Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43184 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. SHIVARAJ
MFA/202240/2025 · 2025-07-17
Ravi V Hosmani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43184 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43184 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$#
%$ && ''
(&) *
!"#
$
"# %
&$ '
$(
)
*
+, +$ + -
(+
+ !"#
+#- +
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
,"
+ -* (+ +!"#. %
-,&)
"
,,$
* * *
"
,, $ * *
(
*
+
+ /$
*
$ 0122345645 7895:34; 149 1<1=9 91;39 " >1??39 @A 992 346B= 6C62 *8953 149 *
16D08= 64 4B,,;06?1>>3126?E6239
=6
B09 1F33=899640345;119CBD1;31>>31=645 EB= =6
B09 @9812 (1AA8: 231=439 DB84?32 ?8@:6;;39 1>>312 <1? @A 64?8=3= B4 G814;8: 41:32A 63 E84D;6B412 96?1@626;ADB4?693=39@A;=6@8412<1?B406503=?693
- 3 -
, 03=3 6? 9321A BE 91A? 64 E62645 1>>312 64D3 9321A 6? 4B; ?8@?;14;612 6:>85439 1<1=9 <1? 3H1:6439 B4 :3=6;? # ? >3= 1<1=9 B4 " D216:14;06C1=17 15=6D82;8=6?; 1539 A31=? ?;1;39 ;B 01C3 @334 =69645 :B;B=DAD234B ,.-#B43B98=51*12101226:164=B19 1; ."" >: 431= 1=698991 9=6C3= BE D1= 4B ,"
9=BC3 6; =1?0 149 43526534; :1443= 149 91?039 15164?;
:B;B=DAD23 D18?645 1DD6934; 4 ?169 1DD6934; D216:14;
?8?;16439 5=63CB8? 6478=63? 149 <1? 646;6122A 19:6;;39 ;B BC3=4:34; B?>6;12 3B98=51 149 ;03=31E;3= ;B $1?1C1 B?>6;1216D08=3?>6;3;1I645;=31;:34;039694B;=3DBC3= E822A149?8?;16439>3=:1434;>0A?6D1296?1@626;A22356452B?? BE31=4645D1>1D6;A03E6239D216:>3;6;6B48493=3D;6B4..BE D;15164?;B<43=14964?8=3=BED1=
" 4 DB4;3?; <03=364 B<43= 149 64?8=3= B>>B?39 D216:>3;6;6B4B41225=B849?64D289645;01;=693=BE:B;B=DAD23 <1? =1?0 149 43526534; 64 D18?645 1DD6934; 9=6C3= BE 64?8=39 C306D23<1?4B;01C645C12691493EE3D;6C39=6C64526D34D33;D ;=6@8412 E=1:39 6??83? 149 =3DB=939 3C6934D3 216:14;
3H1:643906:?32E149=17349=1 B;01=61??149
- 4 -
H?;B#<3=35B;:1=I394?8=3=3H1:64396;?BEE6D6121? 1495B;:1=I39H149 . 4 DB4?693=1;6B4 =6@8412 0329 1DD6934; 019 BDD8==39983;B=1?014943526534;9=6C645BED1=@A6;?9=6C3= D216:14; 019 ?8?;16439 6478=63? 149 <1? 34;6;239 EB= DB:>34?1;6B41?EB22B<?+
+ ,-./ 0123
B?? BE 31=4645? B4 1DDB84; BE 96?1@626;A ?,.#
164149?8EE3=645 ?" , B?? BE 64DB:3 98=645 21698> >3=6B9 ?#- # ;;34914;
D01=53? ;=14?>B=;1;6B4 149 B;03= 3H>34?3? ?",. " B?? BE 1:346;63? 149 48;=6;6B4 EBB9 ?" . 396D123H>34?3? ?,#"
3-+ /4
""5
- 55=63C39@A1<1=9B4G814;8:1>>3126?E6239;
<1? ?8@:6;;39 ;0B850 ;=6@8412 ;BBI 4B;3 BE 1??3??:34; BE ;B;12 96?1@626;A BE D216:14; 1; #J 6; DB4?693=39 E84D;6B412 96?1@626;A1;#J1491<1=9393HD3??6C3DB:>34?1;6B4 4?169 5=B849?B850;EB=64;3=E3=34D3
3=8?12BE6:>854391<1=9<B829=3C312;01;<0623 1??3??645 DB:>34?1;6B4 ;=6@8412 93;3=:6439 153 BE D216:14;
- 5 -
@A=3E3==645;B06?153:34;6B43964H"B8493=;6E6D1;31;
," A31=? DB4?693=39 4B;6B412 64DB:3 19B>;39 @A EB= ?3;;23:34; BE D1?3? @3EB=3 BI9121;0 EB= A31= 1;
?#-" 1? :B4;02A 64DB:3 149 >3=:1434; >0A?6D12 96?1@626;A 1??3??39 @A 1; #J ;B 1==6C3 1; E84D;6B412 96?1@626;A1;#J;6??334D216:14;?8?;1643903196478=A149 DB4?3G834; 438=B2B56D12 96?1@626;A 1;
"J
38=B2B56D12 96?1@626;A <B829 @3 <0B23 @B9A 96?1@626;A 149 D144B; @3 DB4?693=39 1? 26:@ 96?1@626;A 4 2650; BE ?1:3 1??3??:34; BE E84D;6B41296?1@626;A1;#JD144B;@3?;1;39;B@33HD3??6C3B= 8478?;6E63903=3EB=31??3??:34;BEDB:>34?1;6B4@A;=6@8412 ;B<1=9? 2B?? BE E8;8=3 64DB:3 1; ?,.# <B829 4B; <1==14;64;3=E3=34D3<1=9BE?";B<1=9?>164149 ?8EE3=645 ?#- ;B<1=9? 2B?? BE 64DB:3 98=645 21698> >3=6B9 ?",. ;B<1=9? 1;;34914; D01=53?
;=14?>B=;1;6B4 149 :6?D322143B8? 3H>34?3? ?" ;B<1=9? 2B?? BE 1:346;63? 149 ?,#" ;B<1=9? :396D12 3H>34?3? 1=3 4B;
G83?;6B439 03=3EB=3 9B 4B; E649 14A 5BB9 5=B849 ;B 64;3=E3=3<6;06:>854391<1=9B4?3G834;2A4B"1? <3221?1>>3121=396?:6??39
- 6 -
4 C63< BE 96?>B?12 BE 1>>312 4B" <B829 4B; ?8=C6C3EB=DB4?693=1;6B4
:B84;6493>B?6;6?B=93=39;B;=14?:6;;39;B;=6@8412
.5 (&& ) $
$ 6?; B+2 B+. ;+I