- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! "" # $ !% %&% ' ' (&)& ' # ( ( !(&)& ' $'* '' # $ $ + $ , $ $ # ''' ! %-)' % $ "+'"( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %+'"( $ # $ $ $ # . . / # 012 344536 12 475857759 :; <05 =631>3?< 3@31?2< <05 A9@>5?< 3?9 3B379 93<59 ''' 432259 1? C %-)' % :; <05 71?=1436 5?1C7 1D16A9@5 3?9 !363:A73@18C720C7<E<05<71:A?36F255G1?@5?03?=5>5?<C8 <05=C>45?23<1C? ' 05=631>3?<3@59'-;5372>5<B1<03==195?<C? '" & ' % 3?9 2A885759 @715DCA2 1?HA7152 5 81659 =631> 45<1<1C? :58C75 <05 <71:A?36 255G1?@ =C>45?23<1C? C8 2 (36C?@B1<01?<5752< 05<71:A?36=C?219571?@ <05 5?<175 5D195?=5 C? 75=C79 3B37959 3 2A> C8 2 "+'"( 36C?@ B1<0 1?<5752< 3< <05 73<5 C8 -I 457 3??A> 87C> <05 93<5 C8 45<1<1C? <166<05 93<5 C8 75361J3<1C? @@715D59:;<052319A9@>5?<3?93B379<05=631>3?<032 - 3 - 475857759 <05 47525?< 344536 255G1?@ 5?03?=5>5?< C8 <05 =C>45?23<1C? ?<0547525?<3445361<12=C?<5?959<03<<05 =631>3?<B32537?1?@2 &(457>C?<0 05C=<C7032 32252259 <05 9123:161<; 3< -I :A< <05 <71:A?36 032 <3G5? 'IB01=012C?6CB572195 053>CA?<2@73?<59A?957<05 C<05705392375362CC?>53@573?9<05758C7575KA52<598C7 5?03?=5>5?< C8 <05 =C>45?23<1C? < 12 8A7<057 2A:>1<<59 <03< 1< 12 <05 =325 C8 <05 ?C 971D1?@ 61=5?=5 <05758C75 75KA52<598C743;3?975=CD57; 0CA@0 <05 =631>3?< 032 2<3<59 <03< 05 B32 537?1?@ 3 2A> C8 2 &( 457 >C?<0 05 032 ?C< 81659 3?;1?=C>547CC8<C47CD50121?=C>5 5>5<B1<03==195?< C?'" & ' <05758C75<05<71:A?3603271@0<6;<3G5?<05 1?=C>5 C8 <05 =631>3?< 3< 2 '&( 3?9 1< ?5592 ?C 1?<578575?=5 05 =631>3?< B32 3@59 '- ;5372 5?=5 <05 >A6<146157 12 E +F 05 =631>3?< 2A2<31?59 873=<A75 C8 71@0< 85>A7 873=<A75 C8 71@0< <1:13 873=<A75 C8 71@0< 81:A63 3?9 C<0571?HA715232457<05BCA?9=57<181=3<5>37G593< L 05 =631>3?< 5L3>1?59 <05 C=<C7 32 # ' 05 C=<C7 32252259<059123:161<;=57<181=3<5A?957 L )3?932252259 - 4 - <059123:161<;32-I<C<05B0C65:C9; 537?59=CA?2568C7 <05 7524C?95?< 37@A59 <03< <05 <71:A?36 032 <3G5? 79 C8 -I32 'I3?91<?559?C<:51?<5785759B1<0 05=631>3?< 032 2A885759 873=<A75 C8 71@0< 85>A7 873=<A75 C8 71@0< <1:13 873=<A75C871@0<81:A633?9C<057>A6<14651?HA7152 05758C75 <012 CA7< 81?92 1< 7532C?3:65 <C <3G5 <05 9123:161<; 32 'I 1?2<539C8 'I 5?=5<056C22C89545?95?=;1232A?957. 2 '&(, ', +,'IM2 &"-( " 05 =631>3?< 032 ?C< 81659 3?; 912=037@5 2A>>37; <C 20CB <05 4571C9 C8 0C241<361J3<1C? C?219571?@ <053@5C==A43<1C?3?9?3<A75C81?HA7152<012CA7<81?921< 7532C?3:65<C3B37932A>C82 &(<CB3792431?3?9 2A88571?@ 2 &( <CB3792 6C22 C8 3>5?1<152 3?9 2 ( <CB3792 <73?24C7<3<1C? 5L<73 ?CA7120>5?< 3?9 3<<5?93?< =037@52 05 <71:A?36 3B37959 3 2A> C8 2 )-))( <CB3792 >591=36 5L45?252 05 23>5 12 =C775=<3?9?5592?C1?<578575?=5 05=631>3?<>1@0<03D5 ?C< 3<<5?959 3?; C<057 BC7G 8C7 3 4571C9 C8 8CA7 >C?<02 5?=5 3 2A> C8 2 &( 2 '&( , " >C?<02 12 - 5 - 3B37959 <CB3792 6C22 C8 1?=C>5 9A71?@ 6319 A4 4571C9 5?=5<05<C<36=C>45?23<1C?1232A?957. ) *+,-./0*1-+231 /412 C22C88A<A75537?1?@=343=1<; 2 &"-( ' 31?3?92A88571?@2 2 &( C22C83>5?1<152 2 &( " 73?24C7<3<1C? 5L<73 ?CA7120>5?< 3?9 3<<5?93?< =037@52 2 ( & 591=365L45?252 2 )-))( - C22 C8 1?=C>5 9A71?@ 6319 A4 4571C9 2 &( 2+) -56 557 & 1?=5 <05 71957 C8 <05 >C<C7=;=65 12 ?C< 03D1?@ 971D1?@ 61=5?=5 32 457 <05 =1<3<1C? C8 754C7<59 1? <05 ?2A73?=5 =C>43?; 12 9175=<59 <C 43; <05 <C<36 =C>45?23<1C? 3?9 63<57 75=CD57 <05 23>5 87C> <05 CB?57C8<05D501=65:;9A547C=522C863B - ==C791?@6;<058C66CB1?@C7957. 1 0534453612366CB591?437<* 11 05 =631>3?< 12 5?<1<659 <C <C<36 =C>45?23<1C?C82 )"''))(36C?@B1<01?<5752< - 6 - 3< <05 73<5 C8 -I 457 3??A> 87C> <05 93<5 C8 45<1<1C? <166 <05 93<5 C8 75361J3<1C? 32 3@31?2< 2 "+'"(3B37959:;<05<71:A?36* 111 05 ?2A73?=5 =C>43?; 12 9175=<59 <C 954C21<<055?<175=C>45?23<1C?3>CA?<36C?@B1<0 1?<5752< B1<01? C?5 >C?<0 87C> <05 93<5 C8 <012 C79573?963<5775=CD57<0523>587C><05CB?57 C8<05D501=65:;9A547C=522C863B* 1D ? 2A=0 954C21< <05 =631>3?< 12 457>1<<59 <C B1<0973B <05 5?<175 3>CA?< 36C?@ B1<01?<5752<3==7A59C?1< -,7 %$ ' # 12< C . 6 C .-) .