- 1 - !" # $% # $% ## &'( ) !" # $ % !!&!'& !" - 2 - ! (( ( !" # $( % ')$% *"" % % ") * ! &+ & ! + )" , - . . / / - 3 - '% $./ % 0123445361278905:631;3<92:3661<=1<>?5291@<905 A?B=;5<9 3<B 3C3DB B395B ") 1< @ 43225B 78 D1<:1436 129D1:9 3<B 5221@<2 ?B=5 3<B 31:0?D $E@D 20@D9 ,905 D17?<36-% C05D578 905 613716198 12 E3295<5B @< 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:6515D524@<B5<9@5G@<5D391<=D524@<B5<9@ H<2?D3<:5:@;43<8@<9054D5;1259039905BD1F5D@E905 1445DB1B<@94@22522F361BBD1F1<=61:5<:53990591;5@E 3::1B5<93<B362@255IE@D5<03<:5;5<9@E:@;45<2391@< @C5F5D 905 :@?<256 E@D 3445663<92 D529D1:9 9012 344536 @<68 3=31<29 613716198 C05D578 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 5G@<5D395B372@6?9568 05 B395 @E 3::1B5<9 B5390 @E 03<BD3205I3D @?6?=34431<905D@3B9D3EE1:3::1B5<91<F@6F5;5<9@E 905F501:653D5<@91<B124?9505B124?951<F@6F5B1<9012 :32512C190D5245:9@EE3295<1<=@E613716198@<9051<2?D5B - 4 - D3905D1<2?D5D@<68@<9054D5;1259039905BD1F5DB1B<@9 4@22522F361BBD1F1<=61:5<:53990591;5@E3::1B5<9 ) 53DBD137?593=?BB3653D<5B:@?<256 34453D1<= E@D 905 3445663<92 3<B ;9 D5591 3916 56I?<B1653D<5B:@?<25634453D1<=E@DD524@<B5<9@ 524@<B5<9@90@?=025DF5BD5;31<5B?<D54D525<95B D1 37? 593=?BB3 93I1<= 9012 @?D9 90D@?=0 905 A?B=;5<9 3<B 3C3DB 43225B 78 905 D17?<36 F505;5<9682?7;1995B90399051<2?D3<:5:@;43<85G:549 5G3;1<1<= 192 @EE1:5D 3<B 4D@B?:1<= 2@;5 B@:?;5<92 <3;568 65=36<@91:5 4@2936 3:I<@C65B=;5<94@61:8 :@48 032<@965B3<85F1B5<:59@20@CC05905D905BD1F5D@E905 1445DB1B<@94@22522F361BBD1F1<=61:5<:53990591;5@E 3::1B5<9055<91D55F1B5<:5@E905C19<5225G3;1<5B@< 75036E@E9051<2?D3<:5:@;43<85F5<3::@DB1<=9@01;12 @<90573212@E@61:5D5:@DB2C05D51<9054@61:503F5E165B :03D=5!20559 3=31<29 905 BD1F5D @E 905 @EE5<B1<= F501:65 ?<B5D 5:91@< '* 3<B )! @E 2@ 362@ ?<B5D - 5 - 5:91@<2 ) " "' @E @9@D 501:652 :9 *"" $E@D 20@D9 , :9-% 3<B ?<B5D 5:91@<2 3<B " @E :93=31<29905@C<5D@E905F501:6515D524@<B5<9 @01212905=D@?<BE@D905C19<5229@B54@2575E@D5 905 @?D9 9039 905 BD1F5D @E 905 D524@<B5<9 @ B1B <@9 4@22522 F361B 3<B 5EE5:91F5 BD1F1<= 61:5<:5 39 905 91;5 @E 3::1B5<9 D1 37? 593=?BB3 032 93I5< 9012 @?D9 90D@?=0 905 <@91:5 231B 9@ 03F5 755< 122?5B 78 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 9@ D524@<B5<9 @ C05D51< 905 1<2?D3<:5:@;43<803293I5<3245:1E1:293<B3943D3@) @E65=36<@91:539G9039905D524@<B5<9@03<B5B @F5D9051445D9@3<?<!61:5<:5BBD1F5DI<@C1<=E?668C566 9039905231BBD1F5DC32<@90@6B1<= 4@225221<=3<8BD1F1<= 61:5<:5 @C5F5D 905 653D<5B :@?<256 2?7;192 9039 G 905 4@2936 3:I<@C65B=;5<9 B541:92 21=<39?D5 @E @<53F1939012:653D6820@C29039905D512<@25DF1:5@E <@91:5 @< D524@<B5<9 @ 05 <@91:5 C32 25<9 ?<B5D 05 3:I<@C65B=;5<9 @?=09 9@ 03F5 :@<931<5B 905 - 6 - 21=<39?D5@ED524@<B5<9@1<@DB5D9@20@C9039905D512 25DF1:5 @E <@91:5 05 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 032 <@9 5G4631<5B 9012 3245:9 @E 905 ;3995D 32 9@ C0@ 12 231B 3F193 C0@ 032 3665=5B68 D5:51F5B <@91:5 3<B C05905D 905D5 12 3<8 1<E@D;391@< @E D5:5149 @E 231B <@91:5 9@ D524@<B5<9 @ 78 231B 3F193 @ 362@ C05905D 905 D524@<B5<9 @ 032 =1F5< 3<8 3?90@D1J391@< 9@ 231B 3F1939@D5:51F53<84@2936:@F5D25<9?<B5D@< 01275036E@901<=@E90392@D9032755<4D@B?:5B78905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 2@ 32 9@ 4D@F5 9039 905D5 12 1<E3:9 25DF1:5@E<@91:5@<D524@<B5<9@ & ?D905D 05 032 2?7;1995B 9039 ;5D5 E161<= @E :03D=5!20559 ?<B5D 905 4D@F121@<2 @E @9@D 501:652 :9 C166 <@9 4D@F5 9039 D524@<B5<9 @ 03F1<= I<@C65B=5 5<9D?295B905F501:659@905BD1F5D@E905@EE5<B1<=F501:65 05D17?<36032<@939366B12:?225B3<8901<=1<9055<91D5 7@B8 @E 905 A?B=;5<9 @C5F5D 39 43D3=D340 @ C0165@<6137161989@438:@;45<2391@<905D17?<36C190@?9 =1F1<= 3<8 D532@<2 032 A?29 29395B 9039 905 BD1F5D @E 905 - 7 - 1445DB1B<@94@22522F361B3<B5EE5:91F5BD1F1<=61:5<:539 905 91;5 @E 3::1B5<9 9039 751<= E?<B3;5<936 F1@6391@< @E 4@61:8:@<B191@<2D524@<B5<9@H1<2?D3<:5:@;43<812 5G@<5D395B ED@; 23912E81<= 905 3C3DB 190 9012 05 2@?=09 9@ 366@C 905 344536 259 321B5 905 A?B=;5<9 3<B 3C3DBB1D5:91<=D524@<B5<9@9@438905:@;45<2391@< 3<B B1D5:9 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 1< F15C @E 259965B 4@2191@<@E63C78905@<7-6545G@?D990395F5<C05< 905D5 12 F361B 1<F361B E3I5 BD1F1<= 61:5<:5 @D <@ BD1F1<= 61:5<:59051<2?D3<:5:@;43<89@4D1;3D1689@23912E8905 3C3DB 3<B D5:@F5D 905 23;5 ED@; 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:65@7?99D5220123D=?;5<9205032D5615B@<905 A?B=;5<9 @E 905 @<-765 45G @?D9 1< 905 :325 @E 9@ :@<95<B 9039 5F5< 1< 905 :325 @E <@ BD1F1<= 61:5<:5 905 @<-76545G@?D9E@66@C1<=905A?B=;5<91<905:325@E !"# $%$ & 1 C.A.No.1175/2025, DD: 29.01.2025 2 (2004) 3 SCC 297 - 8 - 056B90399051<2?D5D124D1;3D1686137659@23912E89053C3DB C1909056175D989@D5:@F5D90523;5ED@;905@C<5D@E905 F501:65 ' 5E?91<= 905 2?7;1221@<2 @E 653D<5B :@?<256 34453D1<= E@D 905 3445663<92 :631;3<92 ;9 D5591 3916 56I?<B1 C190 366 F505;5<:5 2?7;192 9039 905 :03D=52 65F565B 3=31<29 905 BD1F5D @E 905 F501:65 3D5 ?<B5D 905 4D@F121@<2@E@9@D501:65:9*""15?<B5D5:91@<) D53B C190 5:91@<2 " "' @E :9 343D9 ED@; 905 @EE5<:524?<1203765?<B5D9054D@F121@<@E3<B?<B5D 5:91@<23<B"@E:93<B3=31<29905D524@<B5<9 @ 05 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 032 122?5B 65=36 <@91:5 9@ D524@<B5<9 @ ?<B5D G 3<B 3 245:1E1: :@<95<91@< 032755<93I5<1<F15C@E 1<F@I1<=5:91@<3<B"@E :93=31<29905@C<5D@E905F501:659039905@C<5D 5<9D?295B905F501:6503F1<=I<@C65B=59039905BD1F5DB1B <@94@22522F361B3<B5EE5:91F5BD1F1<=61:5<:505<@91:5 25<9@<9053BBD522@E9051<2?D5B12B?6825DF5B245D 905 4@61:8 :@<B191@<2 905 1<2?D5D 12 <@9 613765 E@D 3<8 - 9 - E?<B3;5<936 7D53:0 @E 4@61:8 :@<B191@<2 05 E?D905D 2?7;192903921<:5905@C<5D@E905F501:65C32463:5B' 75E@D5905D17?<363<3BF5D251<E5D5<:50329@75 BD3C<D5=3DB1<=905I<@C65B=5@EBD1F1<=61:5<:521<:5905 :03D=52 ?<B5D 5:91@<2 3<B " @E :9 1<F@I5B 3=31<29905D524@<B5<9@05D524@<B5<9@032<@9 :@<95295B 905 ;3995D 3<B B12:03D=5B 012 7?DB5< 3<B 1< F15C @E :03D=5 20559 E165B 78 905 @61:5 1<F@I1<= 905 4D@F121@<2 @E :9 905 D17?<36 032 :@;52 9@ 3 :@<:6?21@< 9039 905 BD1F5D @E 905 1445D B1B <@9 4@22522 F361B 3<B 5EE5:91F5 BD1F1<= 61:5<:5 32 @< 905 B395 @E 3::1B5<9 3<B D1=0968 5G@<5D395B 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 ED@; 23912E81<= 905 3C3DB C01:0 B@52 <@9 :366 E@D 3<8 1<95DE5D5<:53990503<B2@E9012@?D9 " @ 7?99D522 05D 3D=?;5<9 905 653D<5B :@?<256 032 D5615B @< 905 A?B=;5<9 @E 905 @!@DB1<395 5<:0 @E 9012@?D91<905:325@E 3<B 29D5225B @< 3 @)*' *.)) - 10 - 43D3 @2 3<B " 3<B A?B=;5<9 1< 905 :325 @E ! " #3<B29D5225B@<43D3@23<B* () * +' " % , - -- " $ ..,/0.1-!- -- "$ - " /- "2 3 " 4 " 5" % " $ - - - -$ .1- $ .- - " " -- 6 0 7 3 % - - % " 4 @& *.) - 11 - " " 5" "5" % " % * " % 8" - - "" 9* - " -" - % - $ - 10:;0;: ; - *-, * "%8" - ' " " -" - *-, "% - 6 * 3F1<=053DB905653D<5B:@?<25634453D1<=E@D 905 43D9152 45D?25B 905 5<91D5 344536 4345D2 36@<= C190 9D136@?D9D5:@DB29054@1<990393D1252E@D:@<21B5D391@< 12E@66@C2. 05905D 905 D17?<36 12 A?291E15B 1< E3295<1<= 5<91D5 613716198 @< 905 1<2?D5B D3905D1<2?D5D9@23912E89053C3DB@<68@< 905 73212 @E :03D=5!20559 ;395D136 1< 905 - 12 - 3725<:5 @E 3<8 5F1B5<:5 D5615B 78 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 9@ 4D@F5 905 I<@C65B=5@E9051<2?D5B1E9053<2C5D12 @905DC125 C05905D 905D5 12 3<8 1<95DE5D5<:5D5>?1D5BK ?D3<2C5D9@90537@F54@1<9E@D:@<21B5D391@< 121<3D968EE1D;391F5E@D905E@66@C1<=. 9 12 <@9 1< B124?95 9039 905 4@61:5 03F5 D5=1295D5B 905 :325 3=31<29 905 BD1F5D @E 1445D E@D 905 @EE5<:524?<1203765?<B5D5:91@<2'*3<B)!@E 36@<=C1905:91@<2)""'@E:92@362@?<B5D 5:91@<2 3<B " @E :9 3=31<29 905 D524@<B5<9 @ 2 :@?6B 75 255< ED@; 905 D5:@DB2 905 <@91:5 122?5B789051<2?D3<:5:@;43<89@905D524@<B5<9@ B395B"3245DG93I1<=245:1E1::@<95<91@< 39 43D3 @) 9039 905 1<2?D5B 032 905 I<@C65B=5 @< 905 73212 :03<=52 1<F@I5B ?<B5D 905 4D@F121@<2 @E :9 1<F@I5B 3=31<29 01; @C5F5D 905 3:I<@C65B=;5<9 - 13 - 4D@B?:5B:653D6820@C2903919C32D5:51F5B783F193 051<2?D5D032<@965B3<85F1B5<:5329@C0@12905231B 45D2@< C0@ 032 D5:51F5B 905 <@91:5 25<9 9@ D524@<B5<9 @905803F5<@94D@B?:5B3<8B@:?;5<99@90395EE5:9 05905D 231B 3F193 C0@ 032 D5:51F5B 905 <@91:5 C32 03F1<= 3<8 3?90@D198 78 905 D524@<B5<9 @ 9@ D5:51F5 905 23;5 3<B 905 D524@<B5<9 @ =31<5B I<@C65B=5 90D@?=0 231B 3F193 D5=3DB1<= 905 <@91:5 25<9 90D@?=0 12 <@9 5293761205B 78 5F1B5<:5 75E@D5 905 D17?<36 @ B@?79 905 <@91:5 C32 B1D5:95B 32 45D 905 3BBD522 3F31637651<9054@61:87?9905E3:9D5;31<2903919C32<@9 D5:51F5B 78 D524@<B5<9 @ < 905 3725<:5 @E 3<8 :@=5<9 5F1B5<:5 D5=3DB1<= 25DF1:5 @E <@91:5 19 75:@;52 F5D8B1EE1:?69E@D?29@3::549905:@<95<91@<@E9051<2?D5D 9@ 0@6B 9039 905D5 12 25DF1:5 @E <@91:5 @< 905 D524@<B5<9 @H1<2?D5B 2 45D 905 A?B=;5<9 D5615B 1< ", 905 1<F5291=391@< @EE1:5D B?D1<= 1<F5291=391@< 122?5B 3 <@91:5 ?<B5D 5:91@< )) - 14 - :99@905@C<5D@E905F501:653<B905@C<5D@E905 F501:65D54615B9@905231B<@91:53B;1991<=9039D1B5D@E905 F501:65 C32 <@9 4@225221<= 61:5<:5 32 @< 905 B395 @E 3::1B5<9 012 12 905 B5:121F5 E3:9@D 1< 905 231B :325 E@D 905@!@DB1<3955<:0@E9012@?D99@0@6B9039905@C<5D @E905F501:65:@<2:1@?26803F1<=I<@C65B=545D;1995B905 45D2@< 9@ D1B5 905 ;@9@D:8:65 <@9 03F1<= 61:5<:5 ?<B5D 63C 05 231B :325 12 B1291<=?1203765 @< E3:92 C05< :@;43D5B9@905E3:92@<03<B22?:019C166<@9:@;5 9@90531B@E9051<2?D5B ) @E3D 32 905 A?B=;5<9 1< 905 :325 @E " @!@DB1<395 5<:0 @E 9012 @?D9 032 056B 9039 905D5 12 3B;1221@< 78 905 :631;3<92 1< 905 5F1B5<:5 9039 D1B5D C32 D1B1<= 905 F501:65 C190@?9 905 61:5<:5 < 905 :325 @< 03<B 905D5 12 <@9 5F5< 3 21<=65 2?==5291@< 9@ 905 C19<522 9039 905 BD1F5D @E 905 F501:65 C32<@94@225221<=61:5<:53990591;5@E3::1B5<95G:549 905 2?==5291@< 9039 19 C32 <@9 @< 905 <5=61=5<:5 399D17?937659@BD1F5D@E1<2?D5D9053::1B5<903B@::?DD5B - 15 - 7?91912@<905<5=61=5<:5@EB5:5325B3<B905459191@<12 E165B @<68 E@D 255I1<= :@;45<2391@< @< E3625 :325 D5=1295D5B 3=31<29 905 BD1F5D @E 905 1445D G:549 9012 905D5 12 <@ 2?==5291@< E@D90:@;1<= 1< 905 5F1B5<:5 @E 153445663<9@905D51<<90525:1D:?;293<:52 905 A?B=;5<9 @E 905 @!@DB1<395 5<:0 C166 <@9 :@;5 9@ 905 31B @E 905 1<2?D5D 32 19 12 B1291<=?1203765 @< E3:92 ;5D5 D5=129D391@< @E :325 1< 905 3725<:5 @E 3<8 4D@@E 9@ 905 5EE5:9 9039 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:65 5<9D?295B 905 F501:65:@<2:1@?26803F1<=I<@C65B=5@E<@61:5<:5C@?6B <@9 372@6F5 905 1<2?D5D 372@6?9568 ED@; 613716198 B;1995B68 905 @C<5D C32 463:5B 5G43D95 3<B 905 B5:5325B C32 3 901DB 43D98 3<B ;5D5 @C<5D 463:5B 5G243D9590523;5:3<<@9753=D@?<B9@E3295<613716198 @< 905 1<2?D5B 05 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 <@D 65B 3<8 5F1B5<:5 9039 905 1<2?D5B :@<2:1@?268 5<9D?295B 905 F501:659@905BD1F5DC0@C32<@903F1<=BD1F1<=61:5<:5 < F15C @E 905 A?B=;5<9 @E 905 @<-765 45G @?D91< "C01:012F5D8:6@259@905E3:92 - 16 - @E 905 :325 32 1< 905 231B :325 362@ 905 BD1F5D @E 905 @EE5<B1<=F501:65C32<@903F1<=61:5<:59@BD1F590523;5 3<B 5F5< D17?<36 32 C566 32 905 1=0 @?D9 5G@<5D395B 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 ED@; 4381<= :@;45<2391@< @C5F5D 93I1<= <@95 @E 905 A?B=;5<9 @E $ " % & ' 905@<-76545G@?D9B1D5:95B9051<2?D3<:5:@;43<89@ 23912E8 905 3C3DB 4D1;3D168 C190 6175D98 9@ D5:@F5D 905 23;5 ED@; 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:65 05 D532@< 751<= :631;3<920@?6B<@975366@C5B9@2?EE5D3<BD?<37@?9905 D565325@E905:@;45<2391@<3C3DB5BC05<3<1<95D529@E 901DB 43D98 12 1<F@6F5B 3<B 1E 905D5 12 3 B1D5:91@< 9@ 905 @C<5D9@23912E819C@?6B75F5D803DBE@D905:631;3<929@ =595G5:?91@<323C3DBC166D5;31<3234345D3C3DB3<B <@91<D53619801212905D532@<905@<-76545G@?D91< :395<3 @E :3252 3<B 1< 905 A?B=;5<9 29395B " @E 905 @41<1@<90399051<2?D3<:5:@;43<8754D1;3D168;3B59@ 5 (2004) 3 SCC 297 - 17 - 23912E89053C3DBC19036175D989@D5:@F5D90523;5ED@; 905@C<5D@E905F501:65151<2?D5B < 95D;2 @E 905 A?B=;5<9 @E 905 @<-765 45G @?D9"3<B32905A?B=;5<92D5E5DD5B78905653D<5B E@D9051<2?D3<:5:@;43<83D5<@934461:37659@905E3:92 @E905:325C53D5@E905@41<1@<9039905E1<B1<=@E905 D17?<36125DD@<5@?21<9@9365G@<5D391@<@E9051<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8D532@<751<=905D512372@6?9568<@B12:?221@<1< 9055<91D57@B8@E905A?B=;5<9D5=3DB1<=905D532@<E@D 3DD1F1<= 9@ 905 :@<:6?21@< E@D 5G@<5D391<= 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 372@6?9568 C190@?9 3<8 4D@@E 05 D17?<36 5G:549 @725DF1<= 39 43D3 @ 9039 905 BD1F5D @E 905 1445DB1B<@94@22522F361BBD1F1<=61:5<:53990591;5@E 3::1B5<9 3;@?<92 9@ E?<B3;5<936 7D53:0 @E 4@61:8 :@<B191@<2 905 1<2?D5D 12 <@9 613765 9@ 23912E8 905 3C3DB @C5F5D 905 E3:9 D5;31<2 9039 1< 905 :03D=5!20559 905 :03D=5?<B5D9054D@F121@<2@E:93=31<29905BD1F5D @E905F501:6532C56632@C<5D@E905F501:65C321<F@I5B 78905@61:5<90525:1D:?;293<:52C53D5@E905E1D; - 18 - @41<1@< 9039 905 D17?<36 @?=09 9@ 03F5 ;3B5 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 4D1;3D168 613765 9@ 23912E8 905 3C3DB C190 6175D98 9@ D5:@F5D 905 23;5 ED@; 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:6532901DB43D98D1=0921<F@6F5B1<905 75E@D5905 D17?<36 ::@DB1<=68 C5 3<2C5D 905 4@1<9 E@D :@<21B5D391@<43D9681<3EE1D;391F5683<B4D@:55B5B9@4322 905E@66@C1<=. 1% 0534453612**+,-.#/01L 11% 05 A?B=;5<9 B395B ") 43225B 78 905 D1<:1436 129D1:9 3<B 5221@<2 ?B=53<B 31:0?D 1< @ 5G@<5D391<= 905 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 372@6?9568 ED@; 23912E81<= 905:@;45<2391@<1205D578( 111% 05 D524@<B5<9 @ H 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 12 4D1;3D168 23912E8 905 5<91D5 :@;45<2391@< 3C3DB5B78905D17?<3636@<=C1901<95D529ED@; 905 B395 @E 459191@< 9166 D5361J391@< C190 3 6175D98 - 19 - 9@ D5:@F5D 905 23;5 ED@; 905 @C<5D @E 905 F501:65 1F% 05D524@<B5<9@ ! 1<2?D3<:5 :@;43<8 20366 B54@219 905 5<91D5 :@;45<2391@< 36@<= C190 1<95D529C1901<1GC55I2ED@;905B395@ED5:5149 @E 3 :@48 @E 9012 @DB5D 75E@D5 905 :@<:5D<5B D17?<36 F% 127?D25;5<9 32 C566 32 344@D91@<;5<9 @E 905 :@;45<2391@< 3;@?<9 20366 75 32 45D 905 1;4?=<5B@DB5D@E905D17?<36 F1% @@DB5D329@:@29 -2 &# ( % -2 &( % 129@.6@.) .