- 1 - ! "#!## #$$ %&'($)* +'), - ! "#$% & ' ( ! )! "#$% & ' *+$ ( ! ) ,,&,&, $%,& # Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ! ! ! ( ) ( ! ( - ! !# - ! ./ 01234567578 67 1$%,& # 17 8./ 964/ 19 8./4/5:7/;#8.;;68617546<64!=;>/57;!6?5@53=:5 A91: B.1:8 C8./ :654 1=:8DE 6B 623=>767> 8./ ?=;>2/78 ;58/; ,,&,&, 50F=68867> 8./ :/B317;/78"500=B/; 91: 8./ 199/70/ 3=76B.5G4/ =7;/: /08617 *$ 19 8./ />1865G4/ 7B8:=2/78B 08 $$ A91: B.1:8 C8./ 08DE , :6/99508B198./05B/5:/8.588./533/445785B 01234567578 964/; 8./ 3:6<58/ 012345678 5>567B8 8./ 500=B/; 544/>67> 01226BB617 19 8./ 199/70/ 3=76B.5G4/ - 3 - =7;/:/08617 *$198./0886B0178/7;/;8.588./ 01234567578"12357@ 6B 5 967570654 012357@ 3:1<6;67> 967570654 ./43 91: 3=:0.5B67> </.604/B ./ 500=B/; /78/:/; 6781 5 4157"0=2".@318./058617 5>://2/78 ;58/; ,% ,,& , 91: 8./ 3=:31B/ 19 3=:0.5B67> 585 ./5<@ </.604/ G/5:67> />1"*# &#% 91: B##&&&&" ./ 500=B/; .5; 718 :/356; 8./ 4157 521=78 5B 5>://; ./:/ H5B 5 B/884/2/78 5>://2/78 G/8H//7 8./ 01234567578 57; 8./ 500=B/; 5001:;67> 81 H.60. 8./ 500=B/; 5>://; 81 :/35@ 8./ B/884/; 521=78 19 B+#&&&&" 1H5:;B :/35@2/78 19 B=0. B/884/2/78 521=78 8./ 0./F=/ I " H5B 6BB=/; 17 * ,& (./7 8./ 0./F=/ H5B 3:/B/78/; 91: /705B.2/78 8./ B52/ H5B ;6B.171=:/; 5B 8./:/ H5B 67B=99606/78 9=7; 67 8./5001=78198./500=B/;4/>5471860/H5B6BB=/;81 8./500=B/; 71869@67> .62 5G1=88./;6B.171=: 19 0./F=/ 57; 054467> =317 .62 81 :/35@ 8./ 0./F=/ 521=78 7B8/5;19:/35@67>8./0./F=/521=788./500=B/;.5; 6BB=/;:/34@5B3/: I "%86BB858/;8.588./500=B/; - 4 - .5; 5>://; 81 :/35@ 8./ 0./F=/ 521=78 57; 8./:/G@ 0122688/;57199/70/3=76B.5G4/=7;/:/08617 *$19 08 001:;67>4@ 5 3:6<58/ 012345678 H5B 052/ 81 G/ 964/; * ./ 500=B/; .5B 533/5:/; G/91:/ 8./ :654 1=:857;34/5;/;718>=648@./01234567578/I5267/; (" 57; >18 25:J/; IB " 81 "$ 67 B=331:8 19 68B 0178/7861700=B/;;/76/;5448./670:62675867>258/:654B 5<5645G4/ 17 :/01:; G=8 .5B 718 4/; 57@ /<6;/70/ 67 B=331:819.6B;/9/70/./:6541=:8598/:85J67>6781 017B6;/:58617 544 8./B/ 258/:654B 17 :/01:; 052/ 81 5 01704=B6178.588./01234567578.5B7183:1</;8./>=64819 8./ 500=B/; G/@17; :/5B175G4/ ;1=G8 001:;67>4@ 35BB/; 8./ 623=>7/; ?=;>2/78 50F=68867> 8./ 500=B/; /67> 5>>:6/</; G@ 8./ B52/ 8./ 01234567578 6B G/91:/ 8.6B1=:8 /5:; 8./ 4/5:7/; 01=7B/4 533/5:67> 91: 8./ 533/44578/B317;/788.1=>.B/:</;H68.8./71860/.5B - 5 - :/2567/; =7":/3:/B/78/; /:=B/; 8./ 258/:654B 6704=;67>8./:6541=:8:/01:;B # 7 <6/H 19 8./ 0178/78617B =:>/; G@ 4/5:7/; 01=7B/491:8./533/445788./316788.58H1=4;5:6B/91:2@ 017B6;/:586176B @57BH/:818./5G1</316786B678./CD91: 8./91441H67> % 86B8./0178/78617198./012345675788.588./ 500=B/; .5; /78/:/; 6781 5 4157"0=2".@318./058617 5>://2/78 ;58/; ,% ,,& , H.60. 6B 3:1;=0/; 5B 3/: I "+B3/:8.6B;10=2/788./500=B/;.5;G1::1H/; 5B=219B##&&&&"91:3=:0.5B/19./5<@</.604/./ 5001=78B858/2/786B3:1;=0/;5B3/: I "$B3/:8.6B ;10=2/78 5 B=2 19 B&+,&$ H5B ;=/ 5B 17 - 6 - * ,& 6/ 5B 17 8./;58/ 19 8./ 0./F=/ 86B 718 /I34567/;G@8./012345675785B81H.@8./0./F=/ I " H5B 6BB=/; 91: B+#&&&&" H./7 8./ 521=78 ;=/ H5B 174@B&+," + 8 6B 8./ 0178/78617 19 8./ 01234567578 8.58 8./:/H5B5B/884/2/785>://2/7857;8./500=B/;5>://; 81 35@ B+#&&&&" (./7 8./ 521=78 ;=/ 68B/49 H5B B&+," 8./:/ H5B 5GB14=8/4@ 71 :/5B17 91: 8./ 500=B/; 81 5>:// 81 35@ B+#&&&&" 1:/1</: 8./ 01234567578 6B 5 967570654 012357@ 1 ;10=2/78 6B 3:1;=0/;81B.1H8.588./500=B/;.5B5>://;81B/884/58 B+#&&&&"8057718G/B56;8.5868.5B/78/:/;6781 8./B/884/2/781:544@H68.8./500=B/; I "%6B8./:/34@ 81 8./ 71860/ 6BB=/; G@ 8./ 500=B/; B3/06960 ;/9/70/ H5B85J/7G@8./500=B/;8.5857521=7819B+#&&&&" H5B 718 ;=/ 9:12 .62 ./:/ H5B 71 B=0. B/884/2/78 G/8H//7 8./ 35:86/B ./ 0./F=/ I " H5B 5 G457J 0./F=/ 1G8567/; G@ 8./ 01234567578 58 8./ 862/ 19 - 7 - /78/:67> 6781 8./ 4157"0=2".@318./058617 5>://2/78 57; 8./B52/H5B26B=B/;G@8./01234567578 $ (./7 8./ 5001=78 B858/2/78 I "$ 6B 85J/7 6781 017B6;/:58617 8./ 500=B/; .5B 3:1G5G46K/; .6B ;/9/70/./01234567578.5B0178/7;/;8.588./500=B/; .5; 5>://; 81 :/35@ B+#&&&&" 91: 8./ 4157 521=78 8.58 H5B 19 B##&&&&" 8.1=>. 8./ 521=78 8.58 H5B ;=/ 5B 17 8./ ;58/ 19 0./F=/ H5B 174@ B&+," =0.0178/78617B057718G/500/38/;/70/52198./ 1367617 8.58 8./ 01234567578 6B 718 B=00/BB9=4 67 3:1<67> 68B 0178/78617 7;/: B=0. 06:0=2B8570/B 8./ G/7/968 19 ;1=G8 H644 .5</ 81 G//I8/7;/; 81 8./ 500=B/; 57; ./ 6B /78684/;81G/50F=688/; .5</>17/8.:1=>.8./623=>7/;?=;>2/7819 8./ :654 1=:8 H.60. .5B 533:/0658/; 8./ 258/:654 17 :/01:;57;.5B:6>.84@35BB/;8./623=>7/;?=;>2/78 ;1718967;57@:/5B1781678/:9/:/H68.8./B52//70/ 3:10//;8135BB8./91441H67> - 8 - ./ 533/54 6B ./ 623=>7/; ?=;>2/78 57; 1:;/: ;58/;,,&,&, 35BB/; G@ 8./ #8. ;;6861754 6<64 !=;>/ 57; ! 6?5@53=:5 67 1$%,& # 6B .* '##) ! ( 6B81 41*,