Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43197 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER v. NAZEER S/O RAJ AHMED,
MFA/200209/2025 · 2025-09-02
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43197 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43197 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#$ %&
'
"#$
'
"#$
(
"#$
(
"#$
%
&
! "
# #
$
%
"
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#& % '
#& %(% %
% & %(% %
! & %(% %
! &
"
% & % ! & #)%#
#&
* % &
%
! & ) '
' % &
% % #
&+ & %)%#
- 3 -
#
#
$
% , -! ",
, ' , & + *
#"
& ' "
+
#
) %
# !! %
&
)
. #
% )
'%
&
! "
# #
$
%
"
&
- 4 -
&
&
*
&
"
! #&
'
&
)-/
% &
%
! & ) /'
* % &
% % #
&+ & %)%# /
'
#
#
/ $
% !, - & ",
', * , & +
#"
- 5 -
& ' "
+
#
) %
# !! %
&
)
. #
% )
'%
&
0 ! "
# #
$
%
"
1 & % '
&
%#)%#
% &
% % #
&+ & %)%#
- 6 -
#
#
$
,
,"
& ' "
+
#
) %
# !! %
&
)
. #
% )
(%
&
! "
# #
$
%
"
&
! & )-/
% &
%
- 7 -
! & ) /'
% &
% % #
&+ & %)%# /
! #
#
/ $
% , !"
& ' "
+
#
) %
# !! %
&
)
. #
% )
( %
&
/
! "
# #
$
%
"
- 8 -
&
!' # %" & )%#
% &
%
! & ) /'
% &
% % #
&+ & %)%# /
! #
#
/ $
% , !, - "
& ' "
+
#
) %
# !! %
*&
)
. #
% )
- 9 -
% #
2
2 3
%
3
%
! 2 3
%
"
45657895:;;5:<6=>?450@;0@:?80A:@868AB0C?07 ?45 6:D5 :EE8F5A? 40G595@ 0A F8775@5A? E<:8D ;5?8?80A6 :@5 ?:H5A ?0B5?45@ 70@ F86;06:< 78<5F 0A ?45 B@0CAF 07 <8:=8<8?>:6G5<<:6IC:A?CD
45 F:?5 07 :EE8F5A? 8A90<95D5A?
07 9548E<5 8AJC@>&F5:?486A0?8AF86;C?545F86;C?586G8?4@5B:@F ?0 <8:=8<8?> 07 K 7:6?5A5F 0A ?45 :;;5<<:A?&0@;0@:?80A 60:<60?45IC:A?CD07E0D;5A6:?80A
5:@F @8
:AJCA:?4
:<:>:645??> <5:@A5F E0CA65< :;;5:@8AB 70@ ?45 0@;0@:?80A 8A :<< ?45 :;;5:<6 :AF @8 :AJ559 :?8< <5:@A5F E0CA65< :;;5:@8AB 70@ E<:8D:A?6 :AF @8
:A98AF@: 5FF> <5:@A5F E0CA65<
- 10 -
:;;5:@8AB 70@ @56;0AF5A? 0 ?4:? 86 ?45 8A6C@:AE5 E0D;:A>07?450?45@9548E<58A90<95F8A?45:EE8F5A? ! @8 :AJCA:?4 :<<:>>:645??> G8?4 :<< 9545D5AE5 6C=D8?6 ?4:? ?45 @8=CA:< 4:6 E0DD8??5F 65@80C6 5@@0@ 8A 7:6?5A8AB ?45 <8:=8<8?> 07 E0A?@8=C?0@> A5B<8B5AE5 ?0 ?45 5L?5A? 07 K 0A ?45 =C6 45 E4:@B5 6455?4:6=55A78<5F=>?45;0<8E5:B:8A6??45F@895@07?45 =C6:6G5<<:6?45E@C865@J55;G48E486:<60@56;0A68=<570@ ?45 :EE8F5A? 6 ;5@ ?45 6;0? 6H5?E4 ?45 @0:F 86 A0? : 6?@:8B4?@0:F?45F@895@07?45E@C865@F@0958?8A:M8BM:B D:AA5@ 45 F@895@ 07 ?45 E@C865@ J55; G:6 @:64 :AF A5B<8B5A? G48<5 F@898AB ?45 9548E<5 :AF E0A?@8=C?5F D0@5 ?4:A?450A5G48E44:6=55A7:6?5A5F=>?45@8=CA:<5 7C@?45@ 6C=D8?6 ?4:? F@895@ 07 ?45 E@C865@ G:6 A0? ;0665668AB9:<8F:AF5775E?895:66CE4?45;0<8E54:95 8A90H5F;@098680A607
E?:B:8A6??450GA5@A?4565 E8@ECD6?:AE56?456:D5@5IC8@56?0=58A?5@75@5AE5:??45 4:AF607?4860C@?0:<60?45IC:A?CD07E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F 8A @56;5E? 07 5:E4 E<:8D ;5?8?80A6 @5IC8@5F
- 11 -
@5E0A68F5@:?80A :6 ?45 6:D5 :@5 5L0@=8?:A?<> :G:@F5F EE0@F8AB<> 60CB4? ?0 :<<0G :<< ?45 :;;5:<6 @5FCE5 ?45 IC:A?CD E0A?@8=C?0@> A5B<8B5AE5 7:6?5A5F 0A ?45 F@895@ 07?45=C6:AF@5FCE5?45E0D;5A6:?80A
57C?8AB?456C=D86680A607?45<5:@A5FE0CA65< :;;5:@8AB 70@ ?45 0@;0@:?80A @8 :AJ559 :?8< G8?4 :<< ?45 9545D5AE5 6C=D8?6 ?4:? ?45 @8=CA:< 4:98AB E0A68F5@5F ?45 6;0? 6H5?E4 70CAF ?4:? ?45 =C6 G:6 ;@0E55F8AB?0G:@F6??8B54:<<8B0A50A?455L?@5D5@8B4? 68F5 07 ?45 @0:F :AF E:C65F ?45 :EE8F5A? 45 F@895@ 07 ?45J55;G:6F@898AB8?8A:D0F5@:?56;55F=C?70@@:64 :AFA5B<8B5A?F@898AB07?45=C6=>8?6F@895@4:6@56C<?5F 8A ?45 :EE8F5A? 45 @8=CA:< 0A ?45 =:686 07 ?45 ;0<8E5 @5E0@F6 E0A68F5@8AB ?45 7:E? ?4:? ?45 ;0<8E5 4:95 78<5F E4:@B5 6455? :B:8A6? =0?4 ?45 F@895@6 07 ?45 0775AF8AB 9548E<56:FF<5F?45E0A?@8=C?0@>A5B<8B5AE5?0?455L?5A? 07K0A?45F@895@07?45=C6=58AB:45:9>;:665AB5@ 9548E<5:AFK0A?45E@C865@9548E<5:AF6C=D8?6?4:?8? F056A0?E:<<70@:A>8A?5@75@5AE507:@:6?45IC:A?CD86
- 12 -
E0AE5@A5F ?45 @8=CA:< :7?5@ E0A68F5@8AB ?45 5A?8@5 D:?5@8:< ;<:E5F =570@5 8? :G:@F5F :;;@0;@8:?5 E0D;5A6:?80A :AF6C;;0@?6 ?45 JCFBD5A? :AF:G:@F :AF 60CB4? ?0 F86D866 :<< ?45 :;;5:<6 78<5F E:<<8AB 8A IC56?80A ?45 JCFBD5A? :AF :G:@F ;:665F => ?45 @8=CA:< 8A @56;5E?895E<:8D;5?8?80A6 * @8 :A95AF@: 5FF> <5:@A5F E0CA65< :;;5:@8AB 70@ ?45 8A6C@:AE5 E0D;:A> 07 ?45 0?45@ 0775AF8AB 9548E<5 4:6 6C=D8??5F ?4:? ?45 @8=CA:< 4:6 ;@0;5@<> 7:6?5A5F ?45 <8:=8<8?> :?
?45 @:?80 07 K :AF K456:D586JC6?:AF;@0;5@:AF8?F056A0?E:<<70@ :A> 8A?5@75@5AE5 0 7:@ :6 IC:A?CD 86 E0AE5@A5F ?45 6:D5 86 :EE5;?5F :6 ?45 8A6C@:AE5 E0D;:A> 4:6 A0? ;@575@@5F :A> :;;5:< EE0@F8AB<> 60CB4? ?0 F86D866 :<< ?45:;;5:<678<5F=>?450@;0@:?80A ' :98AB45:@F?45<5:@A5FE0CA65<:;;5:@8AB70@ ?45;:@?856;5@C65:<<?45:;;5:<;:;5@660:<60?45?@8:< 0C@?@5E0@F
- 13 -
45 ;08A?6 ?4:? G0C<F :@865 70@ 0C@ E0A68F5@:?80A:@5:670<<0G62 #45?45@ ?45 @8=CA:< 86 JC6?8785F 8A 7:6?5A8AB?45E0A?@8=C?0@>A5B<8B5AE5 ?0?455L?5A?07K0A?45F@895@07 ?45=C6N #45?45@ ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F =>?45@8=CA:<86JC6?:AF;@0;5@:AF 87 A0? G45?45@ 8? @5IC8@56 :A> E0A68F5@:?80A :? ?45 4:AF6 07 ?486 0C@? 58?45@ @5FCE8AB 0@ @5?:8A8AB ?456:D5N
+ C@ :A6G5@ ?0 ?45 :=095 ;08A?6 70@ E0A68F5@:?80A2 08A? 02 778@D:?8958A607:@:6;08A? 0
8A:<<?45:;;5:<6
08A? 02 :@?<>:778@D:?8958A@56;5E?07
0'&
0&
0& :AF:778@D:?8958A
0+&:AF
0+&70@?45 70<<0G8AB2
- 14 -
08A? 02 45 ;5@C6:< 07 6;0? 6H5?E4 E<5:@<> 640G6?4:??45=C64:6G5A?0A?45G@0AB68F507?45@0:F :AF E:C65F ?45 :EE8F5A? ? 86 ?@8?5 ?4:? G45A =0?4 ?45 ;5@60A6:@545<F?0=5A5B<8B5A?8AF@898AB?45;5@60AG40 4:6B0??45<:6?E4:AE5?0:908F?458AE8F5A?86@56;0A68=<5 70@ ?45 :EE8F5A? 0A68F5@8AB ?45 6:D5 ?45 F@895@07 ?45 =C6?40CB44:98AB0A?45<57?68F5:6E0C<F=5655A7@0D ?45 6;0? 6H5?E4 A0? 56?:=<8645F ;@0;5@ E:@5 :AF E:C?80A :AF E0C<F 4:95 :908F5F ?45 :EE8F5A? 87 4:F =55A <8??<5 E8@ECD6;5E? 45 @8=CA:< G:6 07 ?45 0;8A80A ?4:? ?45 F@895@07?45E@C865@G:6A0?;0665668AB5775E?895:AF9:<8F :6 6CE4 ;0<8E5 4:95 8A90H5F 5E?80A - '' 07 E? :B:8A6? ?45 0GA5@ 07 ?45 E@C865@ 9548E<5 486 70@ ?45@8=CA:< E0D56 ?0 : E0AE<C680A ?4:??45F@895@07 ?45 E@C865@G:6:<60@:64:AFA5B<8B5A?:AFE0A?@8=C?5F?0?45 :EE8F5A?:AF7:6?5A5FKE0A?@8=C?0@>A5B<8B5AE50A?45 F@895@ 07 ?45 E@C865@ A ?4565 E8@ECD6?:AE56 G8?40C? - 15 -
DCE4F5<8=5@:?8AB0A?45;08A??4578AF8AB07?45@8=CA:< 86H5;?8A?:E?0A?45;08A?07<8:=8<8?> ) %
08A? 0207:@:6IC:A?CD86E0AE5@A5F8A
0'& :@868AB 0C? 07 0& ?4:??45:B507?45F5E5:65F640GA?0=5!>5:@6:60A ?45F:?507:EE8F5A?6;5@?45<:G<:8F0A=>?450A3=<5 ;5L 0C@? 8A ?45 E:65 07 ! "#
96 $% !& # &!1 ?45 7C?C@5 ;@06;5E?C6 :? ?45 @:?5 07 !K ?0 =5 :FF5F G45@5 ?45 F5E5:65F G:6 =5<0G!A?45E:650A4:AF?45F5E5:65FG:6@CAA8AB ! >5:@6 A ?4565 E8@ECD6?:AE56 ?45 7C?C@5 ;@06;5E?C6 G48E4 86 :FF5F :? ?45 @:?5 07 !K @5IC8@56 @5 E0A68F5@:?80A0G595@DC<?8;<85@G0C<F=58A6?5:F07 ! 86 ?:H5A => ?45 @8=CA:< EE0@F8AB<> ?45 6:D5 86 E0A68F5@5F :? K :AF DC<?8;<85@ :?
A ?4565 E8@ECD6?:AE56?45E0D;5A6:?80A:G:@F5F=>?45@8=CA:< CAF5@ ?45 45:F <:G6 07 F5;5AF5AE> @5IC8@56
1'"**
- 16 -
@5E0A68F5@:?80A :AF :EE0@F8AB<> 0A @5E0A68F5@:?80A ?45 6:D5E0D56?02 *
+,-./0*+,1 20)-
06607F5;5AF5AE> !'OKLLL &!" 6!+*&
06607E0A60@?8CD !L" OK56E:<:?80A" 6&
066 07 56?:?5 :AF 7CA5@:< 5L;5A656OK56E:<:?80A 6 &
-+* 1 3 4 %
EE0@F8AB<> ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F => ?45 @8=CA:< 86 @5FCE5F ?0 6'!*& @0CAF5F 077 ?0 6'!& :6 :B:8A6? 1 (
'& :G:@F5F => ?45 @8=CA:< 45 @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A 64:<< E:@@> 8A?5@56? :? ?45 @:?5 07 *K ;5@ :AACD 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 ;5?8?80A ?8<< @5:<8M:?80A EE0@F8AB<> ?45 ;08A? 70@ E0A68F5@:?80A86:A6G5@5F8A:778@D:?895 0@ ?45 70@5B08AB @5:60A6 ?486 0C@? ;@0E55F6 ?0;:66?4570<<0G8AB2
- 17 -
8" 45:;;5:<86:<<0G5F8A;:@? 88" 45JCFBD5A?:AF:G:@FF:?5F!! ;:665F => ?45 FF< 5A80@ 898< %CFB5 - :<:=C@:B88A 0&86 45@5=>D0F8785F, 888" 45:;;5<<:A?6&E<:8D:A?6:@55A?8?<5F70@: ?0?:< @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A 07 6 ''& :6 :B:8A6? 6'!& :<0AB G8?4 8A?5@56? :? *K ;5@ :AACD 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 78<8AB 07 ?45 ;5?8?80A ?8<< @5:<8M:?80A, 89" 45:D0CA?8AF5;068?64:<<=5?@:A6D8??5F ?0 ?45 E0AE5@A5F@8=CA:<70@F86=C@65D5A? 70@?4G8?4 9" :<:AE5 @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A :<0AB G8?4 :EE@C5F 8A?5@56? 6?:?5F 6C;@: 64:<< =5 F5;068?5F => ?45 0@;0@:?80A =570@5 ?45 E0AE5@A5F @8=CA:< G8?48A 68L G55H6 7@0D ?45F:?507@5E58;?07E0;>07?4860@F5@=> ?45:;;5<<:A?&0@;0@:?80A,
- 18 -
98" 86=C@65D5A? :AF :;;0@?80AD5A? 86 :6 ;5@ ?450@F5@07?45@8=CA:<, 988"
00@F5@:6?0E06? ) '%
! :98AB E0A68F5@5F ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F => ?45 @8=CA:< 8A 0& :B:8A6? ?45 ;@565A? :;;5:<6 78<5F G5 78AF A0 8A78@D8?856 8A ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F 45 6:8F E0D;5A6:?80A 86 :G:@F5F 8A ?5@D6 07 <:G 45 F5E5:65F G:6 >5:@6 :6 0A ?45 F:?5 07 :EE8F5A? !K 7C?C@5 ;@06;5E? 86 E0A68F5@5F :6 ;5@ ?45 $% !& 6C;@: :AF :G:@F5F :;;@0;@8:?5 E0D;5A6:?80A8AE<CF8ABD5F8E:<5L;5AF8?C@568AE545G:6 8A;:?85A? 70@ : ;5@80F 07 * F:>6 :AF 6CEECD=5F ?0 ?45 8AJC@856?45@5:7?5@G48<5CAF5@?@5:?D5A??45@8=CA:<4:6 E0A68F5@5F ?45 5A?8@5 E:65 70@ :G:@F8AB :;;@0;@8:?5 E0D;5A6:?80A G48E4 F056 A0? E:<< 70@ :A> 8A?5@75@5AE5 EE0@F8AB<>?45:;;5:<78<5F=>?45;;5<<:A?&0@;0@:?80A 866:A6D5@8?60A=0?4?45B@0CAF6:EE0@F8AB<>F86D8665F
- 19 -
0@ ?45 70@5B08AB @5:60A6 ?486 0C@? ;@0E55F6 ?0;:66?4570<<0G8AB2
8" 45:;;5:<86F86D8665F 88" 45 :G:@F JCFBD5A? :AF :G:@F ;:665F => ?45 @8=CA:< 8A 0& F:?5F !!86E0A78@D5F 888" 45 :D0CA? 8A F5;068? 64:<< =5 ?@:A675@@5F ?0 ?45 E0AE5@A5F@8=CA:<70@F86=C@65D5A?
70@?4G8?4 89" 45 =:<:AE5 :D0CA? ?0 ?45 5L?5A? 07 K <8:=8<8?> 7:6?5A5F 0A ?45 :;;5<<:A?&0@;0@:?80A 64:<< =5 F5;068?5F =570@5 ?45 E0AE5@A5F @8=CA:< G8?48A * G55H6 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 @5E58;? 07 E0;> 07 ?4860@F5@ 9" 45:;;0@?80AD5A?:6G5<<:6F86=C@65D5A? 86:6;5@?450@F5@;:665F=>?45@8=CA:< 98"
00@F5@4:6?0E06?6
- 20 -
)
'%
* 486:;;5:<86:@868AB0C?07 0& F:?5F!!:98ABE0A68F5@5F?458AJC@8566C775@5F :AF ?45 F86:=8<8?> @56C<?5F ?45 @8=CA:< 4:6 ;@0;5@<> E0A68F5@5F ?45 5A?8@5 D:?5@8:<6 0A @5E0@F :AF :G:@F5F :
E0D;5A6:?80A076+ ++&CAF5@9:@80C645:F6:AF F056 A0? E:<< 70@ :A> 8A?5@75@5AE5 :? ?45 4:AF6 07 ?486 0C@? ' :98ABE0A68F5@5F?456:D5=0?4?45B@0CAF6 @:865F => ?45 :;;5<<:A? :@5 :A6G5@5F :B:8A6? ?45 :;;5<<:A? 0@ ?45 70@5B08AB @5:60A6 ?486 0C@? ;@0E55F6 ?0;:66?4570<<0G8AB2
8" 45:;;5:<86F86D8665F 88" 45 :G:@F JCFBD5A? :AF :G:@F ;:665F => ?45 @8=CA:< 8A 0& F:?5F !!86E0A78@D5F
- 21 -
888" 45 :D0CA? 8A F5;068? 64:<< =5 ?@:A675@@5F ?0 ?45 E0AE5@A5F@8=CA:<70@F86=C@65D5A? 70@?4G8?4 89" 45 =:<:AE5 :D0CA? ?0 ?45 5L?5A? 07 K <8:=8<8?> 7:6?5A5F 0A ?45 :;;5<<:A?&0@;0@:?80A 64:<< =5 F5;068?5F =570@5 ?45 E0AE5@A5F @8=CA:< G8?48A * G55H6 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 @5E58;? 07 E0;> 07 ?4860@F5@ 9" 45:;;0@?80AD5A?:6G5<<:6F86=C@65D5A? 86:6;5@?450@F5@;:665F=>?45@8=CA:< 98"
00@F5@4:6?0E06?6
)
(%
+ 486 :;;5:< 86 :@868AB 0C? 07 0& F:?5F !! 0A68F5@8AB ?45 8AJC@856 6C775@5F :6 G5<<:6?45?@5:?D5A??:H5A:AF?45D5F8E:<5L;5AF8?C@5 45E0D;5A6:?80A:G:@F5F=>?45@8=CA:<:??45@:?507 6& 86 0A ?45 48B45@ 68F5 G48E4 @5IC8@56 @5E0A68F5@:?80A 45 8AJC@856 6C6?:8A5F 6?:?5F ?0 =5 # <0G5@<57?68F5;:@85?:<6E:<;=<CA?8AJC@>?0:=F0D5A:AF
- 22 -
0?45@ 8AJC@56 095@ ?45 =0F> 6 ;5@ L' G0CAF E5@?878E:?5 ?45 8AJC@856:@5 6?:?5F ?0=568D;<5 8A A:?C@5 C?:6;5@?45F86E4:@B5=8<<?458AJC@5FG:6:A8A;:?85A? 7@0D ** ?0 '' 70@ F:>6 ? 86 6C@;@868AB<> 640EH8AB 70@ 68D;<5 8AJC@> 86 6C;@: ?45 :;;5<<:A? G:6 8A;:?85A? 70@ : ;5@80F 07 F:>6 A?4565 E8@ECD6?:AE5 E0A68F5@8AB ?45 5A?8@5 D:?5@8:< 0A @5E0@F ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A :G:@F5F => ?45 @8=CA:< @5FCE5F ?0 6*&:6B<0=:<E0D;5A6:?80A:<0ABG8?48A?5@56?:? ?45 @:?5 07 *K ;5@ :AACD 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 ;5?8?80A ?8<< @5:<86:?80A 0@ ?45 70@5B08AB @5:60A6 ?486 0C@? ;@0E55F6 ?0;:66?4570<<0G8AB2
8" 45 :;;5:< 78<5F => ?45 0@;0@:?80A 86 :<<0G5F8A;:@? 88" 45 JCFBD5A?
:AF :G:@F ;:665F => ?45 FF<5A80@898<%CFB5-
:<:=C@:B8 8A 0& 86 45@5=> D0F8785F :AF
- 23 -
@5FCE5F?0Rs.*&B<0=:<<>8?64:<<E:@@> 8A?5@56?:??45@:?507*K;5@:AACD7@0D ?45F:?507;5?8?80A?8<<@5:<8M:?80A 888" 45:D0CA?8AF5;068?64:<<=5?@:A6D8??5F ?0 ?45 E0AE5@A5F @8=CA:< 70@?4G8?4 70@ F86=C@65D5A? 89" 45 K 07 ?45 =:<:AE5 @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A :<0AB G8?4 ?45 :EE@C5F 8A?5@56? 6C;@: 64:<< =5 F5;068?5F => ?45 0@;0@:?80AG8?48A*G55H67@0D?45F:?507 866C5 07 E0;> 07 ?486 0@F5@ =570@5 ?45 E0AE5@A5F@8=CA:< 9" A F5;068? 5A?8@5 :D0CA? 64:<< =5@5<5:65F 8A7:90C@078AJC@5F&E<:8D:A? 98"
00@F5@4:6?0E06? )
( %
458AJC@>6C775@5F:6;5@?45598F5AE507?45 F0E?0@:@57@:E?C@5?0AF @F:AF!?4D5?:?:@6:<=0A560A @8B4? 7@:E?C@5 07 @8B4? ECA5870@D =0A5 :AF 7@:E?C@5 07 :E5?:=C<CD 45 F0E?0@ G40 4:6 =55A 5L:D8A5F 4:6
- 24 -
6?:?5F ?4:? ?45@5 86 : F86:=8<8?> ?0 ?45 5L?5A? 07 K ?0 ?45 @8B4? <0G5@ <8D= :AF ?0 ?45 ?0?:< =0F> 8? 86 K :98ABE0A68F5@5F?455A?8@5598F5AE50A@5E0@F?45@586 A0?48AB8A?45G0CAFE5@?878E:?56CBB56?8AB@5B:@F8AB?45 7@:E?C@5 07 :E5?:=C<CD 45 F0E?0@ 4:6 6?:?5F ?45 F86:=8<8?> ?0 ?45 ;:@?8EC<:@ <8D= :? K :AF :? ?45 95@> 6:D5 ?8D5 6?:?5F 8? 86 K ?0 ?45 G40<5 =0F> 45 @8=CA:<4:6?:H5A?456:D5?0?455L?5A?07K?0?45 G40<5 =0F> 00H8AB ?0 ?45 A:?C@5 07 8AJC@856 45 F86:=8<8?> 86 @5FCE5F ?0 K 8A6?5:F 07 K #48<5 @5?:8A8AB ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A CAF5@ 0?45@ 45:F6 EE0@F8AB<> ?45 6:D5 @5IC8@56 @5F5?5@D8A:?80A :AF @5E:<EC<:?80A A@5F5?5@D8A:?80A?456:D5E0D56?02 *
+,-./0*+,1 20)-
:8A:AFC775@8AB 6 &
??5AF:A? E4:@B56 700F :AF E0A95>:AE5E4:@B56 6'&
066077C?C@58AE0D5 !'LL!L&" 6+' *& ! 5F8E:<5L;5AF8?C@5 6&
066 07 8AE0D5 FC@8AB ?@5:?D5A?;5@80F !'L " 6!!& * C?C@5D5F8E:<5L;5A656 6& ' 06607:D5A8?856 6!&
-+* 1(45%
- 25 -
EE0@F8AB<> 0A @5F5?5@D8A:?80A ?45 E0D;5A6:?80A 86 @5FCE5F 7@0D 6''*& ?0 6*& 45 @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A 64:<< E:@@> 8A?5@56? :? ?45 @:?5 07 *K ;5@ :AACD 7@0D ?45 F:?5 07 ;5?8?80A?8<<@5:<86:?80A 0@ ?45 70@5B08AB @5:60A6 ?486 0C@? ;@0E55F6 ?0;:66?4570<<0G8AB2
8" 45 :;;5:< 78<5F => ?45 0@;0@:?80A 86 :<<0G5F8A;:@? 88" 45 JCFBD5A? :AF :G:@F ;:665F => ?45 FF<5A80@898<%CFB5-
:<:=C@:B8 8A 0*& 86 45@5=> D0F8785F :AF@5FCE5F?0Rs.*&8?64:<<E:@@> 8A?5@56?:??45@:?507*K;5@:AACD7@0D ?45F:?507;5?8?80A?8<<@5:<8M:?80A 888" 45:D0CA?8AF5;068?64:<<=5?@:A6D8??5F ?0 ?45 E0AE5@A5F @8=CA:< 70@?4G8?4 70@ F86=C@65D5A? - 26 -
89" 45 =:<:AE5 K 07 E0D;5A6:?80A @5FCE5F E0D;5A6:?80A :<0AB G8?4 ?45 :EE@C5F 8A?5@56?
6?:?5F 6C;@: 64:<< =5 F5;068?5F => ?45 0@;0@:?80A G8?48A * G55H6 7@0D ?45 F:?507866C507E0;>07?4860@F5@=570@5?45 E0AE5@A5F@8=CA:< 9" 45F5;068?:6G5<<:6@5<5:6507:D0CA?86 :6;5@?450@F5@;:665F=>?45@8=CA:< 98"
00@F5@4:6?0E06? 988" 45@5B86?@>86F8@5E?5F?0?@:A6D8??45?@8:< 0C@?@5E0@F670@?4G8?4G8?48AG55H67@0D ?45 F:?5 07 @5<5:65 07 ?486 0@F5@ ?0 5A:=<5 ?45 0@;0@:?80A ?0 F5;068? :AF ?45 E<:8D:A?6?0655H70@@5<5:65:AFF5;068? EE0@F8AB<>:<<?45:;;5:<6#' !#
6%
"$ ! 6%
"$ ! 86? 02< 02+