- 1 - ! "#$## # %& %'() %(( * ! !"#$%" ! %# "#$%$ & ! ! '# ! $ # ! ! !! "#$% & ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ! ( ! '# ! ! $'$ )! "#)) & # ) ! "#$%$ & ! ' ! ! ! !"#$% * +!! , ! - ! ! ! ! &! +! - 3 - !! "#$# " ./012134567892:3;<40 ! !! ! % ! &! "#$## $$'$$ " ./012134567892:3;<40 * + ! ! ! = - ! %$ + - #$ ! & !! # ))# ! ! ! $+%- ! ! (" ' % $ ! + - ! ! ! ! ! > !! - 4 - +! > !! - .42 :?@4@4;0 42 A4B?6 2??9403 C/12.403 ;A @.? :7;D??64032 :?06403 40 74E? ;# 7?342@?7?6 F5 !/012134 ;B4D? @1@4;0 42@74D@ 163474 +;0 @.? A4B? ;A 4<4B /63? 106 + /04;7 4<424;0- .;71:/7- A;7 @.? ;AA?0D?:/042.1FB?/06?7?D@4;0$+%-;A@.?.171@451 515110.4@1 +A;72.;7@GH- .?342@;A@.?D;E:B140@B;63?6F5@.?6?A1D@; D;E:B14010@42@.1@@.?2?D;067?2:;06?0@I.;427/00403 1@71640313?0D5/06?7@.?01E?1062@5B?;A .1J4 716403 ;E:105 1@ !/012134 .12 1BB?3?6 @.1@ @.? :7?2?0@:?@4@4;0?72106@.?2;B?:7;:74?@;7;A.74192.E4 /7310@?7:742?2I.;17?1BBDB;2?7?B1@4<?2406/D?6.4E @;2?BB:1665I;7@.2'#"@42A/7@.?71BB?3?6 @.1@ 6?2:4@? 6?B4<?75 ;A @.? 2146 C/10@4@5 ;A :1665 @.? :?@4@4;0?72 106 @.? :7;:74?@;7 ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 A14B?6 @; :15 @.? 21B? D;0246?71@4;0 @.?7?F5 642.;0?2@B5 I4@..;B6403 @.? 1E;/0@ B?31BB5 6/? @; @.? - 5 - 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@ 0 @.? F1242 ;A @.42 1BB?31@4;0 1 I74@@?0 D;E:B140@ I12 B;63?6 F?A;7? @.? K/74264D@4;01B :;B4D?I.4D.D1E?@;F?7?342@?7?64074E?;# A;7 @.? ;AA?0D? :/042.1FB? /06?7 ?D@4;0 $+%- ;A @.? .171@451515110.4@1 .? :?@4@4;0?72 .1<? 1::7;1D.?6 @.42 ;/7@ 2??9403C/12.403;A@.?:7;D??64032D;0@?06403@.1@@.?5 17? :17@0?72 ;A .74 ?091@1 14 4D? 4BB 106 17? 40 0; E100?7 D;00?D@?6 I4@. @.? @71021D@4;0 1BB?3?6 40 @.? D;E:B140@@422:?D4A4D1BB5/73?6@.1@@.?D;E:B140@4@2?BA 642DB;2?2 @.1@ 1BB @.? 40<;4D?2 I?7? 7142?6 @.7;/3. @.? 40 @.? 01E? ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 I.4D. 42 1 :7;:74?@175 D;0D?70 ;I0?6 F5 1DD/2?6 ; .?7?A;7? ?<?0 122/E403 @.? 1BB?31@4;02 E16? 40 @.? D;E:B140@ @; F? @7/? 40 @.?47 ?0@47?@5 @.? 21E? 6; 0;@ 642DB;2?@.?D;EE4224;0;A105;AA?0D?F5@.?:?@4@4;0?72 I.;17?I.;BB5/0D;00?D@?6@;@.?F/240?22;76?1B4032;A .74192.E4/7310@?7:742?2 - 6 - % ?7 D;0@71 B?170?6 D;/02?B A;7 @.? 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@ 671I403 1@@?0@4;0 @; @.? D;0@?0@2 ;A @.? D;E:B140@ 2/FE4@2 @.1@ @.?7? 42 1 2:?D4A4D 7?A?7?0D? @; .74?091@1144D?4BB1064@2:17@0?72I.;17?0;0? ;@.?7 @.10 @.? D.4B67?0 ;A 1DD/2?6 ; @.? 2;B? :7;:74?@;7 ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 @ 42 @.?7?A;7? D;0@?06?6 @.1@ 1B@.;/3. @.? 40<;4D?2 I?7? 422/?640@.?01E?;A.74192.E4/7310@?7:742?2@.? :1665 I12 40 A1D@ 2/::B4?6 @; F;@. ?0@4@4?2 !?0D? @.? 2?D;067?2:;06?0@.12743.@B51BB?3?6@.1@@.?:?@4@4;0?72 40 D;BB/24;0 I4@. 1DD/2?6 ; .1<? D.?1@?6 .4E ;A 1 2/F2@10@41B2/E;A2'#" # ?170?6 !43. ;/7@ ;<?70E?0@ B?16?7 1::?17403A;7@.?A472@7?2:;06?0@L@1@?.122/::;7@?6@.? 2/FE4224;02 ;A @.? B?170?6 D;/02?B A;7 @.? 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@ D;0@?06403 @.1@ @.? 1BB?31@4;02 :74E1 A1D4? 642DB;2? 10 ?B?E?0@ ;A D.?1@403 1@@74F/@1FB? @; F;@. @.? :?@4@4;0?72 106 1DD/2?6 ; !? 2/FE4@2 @.1@ @.? 40<?2@431@4;0 42 1@ 1 012D?0@ 2@13? 106 @.1@ 4@ I;/B6 F? - 7 - :7?E1@/7?A;7@.42;/7@@;40@?7A?7?/06?7?D@4;0%$;A 7 DD;76403B5 .? :7152 @.1@ @.? :?@4@4;0 F? 642E422?6 :?7E4@@403 @.? 40<?2@431@4;0 @; :7;D??6 40 1DD;7610D?I4@.B1I ' .42;/7@ .12D17?A/BB5 .?176@.?2/FE4224;02 16<10D?6 F5 @.? B?170?6 D;/02?B A;7 @.? :?@4@4;0?72 @.? B?170?6 !43. ;/7@ ;<?70E?0@ B?16?7 A;7 @.? A472@ 7?2:;06?0@L@1@?106@.?B?170?6D;/02?BA;7@.?2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@L6?A1D@;D;E:B14010@ ) !1<403 7?3176 @; @.? 74<1B D;0@?0@4;02 @.42 ;/7@A40624@1::7;:741@?@;?M@71D@@.?7?B?<10@:;7@4;0;A @.? D;E:B140@ B;63?6 F5 @.? 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@ I.4D. 7?16212A;BB;I2 !"# $% &&% ' ( )*+ ,--./-/-0012 34 5 678 9 $% :"$;< =,=+, > ?@A+ 6 $% 3:" 7 (B C &@ @43 C ,11D ;( EA ( # B(BF;< $% :"$ G? H - 8 - I J 3 A J 4 9 &K :"$;<G?LMNAF=:+ ?N)+A G? :O )+ K*+ (B CP 'J2 QRST &7UC49VRA 68(B CP&:&@ 6AST &;< >+ &7 C V J4R 11D ;;< S1/WW11D R S0WDW11D A > ?@A+ 6O $% :"$ C C;JXAJ ) R(B CP'J2QRST&@ &Y * <&&K:"$G?LMNAF=:+ ?N)+ R;< =Z=E [*+ &@ V G? :O )+ K*+A :" 1 * 7+;< ?U \A 1] V 9 :" -0.^ \ (B CP '.1_ L`>*+ J2 &: &@4 3 C , (B C 'J2 :" $ /91090.9/DW] $P 7( %4 3 C ,a $ 0 1 D17?A/B 7?16403 ;A @.? D;E:B140@ 106 @.? 1BB?31@4;02 ?M@71D@?6 2/:71 @.42 ;/7@ A4062 @.1@ @.? 2:?D4A4D<?724;0;A@.?2?D;067?2:;06?0@42@.1@@.??0@47? @71021D@4;0I12D1774?6;/@@.7;/3.40<;4D?27142?6F5@.? 40 A1<;/7 ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 0D? 2/D. 1 A1D@/1B E1@74M 42 16E4@@?6 F5 @.? 6?A1D@; - 9 - D;E:B14010@.4E2?BA4@42E104A?2@@.1@@.?@71021D@4;040 C/?2@4;0 I12 ?MDB/24<?B5 F?@I??0 .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 106 @.? 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@L6?A1D@; D;E:B14010@ .? 2/F2?C/?0@ D;0@?0@4;0 ;A @.? 2?D;06 7?2:;06?0@@.1@0;@I4@.2@106403@.?40<;4D?2F?403422/?6 40@.?01E?;A.74192.E4/7310@?7:742?21:;7@4;0 ;A@.?:1665I121B2;2/::B4?6@;@.?:?@4@4;0?72I.;17? :17@0?72;A.74?091@1144D?4BB421E1@@?740<;B<403 :/7?642:/@?6C/?2@4;02;AA1D@/D.1D;0@?0@4;0D100;@ F51052@7?@D.A;7E@.?A;/061@4;0A;7404@41@403D74E401B :7;2?D/@4;0:17@4D/B17B5I.?0@.?16E4@@?66;D/E?0@2;0 7?D;76 @.? 40<;4D?2 /0?C/4<;D1BB5 ?2@1FB42. @.1@ @.? @71021D@4;0 I12 D;0A40?6 @; .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 0 @.? D;0246?7?6 ;:404;0 ;A @.42 ;/7@ @.? E?7? 1BB?31@4;0 @.1@ @.? :?@4@4;0?72 .1::?0 @; F? DB;2?B5 7?B1@?6 @; 1DD/2?6 ; I.; 42 @.? :7;:74?@;7 ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 D100;@ F5 4@2?BA 34<? 742? @; D74E401B B41F4B4@5 40 @.? 1F2?0D? ;A 105 406?:?06?0@ ;7 - 10 - 2:?D4A4D 1<?7E?0@ 1@@74F/@403 6?D?4@A/B ;7 A71/6/B?0@ D;06/D@;0@.?47:17@74E401BB1ID100;@F?2?@40E;@4;0 ;0 D;0K?D@/7?2 106 122/E:@4;02 I.?0 @.? 6;D/E?0@175 ?<46?0D?1<14B1FB?;07?D;760?31@?2@.?47:17@4D4:1@4;040 @.? 1BB?3?6 @71021D@4;0 <?0 4A @.? 40<?2@431@4;0 42 :?7E4@@?6@;:7;D??6A/7@.?7@.?E1@?741B;07?D;766;?2 0;@:74E1A1D4?4064D1@?105D/B:1F4B4@5;A@.?:?@4@4;0?72 106 @.? :;224F4B4@5 ;A 2?D/7403 1 D;0<4D@4;0 131402@ @.?E 1::?172 .43.B5 7?E;@? 106 4E:B1/24FB? BB;I403 @.? 40<?2@431@4;0 @; D;0@40/? 131402@ @.?E I;/B6 @.?7?A;7? 1E;/0@ @; 10 1F/2? ;A @.? :7;D?22 ;A B1I DD;76403B5 @.42;/7@42;A@.?D;0246?7?6<4?I@.1@@.?:7;D??6403240 74E? ;# 17? /02/2@1401FB? 402;A17 12 @.? :7?2?0@:?@4@4;0?7217?D;0D?70?6 @ 42 1B2; 24304A4D10@ @; 0;@? @.1@ @.? 40<;4D?2 A;7E403 @.? <?75 A;/061@4;0 ;A @.? D;E:B140@ 17? 16E4@@?6B5 671I0 40 @.? 01E? ;A .74 192.E4 /731 0@?7:742?2 1 2;B? :7;:74?@;72.4: D;0D?70 ;I0?6 106 E1013?6 ?MDB/24<?B5 F5 1DD/2?6 ; 0 @.? 1F2?0D? ;A - 11 - 105E1@?741B@;2.;I@.1@@.?:?@4@4;0?7240@.?47D1:1D4@5 12:17@0?72;A.74?091@1144D?4BBI?7?:17@4?2@; @.?2146@71021D@4;0;7.16:B15?61057;B?40406/D403@.? 6?A1D@; D;E:B14010@ D;0@40/1@4;0 ;A :7;D??64032 131402@ @.?E I;/B6 1E;/0@ @; 2/FK?D@403 @.?E @; 0??6B?22 .17122E?0@ !?0D? @.? :7;D??64032 404@41@?6 131402@ @.? :?@4@4;0?7240@.?1A;7?2146D74E?17?B41FB?@;F?C/12.?6 DD;76403B5@.42;/7@:122?2@.?A;BB;I403 +4- .?:?@4@4;042.?7?F51BB;I?6 +44- .? :7;D??64032 40 74E? ;# 7?342@?7?6 F5 !/012134 ;B4D? @1@4;0 42@74D@ 163474 :?06403 ;0 @.? A4B? ;A @.? 4<4B /63? 106 + /04;7 4<424;0- .;71:/7 A;7 @.? ;AA?0D?:/042.1FB?/06?7?D@4;0$+%-;A@.? .171@451 5151 10.4@1 17? C/12.?6 402;A1712@.?:?@4@4;0?7217?D;0D?70?6 +444- 0<4?I;A@.?642:;21B;A@.?E140:?@4@4;0105 :?06403 40@?7B;D/@;75 1::B4D1@4;0 2@1062 - 12 - 642:;2?6 ;A 1DD;76403B512 4@6;?2 0;@ 2/7<4<? A;7D;0246?71@4;0 +) %##( $ 42@;B;%