Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43189 (KAR)

GURAPPA v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER

WP/201568/2025 · 2025-11-04

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!"!#$% & %'"%"% ( ") ! " #$ % ! $$ & ' (( # $ '& $ (( Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) $ (( ! " $## ( '% ( '' ''* ( ( % ( $$ $$+, $ ( ' - '&'&' % ( . $( ($ ( $ ( $ $ $ / $$#$ - 3 - ! " / $$#$% 0+1 2,3+3+45 +1 6+7,8 9: 30, 2,3+3+45,; 1,,<+5= 64774>+5=;,7+,6 ! " #$#$% & '() ' 0, ?@1, 46 30, 2,3+3+45,; +1 30@3 0, 0@1 9,,5 @77433,8 =A53@ 46 7@58 34 9, A1,8 64; ?4BB,;?+@7 2A;241,1 0@3 0, 0@1 2@+8 1'C 34 ;,12458,53 4'9:>@:464) '8@3,8''&C'&'8;@>5+5 30, 5@B, 46 0+,6 ??4A531 66+?,; @=@7<43, 0@3 304A=030,1@+81+3,0@19,,5@77433,8 >@33A<0@3@0@1 543 9,,5 B@8, +5 0+1 5@B, ,5?, 0, B@8, ;,2;,1,53@3+45 >0+?0 0@1 543 9,,5 ?451+8,;,8 9: 30, - 4 - ;,12458,53@A304;+3+,1==;+,D,89:30,1@B, 2,3+3+45,; 9,64;,30+14A;3 ,@;5,8 88+3+45@7 4D,;5B,53 8D4?@3, @22,@;+5= 64; ;,12458,53 41 @58 ' 1A9B+31 30@3 55,EA;, 9@1,8 45 >0+?0 30, 2,3+3+45,; ?7@+B,8 34 0@D,9,,5@77433,8=A53@467@5884,15439,@;@5:8@3, 4; 4;8,; 46 @7743B,53 , 04>,D,; 1A9B+31 30@3 30, ;,FA,134630,2,3+3+45,;>+779,D,;+6+,86;4B30,;,?4;81 @58+664A5830@330,7@580@19,,5@77433,8+530,B@55,; <54>5 34 7@> 5,?,11@;: @?3+45 +5 30, B@33,; >4A78 9, 3@<,5 ) 0,1A9B+11+453@<,545;,?4;8 ,@;8,;A1,830,;,?4;81 E?,23 2;48A?+5= 55,EA;, @5 A58@3,8 ?4BBA5+?@3+45 2A;24;3,87: +11A,8 9: ;,12458,53 4' ,0@9+7+3@3+45 66+?,; 5430+5= 0@1 9,,5 2;48A?,8 9: 30, 2,3+3+45,; +5 GA13+6+?@3+45 46 0+1 ?7@+B ,3+3+45,; 04>,D,; ?7@+B1 34 0@D, 2@+8 @ 1AB 46 1'C 9: >@: 46 - 5 - 4) '8@3,8''&C'&'8;@>5+530,5@B,460+,6 ??4A531 66+?,; @=@7<43, 34>@;81 30, ?413 46 30, ?4BB,;?+@71+3, * +5?, 30, ,@;5,8 88+3+45@7 4D,;5B,53 8D4?@3, 0@1 1A9B+33,8 30@3 30, ;,12458,53@A304;+3+,1 >+77 D,;+6: 30, ;,?4;81 >+30 ;,=@;8 34 =,5A+5,5,11 4; 430,;>+1, 46 30, =;@53 9,+5= B@8, +5 6@D4A; 46 30, 2,3+3+45,; 30, 2,3+3+45 +1 >+30 30, 64774>+5= 8+;,?3+451 "+% 0, ;,12458,53 41 @58 ' 10@77 D,;+6: +6 =A53@467@58@1?7@+B,89:30,2,3+3+45,;0@1 +58,,8 9,,5 =;@53,8 +5 0+1 6@D4A; @58 30, 2,3+3+45,;0@12@+830,@B4A53461'C 9: >@: 46 4) ' 8@3,8 ''&C'&' 8;@>5+530,5@B,460+,6??4A531 66+?,; @=@7<43, @1?7@+B,8 "++% 5D,;+6+?@3+454630,1@B, +630,?7@+B4630, 2,3+3+45,; 64A58 34 9, 3;A, @58 ?4;;,?3 - 6 - 6A;30,; @?3+45 @1 ;,FA+;,8 A58,; 7@> +5 BA3@3+5= 0+1 5@B, @58 +11A+5= >@33A #0@3@9,3@<,5 "+++% A?0 8,?+1+451 10@77 9, 3@<,5 @58 30, 1@B, 10@779,?4BBA5+?@3,83430,2,3+3+45,;>+30+5 @54A3,;7+B+34630;,,B453016;4B30,8@3, 46;,?,+234630,?,;3+6+,8?42:4630+14;8,; "*+ (%"%) '! SDU LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 4 CT:PK