- 1 - ! " # $!%!&!! !!&& '( ) * ! " # # $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % & ' ( " ) $*#! +$' , + $*#! % & +- *!*! ( + + &( + + !!! $ ! ! + + ) ) , % ./0122314/025363553789:.3;41/<1=:01>1/=0: :.3 ?7><3=: 1=7 1@157 71:37 !!! 210037 /= - 3 - A! !89:.35/=;/2143=/A5/B/4?7>31=7 C/D1912?51&6A50.A5:E:.3:5/8?=14F( =3 5/ ?51221 <3: @/:. 1;;/73=: A= !! 1=7 7/37 7?3 :A :.3 /=D?5/30 0?0:1/=37 /= :.3 1;;/73=: /0 <A:.35 @/63 1=7 ;./4753= 6/437 ;41/< 23:/:/A= 836A53:.3:5/8?=14033G/=>;A<23=01:/A=A60H!!!! $ .3:5/8?=1416:35;A=0/735/=>:.33=:/533B/73=;3A=53;A57 .101@1573710?<A60 #H!! $14A=>@/:./=:3530:1: :.3 51:3 A6 #I 235 1==?< 65A< :.3 71:3 A6 23:/:/A= :/44 5314/J1:/A= >>5/3B37 89 :.3 01/7 ?7><3=: :.3 ;41/<1=:0 .1B3 253635537 :.3 25303=: 122314 033G/=> 3=.1=;3<3=: A6 :.3;A<23=01:/A= 3157:.34315=37;A?=034065A<8A:.0/730 " =:.325303=:122314/:/0<1/=49;A=:3=737:.1: :.3 :5/8?=14 .10 >51=:37 /=173K?1:3 ;A<23=01:/A= .3 73;31037 @10 1= 1>5/;?4:?5/0: 1=7 7A/=> ;AA4/3 @A5G 1=7 315=/=> 1 0?< A6 0!!! $ 235 <A=:. 8?: :.3 :5/8?=14 .10;A=0/73537./0/=;A<31:0"! $235<A=:.10235 :.3 ;.15: 25321537 89 :.3 '15=1:1G1 :1:3 3>14 35B/;30 - 4 - ?:.A5/:9 0?<A60"!!!! $/01@15737?=735:.3.317 A64A00A6;A=0A5:/?<1=7=A1<A?=:0@353>51=:37:A@1570 4A00A64AB31=71663;:/A=6A5;./4753=1=7<A:.351=7"!IA6 :.3 /=;A<3 /0 =A: 17737 :A@1570 4A00 A6 6?:?53 25A023;:0 +?5:.35.325190:A3=.1=;3:.351:3A6/=:3530:65A<#I:A HI .A?>. :.3 ;41/<1=:0 .1B3 0:1:37 /= :.3/5 ;41/< 23:/:/A=:.1::.373;31037@101>37*9315010A=:.371:3 A6 :.3 731:. 1=7 @10 315=/=> 1 0?< A6 0!!! $ 235 <A=:.:.39.1B3=A:6/4371=9/=;A<325AA6.3536A53:.3 :5/8?=14.105/>.:49;A=0/73537:.3/=;A<3A6:.373;310371: 0"! $ 235 :.3 ;.15: 25321537 89 :.3 '15=1:1G1 3>14 35B/;30 ?:.A5/:93=;3:.301<3=3370=A/=:356353=;3 # = B/3@ A6 :.3 7/;:?< 41/7 7A@= 89 :.3 A=F843 23L A?5: /= :.3 ;103 A6 532A5:37 /= ! !" "!I :A 83 17737 :A :.3 /=;A<3 A6 :.3 73;31037 :A@15706?:?5325A023;:01=7 ":./0:A83737?;:37:A@1570 2350A=143L23=030/=B/3@A6:.373;/0/A=.34789:.3A=F843 - 5 - 23L A?5: /= :.3 ;103 A6 # $ 532A5:37 /= % ! 3=;3:.34A00A67323=73=;9@A?478310?=735) 0"! $ M "!I $ ":. I N 0 H"! $ /=;3 :.3 ;41/<1=: A /0 :.3 <A:.35 0.3 /0 3=:/:437 6A5 1 0?< A6 0"!!!! $ :A@1570 6/4/14 ;A=0A5:/?< ;41/<1=: A /0 :.3 @/63 0.3 /0 3=:/:43 6A5 1 0?< A6 0"!!!! $:A@15704A00A6;A=0A5:/?<;41/<1=:A0 :A 153:.3;./4753=:.391533=:/:4376A510?<A60"!!!! $ 31;. :A@1570 2153=:14 ;A=0A5:/?< 44 :.3 ;41/<1=:0 153 3=:/:4376A510?<A60 !!!! $:A@1570;A=B3=:/A=14.3170 10235:.37/;:?<41/77A@=89:.3A=F843 23LA?5:/=:.3 ;103 A6 &53635537 0?251( .3 :A:14 ;A<23=01:/A= @A?478310?=735) !+ ,-./012,3/-453 1634 A00A67323=73=;9 0 H"! $ A00 A6 ;A=0A5:/?< &0"!!!! $( 0!!!!! $ A=B3=:/A=14.317 0 !!!! $ 4-+ /"7 - 6 - * 315=37 ;A?=034 6A5 :.3 =0?51=;3 ;A<21=9 0?8</:0:.1::.3;A<23=01:/A=1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14.10 833=732A0/:3714A=>@/:./=:3530: H ;;A57/=>49:.36A44A@/=>A5735) &/( .3122314/0144A@37/=215:- &//( .3 ;41/<1=:0 153 3=:/:43 :A :A:14 ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0 *H"! $ 14A=> @/:. /=:3530:1::.351:3A6#I2351==?<65A<:.371:3 A6 23:/:/A= :/44 5314/J1:/A= 10 1>1/=0: 0 #H!! $1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14- &///( .3 5302A=73=: A /0 7/53;:37 :A 732A0/: :.3 3=.1=;37 ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0!#! $14A=>@/:./=:3530:@/:./=1235/A7 A6A=3<A=:.- &/B( .3 122A5:/A=<3=: A573537 89 :.3 :5/8?=14/0?=14:3537- &B( = 0?;. 732A0/: 0/=;3 :.3 ;41/<1=:0 1223441=: A0 " 1=7 153 </=A50 :.3/50.1530.14483G32:/=16/L37732A0/:/=1=9 - 7 - =1:/A=14/J37 1=G :/44 :.39 1::1/= :.3 1>3 A6 <1DA5/:9- &B/( 223441=:A ;41/<1=:/0235</::37:A @/:.751@ :.3 /=:3530: A= :.3 6/L37 732A0/: /= :.3 =1<30A6:.31223441=:0A0 "1=7A=;3/=1 :.533<A=:.0:A<33:A?:719:A7193L23=030- &B//( 223441=: A0 1=7 ;41/<1=:0 153 235</::37 :A @/:.751@ :.3/5 3=:/53 0.153 1<A?=: A=0?;.732A0/: /.7 '&!! ) % /0:A)4A)