Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43178 (KAR)
MALLIKARJUN v. THE STATE AND ANR
CRL.P/200386/2024 · 2025-10-28
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43178 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43178 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$##
#
% %&'( %'' )
!"
#
$% %
&
"
"' $ (
&
'
$
& ! Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
")
#
$ %(
"*
'%&
(
' ($
&
'
(
(
((
' "'''
(
(
((
+ $& !'! )! ( ! (
(
,
$ ,
&
-./ 012.2.34 ./ 5.617 84719 1:2.34 ' 35 -;9;2.<;
;=;9.> 89;>/-; ;4-.2; ''! /11>.4= 23 ?8;/- 2-1 093:117.4=/ ;=;.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419 .4 3' "''' ;9./.4= 382 35 9.@1 3"A'''" 35 ;6;B89;=. .2< 3@14 36.:1 2;2.34 ;6;B89;=. 539 2-1 35514:1/ 084./-;B61 84719 1:2.34/ + $& !'! ) 91;7 C.2- 1:2.34 ! 35 ;47 1:2.34/ ! ;47 35 3C9<
- 3 -
93-.B.2.34:2"+)"0147.4=342-15.6135776( ;6;B89;=. ' -1/1:34791/0347142C.51637=17;:3@06;.42 34 '"A''" ;661=.4= 2-;2 -19 -8/B;47 -;7 /8BD1:217 -19 23 -;9;//@142 ;47 .66291;2@142 915199.4= 23 ;4 .4:.7142 /;.7 23 -;E1 3::89917 34 ")"''" 2 ./ /.=4.5.:;422343212-;22-1:3@06;.42C;/5.61741;96</.F @342-/;52192-1;661=17.4:.7142-1/;.7:3@06;.42C;/ 142192;.417 B< 2-1 D89./7.:2.34;6 36.:1 2;2.34 C-.:- :86@.4;217.42-191=./29;2.3435;:9.@1 034:3@0612.34 352-1.4E1/2.=;2.342-14E1/2.=;2.4=
55.:19-;/43C5.617 ; :-;9=1 /-112 2 ./ ;6/3 0192.4142 23 4321 2-;2 2-38=- 786< /19E17 C.2- 432.:1 .//817 B< 2-./ 3892 2-1 /1:347 91/0347142C.51 -;/ :-3/14 432 23 :3421/2 2-1 091/142 093:117.4=/ ! -./ 3892 -;/ -1;97 2-1 61;9417 :384/16 ;001;9.4= 539 2-1 012.2.3419/ ;47 2-1 61;9417 .=- 3892 3E194@14261;71991091/142.4=2-12;21
- 4 -
15391;7E192.4=232-1;661=;2.34/35:98162<;/ 91561:217 .4 2-1 :-;9=1/-112 @;219.;6/ .2 B1:3@1/ 41:1//;9<232;>14321352-10;9;6616093:117.4=/.4.2.;217 B12C114 012.2.3419-8/B;47 ;47 91/0347142 3'C.51 -1 91:397/ 7./:63/1 2-;2 012.2.3419 -;7 .4/2.28217
3 ''!B153912-1(;@.6<3892/11>.4=91/2.282.3435 :34D8=;6 9.=-2/ -1 /;.7 012.2.34 :;@1 23 B1 ;663C17 B< D87=@142;47397197;217"+)''.4:12-15.47.4=/ 91:39717B<2-1(;@.6<3892.42-1/;.7D87=@142B1;9;
7.91:2 41F8/ 23 2-1 ;661=;2.34/ 35 -;9;//@142 ;47 .66 291;2@142 43C 84719 :34/.719;2.34 .2 C3867 B1 ;009309.;21 23 1F29;:2 0;9;=9;0- 3"A 35 2-1 /;.7 D87=@142C-.:-91;7/2-8/
- 5 -
! "
#
! #
$! %
&
2 C3867 B1 ;6/3 ;003/.21 23 ;7E192 23 2-1 5.47.4=/91:39717B<2-1(;@.6<3892.4 3!++''! 4 3!++''! /1:347 91/0347142C.51 /38=-2 7.//3682.34 35 @;99.;=1 34 2-1 =93847 35 :98162< ;47 71/192.34 C-.:- C;/ 7./@.//17 E.71 D87=@142 ;47 39719 7;217 'A''' ;9;=9;0- 3/" ' ;47 '" 35 2-1 /;.7D87=@142C3867B19161E;42;47/;@1;911F29;:217 B163C ' ! ()('*(+! ! % *(+
#
! - 6 -
*'
**(+! ! ! ! ,
-
*.(**(/
,
0
'
! ()(.*(/
,
! " ! 12%(+3*(*. 24
2
5651"2!5 !,
0 $
,
12 %(+3*(*. *(7%%*8#
4
.9:9 : $ 1 #! /''! ;
<! #! ! ! ! <
! " ! 44 ! ; ;
! !
- 7 -
0 $- # 2
! ;
! ! ! !;"
! ! ! 9: ! 9*:
9
: 4
8 9:
! 9*:
;
* ! "
!*(/
,
'*(*.! ,
,
***(*.! ! ! ! 0
0
12 (+3*(*. ! ! %*
&
- 8 -
) 4 ; :;91586 0198/;6 35 2-1 1F29;:217 0392.34/ 593@ B32- 2-1 7.E39:1 ;47 91/2.282.34 093:117.4=/ .2 B1:3@1/ @;4.51/26< 1E.7142 2-;2 2-1 /1:347 91/0347142C.51.4-19061;7.4=/B153912-1(;@.6<3892 -;/ :;21=39.:;66< ;7@.2217 2-;2 /-1 -;/ B114 91/.7.4= ;2 -19 0;9142;6 -3@1 /.4:1 (1B98;9< '"+ 19 /361 =9.1E;4:1;/91561:217.42-3/1093:117.4=/C;/2-;22-1 012.2.3419-8/B;47 -;7 ;661=176< 5;.617 23 B9.4= -19 B;:> 23 2-1 @;29.@34.;6 -3@1 3C1E19 2-1 91:397 .4
3 ''!
$012.2.34 539 91/2.282.34 35 :34D8=;6 9.=-2/& 84@./2;>;B6< 91E1;6/ 2-;2 2-1 -8/B;47 -;7 @;71 B34;
5.71 155392/ 23 91/8@1 :3-;B.2;2.34 C-.:- C191 @12 C.2- :34/./2142 9158/;6 B< 2-1 C.51 1/0.21 ; 71:911 539 91/2.282.3435:34D8=;69.=-2/-;E.4=B114=9;4217.45;E389 352-1-8/B;472-1C.517.7432:-33/123:3@06<C.2-2-1 71:911;47:342.48172391/.71/10;9;216< A -1 5.47.4=/ 91:39717 B< 2-1 (;@.6< 3892 .4 2-1 7.E39:1 093:117.4=/ 0;92.:86;96< 0;9;=9;0- 3" 5892-1971@34/29;212-;22-1@;9.2;6:3-;B.2;2.34B12C114
- 9 -
2-1 0;92.1/ 6;/217 539 346< ;B382 ' 7;</ ;5219 @;99.;=1 -1(;@.6<38928034;0091:.;2.34351E.714:1:;@123 2-1 :34:68/.34 2-;2 2-1 C.51 -;7 E36842;9.6< C.2-79;C4 593@ 2-1 :3@0;4< 35 -19 -8/B;47 C.2-382 91;/34;B61 :;8/1 ;47 2-;2 /-1 -;7 5;.617 23 /8B/2;42.;21 -19 ;661=;2.34/ 35 :98162< ;47 .66291;2@142 -1/1 :34:899142 5.47.4=/ 35 5;:2 91:39717 B< ; :3@012142 :3892 35 :.E.6 D89./7.:2.34 ;91 /.=4.5.:;42 ;47 B1;9 7.91:26< 8034 2-1 091/142:9.@.4;6093/1:82.34
42-1B;:>7930352-1/1841?8.E3:;65.47.4=/.5 2-1 :3@06;.42 637=17 B< 2-1 /1:347 91/0347142C.51 34 '"A''" ./ 1F;@.417 .4 .2/ 093019 019/01:2.E1 2-./ 3892 ./ 35 2-1 :34/.71917 30.4.34 2-;2 2-1 ;661=;2.34 35 :98162<847191:2.34+ :;4432B191;=.2;217.4;
:9.@.4;6 5398@ -1 (;@.6< 3892 .4 2C3 .4710147142 093:117.4=/341/11>.4=91/2.282.3435:34D8=;69.=-2/;47 2-1 32-19 :34:194.4= 7.//3682.34 35 @;99.;=1 -;/ ;5219 58665617=17;7D87.:;2.3441=;2172-1;661=;2.34/35:98162< ;4791:39717;:;21=39.:;65.47.4=2-;2.2C;/2-1C.51C-3
- 10 -
-;7 71/19217 2-1 -8/B;47 C.2-382 ;4< D8/2.5.;B61 :;8/1 4:12-1:3@012142(;@.6<3892-;/71219@.4172-;22-1 C.51C;/2-1715;862.4=/038/1;472-;243;:235:98162< /2337093E172-1:342.48;2.3435;:9.@.4;6093/1:82.3434 2-1/;@1/12355;:2/C3867;@384223916.2.=;2.3435;4 .//81;691;7</122617B<D87.:.;671219@.4;2.34 + 4 2-1 :3429;9< 2-1 5.47.4=/ .4 2-1 91/2.282.34 093:117.4=//01:.5.:;66<91:3972-;22-1C.51-;771/19217 -19-8/B;47C.2-38291;/34;B61:;8/1C-.612-15.47.4=/ .4 2-1 7.E39:1 :;/1 91.4539:1 2-;2 2-1 ;661=;2.34/ 35 .66 291;2@142 ;47 -;9;//@142 C191 84/8B/2;42.;217 -19153912-12C.45.47.4=/5.9/22-;22-1C.51./=8.62<35 71/192.34 ;47 /1:347 2-;2 2-1 :-;9=1 35 :98162< ./ 845384717 :61;96< 71@36./- 2-1 /8B/29;28@ 35 2-1 093/1:82.34:;/1-14/8:-D87.:.;671219@.4;2.34/B<;
:3@012142 (;@.6< 3892 /8B/./2 2-1 :342.48;2.34 35 2-1 :9.@.4;6 093:117.4=/ 84719 1:2.34 + 91;7 C.2- 1:2.34/ !'! ) ;47 1:2.34/ !
) ;47 1:2.34/ ! ;47 35 2-1
- 11 -
3C9< 93-.B.2.34 :2 C3867 432 346< B1 917847;42 B82 C3867;6/3:34/2.2821;=93//;B8/1352-1093:1//356;C
" 2./;6/39161E;422343212-;22-1012.2.345.617 B< 2-1 .46;C/ /11>.4= ?8;/-.4= 35 2-1 093:117.4=/ 34 .7142.:;6 ;661=;2.34/ -;/ ;691;7< B114 ;663C17 B< 2-./ 3892 ;47 2-1 093:117.4=/ ;=;.4/2 2-1@ -;E1 B114 ?8;/-174E.1C352-1/171E1630@142/;470;92.:86;96< .4 2-1 6.=-2 35 :34:899142 5.47.4=/ 35 2-1 (;@.6< 3892 -367.4= 2-;2 2-1 C.51 C;/ ;2 5;862 ;47 2-;2 2-191 C;/ 43 :98162< ;229.B82;B61 23 2-1 -8/B;47 019@.22.4= 2-1 093/1:82.34 23 093:117 5892-19 C3867 /19E1 43 61=;6 08903/1;47C3867346</8BD1:22-1012.2.3419-8/B;4723 84C;99;4217 -;9;//@142 -8@.6.;2.34 ;47 -;97/-.0 -./ 38922-19153915.47/.2;5.2:;/1231F19:./1.2/.4-19142 03C19/ 84719 1:2.34 ' 35 2-1 371 35 9.@.4;6 93:1789123091E1422-1;B8/1352-1093:1//356;C;47 23/1:8912-1147/35D8/2.:1
"" (392-15391=3.4=91;/34/2-153663C.4=39719./ 0;//17
- 12 -
. -19.@.4;612.2.34./;663C17 .. -1 093:117.4=/ 0147.4= ;=;.4/2 2-1 012.2.3419.4 3' "''';9./.4=38235 9.@1 3"A'''"35;6;B89;=..2<3@14 36.:1 2;2.34 ;6;B89;=. 539 2-1 35514:1/ 084./-;B61 84719 1:2.34/ + !'! )91;7C.2-1:2.34!352-147.;414;6 371 ;47 1:2.34/ ! ;47 35 2-1 3C9< 93-.B.2.34 :2 "+)" 0147.4= 34 2-1 5.61 35 2-177.2.34;6(;6;B89;=.;91-191B< ?8;/-17 ... 34/1?81426<;66.421963:8239<;006.:;2.34/.5 ;4</2;477./03/1735
*( %##' $
./2 3'6 3"