Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43142 (KAR)
MAHABUBBI v. SADDAM AND ANR
MFA/201528/2022 · 2025-10-14
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43142 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43142 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ $$
%&'
(
!"#" $
%
&
"
'
( )"&
!"#"
(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
!"#" $
% ' (*
"&
' ' ")+%"& '
' ("#(#("
'
,
"#" (#"
'
-
#
" ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 ( 3<8/==./><8:<>.1;?23.@>/<6/72/4/<78223. A5146.72 /71 /B/01 1/2.1 ("#(#(" =/88.1 ;? 23. 11<2<97/>.7<90<C<>514./71<A/?/=50/ D:90 83902 E0<;57/>FG <7
9"#" (#" 8..H<74 .73/7@.6.729:@96=.78/2<97
- 3 -
+
3. :/@28 9: 23. @/8. /0. 23/2 23. /==.>>/72 @>/<6/72 6.2 B<23 / 09/1 20/::<@ /@@<1.72 97 ""# (#" B3.783.B/8=09@..1<74/8/=<>><970<1.097/69290@?@>. ;./0<74
9( )" 0.85>2<74 <7 <7A50<.8 29 23. @>/<6/72 2 <8 23. @/8. 9: 23. @>/<6/72 23/2 239543 83. B/8 20./2.1 /8 <7=/2<.72 2<>> ( # (#" /71 8=.72 354. /69572 :90 20./26.72 83. 85::.0.1 =.06/7.72 =3?8<@/> 1<8/;<><2? 3.7@. 83. :<>.1 @>/<6 =.2<2<97 ;.:90. 23. 0<;57/> @>/<6<74 @96=.78/2<97 9: 8(#### @972.71<74 23/2 83. B/8 /4.1 ?./08 /2 23. 2<6. 9:
/@@<1.72 /71 ;? 19<74 99><. B90H 83. B/8 ./07<74 8"#### =.0 69723 3. 0<;57/> @978<1.0<74 23. .72<0.6/2.0</>8/C/<>/;>.970.@9013/1/B/01.1/8569: 8"()#( B<23 <72.0.82 /2 !I =.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<97 2<>> 0./><J/2<97 /71 1<0.@2.1 0.8=971.72 9(7850/7@.96=/7?29=/?23.@96=.78/2<97
440<.C.1 ;? 23. 8/<1 A5146.72 23. <7A50.1 @>/<6/72 3/8 =0.:.00.1 23<8 /==./> <7 B3<@3 <2 <8 @972.71.1 23/2 239543 23. @>/<6/72 82/2.1 23/2 83. B/8
- 4 -
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
23. @96=.78/2<97/B/01.1;?23.0<;57/><8A582/71=09=.0 /717..1879<72.0:.0.7@. ! 16<22.1>? <2 <8 23. @/8. 9: 23. 1<8/;<><2? 85::.0.1 ;? 23. @>/<6/72 <7 / 09/1 20/::<@ /@@<1.72 3. @>/<6/72 82/2.8 23/2 83. B/8 ./07<74 8"#### =.0 69723/7123.0<;57/>3/82/H.78 ### 52/823. /@@<1.72<89:23.?./0(#" /8=.023.@3/02<885.1;?23. - 5 -
/07/2/H/ 2/2. .4/> .0C<@.8 52390<2? 23<8 9502 1..68 <2 /==09=0</2. 29 0./88.88 23. <7@96. 9: 23. @>/<6/72/28"")# =.069723 ) 8=.0K,9571.02<:<@/2.<885.1;?( 9@290 23. @>/<6/72 3/8 8582/<7.1 +#I 1<8/;<><2? ;52
23. 0<;57/> /88.88.1 B39>. ;91? 1<8/;<><2? /2 I 1<8/;<><2? 3. @>/<6/72 8582/<7.1 @52 >/@.0/2.1 B9571 9C.0 0<432 9@@<=<2/> 0.4<97 /71 @/7 9: ;0/<7 839B8 85;150/>3.69003/4<@/71@97258<979::0972/>>9;.B3<@3 /0. 40<.C958 <7 7/250. 8 =.0 <8/;<><2? .02<:<@/2. 23. ( 3/8 9;8.0C.1 23/2
23.
@>/<6/72 3/8 >982 @97@.720/2<97 83. 3/8 >.88 6.690? 23.0.:90. (#I 1<8/;<><2? 9: 3.0 7.509>94<@/> @971<2<97 /71 />89 23/2 83. 3/82<74><74/71756;7.8883.3/8B./H7.88/7157/;>. 29 ><:2 /7? 2?=. 9: B.<432 23.0.:90. 1<8/;<><2? 9: "#I 7.509>94? @971<2<97 3. 0<;57/> 3/8 2/H.7 B39>. ;91? 1<8/;<><2?/2I9723.409571(3/87.C.020./2.123. @>/<6/72 /71 3. <8 792 /
.5097 504.97 29 /88.88 23. 1<8/;<><2?9:7.509>94<@/>@971<2<97
- 6 -
978<1.0<74 23. 7/250. 9: <7A50<.8 =.0<91 9: 398=<2/> /71 923.0 :/@28 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 0./88.88 :57@2<97/> 1<8/;<><2? /2 " + 9: +#I /88.88.1 ;? 23. 9@290 B3<@3 @96.8 29 "#I @@901<74>? 23. @>/<6/72<8.72<2>.1:90>9889::5250../07<74/8571.0 8"")# K"(K"K"#IL8")##
16<22.1>? 23. @>/<6/72 B/8 20./2.1 /8 <7=/2<.72 <7 23. 398=<2/> /71 571.0497. :9>>9B 5= 20./26.72 978<1.0<74 23. 8/6. 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 40/72 / 856 9: 8#### :90 =/<7 /71 85::.0<74* 8+#### :90 >988 9: /6.7<2<.8 /71 8+#### :90 20/78=902/2<97 .K20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72@3/04.8
"# 5. 29 23. <7A50<.8 8582/<7.1 23. @>/<6/72 6<4327923/C./22.71.1/7?B90H/2>./82:90/=.0<919:+ 697238 ;52
23. 0<;57/> 3/8 792 /B/01.1 /7? @96=.78/2<97 :90 >988 9: <7@96. 150<74 >/<1 5= =.0<91 .7@. 23<8 9502 :<718 <2 0./897/;>. 29 /B/01 / 856 9:
- 7 -
%8"")# K +& 8+(# :90 >988 9: <7@96. 150<74 >/<15==.0<919B.C.023.@96=.78/2<979:8 #( /B/01.1 ;? 23. 0<;57/> :90 6.1<@/> .K=.78.8 7..18 79 <72.0:.0.7@. "" 3. @96=.78/2<97 /B/01.1 ;? 23. 0<;57/> <8 691<:<.1/8571.0 > 9 ./18 B/01;?23. 0<;57/> B/01;?23<8 9502
" /<7/7185::.0<74 8(#### 8#### ( .1<@/>K=.78.8 8 #( 8 #( + 988 9: :5250. ./07<74@/=/@<2? 8!)(## 8")##
0/78=902/2<97 .K20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72 @3/04.8 8### 8+####
9889:/6.7<2<.8 8(#### 8+#### ! 988 9: <7@96. 150<74 >/<1 5= =.0<91
8+(# 92/> 8"()#( 8+""( 3.0.B<>>;..73/7@.6.729:8((!#
- 8 -
"( 723.0.85>223.:9>>9B<74901.0<8=/88.1 %<& ==./><8
%<<&
3. @>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 23. .73/7@.1 @96=.78/2<97 9: 8((!# B<23 <72.0.82 /2 !I =.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<972<>>23.1/2.9:0./><J/2<97 %<<<& .8=971.72 9( , 7850/7@. 96=/7? <8 1<0.@2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. /:90.8/<1 @96=.78/2<97/69572/>974B<23<72.0.82B<23<7 97.69723:09623.1/2.9:23<8A5146.72 %<C& 7 85@3 1.=98<2 23. @>/<6/72 <8 =.06<22.129B<2310/B23..72<0./69572/>974 B<23<72.0.82/@@05.197<2
)*+ %$' #
<82
9">
9+