Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43159 (KAR)

SHRI. ISHWAR AND ANR v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/203132/2023 · 2025-09-23

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $" % %!"" &' !" # !" $ % & & ' & !" !" & & !" $ % ( ) ( ' Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ( *+ ,-./-.0-1234567183,097:70-0-357,6.5;,-.19., .3 .135< =-09 ,-.11->.,?45 .94>., 83, 097 ,76:35;7506.::7.,7;-5:7,635 97 ,-0 70-0-35 -6 8-17; 677>-5< 097 83113=-5< ,71-786 .' 3 -6647 . =,-0 38 7,0-3,.,- 3, . ;-,720-35 03 @4.69 097 3,;7, ;.07; "#" -5 -17 3& " "! !## :.667; AB0978-,60,76:35;750.4093,-0B.6-117<.1.5; .,A-0,.,B/-;7 557C4,7 A' 3 -6647 . =,-0 38 .5;.D46 ;-,720-5< ,76:35;7506.5;53003;717070975.D738 097 :70-0-357,6 -5 ,76:720 38 B3 % E E' D7.64,-5< " 2,7 " 450.6 6-04.07; .0 D.1.:4, &-11.<7 .14>. .5; -60,-20-;., - 3 - 97:70-0-35./7,D7506.,709767 0 -6 60.07; 09.0 097 8-,60 :70-0-357, =.6 -6647; =-09 *+ 3,D 45;7, 3,D 3 -5 ,76:720 38 097 :3,0-35 38 1.5; -5 B3 D7.64,-5< " 2,7 " 450.6 A7-5< .66-<57; =-09 -66.36-527097B=7,7-50972410-/.0-35380976.D797 1.5;-5B3030.11BD7.64,-5<F 2,76"!450.6=.6 3,-<-5.11B 3/7,5D750 .,.D:93> .5; .5; 097,7 =.6 . ,787,7527 03 097 :7,6356 A7135<-5< 03 097 297;417; .607 23DD45-0B-52410-/.0-35380976.-;1.5;83,.135<0-D7.6:7, 097,7:3,0380977/754756:7203,.5;572766.,B750,-76=7,7 D.;7-5097:7,0.-5-5<030971.5;6-527F F0-11FF F! 4,64.50 03 097 -664.527 38 3,D 097 5.D7 38 097 :70-0-357,6.,7;41B,7817207;-5097,7/7547,723,;6:7,0.-5-5< 030971.5;A7.,-5<B3D7.64,-5<03.57C075038" 2,7 "450.68,3DFF!F35=.,;6 0 -6 6.-; 09.0 097,7 =.6 . ,7@4-,7D750 83, 097 760.A1-69D750 38 . 3/7,5D750 29331 .0 D.1.:4, &-11.<7 7527 097 ;;-0-35.1 7:40B 3DD-66-357, 9.; 634<90 -583,D.0-358,3D0977:40B3567,/.03,383,760677>-5<097 572766.,B -583,D.0-35 ,7<.,;-5< 1.5; -5 B3 D7.64,-5< - 4 - F 2,76"!450.638 D.1.:4,&-11.<7/-;723,,76:35;7527 ;.07;""".5;-5,76:3567030976.-;17007,097388-27 38 097 09-,; ,76:35;750 -6647; 21.,-8-2.0-35 09.0 097 1.5; -5 B3 -6 57-097, . 530-8-7; 53, . ,767,/7; 83,760 45;7, 720-35!380973,760 2053,-6-0.;77D7;83,760G93=7/7, -0-6.*+.5;*+21.661.5;A7-5<0,.5687,,7;AB0977/7547 7:.,0D750-58./3,380973,7607:.,0D750 97 :70-0-357,6 235075; 09.0 097B =7,7 -6647; =-09 . 530-27AB097388-27380978-,60,76:35;750A.67;35097.117<7; ,7:3,0 ,727-/7; AB 097 09-,; ,76:35;750 ,7<.,;-5< 097 .117<7; 752,3.29D750 .5; 097 6.D7 A7-5< 097 ;77D7; 83,760 .6 097 .96-1;., -;., 9.5;7; 3/7, 097 6.-; 1.5; 03 097 3,760 7:.,0D750/-;717007,;.07;" FF.5;097,783,7634<90 03235;420.5-5@4-,B97:70-0-357,64AD-007;.11097,723,;6 :7,0.-5-5< 03 097 1.5; .5; 634<90 03 ;,3: 097 :,3277;-5<6 3=7/7, 097 09-,; ,76:35;750 8-17; .53A?720-35 ,71B-5< 4:35 097 1-60 38 *+ .5; *+ 1.5;6 634<90 03 A7 0,.5687,,7; AB 097 .96-1;., -5 8./3, 38 097 3,760 7:.,0D750 .67; 35 097 2350750-35 ,.-67; AB 097 09-,; ,76:35;750 097 66-60.50 3DD-66-357, :,3277;7; 03 931; 09.0 097 .96-1;., 9.; 53 - 5 - .4093,-0B 03 -6647 097 3,;7, 38 <,.50 AB 235075;-5< 09.0 097 1.5;A7-5<1.66*+.5;*+452410-/.A171.5;.5;0976.D7=.6 9.5;7; 3/7, 03 097 3,760 7:.,0D750 -5 FF 0 -6 .163 3A67,/7; 09.0 097 64A?720 1.5; 8.116 =-09-5 " >D6 ,.;-46 38 -;., 45-2-:.1 -D-06 97527 <,.50 D.;7 AB 097 .96-1;., -6 2350,.,B 03 417 " %-/' 38 097 (.,5.0.>. .5; ,.50 4176 F#F.5;:,3277;7;03931;09.009764A?7201.5;-60973,760 .5;.5;530.7/7547.5;.5;097:,3/-6-35638(.,5.0.>. .5;,.504176.,7530.::1-2.A17.5;670.6-;70973,;7,38 .96-1;., -664-5< 3,D .5; 097 6.D7 =.6 2.527117; .5; ;-,7207;0971.5;03A7,764D7;.5;/7607;-50973/7,5D750 8,778,3D.117524DA,.5276AB;-,720-5<097.96-1;.,03D.>7 750,-76 -5 097 .6 H3,760 7:.,0D750 3/7,5D750 38 (.,5.0.>.+ -5 933D- 380=.,7 /-;7 3,;7, ;.07; "#" 5;7,097672-,24D60.5276097:70-0-357,-6A783,709-634,0 ! 345671 83, 097 ,76:720-/7 :.,0-76 4,<7; 67/7,.1 2350750-356 ,<-5< 67/7,.1 2350750-356 2345671 83, 097 :70-0-357, :1.27;,71-.52735097;72-6-35-5 - 6 - & ( -5 3"""F " ;-6:367; 3835!"" 97 60.07D750 38 3A?720-356 -6 8-17; AB 097 3/7,5D750 ,<-5<67/7,.12350750-3560973/7,5D750:1.27;,71-.52735 09783113=-5<;72-6-356 ' ( ( & & I & "F" FF# ' & & I %&' FF# FF# ' & & I"! 7.,; 097 .,<4D7506 .5; :7,467; 097 ,-0 :.:7,6 =-09 2.,7 97 8.206 .,7 6488-2-7501B 6.-; .5; ;3 530 ,7@4-,7 ,7-07,.0-3597-6647,7/31/76.,345;0977C7,2-6738097:3=7, AB 097 66-60.50 3DD-66-357, 45;7, 097 :,3/-6-356 38 097 (.,5.0.>..5;7/7547 20F#!488-27-003530709.0097 1.5; -5 B3 D7.64,-5< F 2,76 "! 450.6 6-04.07; .0 - 7 - D.1.:4,&-11.<7=.6.3/7,5D750.,.D:93>.5;.5;097 6.D7 =.6 45;7, 2410-/.0-35 38 45.4093,-J7; :7,6356 5;7, . 30-8-2.0-353F;.07;F"FF097.9.6-1;., -6647;.7,0-8-2.0738.<4/.1-9-0 0-6.,<47;35A79.18380973/7,5D75009.00971.5;-5 @4760-35-61.66*+.5;*+452410-/.A171.5;.5;097.96-1;., /-;717007," FF0,.5687,,7;.5;9.5;7;3/7,0971.5;03 0973,7607:.,0D7500-6.,<47;35A79.1838097:70-0-357, 09.0 097 1.5; -5 B3 -6 57-097, . 530-8-7; 53, . ,767,/7; 83,760 45;7, 720-35 ! 38 097 3,760 20 53, -6 -0 . ;77D7; 83,760 35 -560,420-35 64AD-06 09.0 30-8-2.0-35 45;7, 720-35!-6530-6647;-5,76:720381.5;66-04.07;.0 D.1.:4, &-11.<7 <,7.0;7.138.,<4D750-6.;;,7667;.A3406720-35!38 0973,760 2097>7B.6:720638097.,<4D750.,77C.D-57; 720-35 ! 38 097 3,760 20 ;7.16 =-09 530-8-2.0-35 AB 097 <3/7,5D750.5;-0,7.;6.683113=6 720-35!30-8-2.0-35AB3/7,5D750I%'9757/7,-0 9.6A775;72-;7;0323560-0407.5B1.5;.,767,/7;83,760097 0.073/7,5D75069.11-6647.530-8-2.0-35 - 8 - %.' ;721.,-5< 09.0 -0 9.6 A775;72-;7; 0323560-0407 64291.5;.,767,/7;83,760G %A' 6:72-8B-5< .6 57.,1B .6 :366-A17 097 6-04.0-35 .5;1-D-063864291.5;G.5; %2' .::3-50-5< .5 388-27, %97,7-5.807, 2.117; 097 K3,760 70017D750 88-27,L' 03 -5@4-,7 -503 .5; ;707,D-57 097 7C-607527 5.04,7 .5; 7C0750 38 .5B ,-<906 21.-D7; AB 3, .117<7; 03 7C-60 -5 8./34, 38 .5B :7,635 -5 3, 3/7, .5B 1.5; 23D:,-67; =-09-5 6429 1-D-06 3, -5 3, 3/7, .5B 83,760 :,3;427 .5; 03 ;7.1 =-09 097 6.D7 .6 :,3/-;7;-509-69.:07, %' 97 388-27, .::3-507; 45;7, 21.467 %2' 38 64A 6720-35 %' 69.11 A7 . :7,635 530 931;-5< .5B 83,760 388-27 7C27:0 09.0 38 3,760 70017D750 88-27,GA40.3,76088-27,D.BA7.::3-507;AB 097 0.07 3/7,5D750 03 ,7:,76750 -0 -5 097 -5@4-,B 45;7, 09-6 9.:07, AB 097 3,760 70017D75088-27, - 9 - 97 3/7,5D750 9.6 :1.27; ,71-.527 35 . 60.07D750 693=-5< 097 ,7D.-5-5< *+ .5; *+ 1.66 1.5; %3/7,5D750 .5;' 0,.5687,,7; 03 097 3,760 7:.,0D750 38 .14>. -;., 6-<57; AB 097 .96-1;., 35 " FF 03 235075; 09.0 097 83,7601.5;2341;5309./7A775<,.507;030978-,60:70-0-357, .<4/.1-9-02341;5309./7A775-6647;-5,76:72038.83,760 1.5;972350750-35380973/7,5D75009.0-0+6.83,7601.5; 2.5530A76460.-57;.6-0-6:-/30.103530709.00973,760 20 9.6 23D7 -503 83,27 -5 F# 93=7/7, -5 097 .A67527 38 . 530-8-2.0-35 45;7, 720-35 ! 38 097 (.,5.0.>. 3,760 20 097 .96-1;., .::7.,6 03 9./7 :,7:.,7; . 60.07D750 09.0 097 64A?720 1.5; 9.6 A775 0,.5687,,7; 03 097 3,760 7:.,0D750 77;1766 03 6.B 097 3,760 20 D.5;.076 -664.527 38 . 30-8-2.0-3545;7,720-35! 6.1,7.;B5307;.A3/7097,7-6 53 30-8-2.0-35 45;7, 720-35 ! 38 097 (.,5.0.>. 3,760 20 F#97,783,70972350750-35380973/7,5D75009.0-0-6. 83,7601.5;D460572766.,-1B8.-1 # 7C0 170 D7 2356-;7, =97097, 097 66-60.50 3DD-66-357,2341;9./75411-8-7;0973,D.807,.1.:6738 .1D360 0=750B5-57 B7.,6 97 .56=7, -6 53 97 ,7.635 -6 - 10 - 6-D:17 97 1.= -6 =711 670017; 09.0 097 :3=7, D460 A7 7C7,2-67;=-09-5.,7.635.A170-D75097:,767502.67097,7 -6.5-53,;-5.07;71.B5DB/-7=097:,3277;-5<6.,7217.,1B A.,,7;AB1.29764,097,D3,70973/7,5D7502341;5309./7 7C7,2-67;:3=7,032.5271097<,.50635097<,345;09.0097,7 -6 . /-31.0-35 38 417 " 38 097 (.,5.0.>. .5; 7/7547 4176 34567183,097,76:720-/7:.,0-76:1.27;,71-.52735097 ;72-6-356 ,787,,7; 03 64:,. ;3 530 09-5> 09.0 097 1.= -6 -5 ;34A0.29;72-6-3504,5635-063=58.20697:,767502.67-6 .16307607;-50971-<9038097.83,76.-;;72-6-356 3,097,7.635660.07;.A3/70973,;7,38097 66-60.50 3DD-66-357, -6 1-.A17 03 A7 670 .6-;7 223,;-5<1B -0 -6 670 .6-;7 97 ,-0 38 7,0-3,.,- -6 3,;7,7; 97 ,;7, ;.07; "#" :.667; AB 097 66-60.50 3DD-66-357, -5 -17 3 & " "! !##/-;7 557C4,7-6@4.697; 76410.501B097,-070-0-35-6 - 11 - 72.467 38 097 ;-6:36.1 38 097 ,-0 70-0-35 :75;-5< -507,132403,B .::1-2.0-356 -8 .5B .,7 ;-6:367; 38 .5; 097 -507,-D;-,720-35-8.5B60.5;6;-629.,<7; () &%!""' % ( -60313