- 1 - !" #$% $ $ &' ( ! " # $#%% # & %% # ! # %% # # # #!' ! ## ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ## ! ( # # # ( ! ' %% # # ) ! * * # ( ! ) * # ! " ## $ #+ , + (#), !!!# '# ++#& - 3 - * # + # !!( + # # +# # &* # # # + # % # !'! ) %% ## # # # % ( ! ' ##- & # * # #. %%+ #+#%# + # %# #+ %## # /. * % # # % #0% %% $ #0% %%& 123234516378194612:374;628135<=<<631>1?8@2:1 46?16 A=771? 8@ 2:1 1A;2@ 4BB37734516 A64?;C1? =2 551D;61 8@ E:3C: 2:1 61>37345 A1232345 93F1? 8@ 617A45?152#4(:16135:=78115=FF4E1?:17=3?1526317 A162=357 24 F=5? 35 @#4!) B1=7;635< ( =C617 <;52=7 732;=21? =2 2=<= >3FF=<1 ;B5=8=? =F;G= $:16135=92166191661?24=7/7;8H1C2F=5?.& - 4 - ! 1=651? C4;571F 946 2:1 A123234516 2=G35< 2:37 4;622:64;<:2:161C46?7B461A=623C;F=6F@2:1H;?<B152 =5? ?1C611 A=771? 35 #4()! 45 2:1 93F1 49 2:1 635C3A=F 3>3F ;?<1 =2 ;B5=8=? 7;8B327 2:=2 2:1 617A45?152#4(:=7 54 7:=61 63<:2232F1 =5? 35216172 35 2:1 7;8H1C2 F=5? :=2 2:1 7=3? 7;32 E=7 93F1? 8@ 2:1 617A45?152#4(9462:161F31949?1CF=6=2345494E5167:3A =5? C4571I;1523=F 61F319 49 35H;5C2345 35 617A1C2 49 F=5? 81=635< @#4 B1=7;635< ! =C617 <;52=7 =5? @#4! :=2 35 2:1 7=3? 7;32 2:1 617A45?152 #4( :16135 :3B71F9 :=7 61F31? ;A45 = ?4C;B152 5=B1F@ B1B46=5?;B 49 A=6232345 A64?;C1? 2:16135 =2 D 35 216B7 49 E:3C: 7;8H1C2 F=5? 35 @#4!) E:3C: 242=FF@ B1=7;617 ! =C617 ! <;52=7 :=7 8115 =FF4221? 24 2:1 7:=61 49 ;7:A=>=2:3 $617A45?152 #4 :16135& 22=BG;B=6 $617A45?152 #4' :16135& =5? =22=26=@= $:;78=5? 49 617A45?152 #4)& 1=C: 8135< 15232F1? 946 =C617 <;52=7 1=C: :4;<: =5 1D2152 49 =C617 <;52=7 1=C: :=>1 8115 =FF4221? 24 2:1 7:=617 49 2:1 =94617=3?2:611A1674572:161>15;11526317E161B=?135 - 5 - 2:1 5=B1 49 22=BG;B=6 24 2:1 1D2152 49 ( =C617 <;52=717;8B3272:=22:1A=6231724D :=?B;2;=FF@ 1D1C;21?C45936B=2345?11?7C45936B35<2:1F=6<161D2152 49 2:1 F=5? <3>15 24 2:1 7:=61 49 22=BG;B=6 :;7 :1 7;8B327 2:=2 45C1 2:1 A64A162@ 35 @#4!) :=7 1>15 =CC46?35<24617A45?152#4(8115=FF4221?242:17:=617 49 ;7:A=>=2:3 22=BG;B=6 =22=26=@= 2:161 61B=357 542:35<946617A45?152#4(24CF=3B=5@7:=6163<:2232F1 46 35216172 E:=2741>16 4>16 2:1 7=B1 1 7;8B327 2:=2 =84>1 8135< 2:1 9=C2;=F =?B3221? A4732345 H;72 24 C61=21 3BA1?3B152 24 2:1 A123234516 :16135 E:4 A;6C:=71? 2:1 7=3? ( =C617 ) <;52=7 49 F=5? 964B 22=BG;B=6 617A45?152 #4( :16135 A6191661? 2:1 61>37345 A1232345 C:=FF15<35< 2:161>15;1 1526317 B=?1 35 2:1 5=B1 49 :37 >15?46717;8B3272:11A;2@4BB377345161DC11?35< :37H;637?3C23453548716>35<2:=222=BG;B=6?3?542:=>1 =5@ 63<:2 4>16 ( =C617 ) <;52=7 49 F=5? =5? C4571I;152F@ 46?161? 946 C=5C1FF=2345 49 61>15;1 1526317 B=?1 35 :37 5=B1 15C1 711G7 946 =FF4E35< 49 2:1 A1232345 - 6 - 1=651?C4;571F=AA1=635<946617A45?152#4( 45 2:1 42:16 :=5? >1:1B152F@ 7;8B327 2:=2 2:1 7;32 946 ?1CF=6=2345E=793F1?54235617A1C249F=5?35@#4!) 1 7;8B327 2:=2 617A45?152 #4( :=7 :37 35?1A15?152 7:=6163<:2232F1=5?352161721>1535@#4!):=22:1 A=6232345 542 :=>35< 8115 1991C21? 35 2:1 B=5516 G54E5 24F=E617A45?152#47'24)C=5542CF=3B1DCF;73>163<:2 4>16 2:1 7=B1 :1 A123234516 :16135 2:1619461 C4;F? 542 <12 =5@ 63<:2 232F1 =5? 35216172 4>16 2:1 A64A162@ B1=7;61? 35 ( =C617 ) <;52=7 CF=3B1? 24 :=>1 8115 A;6C:=71? 8@ :3B 964B :;78=5? 49 617A45?152 #4) 1 9;62:16 7;8B327 2:=2 617A45?152 #4( C45235;1? 24 81 35 A477177345 49 2:1 A64A162@ :1619461 54 3FF1<=F32@ 46 3661<;F=632@C4BB3221?352:146?16A=771?8@2:11A;2@ 4BB37734516 E=66=5235< 3521691615C1 15C1 711G7 946 ?37B377=F492:1A1232345 1=6? 16;71?2:161C46?7 - 7 - :1 7;32 35 #4()! 37 93F1? 8@ 617A45?152 #4( 946 2:1 61F319 49 ?1CF=6=2345 49 :37 4E5167:3A =5? C4571I;1523=F 61F319 49 A16B=5152 35H;5C234535617A1C249F=5?35#4 B1=7;635<! =C617 <;52=7 732;=21? =2 45<=6=A;6= >3FF=<1 =5? #4 :1 7=3? 7;32 :=7 8115 A=62F@ ?1C611? >3?1 H;?<B152 =5? ?1C611 ?=21? ! =6= ! 49 2:1 7=3?H;?<B15261=?7=7;5?16 ! "# !$ %& ' ! ! ( !$ )* $ + !, %**-** ". )&- /$$ )'0".)*- ' % /0 1 / /$$ /'0 ". )*23 4 " /%0*25 % 6 .$ . 0 0 ( *'*'**- $ ! $ ! ! ".)*-0*0& &-7 0( ( ) 8 - 8 - ( :1 ?4C;B152 =2 D 6191661? 24 35 2:1 =94617=3?H;?<B15237=B1B46=5?;B49A=62323452:=2:=7 8115 152161? 3524 =B45<72 2:1 A=62317 35 216B7 49 E:3C: F=5? 35 @#4!) :=7 8115 =FF4221? 24 2:1 1D2152 49 =C617 <;52=7 1=C: 35 9=>4;6 49 ;7:A=>=2:3 22=BG;B=6=5?=22=26=@=$617A45?152#4617A45?152 #4' =5? :;78=5? 49 617A45?152 #4) 617A1C23>1F@& :37 ?4C;B15237A64?;C1?=5?61F31?;A45545142:162:=58@ 617A45?152#4(:16135:3B71F935:374E57;321:=7542 35323=21?=5@A64C11?35<7CF=3B35<=5@7:=6163<:2232F146 35216172352:17=3?F=5?35@#4!)23FF?=21?B3221?F@ :1 :=7 542 6=371? =5@ ?37A;21 E32: 61<=6? 24 2:1 7=3? B1B46=5?;B A=6232345 :1 61>15;1 1526317 B=?1 35 2:1 5=B1 49 =22=26=@= 2:1 :;78=5? 49 617A45?152 #4) :16135 E:4 =?B3221?F@ E=7 =FF4221? =C617 <;52=7 C=5542 81 2:1619461 81 ?37A;21? :1 45F@ 377;1 37 2:=2 35721=? 49 =C617 <;52=7 49 F=5? 5=B1 49 7=3? =22=6=@=:=78115B;2=21?242:11D215249(=C617 <;52=7 35C1 F=5? 35 @#4!) :=7 8115 A=62323451? 35 216B749B1B46=5?;B49A=6232345=7A16D 6191661? - 9 - 24 35 2:1 =94617=3? A=6=<6=A: 49 2:1 H;?<B152 35 #4()! 2:1 7=B1 C=5542 81 C=FF1? 35 I;172345 819461 2:1 1A;2@ 4BB37734516 :1 1A;2@ 4BB37734516 2:1619461 :=? 54 H;637?3C2345 24 732 ;A45 =5? =?H;?3C=21 2:1 >=F3?32@ 42:16E371 49 2:1 7=3? B1B46=5?;BA=623234546=5@42:16=66=5<1B1522:=2:=? 8115 152161? 3524 812E115 2:1 A=62317 A;67;=52 2:16124 :16194612:16137C4573?16=8F1946C1357;8B3773458135< B=?14581:=F9492:1A123234516 ' :4;F? 617A45?152 #4( :=>1 =5@ <631>=5C1 E32: 61<=6? 24 2:1 A=6232345 152161? 3524 35 617A1C2 49 @#4!) 35 216B7 49 B1B46=5?;B A=6232345 =7 A16 D 6191661?24=2A=6=<6=A: !492:1H;?<B152A=771? 352:17;32E:3C:E=793F1?8@617A45?152#4(:3B71F932 E=7=FE=@74A15946:3B24711G=?H;?3C=2345492:1377;1 352:1B=5516G54E524F=E#42:35<37864;<:24561C46? 61<=6?35<2:1617A45?152#4(:=>35<2=G15=5@721A746 35323=235<=5@=C2345352:3761<=6? 52:=2>31E492:1B=22162:194FF4E35< - 10 - 3& *632A123234537 33& :146?163BA;<51?A=771?8@617A45?152 #4 J 1A;2@ 4BB37734516 3?=6 =2 551D;61242:1E632A123234537I;=7:1? 333& 38162@ 37 61716>1? 24 617A45?152 #4( 24 711G7;C:61B1?@=7B=@81=>=3F=8F1=5? A16B37738F1;5?16F=E3974=?>371? )' &$ $( % # 372#4 F#4'