- 1 - !" #$%% "" &%' ( ! " # $% # &'()%* # +'()"%" ! , % % %* " Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "*" # * %' % # & # "%)%%% "((-%%& *%%%%%%& . "/ 0 # # 1 # $ 23452 6278 9::;9< 78 <786;= >3? 9=@78873A B762 62; C3A8;A63><;9?A;=C34A8;<>3?D36287=;8767869E;A4:>3? >7A9<=78:389< 278 9::;9< 78 >7<;= DF 62; 9::;<<9A6&C<97@9A6 C29<<;A57A5 62; G4=5@;A6 9A= 9B9?= =96;= * %' % :988;=7A3 "%)%%%DF62; ?< ;A73?7H7<#4=5; I & 7G9F9:4?9 2;?;7A9>6;? ?;>;??;= 63 98 J62; ?7D4A9<K >3? 823?6 >3? 8;667A5 987=; 62; C3A6?7D463?F A;5<75;AC;9A=;A29AC;@;A63>C3@:;A89673A - 3 - ?7;>>9C68<;9=7A563>7<7A53>C<97@:;67673A9?; 984A=;? 2963A"( %- %%969D346'%%9 @ 62;C<97@9A6 B98 ?7=7A5 62; @363?CFC<; D;9?7A5 3 &-&$-(* 63B9?=84=23<>?3@7<95796629667@;3A;9?D;9?7A5 3 &$"0&()*$ C9@; >?3@ 3::3876; =7?;C673A 7A 9 2752 8:;;=9A=7A9?9829A=A;5<75;A6@9AA;?9A==982;=63 62; @363?CFC<; 3> 62; C<97@9A6 8 9 ?;84<6 62; C<97@9A6 848697A;=5?7;H3487AG4?7;89A==4?7A56?;96@;A6278?7526 <;5 D;<3B EA;; 298 D;;A 9@:4696;= 2; C<97@9A6 >7<;= C<97@:;67673A9A=?7D4A9<298988;88;=62;C3@:;A89673A 9A= :988;= 62; 9B9?= 9A= 9<83 2;<= 6296 C<97@9A6 298 C3A6?7D46;='%/63B9?=862;9CC7=;A6 * ;9?= <;9?A;= C34A8;< >3? 62; 9::;<<9A6 9A= <;9?A;=C34A8;<>3??;8:3A=;A63 &A84?9AC;3@:9AF $ ;9?A;= C34A8;< >3? 62; 9::;<<9A6&C<97@9A6 B34<= C3A6;A= 6296 62; ?7D4A9< 298 ;??;= 7A 69E7A5 62; C3A6?7D463?F A;5<75;AC; 3A 62; :9?6 3> 62; C<97@9A6 96 - 4 - '%/ 2;C29?5;&82;;6298D;;A>7<;=9597A8662;=?7H;? 3>62;9?>3?3>>;AC;4A=;?;C673A-**(3> 9A= C29?5;&82;;6>7<;=9597A8662;C<97@9A678>3?3>>;AC;4A=;? ;C673A * ?;9= B762 ;C673A8 "(" "$) "-) 3> 363? ;27C<;8C6"-((>3?823?6J62; C6K 3A87=;?7A5 62; 89@; 62;?; 78 A3 ?982 9A= A;5<75;A6 =?7H7A5 3A 62; :9?63>62;?7=;?3>62;@363?CFC<;B2378C<97@9A6 ' ;>4?62;?84D@768629662;9CC7=;A629869E;A :<9C; 3A 62; <;>6 87=; 3> 62; ?39= 3A B27C2 62; C<97@9A6 B98?7=7A5278@363?CFC<;9A=62;89@;C9AD;8;;A7A62; 8E;6C2;AC<38;=63L *&929M9?6296768;<>7A=7C96;6296 9CC7=;A63CC4??;==4;63;A67?;A;5<75;AC;3A62;:9?63> 62;=?7H;?3>62;9? ) ; >4?62;? C3A6;A=;= 6296 62; C<97@9A6 B98 B3?E7A57A7?9A7459?8 7@76;=98;A6?7>459<:;?963?& 9A= 2; 78 =?9B7A5 5?388 89<9?F 3> 8 "(%%%& 9A= A;6 89<9?F3> 8 "*%"&98:;?L "9A=7A3?=;?63823B - 5 - 6296 2; 78 B3?E7A5 7A 7?9A7 459?8 2; 298 :?3=4C;= L ")2787=;A676FC9?=7884;=DF7?9A7459?8 ; >4?62;? 84D@768 6296 98 62; C<97@9A6 78 B3?E7A5 98 ;A6?7>459< :;?963? 7A 7?9A7 459?8 2; C9AA36D;;N496;=B7629C33<7;;A676<7A5A3673A9<7AC3@; 98:;?C29?6:?;:9?;=DF62; ( ; >4?62;? 84D@768 6296 62; 3C63?& B23 2987884;==789D7<76FC;?67>7C96;&L "*2988696;=629662; C<97@9A67829H7A5=789D7<76F3>4::;?9A=<3B;?<7@D6362; ;L6;A63>'/9A=62;?7D4A9<;??;=7A69E7A5=789D7<76F96 '"/ 2; C<97@9A6K8 ?7526 <;5 D;<3B EA;; 298 D;;A 9@:4696;=9A=89@;C9AD;8;;A7A:23635?9:28&L "" ;>4?62;?84D@7686296C<97@9A6298D;;A?;@3H;=>?3@ 8;?H7C;=4;6362;7AG4?7;8848697A;=DF27@ - ; >4?62;? 84D@768 6296 62; C3@:;A89673A 9B9?=;=>3?:97A9A=84>>;?7A5,<3883>7AC3@;=4?7A5<97= 4::;?73=,<3883>9@;A767;89?;3A62;<3B;?87=;B27C2 A;;=8 63 D; ;A29AC;= ; >4?62;? 84D@768 6296 98 62; - 6 - ?7526 <;5 D;<3B EA;; 298 D;;A 9@:4696;= 2; ?;N47?;8 9?67>7C79< <7@D >3? 6296 2; ?;N47?;8 63 D; 9B9?=;= C3@:;A89673A 2; ?7D4A9< 298 A36 9==;= >464?; :?38:;C68 ;H;A 623452 62; =789D7<76F 78 @3?; 6296 '%/ 76262;8;2;:?9F;=639<<3B62;9::;9< "% ;9?A;=C34A8;<>3??;8:3A=;A63 &A84?9AC; 3@:9AFB34<=C3A6;A=6296C29?5;&82;;6298D;;A>7<;= 9597A86 62; ?7=;? 3> 62; @363?CFC<; >3? 3>>;AC; 4A=;? ;C673A*?;9=B762;C673A"("9A="$)?;9=B762;C673A "-)3> C6 2;897=98:;C6768;<>823B8629662;?7=;? 3>62;@363?CFC<;B98A3623<=7A562;=?7H7A5<7C;AC;9A= 278H;27C<;B98A367A84?;=982;B98A3623<=7A5=?7H7A5 <7C;AC;2;B98C3A6?7D46;=6362;;L6;A63>'%/98?7526<F 2;<= DF 62; ?7D4A9< ; >4?62;? 84D@768 6296 =789D7<76F 69E;ADF62;?7D4A9<96'"/78:?3:;?9A=C3??;C6 2; C3@:;A89673A9B9?=;=DF62;?7D4A9<3A9<<2;9=878G486 9A=:?3:;? 76262;8;2;:?9F;=63=78@78862;9::;9< - 7 - "" 9H7A5 2;9?= <;9?A;= C34A8;<8 6278 34?6 298 :;?48;=62;7@:45A;=G4=5@;A69A=?79<34?6 ;C3?=8 " L )7862;C29?5;&82;;6B2;?;7A62;=?7H;?3> 62; 9? 298 D;;A 823BA 98 9CC48;= 3 " >3? 29H7A5 C3@@766;= 3>>;AC; 4A=;? ;C673A8 - **( 3> 9A= ;C673A "(3> C6 2; ?7=;? 3> 62; @363?CFC<; 298 D;;A823BA989CC48;=3 >3?29H7A5C3@@766;=3>>;AC; 4A=;?;C673A*?;9=B762;C673A"(";C673A"$)?;9= B762 ;C673A "-) 3> C6 A C3A87=;?7A5 62; 897= C29?5;&82;;6 62; A;5<75;A6 =?7H7A5 298 D;;A 9<<;5;= 9597A86 62; =?7H;? 3> 62; 9? 2;?; 78 A3 9CC489673A 3> 62; C<97@9A6 D;7A5 ?7=;? 3> 62; @363?CFC<; =?7H7A5 278 @363?CFC<;7A?9829A=A;5<75;A6@9AA;? ;?;<FD;C948; 62;C<97@9A678A3623<=7A562;=?7H7A5<7C;AC;76C9AA36D; 2;<= 6296 62; 2; 298 C3A6?7D46;= 63B9?=8 9CC7=;A6 DF A;5<75;A69C6 H;A3A:;?489<3>62;8E;6C2;AC<38;=63 L *&929M9?62;9CC7=;A629869E;A:<9C;3A<;>687=;3> 62;?39=3AB27C262;C<97@9A6B98?7=7A5278@363?CFC<; 2;?7D4A9<298>97<;=63C3A87=;?627898:;C69A=;??;=7A - 8 - 23<=7A5 6296 62; C<97@9A6 298 9<83 C3A6?7D46;= 63 62; ;L6;A63>'%/ 2;9CC7=;A6298C948;==4;6362;;A67?; A;5<75;AC;3A62;:9?63>62;=?7H;?3>62;C9? 2;?;>3?; ?;8:3A=;A6 3 D;7A5 7A84?;? 3> 62; C9? 78 <79D<; 63 :9F 62;;A67?;C3@:;A89673A9@34A6 "* L "(7862;9::37A6@;A63?=;?3>62;C<97@9A6 7884;= DF 62; 7?9A7 459?8 7@76;= B2;?; 4A=;? 2; 298 D;;A 9::37A6;= 98 ;A6?7>459< :;?963? 3A 89<9?F 3> 8 **& :;? @3A62 9A= =96; 3> 9::37A6@;A6 78 % %- %"* L ") 78 62; =;A676F 9?= 3> 62; C<97@9A6 7884;= DF 7?9A7 459?8 7@76;= 4=23< B2;?;7A 62; =;875A9673A3>62;C<97@9A6298D;;A823BA98;A6?7>459< :;?963? L "7862;89<9?F8<7:3>62;C<97@9A67884;= DF 7?9A7 459?8 7@76;= 4=23< B2;?;7A 278 6369< :9F 298 D;;A 823BA 98 8 "(%%%& 9A= A;6 :9F 298 D;;A 823BA98 8 "*%"& ;?;<FD;C948;62;94623?3>62; L " 298 A36 D;;A ;L9@7A;= 62; ?7D4A9< ;??;= 7A =78C9?=7A5 62; 897= =3C4@;A68 9A= 69E;A 62; 7AC3@; 98 :;?C29?67884;=DF62; :;?83AB3?E7A57A7?9A7 - 9 - 459?898;A6?7>459<:;?963?C9AA36D;;N496;=B7629 C33<7; B238; A3673A9< 7AC3@; 78 >7L;= 7A 62; C29?6 7 ; 4623?76F 8 62; C<97@9A6 298 :?3=4C;= L " ")9A= "(768;<>7A=7C96;62962;785;667A5@3?;7AC3@; 629A 62; A3673A9< 7AC3@; >7L;= DF 62; 4A=;? 62; C29?6 3A87=;?7A5 62; 897= 98:;C6 62; 7AC3@; 3> 62; C<97@9A629863D;69E;A96 8 "'%%%&:;?@3A62 2; C<97@9A6 B98 95;= F;9?8 9A= 62;?;>3?; 9A= 98 62; =789D7<76F78@3?;629A'%/78;A676<;=63>464?;:?38:;C68 96$%/ "$ 2; =3C63? B23 298 7884;= L "*&=789D7<76F C;?67>7C96; 298 8696;= 6296 =789D7<76F 3> 4::;? 9A= <3B;? <7@D8 78 '/ 2;?; 78 >?9C64?; 3> ?7526 ;<D3B 9A= ?7526 EA;; 9A= 62;?; 78 9@:469673A 3> ?7526 <;5 D;<3B EA;; 3A87=;?7A5 62; 89@; 9A= 62; ;H7=;AC; 3> &3C63? 9A= =789D7<76F C;?67>7C96;&L "* 62; =789D7<76F 298 63 D; 69E;A 96 ''/ 98 9597A86 '"/ 69E;A DF 62; ?7D4A9< A H7;B3>62;9D3H;62;C<97@9A678;A676<;=63<3883>>464?; 7AC3@;984A=;? - 10 - 8 "'%%%&O$%/)%%%P 8 "%%%& 8 "%%%&L"L"L''/P) * "' 2; C<97@9A6 298 848697A;= 6B3 >?9C64?;8 9A= 278?7526<;5D;<3BEA;;298D;;A9@:4696;= 3A87=;?7A5 62;897=98:;C62;78;A676<;=639@34A663B9?=8:97A9A= 84>>;?7A5 78 )* 9A= <388 3> 9@;A767;8 78 )* 98 9597A86 8 '%%%%& ;9C2 9B9?=;= DF 62;?7D4A9< ") 2;?7D4A9<298A369B9?=;=62;C3@:;A89673A 63B9?=8966;A=9A69A=C3AH;F9AC;C29?5;8 2;C<97@9A6 298D;;A9=@766;=7A38:769<>3?$%=9F862;?;>3?;2;78 ;A676<;=63966;A=9A69A=C3AH;F9AC;C29?5;87A984@3> )+* " 2;?7D4A9<2989B9?=;=<3883>7AC3@;=4?7A5 <97= 4: :;?73= 7A 9 84@ 3> 8 "*'%%& 3A87=;?7A5 62; 9@:469673A9A=62;362;?>?9C64?;82;78;A676<;=63<388 3>7AC3@;=4?7A5<97=4::;?73=>3?87L@3A6287A984@3> ) * 8 "'%%%&L) - 11 - "( 2;?7D4A9<298?7526<F9B9?=;=C3@:;A89673A 63B9?=8@;=7C9<;L:;A8;898) ++ * "- 8 62; ?7526 <;5 D;<3B EA;; 9@:4696;= 62; C<97@9A6 ?;N47?;8 9?67>7C79< <7@D 9A= 62;?;>3?; 2; 78 ;A676<;= 63 9 84@ 3> )* 63B9?=8 ;L:;A8;8 >3? 9?67>7C79<<7@D % 248 62; C<97@9A6 78 ;A676<;= >3? >3<<3B7A5 9@34A63>C3@:;A89673A4A=;?=7>>;?;A62;9=8 , -./) 0123 .4.5/-/67 38-59612., 0123 .4.5/-/67 389)153 " 3883>>464?;7AC3@; 8 "$*%''%& 8 *')%%& 97A9A=84>>;?7A5 8 '%%%%& 8 "%%%%%& * ;=7C9<;L:;A8;8 8 $$-%%& 8 $$-%%& $ 66;A=9A6C29?5;89A= C3AH;F9AC;C29?5;8 &&&& 8 $%%%%& ' 3883>7AC3@;=4?7A5 <97=4::;?73= 8 "*'%%& 8 -%%%%& ) 3883>9@;A767;8 8 '%%%%& 8 "%%%%%& 3B9?=89?67>7C79<<7@D &&&& 8 '%%%%& 3., ):;; * ) ;* 28.2<-0-23 ) * " 2; 9::;<<9A6&C<97@9A6 78 A36 ;A676<;= 63 7A6;?;86 >3? 62; =;<9F :;?73= 3> *' =9F8 7A >7<7A5 62; 9::;9<98:;?3?=;?=96;=% % %* - 12 - A62;?;84<662;9::;9<=;8;?H;863D;9<<3B;= 7A&:9?6 ;AC;62;>3<<3B7A5 7 2;9::;9<789<<3B;=7A&:9?6 77 2; 9::;<<9A6&C<97@9A6 78 ;A676<;= 63 6369< C3@:;A89673A 3> ) ;* 9597A86 8 "((-%%&989B9?=;=DF62;?7D4A9< 9<3A5 B762 7A6;?;86 ;LC<4=7A5 62; 7A6;?;86 >3? 62; =;<9F;= :;?73= 96 62; ?96; 3> )/ : 9 >?3@ 62; =96; 3> :;67673A 67<< ?;9<7M9673A 777 2;?;8:3A=;A63 &A84?9AC;3@:9AF78 <79D<;63:9F62;;A67?;9B9?=9@34A6B762 7A6;?;86 7H 2;?;8:3A=;A63 &A84?9AC;C3@:9AF78 =7?;C6;= 63 =;:3876 62; C3@:;A89673A 9@34A6 B7627A 9 :;?73= 3> ;7526 B;;E8 - 13 - >?3@ 6278 =9F >97<7A5 B27C2 76 829<< :9F 7A6;?;869662;?96;3>-/: 9 67<<:9F@;A6 H 2;C<97@9A678A36;A676<;=639AF7A6;?;86 >3? 62; =;<9F :;?73= 3> *' =9F8 7A >7<7A5 62;9::;9<98:;?3?=;?=96;=% % %* H7 2; ?;86 3> 62; 3?=;? 3> 62; ?7D4A9< ?;@97A84A9<6;?;= H77 2; ;5786?F 78 =7?;C6;= 63 8;A= D9CE 62; ?79<34?6 ;C3?=89<3A5B762C3:F3>6278 G4=5@;A66362;C3AC;?A;=34?6 /* &%%' $ " $' 6,HE