- 1 - ! " #$ %#&'()*#'' + ! ! "# "!!$ !%$ ! & &! '# (#!(# ! ! ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! ()!( $ *! ! ! + !! (( ) ! ! ! *! ! *! ! (, & ( $ -!! *! ! ! +!!(( ) ! ! ! *! ! *! !*! &!$ ! ! " " . * " ". * /, 010, 0/2345/ 36174601 389:, 181;42159 ;,9<5 0/, :3=>819<1<0 9< >,:918 1?, 3 ) 36174601 3< 0/, @98, 3@ 0/, 8,12<,A 29<:9>18 ,??93<? *4A5,B>,:918*4A5, 181;42159/,2,9<1@0,22,@,22,A03 1? C2918 3420D 9? 9=>45<9<5 0/, E4A5=,<0 A10,A - 3 - (( 1:F49009<5 0/, 2,?>3<A,<01::4?,A @32 0/, 3@@,<:, >4<9?/1;8, 4<A,2 ,:093< (, 2 G ( 3@ 2,H,<093< 3@ 3224>093< :0 - I@32 ?/320 C0/, :0DJ ,12A 29 4;/1?/ 1881>42 8,12<,A >,:918 4;89: 23?,:4032 @32 0/, 1>>,881<036174601 1<A 29 1?/9<10/ 3"9A21=17719A126120/,2,?>3<A,<0>1207 9<>,2?3<,24?,A0/,=10,2918?3<2,:32A ( < H9,G 3@ 0/, 29H18 :3<0,<093<? 425,A ;7 8,12<,A:34<?,8@32;30/0/,>1209,?0/,>39<00/10G348A 129?,@32=7:3<?9A,21093<9?" ' 7 1<?G,2 03 0/, 1;3H, >39<0 9? 9< 0/, CD@320/,@3883G9<5" /,!,>4074>,29<0,<A,<03@389:, 12<10161 36174601 181;42159 ?4;=900,A 0/, :/125, ?/,,0 @32 - 4 - >23?,:409<5 0/, 1::4?,A @32 0/, 1@32,?19A 3@@,<:,? 0 9? 0/, :3<0,<093< 3@ 0/, >23?,:4093< 0/10 0/, 1::4?,A G1? 1>>39<0,A 1? ??9?01<0 <59<,,2 9< 4;89: &326? !,>120=,<03<)-(1<A?,2H,A10A9@@,2,<0>81:,? 9<A9@@,2,<0:1>1:909,?/,36174601389:,03360/,:/,:6 >,293A @23= )-( 03 -' 03 H,29@7 0/, 1??,0?891;98909,?9<:3=,1<A,K>,<A9042,?3@0/,1::4?,A 03 @9<A 340 1? 03 G/,0/,2 /, /1? 1=1??,A G,180/ A9?>23>32093<10,03/9?6<3G<?342:,3@9<:3=,::32A9<5 03 0/, >23?,:4093< /, /1? 1:F492,A 1??,0? G320/ ?)( 1<A /1? 9<:422,A ,K>,<A9042, 3@ ?)# /4? 0/, 03018 1??,0? 1<A ,K>,<A9042, 24<? 03 ?)(- G/,2,1? 0/, 9<:3=, @23= 0/, 6<3G< ?342:, 9? 3<87 ?-' /4? 0/,2, G1? A9?>23>32093<10, 1??,0? 3@ ?-) G/9:/ G1? ,?09=10,A 10 '))-L =32, 0/1< 0/, 6<3G< ?342:, 3@ 9<:3=,/4?909?0/,:3<0,<093<3@0/,>23?,:4093<0/10 0/, 1::4?,A /1? 1=1??,A A9?>23>32093<10, G,180/ 1<A :3==900,A=9?:3<A4:0 - 5 - # <32A,203>23H,90?:3<0,<093<0/,>23?,:4093< ,K1=9<,A&?03(1<A530=126,AK?03'9< ?4>>320 3@ 90? :3<0,<093< /,1::4?,A /1?A,<9,A188 0/, 9<:29=9<109<5 =10,2918? 1H1981;8, 3< 2,:32A 9< /9? ?010,=,<04<A,2,:093<((2;40/1?<30:/3?,<03 8,1A1<7,H9A,<:,9<?4>>320/9?A,@,<:,/,29183420 1@0,2 0169<5 9<03 :3<?9A,21093< 188 0/,?, =10,2918? 3< 2,:32A:1=,030/,:3<:84?93<0/100/,>23?,:4093<9?<30 ?4::,??@48 9< >23H9<5 0/, 54980 3@ 0/, 1::4?,A ;,73<A 2,1?3<1;8, A34;0 ::32A9<587 >1??,A 0/, 9=>45<,A E4A5=,<0 3@ 1:F490018 ,9<5 15529,H,A ;7 0/, ?1=, 0/, 1>>,881<09?;,@32,0/9?3420 ) ,12<,A :34<?,8 @32 0/, 1>>,881<0 :3<0,<A,A 0/10,H,<0/345/(A3:4=,<0?G,2,,K/9;90,A;,@32,0/, 2918 3420 90 /1? :3==900,A 1< ,2232 9< 0169<5 9<03 :3<?9A,21093< 1? =1<7 1? ' A3:4=,<0? 03 2,:32A 0/, 1:F490018 3@ 1::4?,A < 539<5 0/2345/ 0/, 32A,2 ?/,,0 A10,A =19<019<,A ;7 0/, 2918 3420 90 9? ?010,A 0/10 0/, 8,12<,A >,:918 4;89: 23?,:4032 /1? - 6 - >23A4:,A ?,H,218 A3:4=,<0? 183<5 G90/ 0/, =,=3 1<A 0/3?, A3:4=,<0? G,2, =126,A G90/ :3<?,<0 ;7 0/, 8,12<,A :34<?,8 2,>2,?,<09<5 0/, 1::4?,A ::32A9<587 ?,H,218G90<,??,?:90,A9<0/,:/125,?/,,0G,2,59H,<4> /4? K? 03 ' :1=, 03 ;, =126,A 1<A 0/,2,1@0,2 0/,=100,2G1?>3?0,A@322,:32A9<50/,?010,=,<03@0/, 1::4?,A 4<A,2 ,:093< (( 3@ 2 <A,2 ?4:/ :92:4=?01<:,? 0/, :3<0,<093< 219?,A ;7 0/, 8,12<,A :34<?,8@320/,1>>,881<00/100/,29183420/1?2,@,22,A 03?,H,218A3:4=,<0?G/9:/G,2,<,H,2=126,A:1<<30;, 1::,>0,A /, <,K0 :3<0,<093< 219?,A ;7 0/, 8,12<,A :34<?,8 @32 0/, 1>>,881<0 9? 0/10 0/, 2918 3420 /1? <30 >23>,287 H184,A 0/, 538A,< E,G,829,? 0/10 G,2, ?,9M,A A429<50/,219A/,29183420/1?@34<A0/100/,1::4?,A G1?9<>3??,??93<3@'))521=?3@538A,<1209:8,?0 1>>,12? 0/10 0/, >23?,:4093< /1? <30 >23A4:,A 1<7 =10,2918? 03 ?/3G 0/, ,K1:0 H184, 3@ 0/, 538A,< 1209:8,? 1<A 1?03 G/,< 0/,?1=, G,2, 1:F492,A;70/, 1::4?,A - 7 - <A,2 ?4:/ :92:4=?01<:,? 0/, 2918 3420 G90/ ?3=, 54,?? G326 H184,A 0/, 538A,< 1209:8,? G/9:/ :1<<30 ;, @34<A@1480G90/,12<,A:34<?,8@320/,1>>,881<0/1?<30 A9?>40,A1<730/,2?>,:9@9:90,=?016,<9<03:3<?9A,21093< ;70/,29183420<A,2?4:/:92:4=?01<:,?A3<30@9<A 1<7988,51890732>,2H,2?9079<0/,E4A5=,<0>1??,A;70/, 2918 3420 3 30/,2 5234<A? 12, 425,A ;7 0/, 8,12<,A :34<?,8@320/,1>>,881<0 - 0 9? ?,008,A >3?9093< 3@ 81G 0/10 4<8,?? 0/, >23?,:4093< 9? ?4::,??@48 9< >23H9<5 0/10 0/, 1::4?,A /1? 1=1??,A G,180/ A9?>23>32093<10, 03 /9? 6<3G< ?342:, 3@ 9<:3=, 1<A ?4:/ A9?>23>32093<10, 1??,0 9? 108,1?0 L =32, 0/,< /, 9? 891;8, @32 >23?,:4093< 1<A :3<H9:093< &/,<<3?4:/?>,:9@9:5234<A?12,=1A,340A3<30@9<A 1<7 2,1?3< 03 9<0,2@,2, G90/ 0/, 9=>45<,A E4A5=,<0 3@ 1:F490018 >1??,A ;7 0/, 2918 3420 ,<:, G90/340 A9?:4??9<5=4:/1;3400/,9=>45<,AE4A5=,<0>1??,A;7 0/,291834201<?G,20/,1;3H,>39<09<0/,CD 1<A>23:,,A03>1??0/,@3883G9<5" - 8 - /,1>>,189? ,( # ' " 9?03"83" "