Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43171 (KAR)
ASHABEE AND ANR v. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE GOVT OF KARNATKA AND ORS
WA/200270/2024 · 2025-10-14
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43171 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$%"
#$%!%&! ""
'(
! "
#
$
%## ! & ' # (
#!#
'
# ! )
! )! !*+++
! ! ! $
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
##
,## ! ' (! '
## ! '
#
! &(! '
! '
+'
% #
! ! & '
! )
$- &(&(. (
## ) ! ! ) ! #'! )
!# !! */+
! ) )
! ! )
!0
#! *++# ! # ! ! */+ ! ! !'
) ! ! +/ ! )
! '#1/11*
!! ,
## ! ! ) '
! !! !2
! !# ! !2
'!!'
- 3 -
%$ &# !2
! !#(
34567786945:498;<=;8>8?@4A=A:6>=6@6B64C3 A<>@?@?36998=C4=C@38A>;8>;6@8;*++76558; DE986>=8;4=C98<;C84=#!A*/+;45F4558; @38G>4@78@4@4A=:498;DE@386778996=@78@4@4A=8>
38 ?658 A: @38 6778996=@5 45 @36@ @38 98C69 >87>858=@6@4H85 A: A=8 #88>56D G3A G65 @38 6D5A9<@8 AG=8> 4= 7A558554A= 6=; ?<9@4H6@4A= A: 96=; D86>4=C E!A F865<>4=C / 6?>85 54@<6@8; 6@ !6>8@696 #6;6 H4996C88;6F696D<>6C445@>4?@38>857A=;8=@!A 365 :498; 6= 67794?6@4A= <=;8> )A>F !A1 <=;8> 58?@4A= &(A:6=;8:A>F5?@588B4=C6=A??<76=?E>4C3@5 38 >4D<=69 DE A>;8> ;6@8; +// 365 699AG8; @38 67794?6@4A= :498; DE @38 @8=6=@6=;C>6=@8; 6= A??<76=?E >4C3@ 84=C 6CC>48H8; DE @38 564; @38 5 A: A>4C4=69 AG=8>486778996=@38>84=36H8:498;6G>4@78@4@4A=D8:A>8 @345 A<>@ 4= # !A*/*/*+ 38>8 45 6
- 4 -
4=A>;4=6@8 ;896E A: $+ E86>5 4= :494=C @38 G>4@ 78@4@4A= ?36998=C4=C@36@A>;8>76558;DE@386=;>4D<=69;6@8; +/ 86>=8; 4=C98 <;C8 DE A>;8> ;6@8;
+1+*+ 365 ?A=;A=8; @38 ;896E 699AG8; @38 G>4@ 78@4@4A=58@654;8@38A>;8>76558;DE6=;>4D<=69;6@8;
+/ 38 >898H6=@ 76>6C>673 !A5 * 6=; 1 G34?3>86;5@3<5
! " # $%&' ( )
*
+
" ,-* )
%+
*
& .$/' 0 - %& *& *
,
- 5 -
1 2%
-
. 3 4- 56,
7
3
*
$ 84=C 6CC>48H8; DE @38 56F8 @38 @8=6=@ 365 :498; 6 >4@ 77869 D8:A>8 @345 A<>@ 4= >4@ 77869 !A++*+ 4H454A= 8=?3 A: @345 A<>@ A= @3 8?8FD8>+ 365 699AG8; @38 677869 58@ 654;8 @38 A>;8> 76558; DE @38 986>=8; 4=C98 <;C8 >8F4@@8; @38 F6@@8> D6?B @A @38 986>=8; 4=C98 <;C8 >8I<85@4=C @A ?A=54;8>@38F6@@8>A:6:>85376556=677>A7>46@8A>;8>4= 6??A>;6=?8 G4@3 96G 4=?9<;4=C @38 7A4=@ A: ;896E 6=; 96@?38538>898H6=@76>6C>673!A+G34?3>86;5@3<5 ! 1
*
*
*
8
9 ,
,
- 6 -
*
*
: &;<& +
+ *
."
!3"/(2"/"#
+
*
*
8
!
=
8
*
:@8> @38 F6@@8> 365 D88= >8F4@@8; D6?B DE 4F7<C=8; A>;8> ;6@8; *++ @38 G>4@ 78@4@4A= 365 D88= ;45F4558; 38 986>=8; 4=C98 <;C8 365 ?A=54;8> @38 F6@@8> A= F8>4@ G4@3A<@ C4H4=C 6=E :4=;4=C >8C6>;4=C @38;896E6=;96@?3854=:494=C@38G>4@78@4@4A==574@8A:
@38>8456>8I<85@A:4H454A= 8=?3@A?A=54;8>@38F6@@8> 6:>8534=?9<;4=C@387A4=@A:;896E6=;96@?385
=@36@53A>@C>A<=;@38G>4@677869>8I<4>8; @AD8699AG8;6=;A>;8>;6@8;*++>8I<4>8;@A58@
- 7 -
654;8 ??A>;4=C9E >4@ 77869 45 699AG8; A>;8> ;6@8; *++76558;4=#!A*/+4558@654;8 * 38 F6@@8> 45 >8F4@@8; @A D6?B @38 986>=8; 4=C98<;C8@A>8?A=54;8>@38F6@@8>6578>86>948>A>;8> 76558; DE @345 A<>@ ;6@8; ++ 4= !A++*+
)* '"( %
)* '!%&!( %
# 45@!A9!A