063 28A :58?471?62;51785?3A813A6@D=30A06A82D;A01A56=D15 B63 =23451? B=A0 A01 6::1DD62A,=23456271 789:62; 62?28AA01A567A85127182A0=3<5842?0134@9=A3 A06AA015=@426DB63H43A=C=1?=236??D=2<A01D=6@=D=A; 82A016::1DD62A,=23456271789:62;127101:56;3 A8?=39=33A016::16D # 8A=71B63=3341?A8A01:1A=A=8215313:=A1315>=718C 28A=71A01:1A=A=821535196=21?4251:51312A1? - 15431?A0151785?362?7823=?151?A0134@9=33=8238C A01D16521?784231DC85A01=23456271789:62; ' 01:8=2AA06A65=313C857823=?156A=82=351<65?=2<A01 D=6@=D=A; - 10 - ". 0151 =3 28 ?=3:4A1 51<65?=2< A01 8774551271 8C 677=?12A62?6D38A01?16A08C0=>6G4965=2A0136=? 586?A56CC=7677=?12AA06A8774551?82(.(".(8 :58>1 A06A A01 677=?12A 8774551? ?41 A8 5630 62? 21<D=<12A ?5=>=2< @; A01 ?5=>15 8C A01 A567A85 62? A56=D15@165=2<51<=3A56A=828,$) ,$'&#62?, $),$"- A01; 06>1 :58?471? 6 78:; 8C 7065<1, 3011A965G1?63I0=@=A,$B0=70?=37D8313A06AA01 677=?12A8774551??41A8563062?21<D=<12A?5=>=2<@; A01 ?5=>15 8C A01 8CC12?=2< >10=7D1 =1 567A85 62? A56=D15 0151C851 A01 5=@426D B63 H43A=C=1? =2 51785?=2< 6 C=2?=2< A06A A084<0 6 7065<1,3011A B63 C=D1?6<6=23AA015=?158CA0198A857;7D16:15436D8C A017065<13011A965G1?63I0=@=A,$?=37D8313A06A A01677=?12A8774551?82D;?41A834??123A8::=2<8C A01 8CC12?=2< A567A85 62? A56=D15 B=A084A <=>=2< 62; 3=<26D30151C851=A76228A@136=?A06AA01?171631? 0=>6G4965 B63 513:823=@D1 C85 A01 8774551271 8C 677=?12A62?01D?A06A@;:58?47=2<A01:8D=7151785?3 - 11 - 965G1? 63 I0=@=A3 , A8 ,) A01 :1A=A=82153 06>1 :58>1?A016DD1<1?677=?12A62?A015134DA62A?16A08C 0=>6G4965=2A01677=?12A )*+,-+.+/0! " 16521? 784231D C85 A01 =23456271 789:62; 34@9=A3 A06A 82D; A01 A56=D15 B63 =23451? 62? A01 A567A85 B63 28A =23451? B=A0 A01 =23456271 789:62; 62? A8 34@3A62A=6A1 =A3 ?1C1271 A01 =23456271 789:62; :58?471?62?965G1?678:;8CA01:8D=7;8C=23456271 63I0=@=A," "" 15431?A01:8D=7;8C=23456271965G1?63I0=@=A" B0=70 ?=37D8313 A01 249@15 8C A01 A567A85 63 , $),"&$ 62? 28A 63 A56=D15 @165=2< 8,$), $"- I0=@=A " ?813 28A :15A6=2 A8 A01 8CC12?=2< A567A85=2>8D>1?=2A01677=?12A=2K413A=82043A01 5=@426D 7823=?15=2< I0=@=A ," 063 5=<0AD; 01D? A06A A01=23456271789:62;063C6=D1?A813A6@D=30A06AA01 A567A85 B63 28A =23451? 62? 82D; A01 A56=D15 B63 =23451? - 12 - "$ ?828AC=2?62;15585=2A01C=2?=2<351785?1?@;A01 5=@426D =2 51<65? A8 A01 >6D=?=A; 8C A01 :8D=7; 8C =23456271=2513:17A8CA567A8562?A56=D15015=@426D 063 5=<0AD; C63A121? A01 D=6@=D=A; 82 A01 =23456271 789:62; 8C A01 8CC12?=2< >10=7D1 ?8 28A C=2? 62; 15585=2A01=9:4<21?H4?<912A62?6B65? "& 7785?=2<D;:58711?A8:633A01C8DD8B=2<85?15! 01 =371DD621843 %=53A ::16D =3 01 =9:4<21? H4?<912A 62? 6B65? :6331? @; A01 5=@426D =3 0151@; 782C=591? 011<=3A5;=3?=517A1?A8A5623C15A01 69842A =2 ?1:83=A 62? 3 A8 A01 5=@426DC85A0B=A0 - 13 - 2 >=1B 8C A01 ?=3:836D 8C A01 6::16D 88C".".?81328A345>=>1C85 7823=?156A=8262?67785?=2<D;=A3A62?3 ?=3:831?8C 12 %' $ ! =3A8!D8!