Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43293 (KAR)

THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD v. BHIMANNA

WP/203394/2025 · 2025-12-01

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $#% # # &#' ( !) &#' !) &#' ! &#' ! &#' ! &#' !*+ &#' &#' + &#' &#' * &#' * &#' *) &#' *+ &#' ** &#' &#' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! " # $$ # $$ # % $ % # & % $ % ' # % $ % # ( $ )* ! " + " )) - 3 - *'# $ &" $ , & " - !) ! " # . # %' % # ( ' ! " + " )) - 4 - *# $ & " $ , & " - !) ! " # $$ # $$ # % $ % # & % $ % ' # % $ % # ( $ ! " - 5 - + " )) # $ &" $ & " ! ! " # $ # % $ # % $ # ( $ )* ! " - 6 - + " )) # $ &" $ , & " - ! ! " # %' % # ( $ )* ! " + " )) ')# $ &" - 7 - $ , & " - ! ! " # %* % # %*' % # ( ! " + " )) '# $ &" $ - 8 - , & " - !*+ ! " . $ # %' % # ( )* ! " + " )) '*# $ &" $ , & " - - 9 - ! " # %+ % # %+ % ' # %'' # ( )* ' # ( $ ) ! " + " )) '# $ &" $ , & " - - 10 - + ! " # $ %' % # $ # % $ % ' # % $ % * # % $ % # % $ % ) # $ % $ % # ( $ ) ! " - 11 - + /" )) *# $ & " $ , & " ! " # %' # %'' ' . # % $ % * # % $ % # ( $ )* ! " - 12 - + " )) '0# $ &" $ , & " - * ! " # %' # %'' ' # % $ % * # % $ % ! " - 13 - + " )) **# $ &" $ & " - * ! " # $$ % % # $$ # % $ % ' # & % $ % - 14 - * # % $ % # ( $ )* ! " + " )) *# $ &" $ & " 1 *) ! " - 15 - # %+ % # %+ % ' # %'' # ( ! " + " )) '# $ &" $ , & " 1 *+ ! " - 16 - # %+ % # %+ % ' # %'' # ( ! " + " )) *0# $ &" $ & " - ** ! " - 17 - # $ # % $ # % $ # ( $ )* ! " + " )) # $ &" $ , & " - ! " - 18 - # $$ % % # $$ # % $ % ' # & % $ % * # % $ % # ( * ! " + " )) '# $ &" $ & " - % % 1$ - 19 - !%1$ " 23,3 45/6 736/6/89, 5:/,3 : ;8<<89 =>3,6/89 4/62 53?:5@68A/B/9?8AC/:D/C/6EA857:E<3968A;8<739,:6/89/9 635<,8AF>@?<396:9@:4:5@@:63@'0'7:,,3@DE 623 885@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 /9 D:6;2 8A /,;3CC:938>, /5,6 773:C, D3:5/9? 8,''# :9@;8993;63@4/6286235<:6635, :;6, /9 D5/3A :53 62:6 89 :9 :;;/@396 8;;>553@ /9G8CG/9? : </9/ C855E D3:5/9? 53?/,65:6/89 8# + :9@ : 65>;H D3:5/9? 53?/,65:6/89 80# 0 862 623 G32/;C3, 4353 /9,>53@36/6/8935/9623,345/6736/6/89,/,623/9,>5358A 62365>;HD3:5/9?80# 023,:/@:;;/@3962:@ 53,>C63@/968/9F>5/3,:9@@3:62,8A,3G35:C735,89, C:/< 736/6/89, ,33H/9? ;8<739,:6/89 >9@35 3;6/89 )' 8A 868532/;C3, ;60:,43CC:,>9@35 3;6/89))8A 8685 32/;C3, ;6 D3A853 623 5/D>9:C 4353 :CC843@ DE ?5:96/9?;8<739,:6/893/9?@/,,:6/,A/3@623:773:C,:9@ - 20 - ;58,, :773:C, 4353 A/C3@ ,33H/9? 392:9;3<396 :9@ A85 53@>;6/89 /9 623 :A853,:/@ D:6;2 8A </,;3CC:938>, A/5,6 :773:C, ' 23 885@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 2:G/9? :@G3563@686235/G:C;896396/89,8A 6237:56/3,2:@23C@ 62:6623:;;/@3964:,89:;;8>968A;8<78,/6393?C/?39;3 :, ,>;2 D862 623 6856A3:,85, 9:<3CE 623 @5/G35 8A 623 65>;H :9@ 623 @5/G35 8A 623 </9/ C855E 4353 C/:DC3 F8/96CE :9@ ,3G35:CCE :G/9? 23C@ 62>, A>56235 758;33@3@ 68 :,,3,, :9@ A/B 623 C/:D/C/6E 2/C3 3B8935:6/9? 623 /9,>5:9;3 ;8<7:9E 8A 623 </9/ C855E D3:5/9? 53?/,65:6/89 8# + A/B3@ 623 C/:D/C/6E 89 623 84935 8A 623 ,:/@ C855E 68 623 3B6396 8A'I23 /9,>535 8A 623 65>;H D3:5/9? 53?/,65:6/89 80# 0 428 /, 623 736/6/8935 /9 623,3 736/6/89, 2:, D339 A/B3@ 4/62 +I 8A 623 C/:D/C/6E 23 53C3G:96 7856/89 8A 623 85@35 8A 623 8 85@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 :, A8>9@ :6 7:?3 8+ 8A 623,:/@85@3553:@,:,>9@35% - 21 - ! "# $ % &'&( # ) *( ( # +( , , - . /"0 * 9 A>56235:9;3 68 623 :A853,:/@ F>@?<396 :9@ :4:5@ 7:,,3@ DE 623 885@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 ?5:96/9? ;8<739,:6/89 68623 G/;6/<, 3B3;>6/89736/6/89, 2:G3D339A/C3@ <3<8 8A ;:C;>C:6/89 2:, D339 A/C3@ DE 623 @3;53328C@35/9623,:/@3B3;>6/89758;33@/9?,,6:6/9?623 D:C:9;3 :<8>96 7:E:DC3 DE 623 F>@?<396 @3D685 62353/9 !428 /, 623 736/6/8935 /9 623,3 736/6/89," 9 53,789,3 68 ,:/@ <3<8 8A ;:C;>C:6/89 8DF3;6/89, 4353 A/C3@ DE 623 F>@?<396 @3D685 /9 623 3B3;>6/89 736/6/89, !428 /, 623 736/6/8935/9623,3736/6/89,";89639@/9?62:6623F>@?<396 @3D685 2:, :C53:@E 7:/@ :4:5@ :<8>96 68 623 3B6396 8A +I8A623C/:D/C/6EA/B3@DE62/, 8>56:9@/9A:;62:,7:/@ - 22 - 3B;3,,8A623:<8>96:9@62353/,98C/:D/C/6E89F>@?<396 @3D685#736/6/8935 2353/9 68 7:E :9E :<8>96 684:5@, 623 :4:5@23B3;>6/9? 8>56:A63523:5/9?6237:56/3,:9@ 53A355/9? 68 623 F>@?<396 :9@ :4:5@ 7:,,3@ DE 623 8 85@/9:6339;28A62/, 8>56/9623D:6;28A</,;3CC:938>, A/5,6:773:C,53A3553@68:D8G32:,7:,,3@623/<7>?93@ 85@35,:5:?5:7288A42/;253:@,:,>9@35J *1 * / $( $ 2 (3- , 4 ,# ( 5 , # 6 *) #3 #(. , , 7 8696 ) # 36 # ) : , # ;< =0 ) 6 /, 62/, 85@35 7:,,3@ DE 623 3B3;>6/9? 8>56 7>6/9=>3,6/89/9623,3D:6;28A45/6736/6/89, + 5/:9G39@5: 3@@E C3:593@ ;8>9,3C :773:5/9? A85 623 736/6/8935 6:H/9? 62/, 8>56 3B639,/G3CE 6258>?2 623 F>@?<396 :9@ :4:5@ 7:,,3@ DE 623 8 - 23 - 85@/9:6339;28A62/, 8>56G323<396CE,>D</6,62:662/, 8>5642/C3A/B/9?623C/:D/C/6E8A7:E<3968A;8<739,:6/89 /96235:6/88A'I7:E:DC3DE623849358A623/9/855E D3:5/9? 53?/,65:6/89 8 # + :9@ +I 89 623 736/6/89359,>5:9;3 8<7:9E2:,986/,,>3@:9E,73;/A/; @/53;6/89 68 623 3AA3;6 62:6 623 ;C:/<:96,#@3;533 28C@35, 4/CC 2:G3 : C/D356E 68 ,33H 53;8G35E 8A 623 396/53 ;8<739,:6/89 :<8>96 89CE :?:/9,6 623 736/6/8935 9,>5:9;3 8<7:9E2:6623F>@?<396:9@:4:5@7:,,3@ DE62/, 8>56/,,/C396/962:6:,73;6:,62353/,98;C:5/6E 2353A85323,>D</6,62:66233B3;>6/9? 8>568>?26986 68 2:G3 53F3;63@ 623 8DF3;6/89, 5:/,3@ DE 623 736/6/8935 9,>5:9;3 8<7:9E 6 /, A>56235 ,>D</663@ 62:6 /9 623 :D,39;3 8A :9E ,>;2 @/53;6/89 ?/G39 DE 623 885@/9:63 39;28A62/, 8>56736/6/89359,>5:9;3 8<7:9E4/CCD3 D>5@393@ 4/62 C/:D/C/6E 68 53;8G35 'I 8A 623 :<8>96 42/;2 984 623 3B3;>6/9? 8>56 ,33H 623 736/6/8935 9,>5:9;3 8<7:9E687:E3,>D</6,62:6/9:9E3G396 623 ;C:/<:96,#@3;533 28C@35,# 53,789@396, 2353/9 ;:9986 - 24 - ;288,3 89CE 623 736/6/89359,>5:9;3 8<7:9E :6 623 ,6:?38A3B3;>6/89736/6/89623E2:G/9?<:@3:CC6236856 A3:,85, :, 7:56E /9 623 ;C:/< 736/6/89, 39;3 ,33H, A85 :CC84/9?8A62345/6736/6/89,@/53;6/9?6233B3;>6/9? 8>56 68 53;8G35 623 <893E 89CE 68 623 3B6396 8A +I 8A 623 C/:D/C/6E:9@986D3E89@ > 5/:5,2:G:5@2:9 :C/7:6/C C3:593@ ;8>9,3C A8553,789@396,;C:/<:96,@3;533 28C@35, 53A355/9?687:5:?5:728,:9@8A62385@357:,,3@ DE 623 885@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 :9@ 53CE/9? >789 623 F>@?<396 7:,,3@ DE 623 73B 8>56 /9 623 ;:,3 8A !"# $%#&'(# )'*" #"*%+5378563@/9, -. /,>D</6,62:6 /9623;:,38A623F8/966856A3:,85,/6/,:C4:E,873968623 ;C:/<:96, 68 ,33H 53@53,,:C 8A 623 ?5/3G:9;3 A85 623 7>578,38A53;8G35E8A623;8<739,:6/89A58<:9E8938A 6236856A3:,85,85:?:/9,6:CC8A623<23C:4?/G3,,>;2 : C/D356E :, ,>;2 623 736/6/89359,>5:9;3 8<7:9E - 25 - ;:998653,65/;662/,396/6C3<3968A623;C:/<:96,#F>@?<396 @3D685,#53,789@396, 0 3 A>56235 ,>D</6, 62:6 7:5:?5:728, :9@ 8A623F>@?<396:9@85@357:,,3@DE623 885@/9:63 D39;28A62/, 8>562:,;:63?85/;:CCE<:@3/6;C3:562:6623 C/:D/C/6E 8A 623 648 6856 A3:,85, /, F8/96 :9@ ,3G35:C 2353A853 62353 /, 98 :<D/?>/6E 53=>/5/9? :9E A>56235 ;C:5/A/;:6/89 /9 623 <:6635 39;3 ,33H, A85 @/,</,,:C 8A 62345/6736/6/89, 3:5@35>,3@62353;85@, 3:9/9? 8A 623 635< KF8/96 :9@ ,3G35:CL :, A8>9@/9C:;H1,/;6/89:5E062@/6/8953:@,:,>9@35% 0* #" 1%#2( )-8 #( , #( 4, #1 , # ,? , 0 C3:5CE 623 <3:9/9? ,/<7C/;/685 48>C@ /9@/;:63 62:642393G35623=>3,6/898AKF8/96:9@,3G35:CLC/:D/C/6E /, 68 D3 ;89,/@353@ 623 876/89 /, :C4:E, :G:/C:DC3 68 623 7:56E428/,396/6C3@68@35/G3623D393A/668;288,33/6235 - 26 - 893 D364339 623 648 85 <853 85 :?:/9,6 :CC 23 8 85@/9:6339;28A62/, 8>56:67:5:?5:728,:9@ 8A /6, 85@35 @:63@ '0' 7:,,3@ /9 623 D:6;2 8A /,;3CC:938>, /5,6 773:C, 42/;2 /, 7>6 /968 3B3;>6/89 2:,23C@:,>9@35% %: , ( # # ,( , ( ,, %&. #:2 3# 1"4$"#'"5*%,!)... - 2 6(2#7 * " # , ( 2 # / " ( &@ 9 , && : ( 5,7 A # # -&4 ) ( - 4 -;4 . ) ( ( ( ( , . 8( # - , ,, 40 - 27 - % ( ) ) # #0 ' 73B 8>56 /9 623 ;:,3 8A !,>75:" 6:H/9?98638A623F>@?<3968A623>CC39;28A62/, 8>56 /9 623 ;:,3 8A 3# 1 " 4$" #'" 5 *% 5378563@ /9 !) ... :6 7:5:?5:72 8' C:E/9? @849 623 75/9;/7C3, /9G8CG/9? 623 ;:,3 8A ;8<78,/6393?C/?39;32:,23C@:,>9@35% ; . ) , ( , 5 , *( 5 ) #,, # # ,# , 5 #. , ,, 5 # ( ) 5 , 0 9 , :77C/3@ * 23A:;6,8A623753,396;:,353:@/9623C/?268A 7:5:?5:728,:9@8A62385@357:,,3@DE623 8 85@/9:63 39;2 8A 62/, 8>56 :9@ 623 75/9;/7C3, 8A C:4 - 28 - 39>9;/:63@ DE 623 73B 8>56 /9 623 ;:,3 8A !,>75:" 3B65:;63@ 2353/9 :D8G3 623 /,,>3 8A ;89658G35,E 5:/,3@ /9 623,3 736/6/89, ,6:9@ ;C:5/A/3@ 9 62:6 623 736/6/8935 2353/9 D3/9? 623 /9,>535 8A 623 5>;H D3:5/9? 80# 02:G/9?D33923C@C/:DC3A857:E<3968A +I 8A 623 ;8<739,:6/89 :?:/9,6 428< 623 3B3;>6/89 736/6/89,:53A/C3@/,C/:DC3687:E623396/53:<8>964/62 C/D356E6853;8G35'I8A623:<8>9642/;2/,/93B;3,,8A /6, C/:D/C/6E A58< 623 84935 8A 623 /9/ 855E D3:5/9? 8 # + 85 :?:/9,6 /6, /9,>535 /A 735</,,/DC3 >9@35C:4 /62 623 :D8G3 8D,35G:6/89, 736/6/89, :53 "'" ) 23 /<7>?93@ 85@35 7:,,3@ DE 623 B3;>6/9? 8>56/,;89A/5<3@ ,( &# #' % /,68% C8%)J %