- 1 - !"# $ %& $ %& "&#" $$ '#( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! " ! # $ % & % " '(( (% ) *+( *+( # $!!% ", % (-( & " " -$& " % " ! ('('( % ! '.% ! " % +( " "! ) - 3 - " " ! % / ! / ! !% & $ / ! & 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 -$& => <05 =<=: %501;652;<?++$05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32@<05;<A>=: 20=:<& 032 B558 >1659 BC <05 ;631D38<2 ;036658E18E <05 F79ED58< 389 3G3:9 93<59 ((( 432259 BC <05 581=: 1H16 !79E5 I 5DB5: '.% !5G3:E1 18 % +( "3;<2 E1H18E :125 <= <05 >1618E => <05 344536 B:15>6C 2<3<59 3:5 <03< =8 ( (( 3< 3B=7< +( 4D <05 95;53259=03DD593203J0=79:1G324:=;55918E=8 D=<=:;C;65 B53:18E :5E12<:3<1=8 =' '-- 058 05 :53;059 853: 16J =>>1;5 $52D5 >>1;5& =8 !5G3:E1' 363B7:3E1 D318 :=39 3< <03< <1D5 3 1445: B53:18E :5E12<:3<1=8=''((G01;0G32B518E9:1H58183 - 4 - :320 389 85E61E58< D3885: 58938E5:18E <= <05 07D38 61H52 ;3D5 >:=D B3;J 2195 389 932059 3E3182< <05 95;53259 2 3 :5276< => <05 3>=:52319 3;;1958< <05 95;53259 272<31859 E:15H=72 18F7:152 389 27;;7DB59 <= <0518F7:152 05 ;631D38<2 >1659 3 45<1<1=8 7895: 5;<1=8 => <05 ;< 255J18E ;=D45823<1=8 >=: <05 953<0 => <05 95;5325936=8EG1<018<5:52< 4=8 25:H1;5 => 8=<1;5 <05 :524=8958< =2 389 34453:59 <0:=7E0 ;=78256 389 >1659 G:1<<58 2<3<5D58< 958C18E<053H5:D58<2D39518<05;631D45<1<1=8 8 <05 B3212 => <05 4653918E2 => <05 43:<152 <05 631D2:1B7836>:3D59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <05 5H1958;5 05 :1B7836 BC 1D47E859 F79ED58< 389 3G3:903243:<6C366=G59<05;631D45<1<1=83890569<03< <05 ;631D38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 ;=D45823<1=8 => - 5 - 2 -? ('36=8EG1<018<5:52<3<<05:3<5=> K43 389 91:5;<59 <05 827:38;5 =D438C <= 954=21< <05 ;=D45823<1=8 3D=78< 36=8E G1<0 18<5:52< 518E 3EE:15H59<054:5258<344536032B558>1659 05653:859;=78256>=:<05;631D38<2032:31259<05 >=66=G18E;=8<58<1=82 3& "1:2<6C <05 ;631D38<2 3225:< <03< <05 95;53259 G32 3E593B=7<C53:23<<05<1D5=><053;;1958<3890393 38873618;=D5=>2(((('BC:78818E0=<56B7218522 389 9=18E 3E:1;76<7:5 =G5H5: <05 322522D58< => D=8<06C 18;=D5 => <05 95;53259 3< 2-' BC <05 :1B78361278F72<1>1593895::=85=72 B& 5;=896C 32 45: <05 63G 6319 9=G8 BC <05 =8AB65 74:5D5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => *$" + , ,- 18 ;3252 G05:5 <05 95;53259 G32 256>' 5D46=C59=::5;51H593>1L592363:C383991<1=8=>(K=> <05 52<3B612059 18;=D5 <=G3:92 @>7<7:5 4:=245;<2A 12 - 6 - G3::38<59 G058 <05 95;53259 G32 B56=G <05 3E5 => ( C53:205:1B7836032:1E0<6C3446159<0523194:18;146518 <054:5258<;325 ;& 01:96C3245:<05F79ED58<=><05=8AB6574:5D5 =7:<18<05;325=> .# + ! & ,! & ,! - 53;0 => <05 ;631D38<21258<1<659<=;=D45823<1=8=>2((('7895: <050539=>@6=22=>6=H53893>>5;<1=8389;=82=:<17DA 1<0 <05 3B=H5 ;=8<58<1=82 <05 653:859 ;=78256 2=7E0<<=366=G<05344536 - 8 <05 =<05: 0389 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 827:38;5 =D438C 032 :31259 <05 >=66=G18E ;=78<5:' ;=8<58<1=82 3& "1:2<6C 36<0=7E0 <05 ;631D38<2 ;631D <03< <05 95;53259 G32 53:818E 2((((' 45: 3887D <05C 03H5 >31659 <= 27B2<38<13<5 <051: ;631D G1<0 2744=:<18E 9=;7D58<2 =825M758<6C <05 :1B7836 032 ;=::5;<6C 32252259<0518;=D5=><0595;532598=<1=8366C - 7 - B& 5;=896C =8 344:5;13<1=8 => =:36 389 9=;7D58<3:C 5H1958;5 389 ;=82195:18E <05 3E5 389 3H=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 =H5:366 ;=D45823<1=8 3G3:959 BC <05 :1B783612F72<389:532=83B65 1<0 <05 3B=H5 ;=8<58<1=82 <05 653:859 ;=78256 2=7E0<<=912D122<05344536 + 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05F79ED58<3893G3:9=><05:1B7836 ? <128=<1891247<5<03<=03DD593203J0=79:1 9159 18 <05 :=39 <:3>>1; 3;;1958< =;;7::59 =8 ( (( 975<=:32038985E61E58<9:1H18E=><05=>>58918EH501;65 BC1<29:1H5: ( 05 ;631D38<2 ;631D <03< 95;53259 G32 53:818E 2(((('45:3887DB7<>31659<=4:=97;52744=:<18E 9=;7D58<2<=27B2<38<13<5<051:;631D8<053B258;5=> 4:==>=>18;=D5<058=<1=83618;=D5032<=B532252259 ;;=:918E<=<05E719561852122759BC<053:83<3J3<3<5 - 8 - 5E365:H1;527<0=:1<C>=:3;;1958<2=;;7::5918<05C53: (<058=<1=83618;=D5=><0595;5325920366B5<3J58 3<2('4D=<053>=:5231918;=D5<05:1B7836 032:1E0<6C39959(K>=:>7<7:54:=245;<218H15G=><05 63G 6319 9=G8 BC <05 =82<1<7<1=8 58;0 => <05 74:5D5 =7:< 18 /$" 0 $274:3& 072 <05 D=8<06C 18;=D5 ;=D52 <= 2??(' 18;5 <05:5 3:5 >1H5 95458958<21<12344:=4:13<5<=9597;<<0=><0518;=D5 =><0595;53259<=G3:9245:2=8365L458252389:5D31818E 3D=78<032<=B5<3J5832012;=8<:1B7<1=8<=<05>3D16C 0595;53259G323E593B=7<C53:23<<05<1D5=><05 3;;1958<389D76<14615:34461;3B65<=0123E5E:=7412@ A 072 <05 ;631D38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=D45823<1=8 => 1 !, !2 $2??(NN N& =8 3;;=78< => @6=22=>95458958;CA 8 3991<1=8 <05 ;631D38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=D45823<1=8 => 1 2 =8 3;;=78< => @6=22 => 52<3<5A 389 ;=D45823<1=8 => 1 2 =8 3;;=78< => - 9 - @>785:365L458252A631D38<=G1>5=><0595;5325912 58<1<659>=:;=D45823<1=8=>13327895:<050539 =>/6=22=>24=7236;=82=:<17D/ 8H15G=><0563G63199=G8BC<0574:5D5=7:<18 <05 ;325 => / 0 $274:3& ;631D38< =2 389 ;0169:58 => <05 95;53259 3:5 58<1<659>=:;=D45823<1=8=>133253;07895:<05 0539=>@6=22=>43:58<36;=82=:<17DA389;631D38<=2' D=<05: => <05 95;53259 12 58<1<659 >=: ;=D45823<1=8 => 1332 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => @6=22 => >16136 ;=82=:<17DA 072 <05 ;631D38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= <05 >=66=G18E ;=D45823<1=8 4567189:7;7<6= <:6=67968<1 >=:?;78@ >A:1 ;=9 =22=>95458958;C ? ( +-+(( "785:365L458252 ((( (( =22=>52<3<5 ((( (( - 10 - =22=>24=7236;=82=:<17D ((( ((( =22=>3:58<36;=82=:<17D -((( ((( =22=>"16136;=82=:<17D ((( ((( 98@ 3 , ! 8<05:5276<<05>=66=G18E=:95:12432259 3& 05344536128@@B6<:758=9 B& 05F79ED58<=><05631D2:1B783612D=91>159 ;& 05;631D38<23:558<1<659<=3<=<36;=D45823<1=8=> 1 !2323E3182<2 -? ('3G3:959 BC<05:1B7836 9& 05 827:38;5 =D438C 12 91:5;<59 <= 954=21< <05;=D45823<1=83D=78<36=8EG1<018<5:52<3< K 43 >:=D <05 93<5 => >1618E => <05 ;631D 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361O3<1=8 G1<018 3 45:1=9=>21LG55J2>:=D<0593<5=>:5;514<=>3 ;=4C=><012F79ED58< - 11 - 5& 05 344=:<1=8D58< 954=21< 389 :565325 => 3D=78< 20366 B5 D395 18 3;;=:938;5 G1<0 <05 <5:D2=><053G3:9=><05:1B7836 <2 '$ ( & <2 '"&#"( & 12<=6=-