- 1 - !" #!$!%! ! & &' (%)*&(( + ! " # $ #% ! " ##& $ # ' ()"$' "$ "$' " &$ %# ( ** Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % %#' # ()**** ' '' (' # && # ' ' %# & # + # % # # $! " + # % # #$ ,- ./012345356 45 / ()**** /5 6,- 742- /7 2-385-9 99464/532 4:42 %;9<- 359 %#' 4938 "7/8 =,/86 >8432 /;86?$ 8-<4=6-8-9 7/8 6,- /77-5.- 1;54=,3@2- ;59-8 -.64/5 ( /7 -</643@2- 5=68;0-56= .6 "7/8 =,/86 > .6?$ 4= 401;<545< 6,- A;9<0-56 /7 3.B;46632 936-9 ( ** 3.B;46645< 6,- 8-=1/59-563..;=-97/86,-3@/:-=349/77-5.- * '/8 6,- =3C- /7 ./5:-54-5.- 6,- 13864-= 38- 8-7-88-96/3=1-86,-48835C@-7/8-6,-8432/;86 - 3 - ( 84-773.6=/76,-.3=-38-6,366,-./012345356 ,3=742-96,-184:36-./012345645 / ***@-7/8- 6,-8432/;863<345=66,-3..;=-9322-<45<./004==4/5/7 6,-/77-5.-1;54=,3@2-;59-8-.64/5 (/7 .6 64= 6,- ./56-564/5 /7 6,- ./012345356 6,36 6,- 3..;=-9 D3= ,4=784-593596/0--6,4=2-<325-.-==464-=3596/.2-386,- 9-@6=D3=456-8-=6-945=-2245<2/6/ 0-3=;845<E ( 76 =46;36-9 36 499-=,D38 /2/5F 4938 7/8 3 ./5=49-8364/5 /7 = ( ,- ./012345356 3..-16-9 6,- 18/1/=32 8-<4=6-8-9 =32- 9--9 936-9 * ** D3=-E-.;6-9@F6,-3..;=-94573:/;8/76,-./012345356 4042382F6D//6,-812/6=4 - 12/6/= 359)D-8-32=/ =/29;59-86D/=-13836-=32-9--9= 76-81;8.,3=-/76,- 12/6= 78/0 6,- 3..;=-9 6,- ./012345356 D3= 1;6 45 1/==-==4/5 /7 6,- =30- 6 4= 322-<-9 6,36 9;845< -.-0@-8** 6,-./012345356.30-6/C5/D6,366,- 3..;=-9,39324-536-96,-:-8F=30-12/6=4573:/;8/73 6,4891386F@-,4596,-@3.C/76,-./012345356 &,-56,- 3.6/76,-3..;=-9D3=B;-=64/5-9@F6,-./0123453566,- - 4 - 3..;=-9,393<8--96/8-13F6,-18-=-56:32;-/76,-12/6= 4 - = *3594==;-96,8--.,-B;-= 58-=1-.6 /76,-=32-9--98-7-88-96/3@/:-,-,394==;-9.,-B;- 936-9 * * *** 7/8 = &,-5 6,- .,-B;- D3=18-=-56-97/8-5.3=,0-566,-=30-D3=94=,/5/;8-9 3= 6,-8- D3= 7;59= 45=;774.4-56 45 6,- 3../;56 /7 6,- 3..;=-9 ,-2-<325/64.-D3= 4==;-96/6,-./012345356 457/8045<94=,/5/;8/76,-.,-B;-359.32245<;1/5,406/ 8-13F 6,- .,-B;- 30/;56 ;6 6,-3..;=-9 C5/D45< 6,- ./56-56=/76,-5/64.-8-7;=-96/3..-166,-=30-359,- ,3= 5/6 8-1349 6,- .,-B;- 30/;56 ,-8-@F ,- ,3= ./00466-9 6,- /77-5.- 1;54=,3@2- ;59-8 -.64/5 ( /7 .6 ../8945<2F 6,- ./012345356 ,3= 8-B;-=6-9 6,- 8432/;866/63C-./<54G35.-/76,-/77-5.-3596/4546436- 2-<323.64/53<345=66,-3..;=-9 ,-8432/;866//C./<54G35.-/76,-/77-5.- 8-<4=6-8-9 6,- .8404532 .3=- 359 =;00/5-9 6,- 3..;=-9 ,-3..;=-9311-38-9@-7/8-6,-8432/;8612-39-95/6 <;426F359.2340-96/@-684-9 ,-./012345356-E3045-9 - 5 - ,40=-273=& 359</6038C-9 E= 6/45=;11/86 ,4= ./56-564/5 ,- 3..;=-9 ,3= 9-54-9 322 6,- 45.8404536/8F 036-8432= 3:3423@2- /5 8-./89 45 ,4= =636-0-56 ;59-8 -.64/5 ( ( /7 8 359 -E3045-9 ,40=-273=& @;6,3=5/62-935F-:49-5.-45=;11/86 /7 ,4= 9-7-5.- ,- 8432 /;86 376-8 63C45< 456/ ./5=49-8364/5 322 6,- 036-8432= /5 8-./89 .30- 6/ 6,- ./5.2;=4/5 6,36 6,- ./012345356 D3= 5/6 =;..-==7;2 45 18/:45<6,-<;426/76,-3..;=-9@-F/598-3=/53@2-9/;@6 3596,-8-7/8-13==-96,-401;<5-9A;9<0-563.B;46645< 6,-3..;=-97/86,-/77-5.-1;54=,3@2-;59-8-.64/5 ( /7 .6 -45<3<<84-:-9@F6,-=30-6,-./012345356 4=@-7/8-6,4=/;86 -389 84 #3,356-=, 3642 2-385-9 ./;5=-2 7/8 6,-311-22356 359 84 542C;0383083/2-385-9 ./;5=-2 7/8 6,- 8-=1/59-56 -8;=-9 6,- 036-8432= /5 8-./89 45.2;945<6,-8432/;868-./89= - 6 - 5 :4-D /7 6,- 84:32 ./56-564/5= ;8<-9 @F 2-385-9./;5=-27/86,-13864-=6,-1/4566,36D/;29384=- 7/80F./5=49-8364/54= #F35=D-86/6,-3@/:-1/4564=456,-> ? 7/86,-7/22/D45< ) 6 4= 6,- ./56-564/5 /7 6,- ./012345356 6,36 -:-56,/;<,6,-=32-9--9=,3:-@--5-E-.;6-94573:/;8 /7 6,- ./012345356 6,- 3..;=-9 ,39 ,359-9 /:-8 6,- 18/1-86F6/36,4891386F359D,-5=;.,3.6/76,-3..;=-9 D3= B;-=64/5-9 @F 6,- ./012345356 6,- 3..;=-9 ,39 3<8--9 6/ 8-13F 6,- :32;- /7 6,- 12/6= D,4., D3= -=64036-936= * ../8945<2F,-4==;-96,8-- .,-B;-= /;6 /7 D,4., 6D/ .,-B;-= D-8- 7/8 - 7 - = -3., 359 6,- (89 .,-B;- D3= 7/8 = E 4= 6,- /5- /7 .,-B;- 7/8 = 936-9 * * *** ,- =30- D3= 18-=-56-9 7/8 -5.3=,0-56 E * 4= 6,- 35C -1/=46 -.-416 E ( 4= 6,- -6;85 #-0/ 457/8045< 6,- ./012345356 3@/;6 94=,/5/;8 /7 6,- .,-B;- 3= 6,-8-D3= 45=;774.4-56 7;59 45 6,- 3../;56 /7 6,- 3..;=-9 E 4= 6,-2-<325/64.- E 4=6,-1/=6328-.-416 E 4=6,- /=632 3.C5/D2-9<0-56 /7 5/64.- 8-6;85-9 ;5=-8:-9 3= 6,-3..;=-98-7;=-96/8-.-4:-6,-=30- ;845< .8/==-E3045364/5 46 4= =;<<-=6-9 6/ & 6,36 E= 3596,-/6,-86D/.,-B;-=@-2/5<45<6/ 6,- 3..;=-9 D-8- 2/=6 359 46 4= =;<<-=6-9 6,36 6,- =4<536;8-=359/6,-8D84645<=/56,-.,-B;- E 38-5/6 6,36/76,-3..;=-9 ,-=30-D3=9-54-9@F6,-D465-== E.-16 63C45< 6,- 9-7-5.- 6,36 6,- .,-B;-= 45 B;-=64/5 D-8-2/=65//6,-89-7-5.-D3=63C-5@F6,-3..;=-9 ,- 3..;=-9 =6-11-9 456/ 6,- D465-== @/E 359 9-1/=-93=& 5,4=-:49-5.-6,-D465-===636-=6,36 - 8 - 6,-./0123453564=3=6835<-86/,40 /D-:-8,-=636-= 6,36 ,- D3= 6,- ,348035 /7 6,- 830 35.,3F36 78/0 * 6/ * 6835<-2F ,- =636-= 6,36 ,- 5-:-8 -E-.;6-9 35F =32- 9--9 45 73:/;8 /7 6,- ./012345356 ,-8-376-8 6,- .,4-7-E3045364/5 D3= 9-7-88-9 36 6,- 8-B;-=6/76,-2-385-9./;5=-27/86,-3..;=-93599;845< 7;86,-8 .,4-7-E3045364/5 ,- =636-= 6,36 E 9/-= 5/6 @-38 ,4= =4<536;8- /8 ,4= D84645<= 359 6,36 ,- 5-:-8 8-.-4:-9 35F 5/64.- ;845< .8/==-E3045364/5 D465-== =636-9 6,36 =45.- ,- D/8C-9 3= ,348035 /7 6,- 83035.,3F367/8=4E6-80= -3==-86=6,36,-,3=5/6 -E-.;6-9=32-9--94573:/;8/76,-./012345356D,4.,4= B;46-./56838F6/6,-8-<4=6-8-9=32-9--9= E= )6/ -385-9 ./;5=-2 7/8 6,- 8-=1/59-563..;=-9 =;@046= 6,36 6,- ./012345356 D3= 455/.-56 359 D46,/;6 C5/D45< 6,- ./5=-B;-5.-= 6,- 3..;=-9 ,3= <4:-5 =;., -:49-5.- ;66,-73.68-0345=6,36,-D3=311/456-93= 6,- ,348035 /7 6,- 830 35.,3F36 7/8 =4E 640-= 6,36 0-35=362-3=67/8*6/(F-38= - 9 - 6 4= 1-8645-56 6/ 5/6- 6,36 6,- 3..;=-9 390466-9 ,4= 3998-== 3= 0-564/5-9 45 6,- 2-<32 5/64.- 3= D-223=456,-./0123456 -39046=6,364735/64.-4==-56 6/6,-=3493998-==46D422@-=-8:-9/5,40 E 4=6,- 1/=632 -5:-2/1 3998-==-9 6/ 6,- 3..;=-9 8-6;85-9 3= >8-7;=-9? ,--59/8=-0-56039-@F6,-1/=6323;6,/846F D422,3:-318-=;0164/53596,-@;89-54=/56,-3..;=-9 6/ 8-@;6 6,- =30- 3= ,- ./56-59= 6,36 6,- 5/64.- D3= 5-:-86-59-8-96/,40 /-77/86=D,36=/-:-84=039-@F 6,- 3..;=-9 6/ 8-@;6 6,- =349 18-=;0164/5 8-<38945< 6,- 1/=632 -59/8=-0-56 D,4., .2-382F </-= 6/ =,/D 6,36 6,- 3..;=-9,3=8-7;=-96/8-.-4:-6,-2-<325/64.- * 64=1-8645-566/5/6-6,369;845<7;86,-8.8/== -E3045364/5/7& ,-.36-</84.322F39046=6,36 E= ) 6/38-6,-=32-9--9=-E-.;6-9@F,404573:/;8/76,- ./012345356 @;6 ./56-59= 6,36 ,- 45=4=6-9 6,- ./0123453566/<-66,-=32-9--9=.35.-22-9 /D-:-8,- 39046= 6,36 ,- ,3= 5/6 4==;-9 35F 5/64.- 6/ 6,- ./012345356 6/ <-6 6,- =32- 9--9 .35.-22-9 6 4= 32=/ - 10 - 1-8645-566/5/6-6,366,-3..;=-9,3=.36-</84.322F=636-9 6,366,-=;@A-.60366-8=/76,-=32-9--9=36 E 6/ D-8-6,-12/6=359,-,3=,359-9/:-86,-1/==-==4/5/7 6,- =30- 45 73:/;8 /7 /5- ,38364@34 &/ 83@,; :-5 6,/;<, 6,- 12/6= D-8- 5/6 =/29 45 ,-8 73:/;8 6,- 1/==-==4/5 /7 6,- 18/1-86F D3= ,359-9 /:-8 6/ ,-8 /D-:-8 ,- 9-54-9 =;., =;<<-=64/5= 6,36 =45.- 6,- 1/==-==4/5 /7 6,- 12/6= D-8- ,359-9 /:-8 6/ ,38364@34 6,- 3..;=-9 ,39 4==;-9 .,-B;-= 3= 1-8 E 359 6D/ /6,-8 .,-B;-= D,4., 38- =;@A-.6 0366-8 /7 /6,-8 ./0123456= ( 7 6,- 036-8432= /5 8-./89 38- 63C-5 456/ ./5=49-8364/56,-3..;=-939046=6,366,-.,-B;-H E @-2/5<= 6/ ,4= @35C 3../;56 /D-:-8 ,- 9-54-= 6,- =4<536;8- 359 6,- /6,-8 D84645<= 7/;59 6,-8-45 :-5 6,/;<, 6,- 3..;=-9 9-54-= =4<536;8- 7/;59 /5 E D,-5 6,- =349 =4<536;8- 4= ./0138-9 D46, 6,- 390466-9 =4<536;8- /7 6,- 3..;=-9 7/;59 /5 6,- 8-<4=6-8-9 =32- 9--9= 3C32365303 6,- 2-3 359 6,- -1/=464/5= - 11 - 8-./89-9 @F 6,- 8432 /;86 30 =364=74-9 D46, 6,- =4<536;8-7/;59/5 E 4=6,36/76,-3..;=-9,40=-27 6 4= 6,- ./56-564/5 /7 6,- 3..;=-9 6,36 6,- .,-B;-H E D3=63C-53D3F@F6,-./01234535678/0 ,4=/774.- E.-1663C45<=;.,@329=63596,-3..;=-9,3= 5/6 ./012345-9 3<345=6 6,- ./012345356 7/8 ,3:45< 63C-5 3D3F6,-.,-B;- -,3=32=/5/6./012345-96/6,- 35C 3593=C-97/8=6/1145<6,-13F0-56 ,-8-4=3@=/2;6-2F 5/8-3=/53==4<5-9@F6,-3..;=-93=6/D,F,-,3=5/6 63C-5 35F 3.64/5 3<345=6 6,- ./012345356 D,/ =349 6/ ,3:-63C-53D3F6,-.,-B;-35918-=-56-96,-=30-7/8 -5.3=,0-56 6835<-2F 6,- 3..;=-9 ,3= 5/6 .,/=-5 6/ 3..-16 6,- 2-<32 5/64.- 359 ,3= 8-7;=-9 6/ 8-.-4:- 6,- =30- &,-56,-3..;=-939046=6,36 E )6/38- 6,-=32-9--9=-E-.;6-9@F,404573:/;8/76,-./0123456 3597;86,-8=636-=6,366,-1/==-==4/5/76,/=-=46-=D-8- ,359-9 /:-8@F,40 6/ /5- ,38364@34 46 18/@3@24G-9 6,- ./56-564/5 63C-5 @F 6,- ./012345356 6,36 3..;=-9 ,39 - 12 - 3<8--9 6/ 8-13F 6,- 038C-6 :32;- /7 6,- =46- 359 3../8945<2F 6,- .,-B;- 45 B;-=64/5 D3= 4==;-9 59-8 =;., .48.;0=635.-= 6,- 4546432 @;89-5 /5 6,- ./012345356 <-6 94=.,38<-9 359 6,- 18-=;0164/5 ;59-8 -.64/5= ( 359 /7 D/;29384=- 64=7/86,-3..;=-96/8-@;6 6,-2-<3218-=;0164/5 :-56,/;<,6,-3..;=-9,3==6-11-9456/6,- D465-== @/E ,- ,3= 5/6 8-@;66-9 6,- 2-<32 18-=;0164/5 ,- ./56-564/5 /7 6,- 3..;=-9 6,36 6,- =32- 9--9= H E= ) 6/ 38- 5/6 .35.-22-9 359 6,-8-7/8- 6,- ./012345356 4= 5/6 -56462-9 7/8 35F 8-24-7 .355/6 @- 3..-16-9 7/8 6,- =4012- 8-3=/5 6,36 6,- 4==;35.- /7 6,- .,-B;- D46, 6,- =4<536;8- /7 6,- 3..;=-9 4= 18/:-9 359 6,--:49-5.-/58-./893=94=.;==-93@/:-94=.2/=-=6,36 6,-12/6=45B;-=64/5D-8-,359-9/:-8@F6,-3..;=-945 73:/;8/73(891386F7/8D,4.,6,-3..;=-9,393<8--96/ 8-13F6,-:32;-/76,-=46-359;59-8=;.,.48.;0=635.-= 6,-.,-B;-45B;-=64/5D3=4==;-9 5:4-D/76,-3@/:- 30=364=74-9D46,6,-./56-564/563C-5@F6,-./012345356 - 13 - ) -385-9 ./;5=-2 7/8 6,- ./012345356 =;@046= 6,36 6,- ./012345356 D422 ;59-863C- 6/ 742- 35 377493:46 6/ 6,--77-.66,36,-D/;29-E-.;6-6,-.35.-22364/59--945 73:/;8/76,-3..;=-9458-=1-.6/76,-=32-9--9=H E= 6/D,-5-:-86,-3..;=-9.322=;1/5,406/9/=/ ,- =349 =;@04==4/5 4= 123.-9 /5 8-./89 5 :4-D /7 6,- 94=.;==4/5= ,-29 3@/:- 30 /7 6,- /1454/5 6,36 6,- ./012345356 4= =;..-==7;2 45 18/:45< 6,- <;426F /7 6,- 3..;=-97/8/77-5.-;59-8-.64/5 (/7 .6@-F/59 8-3=/53@2-9/;@63593..;=-94=243@2-7/8./5:4.64/5 -3892-385-9./;5=-27/86,-13864-=8-<38945< =-56-5.- ../8945<2F 35=D-8 6,- 3@/:- 1/456 45 6,- 35918/.--96/13==6,-7/22/D45< "4$ ,-.8404532311-324= "44$ ,- 401;<5-9 A;9<0-56 /7 3.B;46632 936-9 ( ** 13==-9 45 8404532 3=- - 14 - / ()**** @F 6,- 2-385-9 99464/532 4:42 %;9<- 359 %#' 4938 4= ,-8-@F =-63=49- "444$ /5=-B;-562F 6,- 8-=1/59-563..;=-9 4= ./5:4.6-9 7/8 6,- /77-5.- 1;54=,3@2- ;59-8 -.64/5 ( /7 6,- .6 - 4= =-56-5.-9 6/ 13F 745- /7 = ";1--= '476--5 3C,= 52F$ D46,45 3 1-84/9 /7 6,8-- 0/56,= 78/0 6/93F 359 45 9-73;26/713F0-56/7745-,-=,322;59-8</ =4012- 40184=/50-56 7/8 3 1-84/9 /7 /5- F-38 "4:$ ;6/76,-745-30/;566/@-9-1/=46-9@F 6,- 8-=1/59-563..;=-9 3 =;0 /7 = 4=/89-8-96/@-13496/6,- 311-22356./0123453563=./01-5=364/5 - 15 - -<4=68F 6/ =-59 @3.C 6,- 8432 /;86 8-./89= 32/5< D46, ./1F /7 6,4= A;9<0-56 7/8 457/80364/5 359 5--97;2 3.64/5 ,% &!!( $ 4=6/ 2/ **