Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43173 (KAR)

SHANTAMMA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/203792/2025 · 2025-12-01

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $#% # # &' ( !"#$ % & ' $ ( !)))$ !"#$)$ * !"#$ # !"#$ % & + ' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( , ( ( ( (- + . ( " $)"$ " * $ $ ( )))# *$),) )#$)) /! $ ( $))* /! ( # $))# /! ( 0+ & 0+ ' 123234516 7893:35; 24 <1 2=1 4>516 35 972?98 @4AA1AA3454B2=1895C<19635;D4" $:19A?635;)" 9761A $ ;?529A 95C D4" * :19A?635; $ 9761A $ ;?529A A32?921C 157=:969C3 3889;1 9:95E988?6 4<83 9AE3 98?E 937=?6 3A26372 3A <1B461 2=3A 4?62 A11E35; B4884>35;61831B AA?1 9 >632 35 2=1 592?61 4B :95C9:?A C3617235; 2=1 61A@45C152A 24 C18121 2=1 1526D 4B -E=963F E=929. 35 2=1 A 4B D4" $ - 3 - :19A?635; )" 9761A $ ;?529A 95C D4" * :19A?635; $ 9761A $ ;?529A 4B 157=:969C3 G3889;1 9:95E988?6 4<83 98?E 9AE3 C3A2 937=?6 <D 745A3C1635; 61@61A15292345A C921C )))# *$),) )#$)) G3C1 551H?61!$95C<D745A3C1635;2=161@4624B 61G15?1 35A@17246 C921C $))* G3C1 551H?61! 95C 61@462 4B 61A@45C152 4# C921C $))#G3C1551H?61! =1 79A1 4B 2=1 @123234516 3A 2=92 A=1 =9A 35=16321C 2=1 9B461A93C A93C @64@162D B64: =16 9571A246A >=4A159:1A=9G1<11561B81721CB64:2=1D196$#! ?@24)#!)=92A4:1>=161352=1D196$!$* 2=1 61A@45C152A >32=4?2 745C?7235; 95D @64711C35;A 46 15I?36D =9C 3881;988D 152161C -E=963F E=929. 35 748?:5 95C$4B2=161746CA4B63;=2@16293535;242=19B461A93C @64@162D 4>1G16 @123234516 3A 745235?35; 24 477?@D 7?823G921 95C 15F4D 2=1 @1232345 @64@16231A =92 95 15I?36D ?@452=1 61@61A15292345 :9C1<D 2=1 @123234516 >9A35C11C745C?721C<D2=19=A38C96>=4=9CB46>96C1C 2=1 61@462 24 2=1 1@?2D 4::3AA34516 45 $))# 7921;4637988D @435235; 4?2 2=92 2=1 9B461A93C 895C >9A 463;35988D ?5C16 2=1 7?823G92345 4B 451 9CC1@@9 G9 - 4 - 35;9@@9 >=4 >9A 2=1 B92=16!35!89> 4B 2=1 @123234516 =16135 =1 A93C 61@462 98A4 35C37921C 2=161 <135; 54 61746CA9G9389<819A242=1<9A3A45>=37=-E=963FE=929. 1526D >9A :9C1 =1619B216 1@?2D 4::3AA34516 G3C1 74::?5379234545)")#=9CB?62=1679881C?@452=1 61A@45C152!9=A38C96 24 A?<:32 =3A 61@462 95C 4@35345 9A 24 2=1 619A45A 45 >=37= -E=963F E=929. 152631A >161 1BB1721C95C>=12=162=161>9A95D@64G3A345?5C1689>24 C18121 2=1 A9:1 =1 A93C 74::?53792345 >9A B46>96C1C 24 9=A38C96 9A B96 <97E 9A )")# 95C 54 B?62=16 972345=9A<11529E15352=3A61;96C * 123234516=9A2=1619B216:9C1961@61A15292345 45 )))# 9A >188 9A 9542=16 61@61A15292345 45 *$),) 95C 451 :461 61@61A15292345 45 )#$)) 24 2=1 1@?2D 4::3AA34516 95C 2=1 9=A38C96 ?2 54 972345=9A<11529E152388C921745A2693535;2=1@123234516 249@@6497=2=3A4?62 # 19651C CC3234598 4G165:152 CG47921 >=4 29E1A 542371 24 61A@45C152A A?<:32A 2=92 15I?36D =9A - 5 - 98619CD<115745C?721C95C2=11@?2D4::3AA34516=9A 79881CB462=1B?62=1661@462B64:2=19=A38C96>=37=3A35 @6471AA 3571 2=1 61746CA >32= 61A@172 24 2=1 <9A3A 45 >=37=2=1-E=963FE=929.=9A<115152161C3524961<135; 26971C 95C 2=92 >4?8C 29E1 A4:123:1 =1 A?<:32A 2=92 3B ;3G15 A4:123:1 9@@64@63921 46C16A >388 <1 @9AA1C 35 2=1 :92216198A4A?<:32A2=9235G31>4B2=1761923454B51> 298?E2=161746CA:3;=2<1132=16352=135;A?;?6298?E46 35 35C=95446 298?E A A445 9A 2=1 61746CA 961 26971C 9@@64@6392146C16A>388<1@9AA1C 196C16?A1C2=161746CA =161746CA35C379212=922=159:14B9571A246A 4B 2=1 @123234516 =9G1 <115 61B81721C 35 2=1 61G15?1 61746CA 95C 32 89A2 A244C 35 2=1 59:1 4B 9CC1@@9 G9 35;9@@9 , =1 74::?53792345A 92 551H?61! C921C $))#95C551H?61!C921C)")#1H7=95;1C <12>1152=11@?2D4::3AA3451695C9=A38C9635C37921 - 6 - 2=922=4?;=152631A-E=963FE=929.=9G1<115:9C1352=1 D196 $"*!$"# 2=161 961 54 61746CA 9G9389<81 35 2=3A :92216 24 9A7162935 95C 3C1523BD 2=1 619A45 B46 1BB17235; A?7=1526D " 1 2=92 9A 32 :9D A3571 2=1 1@?2D 4::3AA3451635=3A74::?53792345C921C)")#=9A 79881C ?@45 2=1 61A@45C152!9=A38C96 24 A?<:32 B?62=16 61@46295C352=183;=24BA?<:3AA345A:9C1<D2=1819651C CC32345984G165:152CG47921>32=61;96C2423:1<135; 29E15 24 269735; 4?2 4B 2=1 61746CA 2=3A 4?62 C11:A 32 9@@64@63921 24 C3A@4A1 4B 2=1 @1232345 C3617235; 2=1 61A@45C152!9?2=463231A241H@1C3212=1:92216 1A@45C152!9=A38C9624A?<:322=161@46224 2=1 AA3A2952 4::3AA34516 95C 1@?2D 4::3AA34516 61;96C35; 2=1 <9A3A 4B 1526D >32=35 2=611 :452=A >=4 2=1619B216A=988@9AA9@@64@6392146C16A4561@61A15292345 :9C1 <D 2=1 @123234516 >32=35 95 4?216 83:32 4B 2=611 :452=A B64: 2=1 C921 4B 61713@2 4B 71623B31C 74@D 4B 2=3A 46C16 - 7 - $) 7746C35;8D>632@12323453A )' &# #( % 3A24$84*