Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43230 (KAR)
SMT SANGITA AND ORS v. MALLAREDDY AND ANR
MFA/200632/2020 · 2025-10-28
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43230 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43230 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "# #$
!! %$& '
! "
#
$$
$
%
$$
$
$$
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$$
&$ ' $
()#%#
*$$
! $
"
& +
&$' $
()
%
(),
*$ ! $
" ! %
"
% $$ %
!"
% ,))$
% )$
&
% $$ $ % - (
).
$ % & $
&
)
$$ %
&
- 3 -
/& $
/& &
# !$
/& $"
01- 233425 67849 4:;1<7 !" <= ;04 <;<9 401:54-:;,))!0494172=;4994=49948;<2->;04:;?=<9 -0<9;"02-@447=1548@A;04:521B27;-@417C2CC914D48@A ;04E68CB47;2782F29882;4832--48@A;04
885 471<9 1D15 &68C4 278 252@692C1 17 <)
%2:;- C1D17C 91-4 ;< ;04 =1517C <= ;04 233425 @914=5A -;2;48 294 ;02; <7 ,) 2; 2@<6; ) 3B <7 <;69(252C1 B217 9<28 7429 :27745 06-@278 <= ;04 :521B27; < @A 72B4 0292729488A 25<7C F1;0 <74 @0152-0 F494 39<:44817C <7 B<;<9:A:54 @42917C 94C1-;92;1<7 <(( , 04 -218 B<;<9:A:54 F2- 918847 @A @0152-0 17 2 92-0 278 74C51C47; B27749 5<-;
:<7;9<5 <D49 ;04 B<;<9:A:54 864 ;< F01:0 0292729488A
- 4 -
=455 8<F7 - 2 94-65; <= ;04 2=<94-218 2::1847; ;04 84:42-48-6-;21748C914D<6-17E6914-2788148<7;04-3<;
04 :521B27;- =1548 2 34;1;1<7 67849 4:;1<7 ## <= ;04 :; -44G17C :<B347-2;1<7 =<9 ;04 842;0 <= ;04 84:42-4825<7CF1;017;494-;
7-49D1:4<=-6BB<7-;0494-3<7847;<-278 23342948 ;09<6C0 :<67-45 278 =1548 F91;;47 -;2;4B47; 847A17C;042D49B47;-B28417;04:521B34;1;1<7
7 ;04 @2-1- <= ;04 3542817C- <= ;04 329;14- ;04 521B-91@6725=92B48;041--64-278;04942=;4994:<9848 ;044D1847:404:521B27;-17<9849;<39<D4;04:2-4 :521B27; < F2- 4H2B1748 049-45= 2- $( 278 C<; 4H01@1;488<:6B47;-72B45AH$;<H$4-3<7847;
< 02- 7<; 548 27A 4D1847:4
7 @4025= <= 94-3<7847; <<74F1;74--F2-4H2B17482-(0<F4D498187<;
C<; B29G48 27A 8<:6B47;- 04 521B- 91@6725 @A ;04 1B36C748E68CB47;17;4925120458;02;;042::1847;;<<G 352:4 <7 2::<67; <= 92-0 278 74C51C47; 891D17C <= ;04 <==47817C D401:54 @A 1;- 891D49 2- 2 94-65; <= F01:0 ;04
- 5 -
84:42-48-6-;2174817E6914-278-6::6B@48;<;0417E6914- 0491@6725=69;0490458;02;;04:521B27;-29447;1;548;< 2 :<B347-2;1<7 <= -)( 25<7C F1;0 17;494-; 2; ;0492;4<=#.322788194:;48;0494-3<7847;( 7-6927:4 <B327A;<843<-1;;04:<B347-2;1<72B<67;25<7CF1;0 17;494-;417C2CC914D48;01-23342502-@447=1548 # 045429748:<67-45=<9;04:521B27;-02-921-48;04 =<55<F17C:<7;47;1<7- 2" %19-;5A ;04 :521B27;- :521B ;02; ;04 84:42-48 F2- 2C48 2@<6; , A429- 2; ;04 ;1B4 <= ;04 2::1847; 278 04 F2- 02D17C 17:<B4 <= -( 349 2776B =9<B 2C91:65;694278-(349B<7;0=9<B@6-174--6; ;0491@67251-7<;E6-;1=14817;2G17C;04B<7;05A17:<B4 <= ;04 84:42-48 2- -( 7 <9849 ;< 39<D4 ;04 -2B4 ;04 :521B27;- 02D4 39<86:48 H$(28029 :298 F049417 ;04 82;4 <= @19;0 <= ;04 84:42-48 02- @447 B47;1<748 2- ,, <F4D49 ;04 521B- 91@6725 02-:<7-184948;042C4<=;0484:42-482- A429-F01:0 1-:<7;929A;<;04B2;491252D2152@54<794:<98
- 6 -
@" 4:<785A 2- 349 ;04 E68CB47; <= ;04 <7?@54 6394B4 <69; 17 ;04 :2-4 <=
42:0 <= ;04 :521B27;- 294 47;1;548 =<9 :<B347-2;1<7 <= - ( 67849 ;040428<= >5<-- <=5<D4 278 2==4:;1<7 278:<7-<9;16B?
:" 2-;5A :<7-184917C ;04 2C4 278 2D<:2;1<7 <= ;04 84:42-48 ;04 <D49255 :<B347-2;1<7 2F29848 @A ;04 91@67251-<7;045<F49-18447:404392A-=<9255<F17C ;04233425
7 ;04 <;049 0278 ;04 5429748 :<67-45 =<9 ;04
7-6927:4 <B327A 02- 921-48 ;04 =<55<F17C :<67;49( :<7;47;1<7- 2" %19-;5A 4D47 ;0<6C0 ;04 :521B27;- :521B ;02; ;04 84:42-48F2-429717C-(349B<7;0;04-2B41- 7<;4-;2@51-048@A;04:521B27;-@A39<86:17C8<:6B47;- 0494=<94;0491@672502-91C0;5A2--4--48;0417:<B4<= ;0484:42-487<;1<7255A
- 7 -
@" 4:<785A;042C4<=;0484:42-48F2-:<7-1849482- A429- 2- 349 ;04 3<-; B<9;4B 943<9; 04 521B- 91@672502-91C0;5A:<7-184948;042C4<=;0484:42-482- A429- :" 01985A <7 23394:12;1<7 <= <925 278 8<:6B47;29A 4D1847:4 278 :<7-184917C ;04 2C4 278 2D<:2;1<7 <= ;04 84:42-48 ;04 <D49255 :<B347-2;1<7 2F29848 @A ;04 91@6725 1- E6-; 278 942-<72@54 47:4 04 392A- =<9 81-B1--25<=;04233425 ) 4298 ;04 5429748 :<67-45 =<9 ;04 329;14- 278 3496-48;04E68CB47;2782F298<=;0491@6725 ,
; 1- 7<; 17 81-36;4 ;02; 0292729488A 8148 17 ;04 9<28 ;92==1: 2::1847; <::69948 <7 ,) 864 ;<92-0 27874C51C47;891D17C<=;04<==47817CD401:54@A1;-891D49
04 :521B27;- :521B ;02; 84:42-48 F2- 429717C -( 349 B<7;0 6; ;04A 02D4 7<; 39<86:48 27A 8<:6B47;-;< 39<D4 ;04 17:<B4<=;0484:42-48 7;04 2@-47:4<=39<<=<=17:<B4;047<;1<72517:<B402-;<@4 2--4--48 - 349 ;04 C61845174- 1--648 @A ;04 2972;2G2
- 8 -
;2;4 4C25 49D1:4- 6;0<91;A =<9 ;04 2::1847; ;2G47 352:4 17 ;04 A429 ) ;04 7<;1<725 17:<B4 <= ;04 84:42-48 02- ;< @4 ;2G47 2; -( 3B 17:4 ;04 :521B27;-02D439<86:48;0428029:298<=;0484:42-48 2; H$ F049417 ;04 82;4 <= @19;0 <= ;04 84:42-48 1- B47;1<7482-,,2-<7;0482;4<=;042::1847; 04521B-91@672502-4994817:<7-184917C;042C4<=;04 84:42-48 2- A429- <7-184917C ;04 -218 8<:6B47; 2; H$;042C4<=;0484:42-4802-;<@4:<7-1849482- ,A429-<;042=<94-21817:<B4 .02-;<@428848 <72::<67;<==6;69439<-34:;-17D14F<=;0452F52188<F7 @A ;04 <7-;1;6;1<7 47:0 <= ;04 6394B4 <69; 17 ;04 :2-4 <=
! ! ""17:4;0494294 =1D4 84347847;- 1; 1- 2339<3912;4 ;< 8486:; ;0 <= ;04 17:<B4 <= ;04 84:42-48 ;<F298- 349-<725 4H347-4- 278 94B21717C 2B<67; 02- ;< @4 ;2G47 2- 01- :<7;91@6;1<7 ;< ;04=2B15A0484:42-48F2-2C482@<6;,A429-2;;04 ;1B4 <= ;04 2::1847; 278 B65;135149 23351:2@54 ;< 01- 2C4
- 9 -
C9<63 1- >? 06- ;04 :521B27;- 294 47;1;548 ;< :<B347-2;1<7 <= -( !-# III " <72::<67;<=>5<--<=84347847:A? 7 2881;1<7 ;04 :521B27;- 294 47;1;548 ;< :<B347-2;1<7<=-(<72::<67;<=>5<--<=4-;2;4? 278 :<B347-2;1<7 <= -( <7 2::<67; <= >=674925 4H347-4-? 7D14F<=;0452F52188<F7@A;046394B4<69;17 ;04 :2-4 <= # !-6392" :521B27; < F1=4 <= ;04 84:42-48 1- 47;1;548 =<9 :<B347-2;1<7 <= - ( 67849 ;04 0428 <= /5<-- <= -3<6-25:<7-<9;16B/278:521B27;<-278:0158947<= ;0484:42-4829447;1;548=<9:<B347-2;1<7<=- ( 42:0 67849 ;04 0428 <= >5<-- <= 32947;25 :<7-<9;16B? 278 :521B27;<- 27832947;-<=;0484:42-4829447;1;548 =<9 :<B347-2;1<7 <= - ( 42:0 67849 ;04 0428 <= >5<--<==15125:<7-<9;16B? 06- ;04 :521B27;- 294 47;1;548 ;< ;04 =<55<F17C :<B347-2;1<7
- 10 -
()*+,-./+0+1*2 1/*2*+.*-1, (0+./+ %,& <--<=84347847:A
%6749254H347-4-
<--<=4-;2;4
<--<=-3<6-25 :<7-<9;16B
<--<=$2947;25 :<7-<9;16B ) <--<=%15125:<7-<9;16B ) .-3
45
7;0494-65;;04=<55<F17C<98491-32--48
2" 042334251--336*1/+)-2.
@" 04E68CB47;<=;04521B-91@67251-B<81=148 :" 04 :521B27;- 294 47;1;548 ;< 2 ;<;25 :<B347-2;1<7 <= , 457 2- 2C217-; -)(2F29848@A;0491@6725 8" 04 7-6927:4 <B327A 1- 8194:;48 ;< 843<-1; ;04:<B347-2;1<72B<67;25<7CF1;017;494-;2;
- 11 -
#. 32 =9<B ;04 82;4 <= =1517C <= ;04 :521B 34;1;1<7;155;0482;4<=94251J2;1<7F1;01723491<8 <=-1HF44G-=9<B;0482;4<=94:413;<=:<3A<= ;01-E68CB47; 4" 04 233<9;1<7B47; 843<-1; 278 94542-4 <= 2B<67;-0255@4B28417;49B-<=;042F298<= ;0491@6725
17 %!& #
17 % #$ & #
1-;<5< #