Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43165 (KAR)

MARULASIDDESHWAR GRAMIN BHARATGAS v. THE TERRITORY MANAGER (LPG)

WP/202244/2025 · 2025-12-26

Ashok S Kinagi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#$ %#& '# ( ! " # $! ! % $ % && ' ((" )) # $ ! & % & ((* ((+ & & & ()+(( ! , (+(( ! , & Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & - ./0/121234/5627/81.29:5210/1212349//;24<63773:24< 05=>/5 ! " # $ ! % " # $ & ! ' ( )* + ( , - ( 52/6 6=?19 7/=824< 13529/ 13 1./ 62724< 1.29 :521 0/121234=5/=963773:9 ./ 5/90348/41 =003241/8 1./ 0/121234/5 =9 = 29152@A135 13 1./ =5/= 73?=1234 36 35/@=7 B277=</ 248.=4A5=7A;=2?.A5829152?1./5/90348/41299A/8 9.3: ?=A9/ 4312?/ 34 +*()+ 13 B/526> ?/51=24 21/C9 C/41234/8 24 1./ 4312?/ ./ 0/121234/5 5/072/8 13 1./ - 3 - 9.3: ?=A9/ 4312?/ 6A5429.24< =77 1./ 8/1=279 @> A073=824< 34 1./ 9>91/C @> ?3C07>24< 13 1./ ?3C072=4?/ 1/5C9 36 1./4312?/" 44/DA5/ 4(*()'1./0/121234/5 9A@C211/8 = 5/EA/91 13 9A007> ?>7248/59 13 219 =</4?> =9 0/51./31262?=1234" 44/DA5/&4)+*()'1./ 5/90348/41 9/41 =4 /C=27 13 1./ 0/121234/5 13 9A55/48/5 ?349AC/596=2724< :.2?. 829?20724=5> =?1234 :277 @/ 1=;/4 /4?/1./2C0A<4/8=?12342924B237=1234360524?207/936 4=1A5=7 FA912?/ =48 1./ 9=C/ 29 :21.3A1 =4> @=929 :21. 241/41234 13 .=5=99 1./ 0/121234/5 /4?/ 1./ 0/121234/5 627/8 1.29 :521 0/121234 ?.=77/4<24< 1./ 053?//824<9 36 1./ 5/90348/41 1=;24< 3B/5 1./ 829152@A1234 :21.3A1 <2B24< =4 300351A421>36@/24<./=58=48:21.3A10=9924<=4>358/5 6359A?.=?1234/4?/1.29:5210/121234 ./ 5/90348/41 627/8 91=1/C/41 36 3@F/?12349 ?341/4824<1.=11./:5210/121234627/8@>1./0/121234/529 431C=241=24=@7//21./5347=:35346=?19=481./9=C/29 72=@7/ 13 @/ 829C299/8 =1 1./ 1.5/9.378 1 29 =793 ?341/48/81.=11./0/121234/5.=98/72@/5=1/7>9A005/99/8 - 4 - 1./ C=1/52=7 6=?19 24?7A824< B=523A9 :=5424<9 =A821 5/03519 9.3:?=A9/ 4312?/9 =48 219 3:4 =8C2992349 5/<=5824< 624=4?2=7 =48 30/5=1234=7 255/<A7=5212/9 A?. ?348A?1829/41217/91./0/121234/5653C=4>829?5/1234=5>35 /EA21=@7/5/72/6129=793?341/48/81.=11./:5210/121234 24B37B/9 = 8290A1/8 EA/91234 36 6=?19 :.2?. 5/EA25/9 8/1=27/8 /D=C24=1234 36 83?AC/41=5> /B28/4?/ 24?7A824< =A82192490/?12345/?3589=481/912C342/9A?.8290A1/8 299A/9?=4431@/=8FA82?=1/824=:521053?//824<9=482129 =793 ?341/48/8 1.=1 1./ 0/121234/5 .=9 =4 /662?=?23A9 =71/54=12B/ 5/C/8> A48/5 1./ 1/5C9 36 29152@A12349.20 <5//C/418=1/8('))((:.2?.053B28/96355/85/99=7 C/?.=429C9 2/ 5@215=1234 =1 7=A9/ 3 36 1./ 29152@A12349.20 <5//C/41 8=1/8 ('))(( /D/?A1/8 @/1://41./0/121234/5=481./5/90348/41./0/121234/5 :21.3A1/D.=A9124<=71/54=12B//662?=?23A95/C/8>.=9627/8 1.29 :521 0/121234 /4?/ 05=>9 13 829C299 1./ :521 0/121234 - 5 - " /=58 1./ 7/=54/8 ?3A49/7 52 =B2485= /88> 635 1./ 0/121234/5 =48 52 =4/9. =7=@A5=<2 7/=54/8 ?3A49/76351./5/90348/41 /=54/8?3A49/76351./0/121234/5=61/5=5<A24< 1./C=11/563593C/12C/13=90/?262?EA/5>039/8@>1.29 3A511.=11./5/29=4/EA=7/662?=?23A95/C/8>29=B=27=@7/ =48:21.3A1/D.=A9124<1./9=C/1./0/121234/5627/81.29 :521 0/121234 &35 1.=1 1./ 7/=54/8 ?3A49/7 635 1./ 0/121234/593A<.1139/?A5/24915A?12349653C1./0/121234/5 13 :21.85=: 1./ :521 0/121234 =48 ./4?/ 1./ C=11/5 :=9 0=99/83B/5=1/5:./41./?=9/:=9?=77/83A18/9021/ 1./9=C/1./7/=54/8?3A49/76351./0/121234/55/C=24/8 A45/05/9/41/8 * 1 1.29 FA4?1A5/ 1./ 7/=54/8 ?3A49/7 635 1./ 5/90348/41 9A@C219 1.=1 26 1./5/ 29 =4> 8290A1/ 35 8266/5/4?/:.=193/B/5=52924<3A1363524?344/?1234:21. =4 =<5//C/41 1./ 0/121234/5 .=9 13 24B3;/ 7=A9/ 36 1./ 29152@A12349.20 <5//C/41 8=1/8 ('))(( / 6A51./5 9A@C219 1.=1 1./0/121234/5 :21.3A1 /D.=A9124< =4 - 6 - =71/54=12B//EA=7/662?=?23A95/C/8>627/81.29:5210/121234 /4?/ 1./ :521 0/121234 627/8 @> 1./ 0/121234/5 29 431 C=241=24=@7/=489//;913829C2991./:5210/121234 + /5A9/8 1./ 5/?3589 =48 ?34928/5/8 1./ 9A@C2992349361./7/=54/8?3A49/76351./0=512/9 ./ 5/90348/41 .=9 0538A?/8 1./ 29152@A12349.20 <5//C/41 8=1/8 ('))(( .=B/ 0/5A9/8 1./ ?341/419 36 1./ 29152@A12349.20 <5//C/41 :.2?. 053B28/9 =4 =5@215=1234 ?7=A9/ :.2?. 5/=89 =9 63773:9 %. # ! " # ( $ " ! !! ( ! ! ( " ! ! ( / 0 ! " 0 !! ( ! 1+2&3 (# - 7 - ( ( ( ( ( 0 # 4 0 ! 35 ! ! # - ' &53C1./0/5A9=7361./=@3B/=5@215=1234?7=A9/ =17=A9/321?7/=57>829?739/91.=126=4>8290A1/35 8266/5/4?/9:.=193/B/5=52924<3A1363524?344/?1234:21. 1./ =<5//C/41 24?7A824< =4> EA/91234 5/<=5824< 219 /D291/4?/B=72821>/1?1./9=C/9.=77@/5/6/55/813=48 624=77>5/937B/81.53A<.=5@215=123441./?=9/34.=48 1./ 5/90348/41 299A/8 = 9.3: ?=A9/ 4312?/ ?=7724< A034 1./ 0/121234/5 635 5/7/=9/ 36 ?344/?12349 @/734<24< 13 1./ 0/121234/5 ./ 0/121234/5 5/072/8 13 1./ 9.3: ?=A9/ 4312?/ ./ 8290A1/ =529/9 @/1://4 1./ 0/121234/5 =48 5/90348/4124?344/?1234:21. 29152@A12349.20<5//C/41 ./9=288290A1/9.=77@/5/937B/81.53A<.=4=5@215=1234 3:/B/5 1./ 0/121234/5 ./5/24 :21.3A1 /D.=A9124< 1./ - 8 - =71/54=12B/ /662?=?23A9 5/C/8> 2/ 1./ =5@215=1234 ?7=A9/ 3 627/8 1.29 :521 0/121234 ./5/635/ :21.3A1 <324< 24131./C/5219361./?=9/1.293A5129361./30242341.=1 1./:5210/121234627/8@>1./0/121234/529431C=241=24=@7/ ??35824<7>053?//8130=991./63773:24< 2% ./:5210/12123429 22% 2@/51>295/9/5B/8131./0/121234/513 24B3;/=5@215=1234?7=A9/26938/925/ 4 B2/: 36 829039=7 36 :521 0/121234 3( (( 83/9 431 9A5B2B/ 635 ?34928/5=1234 ??35824<7> 9=C/ 29 829039/836 )* ' ( & 2913)73'