Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43286 (KAR)

VISHWANATH v. VIJAYKUMAR AND ANR

MFA/200560/2022 · 2025-09-17

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! ! "#! "# !! $%& ' !" #$$ % & ' ( ) ('*' Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $+ $ ) '*" #$ % ,"- *'*."*"" ' $ & , $$ , '!%'& , $ , **"*"'$ "!* "*' $ , /*''( /0 /' **** '"0 $$ , 1 $ 1 , - 3 - # %$1 $ & 234566758349387:;<:7=7>?3@<'!%'&@9?27@?@= 723>874 >? 6=5A3<B ?@ C@:39A ?27 D;:BC7<? 5<: 5E5=: :5?7:**"*"'65447:3<@"!* "*'FA?277<3@= 3G38;:B75<:::3?3@<58@?@=>>3:7<?853C4 =3F;<585? 258H3%27=73<59?7==797==7:?@54I?27 =3F;<58J& " ,5>?;58C5?=3K@9?27>54734?25?@<!**/"*' ?27 >853C5<? E54 6=@>77:3<B @< 234 C@?@=>A>87 F75=3<B =7B34?=5?3@< @!. /..' 5? ?25? ?3C7 >5= F75=3<B =7B34?=5?3@< @!. '* >5C7 9=@C F723<: 3< 5 23B2 4677:5<:3<5=5425<:<7B83B7<?C5<<7=5<::5427:?@?27 C@?@=>A>87 @9 ?27 >853C5<? ;7 ?@ E23>2 27 4;4?53<7: 3<D;=374?@275:5<:?27=7E54F8@@:>8@?3<?27F=53<45 =74;8?@9?275>>3:7<?234879?;667=5<:8@E7=83CF4F7>5C7 G7=AE75H5<:27>5<<@?C@G7234879?43:7@9?27F@:A5<: 272544;997=7:65=5687B357<>7?2767?3?3@<7=9387:>853C 67?3?3@< F79@=7 ?27 =3F;<58 ;<:7= 7>?3@< '// @9 ?27 >? 477H3<B >@C67<45?3@<9@= ?273<D;=374 4;4?53<7:3<?27 =@5: ?=5993>5>>3:7<? - 4 - ! 27 =3F;<58 59?7= >@<43:7=3<B ?27 C5?7=358 @< =7>@=:5<:=7>@=:3<B?277G3:7<>75E5=:7:>@C67<45?3@<@9 4/*''( E3?2 3<?7=74? 5? ?27 =5?7 @9 /0 67= 5<<;C 9=@C?27:5?7@967?3?3@<?388?27:5?7@9=7583L5?3@<5<:278: ?25?=746@<:7<?@4'5<:"5=7D@3<?8A5<:47G7=588A835F87 ?@65A?27>@C67<45?3@< ( 73<B 5BB=37G7: FA ?27 3C6;B<7: D;:BC7<? 5<: 5E5=: 65447: FA ?27 =3F;<58 ?27 >853C5<? 254 9387: ?234 566758477H3<B7<25<>7C7<?@9>@C67<45?3@< ? 34 >@<?7<:7: FA ?27 875=<7: >@;<478 9@= 5667885<??25??27:@>?@=2545447447:?2762A43>58:345F383?A 5?/*0?@*0?@?27879?43:7@9?27F@:A;??27 =3F;<58 254 5447447: ?27 67=C5<7<? :345F383?A 5? "0 E23>2 34 @< ?278@E7=43:7 27 =3F;<582548@4?43B2?@9?2795>??25?27 25:4;997=7:65=5687B355<:27>5<<@?C@G7879?43:7@9?27 F@:A 27 =3F;<58 @;B2? ?@ 25G7 ?5H7< ?27 9;<>?3@<58 :345F383?A5?'**0E2387:7?7=C3<3<B?27>@C67<45?3@<?34 584@>@<?7<:7:?25?54?27>853C5<?2544;997=7:65=5687B35 27 34 :767<:7<? @< ?27 5??7<:5<? ? 34 >@<?7<:7: ?25? ?27 - 5 - >853C5<? E54 5B7: 5F@;? " A75=4 5? ?27 ?3C7 @9 5>>3:7<? 5<: 27 E54 75=<3<B 4!**** 67= C@<?2 FA :@3<B 5B=3>;8?;=58 E@=H 2@;B2 ?27 =3F;<58 254 5E5=:7: >@C67<45?3@< @< G5=3@;4 275:4 F;? ?27 45C7 34 G7=A C75B7= < ?2747 B=@;<:4 27 477H4 ?@ 7<25<>7 ?27 >@C67<45?3@< / $7= >@<?=5 875=<7: >@;<478 56675=3<B 9@= ?27 =746@<:7<?<4;=5<>7 @C65<A G727C7<?8A >@<?7<:7: ?25? ?5H3<B<@?7@9?277G3:7<>7@9?27:@>?@=E2@2545447447: ?27:345F383?A5?/*0?@*0?@?272589F@:A?27 =3F;<58 254 =3B2?8A 5447447: ?27 :345F383?A 5? "0 5<: 27<>7 ?27 M;74?3@<@9?5H3<B?27:345F383?A5?'**0:@74<@?5=347 27 =3F;<58 254 <@? >@CC3??7: 5<A 7==@= 3< 5447443<B ?27 C5?7=358 5G5385F87 @< =7>@=: 5<: =3B2?8A 5E5=:7: D;4? >@C67<45?3@< 5<: ?27=79@=7 3? :@74 <@? =7M;3=7 5<A 3<?7=97=7<>7 5G3<B 275=: ?27 875=<7: >@;<478 9@= ?27 5667885<? >853C5<? 5<: ?27 875=<7: >@;<478 9@= ?27 - 6 - =746@<:7<?<4;=5<>7@C65<A?276@3<?4?25?E@;8:5=347 9@=@;=>@<43:7=5?3@<5=7 5G3<B 275=: ?27 =7467>?3G7 >@;<4784 5<: @< 67=;458@9?27C5?7=358@<=7>@=:@>>;==7<>7@95>>3:7<?5<: ?27 =74;8?5<? 3<D;=374 4;997=7: FA ?27 >853C5<? 5=7 <@? 3< :346;?7 27@<8A344;73<G@8G7:3<?23456675834E3?2=7B5=: ?@?275E5=:@9D;4?5<:=754@<5F87>@C67<45?3@< . 27E@;<:>7=?393>5?7:34>8@474?25??27>853C5<? E54 5B7: 5F@;? A75=4 5? ?27 ?3C7 @9 5>>3:7<? < ?27 >25=B7 4277? 3? 34 C7<?3@<7: 54 (* A75=4 5<: 3< ?27 7K5C3<5?3@< 3< >2379 >853C5<?J4 5B7 34 C7<?3@<7: 54 * A75=47<>7?27 =3F;<58?@@H?275B7@9?27:7>7547:54 A75=4 2@;B2?27>853C5<?254>@<?7<:7:?25?27E54 75=<3<B 4!**** 67= C@<?2 ?@ 4;F4?5<?35?7 ?27 45C7 ?27>853C5<?254<@?6=@:;>7:5<A:@>;C7<?5=A6=@@9< - 7 - ?275F47<>7@93<>@C76=@@9?27<@?3@<583<>@C7254?@F7 ?5H7<5467=?27>25=?@9?275=<5?5H5?5?77B587=G3>7 ;?2@=3?A 4 67= ?27 >25=? 9@= ?27 5>>3:7<? @9 ?27 A75= "*' <@?3@<58 3<>@C7 254 ?@ F7 ?5H7< 5? 4 *** 67= C@<?2 5<: ?27 =3F;<58 254 =3B2?8A ?5H7< ?27 3<>@C7 5? 4 *** 67=C@<?2 '* 27 =3F;<58 254 95387: ?@ ?5H7 <@?7 @9 ?27 7G3:7<>7@9?27:@>?@=E2@347;=@4;=B7@< 27:@>?@=254 >5?7B@=3>588A :76@47: ?25? ?27 >853C5<? 25: 4;4?53<7:275: 3<D;=A:;7?@E23>227254;<:7=B@<7@67=5?3@<54?27=7E54 F8@@: >8@? 3< ?27 F=53< 7 E54 @67=5?7: 9@= 275: 3<D;=A 7G5>;5?7F8@@:>8@?3<?27F=53<% &7254584@:76@47: ?25??27>853C5<?>5<<@?C@G7234879?43:7F@:A6@=?3@<:;7 ?@E23>2?27;667=5<:8@E7=83CF4F7>5C7G7=AE75H5<: @<7 5??7<:7= 34 =7M;3=7: 9@= C@G7C7<? 5<: ?@ ?5H7 >5=7 @9 ?2765?37<? 27=79@=7272545447447:?27:345F383?A5?/*0 ?@*0?@?272589F@:A 27 =3F;<58E3?2@;?>@<43:7=3<B ?2745C75<:E3?2@;?5443B<3<B5<A=754@<2545447447:?27 :345F383?A 5? "0 5<: ?27 45C7 34 @< ?27 8@E7= 43:7 27 @;=? 254 ?@ ?5H7 <@?7 @9 ?27 9;<>?3@<58 :345F383?A @9 ?27 - 8 - 67=4@< 27< 5 67=4@< 34 ;<5F87 ?@ :@ 5<A E@=H 5<: 34 67=C5<7<?8A4;997=3<B9=@C$5=5687B355<:>5<<@?C@G7234 879?43:7F@:A6@=?3@<25G3<B8@4?>@<?=@8@G7=?27;667=5<: 8@E7=83CF43?>5<<@?F77K67>?7:?25?27>5<:@5<AE@=H 3<9;?;=7 27@<JF8767K@;=?3<?27>547@9 ! =76@=?7: 3< "#$##%&'()#$*E27=73<9@=/.0:345F383?A?27@<JF87 67K @;=? ?@@H :345F383?A 5? '**0 < ?27 6=747<? >547 584@ ?27 >853C5<? 254 4;997=7: 65=5687B35 7<>7 ?27 9;<>?3@<58:345F383?A@9?27>853C5<?345447447:5?'**0 '' 27 =3F;<58 254 5E5=:7: 5 4;C @9 4'**** ?@E5=:4 653< 5<: 4;997=3<B 5<: ?27 45C7 34 ?@@ C75B7= @<43:7=3<B?27<5?;=7@93<D;=3744;4?53<7:FA?27>853C5<? ?27 45C7 34 7<25<>7: ?@ 4'***** 54 5B53<4? 4'**** 5E5=:7:FA?27 =3F;<58 '" 547:@<?27:@>;C7<?5=A7G3:7<>7?27 =3F;<58 254 5E5=:7: 5 4;C @9 4('''( ?@E5=:4 C7:3>58 7K67<4745<:27<>7?2745C734=7?53<7: - 9 - '! 27 =3F;<58 254 5E5=:7: 5 4;C @9 4'*** ?@E5=:4 >@<G7A5<>7 5??7<:5<? >25=B74 5<: <@;=342C7<? @<43:7=3<B ?27 67=3@: @9 ?=75?C7<? ?27 45C7 34 7<25<>7: ?@ 4(**** 54 5B53<4? 4'*** 5E5=:7: FA ?27 =3F;<58 '( 3<>7 ?234 @;=? 254 5447447: ?27 9;<>?3@<58 :345F383?A@9?27>853C5<?5?'**0?27M;74?3@<@95E5=:3<B >@C67<45?3@< ?@E5=:4 8@44 @9 3<>@C7 :;=3<B ?=75?C7<? 67=3@::@74<@?5=347 ' < G37E @9 D;:BC7<? @9 ?27 @<JF87 ;6=7C7 @;=?3<>547@9+( ,( - ./ + * 01(/ =76@=?7: 3< "#$#2% #$ ( 334 7G7< 3< 67=4@<58 3<D;=A >853C4 9;?;=7 6=@467>?4 5=7 =7M;3=7: ?@ F7 5::7: ?@ C@<?28A 3<>@C7 5H3<B <@?7 @9 95>? ?25? ?27 >853C5<?E54A75=4@95B75<:47897C68@A7:'*0254?@ F75::7:5467=?27:7>343@<@9?27@<JF87;6=7C7@;=? 3< ?27 >547 @9 5 ! . 1 5( =76@=?7:3<"#$&3%&)()6$5<: ?2756683>5F87C;8?36837=E@;8:F7'' 2;4?27>853C5<?34 - 10 - 7<?3?87:?@54;C@94''/'/** N%4 ***O'*0&K'"K '**0+''P?@E5=:48@44@99;?;=73<>@C7 '/ 27 =3F;<58 254 5E5=:7: 5 4;C @9 4"**** ?@E5=:48@44@95C7<3?3745<:;<25663<744@<43:7=3<B?27 5B7@9?27>853C5<?5<:<5?;=7@93<D;=3745<:?27:345F383?A 4;997=7:FA?27>853C5<?5?'**0?2745C7347<25<>7:?@ 4'***** 54 5B53<4? 4'**** 5E5=:7: FA ?27 =3F;<58 ' @E >@C3<B ?@ ?27 5467>? @9 <@<5E5=:3<B @9 5<A >@C67<45?3@< ?@E5=:4 5??7<:5<? >25=B74 ?27 @<JF87 67K @;=? 3< ?27 >547 @9 %4;6=5& 5E5=:7: 5??7<:5<?>25=B745?4*** 67=C@<?2E23>2>@C74?@ 4/**** 67=5<<;C5G3<B>@<43:7=7:?27C;8?36837=@9 ' 5::3?3@<58 >@C67<45?3@< ;<:7= ?234 275: >5C7 ?@ 4'* **** @E7G7=3<?234>54725G3<B>@<43:7=7:?27 C;8?36837= @9 '' 43<>7 ?27 >853C5<? 34 5B7: A75=4 3? >@C74?@//**** %4*** K'"K''& ' 27 =3F;<58 254<@? 5E5=:7:5<A >@C67<45?3@< ?@E5=:4 9;?;=7 C7:3>58 7K67<474 5G3<B >@<43:7=3<B ?27 - 11 - <5?;=7 @9 3<D;=374 5<: ?27 >853C5<? 254 4;997=7: '**0 :345F383?A54;C@94'***** 345E5=:7:?@E5=:49;?;=7 C7:3>587K67<474 '. >>@=:3<B8A 3< 588 ?27 >853C5<? 34 7<?3?87: 9@= ?@?58 >@C67<45?3@< @9 4"/'"'( 54 5B53<4? 4/*''( 5E5=:7: FA ?27 =3F;<58 7<>7 E7 5<4E7= ?276@3<?@'65=?8A3<5993=C5?3G7 "* @C67<45?3@< =75447447: FA ?234 @;=? 34 54 9@88@E4 75:4 @C67<45?3@< 5E5=:7:FA?27 =3F;<58 @C67<45?3@< 5E5=:7:FA?234 @;=? $53<5<:4;997=3<B 4'**** 4'***** 7:3>587K67<474 4('''( 4('''( @<G7A5<>7 5??7<:5<? >25=B74 5<: <@;=342C7<? 4'*** 4(**** @44 @9 9;?;=7 75=<3<B >565>3?A @< 5>>@;<? @9 67=C5<7<?:345F383?374 4"/(*** 4''/'/** @44 @9 5C7<3?374 5<: ;<25663<744 4"**** 4'***** ??7<:5<?>25=B74 38 4//**** ,;?;=7 C7:3>58 7K67<474 38 4'***** ()* + ,- + ,- - 12 - "' 2;4 ?27 >853C5<? 34 7<?3?87: 9@= 5< 7<25<>7: >@C67<45?3@<@94' "/** "" < G37E @9 ?27 :34>;443@<4 C5:7 5F@G7 E7 6=@>77:?@6544?279@88@E3<B 3 2756675834588@E7:3<65=? 33 27 3C6;B<7: D;:BC7<? 5<: 5E5=: :5?7: **"*"' 65447: FA ?27 7<3@= 3G38 ;:B7 5<:::3?3@<58@?@=>>3:7<?853C4 =3F;<58 5?258H33<@"!* "*'34C@:3937: 333 27 >853C5<? 34 7<?3?87: ?@ >@C67<45?3@< @9 4"/'"'( 54 5B53<4? 4/*''( 5E5=:7: FA ?27 =3F;<58 E3?2 3<?7=74? 5? /0 67= 5<<;C 9=@C ?27 :5?7 @9 67?3?3@< ?388 ?27 :5?7@9=7583L5?3@< 3G 27 =746@<:7<?<4;=5<>7 @C65<A 34 :3=7>?7: ?@ :76@43? ?27 7<25<>7: >@C67<45?3@< 5C@;<? E3?23< 43K E77H4 9=@C ?27:5?7@9=7>736?@9>@6A@9?234D;:BC7<? - 13 - G 27 7B34?=A 34 :3=7>?7: ?@ ?=5<4C3? ?27 =7>@=:4 ?@ ?27 =3F;<58 ?@ 7<5F87 ?27 >853C5<? ?@ E3?2:=5E ?27 >@C67<45?3@< 5C@;<? .- $!& # .- $& #/.01 34?@'8@" ?