- 1 - ! "#" $#!%%! !!&& '%( ) ! "#$ % &$$ "$ '& & & () ) & ! "#$ $ $$ ) )& ( *&& $$) & ! "#$ % &$& ( + " ) &( ( "," ( & ) & ( ) & "$"#$#" ) ( $ && $""!! #"- ) ) & $" ##### )$ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) &( & ( & ) &) & ) .&$) & # /012/3445367867895:;0<0<:5<8=79/>0?85?90;653<?5: >01?856;0<43<9758797893@5?14;0<;7?36:7840836$ $ /3665?27?2A1:2B5?93?:3=3<::395:"$"#$#" 43885:CD::7970?365?70<7E761:253?:&090<>>7:5?9 637B8 <7C1?36 363C1<327 ;0< 8/0<9 F9<7C1?36G 7? & ?0$""!! #"-9/7834453678;765:$ $ B9$<7:5E7 $1443: 653<?5: >01?856 81CB7995: 344536 =38 CD >637B3?9 ;0< 5?/3?>5B5?9 0; >0B45?83970?$ 9 =3881CB7995:0?"-$# $#"-=/5?>637B3?9=384<0>55:7?2 360?2 =79/ <56397E5 0? B090<>D>65 C53<7?2 ?0$ ## :<7E5<0;0<<DC53<7?2?0$&)"! ,!H:<0E5797?<38/3?: ?526725?9 B3??5< 3?: :38/5: 3237?89 B090<>D>65 >3187?2 3>>7:5?9$?3>>7:5?9>637B3?9818937?5:2<75E0187?A1<7583?: 3:B7995: 90 0E5<?B5?9 )0847936 5=3<27 3?: 6395< 90 3B3<5::D)0847936363C1<327$15903>>7:5?9367?A1<758/5< <72/9 /3?: =38 3B4195: 39 56C0= 65E56$ 0?85I15?96D 8/5 - 3 - 818937?5: 45<B3?5?9 4/D87>36 :783C7679D 3?: 6088 0; 53<?7?2 >343>79D$/5<5;0<58/5;765:>637B4597970?1?:5<5>970?"JJ 0;&090<5/7>658>93237?890=?5<3?:7?81<5<0;0<<D$ H$ 58479585<E7>50;?097>50=?5<:7:?0934453</5 =38 463>5: $ ?81<5< 044085: >637B 4597970? :5?D7?2 325 0>>143970? 7?>0B5 3?: 6088 0; 53<?7?2 >343>79D 0; >637B3?938=56638366527?2>0?9<7C190<D?526725?>50?43<90; <7:5< 0; B090<>D>65$ E5? E7063970? 0; 95<B8 3?: >0?:7970?8 0; 4067>D=38366525:$ $ 385: 0? 4653:7?28 9<7C1?36 ;<3B5: 788158 3?: <5>0<:5: 5E7:5?>5$ 637B3?9 5K3B7?5: /5<856; 3?: <$3A1 16@3<?7 38 8$" 3?: 3?: K8$" 90 " =5<5 B3<@5:$ 5840?:5?98:7:?09653:5E7:5?>5$ J$ ? >0?87:5<3970? 9<7C1?36 /56: 3>>7:5?9 0>>1<<5: :15 90 <38/ 3?: ?526725?9 :<7E7?2 0; 0<<D CD 798 :<7E5< >637B3?9 818937?5: 45<B3?5?9 4/D87>36 :783C7679D 3?: 6088 0; 53<?7?2 >343>79D 3?: =38 5?97965: ;0< >0B45?83970? ;<0B 7?81<5<38;0660=8 - 4 - !* +,-./0+1.,231 /412 " 37?3?:81;;5<7?28 H#### &5:7>365K45?858 - "H 0880;53<?7?28:1<7?2637:1445<70: -, # H 0880;;191<553<?7?2:783C7679D ,H## 19<797018;00:3?:3995?:3?9>/3<258 #### J 088 0; ;191<5 3B5?79758 3?: 6088 0; /3447?588 #### 2,* 5 6 7883978;75:=79/I13?91B>637B3?9=387?344536$ 9=38;7<896D81CB7995:9/012/9/5<5=383B4193970?0;<72/9 1445< 67BC 39 56C0= 65E56 9<7C1?36 3=3<:5: 0?6D H#### 90=3<:8 437? 3?: 81;;5<7?2$ 9 =38 ;1<9/5< 81CB7995: 9<7C1?36 =38 ?09 A1897;75: 7? 3=3<:7?2 >0B45?83970? 90=3<:8 6088 0; 7?>0B5:1<7?2637:1445<70:;0<0?6D9/<55B0?9/83?:8012/9 5?/3?>5B5?9$ 9 =38 81CB7995: 9/012/ $ 3885885: 45<B3?5?9 4/D87>36 :783C7679D 39 !-L 9<7C1?36 >0?87:5<5: ;1?>970?36:783C7679D39#L=/7>/=387?3:5I13953?:8012/9 5?/3?>5B5?9$ 9 =38 81CB7995: 3=3<: 0; 0?6D #### 90=3<:860880;3B5?79758=380?60=5<87:5$9=3881CB7995: 9<7C1?36 /3: ?09 3=3<:5: 3?D >0B45?83970? 90=3<:8 ;191<5 B5:7>365K45?8583?:60880;B3<<73254<0845>98$ !$ - 5 - ! " ! # # -$ )53<: 653<?5: >01?856 3?: 45<185: 7B412?5: A1:2B5?93?:3=3<:$ "#$ (<0B3C0E53?:87?>50?6D>637B3?9787?344536;0< 5?/3?>5B5?9 0; >0B45?83970? 407?9 9/39 =016: 3<785 ;0< >0?87:5<3970?78 3B5783?8=5<5:43<96D7?3;;7<B397E5;0<;0660=7?2<5380?8 ""$ /012/ 7? >637B 4597970? >637B3?9 /3: 89395: 9/39 8/5 =38 " D53<8 0; 325 3?: =0<@7?2 38 >00675 3?: 53<?7?2 J## 45< :3D 7$5$ "!### 45< B0?9/ 83B5 =38 ?09 81C893?97395:=79/3?DB395<736$?3C85?>59<7C1?363885885: 79 ?0970?366D 39 " # 7?>0?80?3?>5 =79/ ?0970?36 7?>0B5 3:0495: CD ;0< 859965B5?9 0; >3858 C5;0<5 0@3:3639$ <7C1?36 <5;5<<5: 90 K$$ =01?: >5<97;7>395 3?: K$$"" :78>/3<2581BB3<D=/7653=3<:7?2H#### 90=3<:8437?3?: 81;;5<7?2$ K$$"" :78>/3<25 >3<: 3?: K$$" :783C7679D - 6 - >5<97;7>395=016:7?:7>3959/39>637B3?9818937?5:3B4193970?0; <72/9 3<B 39 56C0= 65E56$ 8 45< :5>7870? 0; )0?GC65 14<5B5 01<97?>3850; 1=/5<57?" #### =383=3<:5:7?>3850;3B4193970? 3=3<:CD9<7C1?36=016:?09C5A1897;75:83B5785?/3?>5:90 " #### $ <7C1?36 /38 3=3<:5: - "H 90=3<:8 B5:7>36 5K45?858 3237?89 C7668 4<0:1>5:$ 7?>5 9/5<5 78 >0B46595 <57BC1<85B5?99/5<5=016:C5?08>045;0<5?/3?>5B5?9$ "$ 0<B366D 7? >385 0; 3B4193970? 45<70: 0; 87K B0?9/8 78 >0?87:5<5: 38 63D0;;$ /5<5;0<5 >637B3?9 =016: C5 5?97965: ;0< ,- ## 38 3237?89 -, # 90=3<:8 6088 0; 7?>0B5 :1<7?2 637:14 45<70:$ /765 3885887?2 >0B45?83970? 9<7C1?36 ?095: K$$" 3?: :54087970? 0; $ 9/39 >637B3?9 /3:818937?5:45<B3?5?94/D87>36:783C7679D905K95?90;!-L$ (0< 41<40858 0; 3885887?2 ;1?>970?36 :783C7679D 83B5 =38 B0:5<395: 90 J#L 3?: 3446D7?2 " <: 0; 67BC :783C7679D 38 =/065 C0:D :783C7679D ;0<B163 79 3<<7E5: 39 #L$ 3B5 =016: ?09 C5 7? >0?80?3?>5 =79/ 9/5 <3970 637: :0=? CD )0?GC65 14<5B501<97?>3850; 2 1 #"! 2 #"""H - 7 - 3?:7?>3850; !"# "$ ;;5>90;:783C7679D0?3E0>3970?/3890C55K3B7?5: 0? >385 90 >385 C3878 3?: B5>/3?7>36 34467>3970? 0; B39/5B397>36;0<B163=016:?09C5344<04<7395$637B3?9=38 "D53<80;3253?:=0<@7?238>00675$0880;0?53<B=016: 81C893?97366D 3;;5>9 /5< 53<?7?2 >343>79D$ 9 83B5 97B5 93@7?2 ?095 0; 40887C7679D 0; 53<?7?2 80B5 7?>0B5 CD 3695<?397E5 3E0>3970? 79 =016: C5 344<04<7395 90 388588 6088 0; 53<?7?2 >343>79D 39 J#L =/7>/ =016: 3680 >0<<5840?: 90 5K95?9 0; :783C7679DB5?970?5:7?>/5:1650;B460D5580B45?83970? >9$ "H$ 845<:5>7870?0;)0?GC6514<5B501<97?>3850; $ % & $ % ' ! !" #()4 >637B3?9 =016: C5 5?97965: ;0< 3::7970? 0; ;191<5 4<0845>985E5?7?>38545<80?367?A1<D>637B8$7?>5>637B3?9 =38 " D53<8 0; 325 3?: 856; 5B460D5: ;191<5 4<0845>98 39 H#L/3890C53::5:$<7C1?36/38344675:>0<<5>9B16974675<0; 3 #H- 4 ##,,H - 8 - F"!G$/18>0B4193970?0;>0B45?83970?90=3<:8;191<560880; 7?>0B5=016:C5 " #MH#LK"K"!KJ#LNH#H#!# 3B5783=3<:5:90>637B3?9$ " $ 637B3?9900@7?43975?99<539B5?9;0<345<70:0;"" :3D83?:9<7C1?363=3<:5:#### 90=3<:8;00:3995?:3?>5 3?: >0?E5D3?>5 >/3<258$ 3B5 34453<8 90 C5 3:5I1395$ 0 8>045 ;0< 5?/3?>5B5?9$ <7C1?36 3=3<:5: #### 90=3<:8 6088 0; 3B5?79758$ 3@7?2 ?095 0; 3=3<: 7? G8 >385 814<3 79 78 ;01?: 7?3:5I1395 3?: 5?/3?>5: 90 " #### $ /012/ 79 78 >0?95?:5: 9/39 9<7C1?36 /38 ?09 3=3<:5: 3?D >0B45?83970?90=3<:8B3<<73254<0845>989/5<578?0B395<736 90 837: 5;;5>9$ )0=5E5< /38 89395: 3C019 ?55: ;0< 4<089/597> 67BC$ 3@7?2 ?095 0; 83B5 3?: ;3>9 9/39 4<089/597> 67BC =016: <5I17<5 <52163< B37?95?3?>5 3?: 45<70:7>36 <5463>5B5?9 79 78 ;01?: 344<04<7395 90 3=3<: "##### 90=3<:883B57?61B481B$/18>637B3?978/56:5?97965:;0< <53885885:>0B45?83970?38;0660=8 !* +,-./0+1.,231 /412 " 37?3?:81;;5<7?28 " #### &5:7>365K45?858 - "H 0880;53<?7?28:1<7?2637:1445<70: ,- ## - 9 - H 0880;;191<553<?7?2:783C7679D H#H#!# 19<797018;00:3?:3995?:3?9>/3<258 #### J 088 0; ;191<5 3B5?79758 3?: 6088 0; /3447?588 " #### ,$ (191<5B5:7>365K45?858 "##### 2,* 7 6 )5?>5407?9;0<>0?87:5<3970?783?8=5<5:43<96D7?3;;7<B397E5$ 0?85I15?96D;0660=7?2 7 44536783660=5:7?43<9A1:2B5?93?:3=3<::395: "$"#$#"43885:CD::7970?365?70<7E761:25 3?: & 363C1<327 7? & ?0$""!! #"- 78 B0:7;75: >637B3?9 78 5?97965: ;0< >0B45?83970? 0; ##J#-H 38 3237?89 !#HJJH 3=3<:5: CD 9<7C1?36360?2=79/ 7?95<58939<3950; JL45<3??1B ;<0B:3950;4597970?9766798<5367O3970?$ 77 5840?:5?97?81<5< 78 :7<5>95: 90 :540879 5?/3?>5: >0B45?83970?=79/7?87K=55@8$ 777 ?:5408799<7C1?3678:7<5>95:90<565385 ##### 7? ;3E01< 0; >637B3?9 3?: @554 <5B37?7?2 3B01?9 7? ;7K5: :540879 ;0< 3 45<70: 0; 572/9 D53<8 7? 3?D ?3970?367O5: C3?@ 0< 408936 :540879 =/7>/5E5< 53<?8 /72/589 <395 0; 7?95<589 =79/ 4<0E7870? ;0< <565385 0; 45<70:7>7?95<58990>637B3?9$ - 10 - 7E 7C5<9D 78 /0=5E5< <585<E5: 90 >637B3?9 90 =79/:<3= 83B57?>3857978?55:5:;0<B3<<73250<81>/09/5< A189>3185$ !-6 '%%!( # 7890$ "60$ H"