- 1 - !" #$ "" %&' ( ! " # "$ %&'()# ) " " %(*(#') ! "+), #%" + + ## + " + Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '')')' " &-)'#* ++ " . +. '')')' " &-)'#* + + ". + + . " /. + $ /. + 012 344536 12 78 905 :631;3<93445663<9 255=1<> 5<03<:5;5<9 ?@ :?;45<2391?< 3A121<> ?B9 ?@ CBD>;5<9 3<D 3E3AD D395D '')')' 1< " ?&)'#* 43225D 78 905 A1<:14365<1?A1F16.BD>53<D3637BA3>1?<68?<905 >A?B<D?@905GB3<9B; ) 53AD ;9 <BA3D03 5231 653A<5D :?B<256 34453A1<> @?A 905 3445663<9:631;3<9 3<D A1 BD03A203< 653A<5D :?B<256 34453A1<> @?A A524?<D5<9 ?) H <2BA3<:5 ?;43<8524?<D5<9 ?#90?B>025AF5DB<A54A525<95D - 3 - ;9 <BA3D03 5231 E190 366 F505;5<:5 2B7;1995D 9039 905 A17B<36 032 93=5< 905 1<:?;5 ?@ 905 :631;3<9 39 905 A395 ?@ 2-'''% E05A51< 905 853A ?@ 905 3::1D5<9 E32 )'# 2 45A 905 :03A9 4A543A5D 78 905 5>36 5AF1:52 B90?A198 ?@ 9012 ?BA9 @?A 3< B<2=1665D 637?BA 12 2#')('%+BA905A205032:?<95<D5D90399?905@A3:9BA52 ?@ A1>09 :63F1:65 2B@@5A5D 78 905 3445663<9 905 A17B<36 032 :?;;1995D3<5AA?A93=1<>905D12371619839#AD1539905A395 ?@I1<2953D:?<21D5A1<>905@A3:9BA522B@@5A5D29395D37?F5 90523;5?B>099?03F5755<93=5<39#I9?905E0?657?D8 3229395D78905?:9?A?362?905:?;45<2391?<3E3AD5D B<D5A366905053D25J:549;5D1:365J45<2523A5?<9056?E5A 21D5 3<D A5GB1A52 A5%:?<21D5A391?< 3<D A5%D595A;1<391?< ::?AD1<>68 2?B>09 9? 366?E 905 344536 3<D 5<03<:5 905 :?;45<2391?< & 5@B91<>9052B7;1221?<2?@905653A<5D:?B<256@?A 9053445663<9A1BD03A203<E190366F505;5<:52B7;1995D 9039 905 A17B<36 1< 905 3725<:5 ?@ 3<8 1<:?;5 4A??@ 032 93=5< 905 1<:?;5 39 2-'''% 3<D 4A?45A68 :?<21D5A5D 905 D123716198 39 I ?<21D5A1<> 905 D123716198 39 I 3<D 905 - 4 - :?;45<2391?<3E3AD5DB<D5A366905053D23A5CB293<D4A?45A 3<DD?52<?9:366@?A3<81<95A@5A5<:53990503<D2?@9012?BA9 3<D3::?AD1<>682?B>099?D12;122905344536 ( 3F1<>053AD905653A<5D:?B<25634453A1<>@?A905 43A9152 45AB25D 905 5<91A5 344536 4345A2 2? 362? 905 A136 ?BA9 5:?AD 905 ?<68 4?1<9 9039 E?B6D 3A125 @?A ;8 :?<21D5A391?<12 05905A 905 :?;45<2391?< 3E3AD5D 78 905 A17B<36 75@19 E1901< 905 5J4A5221?< CB29 :?;45<2391?<K L 8 3<2E5A 9? 905 37?F5 4?1<9 @?A :?<21D5A391?< 12 M43A9681<3@@1A;391F5N@?A905@?66?E1<> 912<?91<D124B9590399053::1D5<9032?::BAA5D1< 905853A)'#245A905:03A94A543A5D7890565>3625AF1:52 3B90?A198?@9012?BA9@?A905853A)'#9051<:?;512@1J5D39 2#')('%05A17B<361<9053725<:5?@3<81<:?;54A??@ ?B>09 9? 03F5 :?<21D5A 905 1<:?;5 39 2#')('% 32 45A 905 :03A9 4A543A5D 78 905 5>36 5AF1:52 B90?A198 1<2953D ?@ - 5 - 2-'''%::?AD1<>6890523;51293=5<05A17B<36032 @3165D 9? :?<21D5A 905 @A3:9BA5 ?@ A1>09 :63F1:65 3::?AD1<>68 :?;;1995D325F5A55AA?A1<93=1<>#AD?@90523;539905A395 ?@ I 1<:5 905A5 12 3 @A3:9BA5 ?@ A1>09 :63F1:65 7?<5 3< 56?<>395D MN % 20345D 7?<5 E01:0 25AF52 32 3 :AB:136 :?<<5:91?<@?A90520?B6D5A3<DB445A61;73<D:?<21D5A1<>905 3F?:391?<?@9051<CBA5D32329?<5GB3AA8E?A=5A905D123716198 9?9055<91A57?D812:?<21D5A5D39#'I?362?90545AB236 ?@905:?;45<2391?<3E3AD5DB<D5AF3A1?B2053D23A5?<905 6?E5A21D53::?AD1<>6890523;5A5GB1A52A5%:?<21D5A391?<3<D A5%D595A;1<391?< * < A5%D595A;1<391?< 3<D A5%:?<21D5A391?< 905 :?;45<2391?<E?A=2?B99? # ?22?@@B9BA553A<1<>:343:198 #')('J#)J#LJ#'I 2#-L*''% ) 31<3<D2B@@5A1<> 2&''''% 5D1:365J45<252 2&-))% & ?22?@3;5<19152 2&''''% ( 995<D3<9:03A>523<D159 2)''''% L ?22 ?@ 1<:?;5 DBA1<> 631D B4 45A1?D #')('J& 2&#'''% )*+ ,-. / <A5%D595A;1<391?<905:631;3<93445663<9125<91965D@?A ,-. / E01:0 12 A?B<D5D ?@@ 9? ,-.-/ 32 - 6 - 3>31<29 2#('''% 3E3AD5D 78 905 A17B<36 ::?AD1<>68 9055<03<:5D:?;45<2391?<E?B6DE?A=2?B99?, 0/ E01:020366:3AA81<95A52939905A395?@LI43@A?;905D395 ?@459191?<9166A5361O391?< - +?A905@?A>?1<>A532?<29054?1<9@?A:?<21D5A391?< 123<2E5A5D1<@3F?BA?@3445663<91<M43A9681<3@@1A;391F5N3<D 4A?:55D29?4322905@?66?E1<> 1 0534453612 11 05CBD>;5<93<D3E3ADD395D'')')'1<" ?&)'#* 43225D 78 905 A1<:1436 5<1?A 1F16 .BD>5 3<D 3637BA3>1 12 05A578 ;?D1@15D 3<D5<03<:5D9?2)'*'''% 111 05 5<03<:5D:?;45<2391?< 20366 :3AA8 1<95A529 39 905 A395 ?@ LI @A?; 905 D395 ?@ 459191?< 9166 A5361O391?< 1F 524?<D5<9 ?) H <2BA3<:5 ?;43<8 20366 D54?219 5<91A5 5<03<:5D :?;45<2391?< 36?<> E190 9053::AB5D1<95A52929395DE1901<21JE55=2 - 7 - @A?;905D395?@A5:5149?@:?48?@9012?AD5A75@?A5 905:?<:5A<5DA17B<36 F < D54?219 ?@ 905 5<03<:5D :?;45<2391?< 905 5<91A5 :?;45<2391?< 75 A565325D 1< @3F?BA ?@ 905 3445663<9:631;3<9?<4A?45A1D5<91@1:391?< F1 ??AD5A329?:?292 1/ %' $ 129 ?#6 ?#'