- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %&' ( ! " # $$ $%& '$$ ( ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $$ $$ # $ ( %&%*+) $%&! # $%& ( %&%,) $- $%&! '$ ( . $ $ . +! , $ ) +() $ $ %- $ !+! !%!%!* $ $ $ $ $ $$ # $$ " - 3 - " / $ / $ ($" / ) 0123445361278905:631;3<92255=1<>5<03<:5;5<9 ?@:?;45<2391?<3A121<>?B9?@CBD>;5<93<D3E3ADD395D !!!* 1< ?!+! 43225D 78 905 DD191?<365<1?A1F16BD>53<D%- 391C3834BA3 (@?A20?A9G905A17B<36H) 05 D395 ?@ 3::1D5<9 1<F?6F5;5<9 ?@ F501:65 D5390 ?@ 7732361 ? ;3;2375;703F1 3<D 613716198 9? 438905:?;45<2391?<3A5<?91<D124B9505?<68D124B95 121<A5245:9?@IB3<9B;?@:?;45<2391?< 53ADA137B593>BDD3653A<5D:?B<256 34453A1<> @?A905 3445663<92 J :631;3<92 A1 B>B291< 653A<5D :?B<256 34453A1<> @?A 905 A524?<D5<9 ? % <195D <D13 <2BA3<:5 ?;43<8 3<D ;9 $A5591 $3916 56=B<D1653<5D:?B<25634453A1<>@?AA524?<D5<9 ?J - 4 - A15<936 <2BA3<:5 ?;43<8 1;195D 1D5 ?AD5A D395D +!<?91:5?@90123445361<A5245:9?@A524?<D5<9 ?23<D12D1245<25DE190 A1 37B 593>BDD3 E190 366 F505;5<:5 2B7;1995D9039905D395?@3::1D5<9E32!05 D5:5325D E32 03F1<> 63<D2 3<D 53A<1<> 3 2B; ?@ 2!!!!%45A;?<90<91;568D5390?@D5:5325D03D >1F5< 3 25A1?B2 76?E 9? 905 @1<3<:136 :343:198 ?@ 905 3;168 32 D5:5325D E32 905 2?65 7A53D E1<<5A 3<D 905 5<91A5@3;16812B<D5A@1<3<:136:A121205A17B<3690?B>0 3E3AD5D :?;45<2391?< 93=1<> 1<9? :?<21D5A391?< 905 ;B6914615A ?@ GH 3<D D5DB:91<> 90 9?E3AD2 45A2?<36 5K45<252 ?@ D5:5325D 0?E5F5A 93=5< 905 1<:?;5 39 2+!!!% 4; B9 32 45A 905 03A9 4A543A5D 78 905 3A<393=3 9395 5>36 5AF1:52 B90?A198 3 2B; ?@ 2&!!!%4;12@1K5D@?A905853A!05D5:5325D E323>5D759E55<9?853A222B:0L?B>099? 03F5755<3DD5D9?E3AD26?22?@@B9BA54A?245:92?362? 905:?;45<2391?<3E3AD5DB<D5A905:?<F5<91?<36053D2 - 5 - 43A91:B63A68 @16136 :?<2?A91B; 12 ?< 905 6?E5A 21D5 E01:0 A5IB1A52A5%:?<21D5A391?< A1 37B 593>BDD3 @BA905A 2B7;1995D 9039 905 A17B<36 032 <?9 3E3AD5D !L 52:36391?< @A?; 905 853A!+@?A53:0:?;46595D45A1?D?@90A55853A2?<905 :?;45<2391?<3E3AD5DB<D5A905:?<F5<91?<36053D205 3::1D5<91<905:325?<03<D?::BAA5D1<905853A!2 2B:0 905 3445663<92:631;3<92 3A5 5<91965D @?A 9E? 95A;2 ?@90A55853A253:0B<D5A905053D!L52:36391?<?<905 :?<F5<91?<36 053D2 3<D 3::?AD1<>68 2?B>09 9? 366?E 905 3445363<D5<03<:5905:?;45<2391?< 5@B91<> 905 2B7;1221?< ?@ 653A<5D :?B<256 @?A 9053445663<92J:631;3<92A1B>B291<3<D;9$A5591 $3916 56=B<D1 653A<5D :?B<256 34453A1<> @?A A524?<D5<9 ?23<DA5245:91F568F505;5<9682B7;1995D9039905 A17B<36 1< 905 3725<:5 ?@ 3<8 1<:?;5 4A??@ 4A?45A68 93=5< 905 1<:?;5 ?@ D5:5325D 39 2+!!!% 4; 05 :?;45<2391?<3E3AD5D78905A17B<36B<D5A366905053D2 12CB293<D4A?45A22B:0<?1<95A@5A5<:512:3665D@?A39 - 6 - 90503<D2?@9012?BA93<D3::?AD1<>682?B>099?D12;122 905344536 + 3F1<> 053AD 905 653A<5D :?B<256 @?A 905 43A9152 45AB25D 905 5<91A5 344536 4345A2 905 ?<68 4?1<9 9039E?B6D3A125@?A?BA:?<21D5A391?<12" 05905A 905 :?;45<2391?< 3E3AD5D 78 905 A17B<36 75@19 E1901< 905 5K4A5221?< GCB29:?;45<2391?<HM & BA 3<2E5A 9? 905 37?F5 4?1<9 12 1< 43A968 3@@1A;391F5@?A905@?66?E1<>" 9 12<?9 1<D124B959039 905 3::1D5<9 1< 905 :325?< 03<D 03D ?::BAA5D ?< ! 2 45A 905 1<:?;5 @1K5D @?A 905 853A ! 3::?AD1<> 9? 905 03A94A543A5D 789053A<393=35>365AF1:52B90?A19812392&!!!% 4; 1<2?@3A 32 B<2=1665D 637?BA < 905 3725<:5 ?@ 3<8 4A??@ ?@ 1<:?;5 905 A17B<36 ?B>09 9? 03F5 93=5< 905 ;?<9068 1<:?;5 @1K5D 78 905 3A<393=3 9395 5>36 - 7 - 5AF1:52B90?A198392&!!!%1<2953D?@2+!!!%2 45A905A5:?AD2D5:5325DE32759E55<3>5D759E55< 9?853A2 <95A;2?@90563E631DD?E<78905?<H765 45K?BA91<905:325?@ L ?B>09 9? 03F5 755< 3DD5D 9? 9052363A8?@D5:5325D9?E3AD2@B9BA54A?245:92 BA905A 905A17B<36032@3165D9?3E3AD344A?4A1395:?;45<2391?< B<D5A905053D6?22?@24?B23632E56632@16136:?<2?A91B; 32 905A5 E5A5 @?BA :631;3<92 3<D 53:0 3A5 5<91965D @?A 2!!!!%B<D5A905053D6?22?@24?B23632E56632@16136 :?<2?A91B; * <F15E?@9051<:?;529395D3<D?<A5% D595A;1<391?< 905 G?22 ?@ 545<D5<:8H E?A=2 ?B9 32 @?66?E2" 2&!!!%NLKKKO2!!!!% ! 245A905CBD>;5<9?@905?<H76545K?BA9 1< 905 :325 905 :631;3<92 3A5 1 - 8 - 5<91965D 9? 2!!!!% 53:0 B<D5A 905 053D ?@ G?22 ?@ 24?B236 ?<2?A91B; 3<D 16136 ?<2?A91B;H ::?AD1<>68 905 3445663<92:631;3<92 3A5 5<91965D @?A 3 2B; ?@ 2!!!!% (2!!!! K ) 9?E3AD2 ?22 @ 24?B236 ?<2?A91B;1<:6BD1<>?22 @ 16136?<2?A91B; BA905A 3 :?;45<2391?< ?@ 2!!!% 53:0 12 3E3AD5D B<D5A 905 053D G?22 @ 29395H <D G B<5A36 5K45<252<DA3<24?A9391?<H BA905A1<F15E?@905CBD>;5<9?@905?<H765 45K ?BA9 1< 905 :325 ?@ ! "# $ !% ! ! 905A5 20366 75 5<03<:5;5<9 ?@ !L ?< 905 :?<F5<91?<36053D2@?A5F5A890A55853A2 <905:325?< 03<D 905 3::1D5<9 ?::BAA5D 1< ! 05A5@?A5 905 :631;3<92 3A5 5<91965D @?A !L 52:36391?< ?@ 53:0 :?;46595D 90A55 853A2 @?A 9E? 95A;2 @A?; !+ ?< 905 (!)++ - 9 - :?<F5<91?<36 053D2 15 2!!!!% (2!!!! N !!!N!!!O2*!!!!K!L) 0B2?<A5%D595A;1<391?<3<DA5%:?<21D5A391?< 905 3445663<92:631;3<92 3A5 5<91965D @?A 9?936 :?;45<2391?<32@?66?E2" )*+,-./)0,*120 .301 ?22?@545<D5<:8 2 !!!!% ?22?@29395 2 !!!% ?22?@ B<5A36K45<252 2 !!!% ?22 ?@ ?<2?A91B; 3<D 16136 ?<2?A91B;(2!!!!K) 2 !!!!% !L 52:36391?< @?A 53:0 :?;46595D 90A55 853A2 ?@ 9E? 95A;2 B<D5A 905 :?<F5<91?<36 053D2 P2!!!! N !!! N !!!K!LQ 2 &!!!% , 45 05 9?936 :?;45<2391?< A5%D595A;1<5D 78 9012 ?BA9 E?A=2 ?B9 9? 2&&!!!% 32 3>31<29 2&!!!% 3E3AD5D 78 905 A17B<36 05 A5% D595A;1<5D:?;45<2391?<20366:3AA81<95A52939905A395?@ L 45A 3<<B; @A?; 905 D395 ?@ @161<> ?@ 905 459191?< 9166 - 10 - A5361R391?<::?AD1<>684?1<9 ?123<2E5A5D43A9681< 3@@1A;391F5 ?A905@?A5>?1<>A532?<29012?BA94A?:55D9? 4322905@?66?E1<>" 1) 0534453612366?E5D1<43A9. 11) 05CBD>;5<93<D3E3ADD395D!!!* 43225D 78 905 DD191?<36 5<1?A 1F16 BD>5 3<D %- 1C3834BA3 1< ?!+!1205A578;?D1@15D. 111) 053445663<92:631;3<923A55<91965D@?A3 9?936 :?;45<2391?< ?@ 2&!!!!% 32 3>31<292&!!!%36?<>E1901<95A52939 L45A3<<B;@A?;905D395?@@161<>?@905 459191?<9166A5361R391?<. 1F) 05 A524?<D5<9 ? J <2BA3<:5 :?;43<8 20366 D54?219 905 5<91A5 A5%D595A;1<5D - 11 - :?;45<2391?< 3;?B<9 36?<> E190 3::AB5D 1<95A529 29395D 75@?A5 905 :?<:5A<5D A17B<36 E1901< 3 45A1?D ?@ 21K E55=2 @A?; 905D395?@A5:5149?@:?48?@9012?AD5A. F) 44?A91?<;5<9 3<D D127BA25;5<9 12 32 45A 905?AD5A?@905A17B<36. F1) ??AD5A329?:?29 +5 %" ' $ +5 %' $ 129 ?"6 ?" "