- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &'( ) !"" # $% & ' ()$ & "* " "" & !" # ' $)+ $ &, & & % )) &#&%) $" ) ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ ' $ & & & & " ") "'$ " " "" )' "" )) ' $ ( ( - '" $ & ./0123./0456.72890:6;:238<1.8 3<8 /==./> <8 =0.9.00.1 ;? 23. @>/<6/72 /4/<782 23. '5146.72 /71 /A/01 1/2.1 & & =/88.1 <7 $ :& &;?11<2<:7/>.7<:0<B<>'514./71 .6;.0 />/;50/4< #9:0 83:02 C23. 20<;57/>D% 8..E<74 .73/7@.6.72 :9 23. @:6=.78/2<:7 /6:572 /A/01.1 ;? 23. 20<;57/> 7 && & 23. @>/<6/72 6.2 A<23 23. /@@<1.72 /71 8599.0.1 <7F50<.8 . 2/E.7 20./26.72 <7 23. :8=<2/> . 9<>.1 / @>/<6 =.2<2<:7 8..E<74 @:6=.78/2<:7 ;.9:0.23.20<;57/>3.20<;57/>/92.0@:78<1.0<7423..72<0. 6/2.0</> .B<1.7@. :7 0.@:01 /A/01.1 / 856 :9 - 3 - 8G />:74 A<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. :9 GH =.0 /7756 90:6 23. 1/2. :9 =.2<2<:7 2<>>23. 1/2. :9 0./><I/2<:7 440<.B.1 ;? 23. 8/<1 '5146.72 /71 /A/01 23<8 /==./> <8 =0.9.00.1 <7 A3<@3 <2 <8 @:72.71.1 23/2 23. @>/<6/72 A/8 A:0E<74 /8 / >/;:50 /2 :>/0 ">/72 /71 ./07<74 / 856 :9 8 =.06:723:78<1.0<7423.<7F50<.88599.0.1;? 23. @>/<6/72 23. :@2:0 /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<><2? :9 23. @>/<6/72 /2 H 2: 23. A3:>. ;:1? /71 23. 20<;57/> 3/8 @:78<1.0.123.1<8/;<><2?/2H)5023.0>./07.1@:578.>9:0 23. @>/<6/72 /==.>>/72 85;6<28 23/2 6./4.0 /6:5728 A.0. 40/72.1 571.0 :23.0 3./18 <. 20/78=:02/2<:7 .J20/ 7:50<836.72 /71 /22.71/72 @3/04.8 /71 />8: 9:0 =/<7 /71 8599.0<748 2358 3. 8..E8 9:0 .73/7@.6.72 :9 23. @:6=.78/2<:7 K J"G<823.A:571@.02<9<@/2.8=.0J"G3. 8582/<7.1 90/@250. :9 >.92 A0<82 /71 <2 <8 / 40<.B:58 <7F50? "/88.88.123.1<8/;<><2?/2H2:23.A3:>.;:1?3. 20<;57/> 3/8 0<432>? 2/E.7 & 01 :9 H <. H <7@. 23. @>/<6/72 3/8 7:2 =0:15@.1 /7? <7@:6. =0::9 <2 A:5>1 ;. /==0:=0</2. 2: 2/E. 23. <7@:6. :9 23. @>/<6/72 /2 - 4 - 8& /8 =.0 23. @3/02 =0.=/0.1 ;? 23. /07/2/E/ 2/2. .4/> .0B<@.8 523:0<2? 8<7@. 23. /@@<1.72 <8 :9 23. ?./0 & .7@. 23. >:88 :9 95250. <7@:6. A:5>1 ;. /8 571.0( 8& L&L&LHM8&& 3. @>/<6/72 A/8 3:8=<2/><I.1 9:0 9:502..7 1/?8 3. 20<;57/> /A/01.1 / 856 :9 8& 2:A/018 6.1<@/> .J=.78.8 3. 8/6. <8 @:00.@2 /71 7..18 7: <72.09.0.7@.3<8:5029<718<20./8:7/;>.2:/A/01/856:9 8 571.0 23. 3./1 =/<7 /71 8599.0<74 / 856 :9 8 9:0 >:88 :9 /6.7<2<.8 / 856 :9 8 2:A/018 20/78=:02/2<:7 .J20/ 7:50<836.72 /71 /22.71/72 @3/04.83.@>/<6/726<4323/B.7:2/22.71.1/7?A:0E/2 >./82 9:0 / =.0<:1 :9 230.. 6:7238 15. 2: 23. <7F50<.8 8582/<7.1;?3<6<723./@@<1.72 .<8.72<2>.12:/856:9 8 #8& L 6:7238% 571.0 23. 3./1 :9 >:88:9<7@:6.150<74>/<15==.0<:1 G .7@. 23. 2:2/> @:6=.78/2<:7 A:5>1 ;. /8 571.0( - 5 - !* +,-./01+2.,342 0523 & "/<7/718599.0<74 8 .1<@/>.J=.78.8 8& :88:995250.<7@:6. 8&& K :88:9/6.7<2<.8 8 0/78=:02/2<:7 .J20/ 7:50<836.72 /71 /22.71/72 @3/04.8 8 G :88 :9 <7@:6. 150<74 >/<1 5= =.0<:1 8 3,* . 67 ./07.1 @:578.> 9:0 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? 85;6<28 23/2 23. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? 3/8 1.=:8<2.1 23. /A/01/6:572 @@:01<74>?23.9:>>:A<74:01.0( #<% 3./==./><8/>>:A.1<7=/02+ #<<% 3. @:6=.78/2<:7 /6:572 :9 8G /A/01.1;?23.20<;57/><8.73/7@.1 2:8KK />:74A<23<72.0.82/223.0/2.:9 GH =.0 /7756 90:6 23. 1/2. :9 =.2<2<:7 2<>> 23. 1/2.:90./><I/2<:7+ #<<<% 3. 7850/7@. @:6=/7? <8 1<0.@2.1 2: 1.=:8<223..73/7@.1@:6=.78/2<:7:98G />:74 A<23 <72.0.82 /2 23. 0/2. :9 GH =.0 /7756 - 6 - A<23<7/=.0<:1:9:7.6:72390:623.1/2.:923<8 :01.0+ #<B% 7 85@3 1.=:8<2 23. @>/<6/72 <8 =.06<22.1 2: A<2310/A 23. .72<0. /6:572 />:74 A<23<72.0.82/@@05.123.0.:7 .-7 &%!! ( $ $ <82:(&>:(,&