Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43135 (KAR)
BASAVARAJ v. HAMPAMMA
RFA/200052/2025 · 2025-09-04
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43135 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43135 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#$!$
%&#' (
! "# $
###% #
&&
# #
'( &&
'
#
' &&
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
# #
'' &&
#
') &&
*
# #
(
&&
( ##% #
+'
&&
##% '
&&
! "#
$
,,
* , ,
) )
'')
# ,
,
,
#
, #
# %
- 3 -
# -# & #
#! ./0 122314 /0 5/436 78 12234419:;241/9:/55 2<18/9= :> 03: 10/63 :.3 ><63< 61:36 ) ) 210036 /9
> '') 78 :.3 39/>< /?/4 @6=3 A #, /9=10@=@< "5>< 0.><:
B:.3 </14 >@<:C$ >9 > 5/436 @963< <63<(@43
31<6431<936D>@90345><12234419:196431<936 D>@90345><<302>9639:0
' .3 12234419: .10 5/436 1 0@/: 1=1/90: :.3 <302>9639:0 /9
> '') 5>< :.3 <34/35 >5 63D41<1:/>9 196 23<E1939: /9F@9D:/>9 .3 51:.3< >5 12234419:;241/9:/55G10D@4:/?1:/9=0@/:4196101:3919: 3 5/436 1224/D1:/>9 /9 ,><E > ( @963< &1<91:1H1 196 35><E0D:
033H/9==<19:>54196 9:.339I@/<878:.3 196</7@914
:.351:.3<>5241/9:/55C0=1?30:1:3E39::.1:
.3 /0 /9 2>00300/>9 :> 3J:39: >5 1D<30 196 .3 .10 140>
- 4 -
2@<D.1036 * 1D<30 /9 8 > *(1 196 1D<30 /9 8 > *(1962<>6@D36014363360735><3:.3</7@914
.3 </7@914 <3:@<936 :.3 0143 63360 >9 :.3 =<>@96 :.1: :.38 1<3 9>: :.3 <3=/0:3<36 0143 63360 .3 0@/: 0D.36@43 2<>23<:8 E310@</9= 1D<30 .10 7339 E@:1:36 /9 :.391E3>5 51:.3< >5241/9:/55 .3 51:.3<>5 241/9:/55 .10 5/436 1 0@/: /9 > )( 1=1/90:
1E21EE1 "63539619:
> $ 10 0.3 D1@036 /9:3<53<39D3 /9 :.3 241/9:/55C0 51:.3<C0 2>00300/>9 >5 :.3 0@/: 2<>23<:8 .3 241/9:/55C0 51:.3< .16 9>: 0>@=.: 5>< <34/35 >5 63D41<1:/>9 39D3
:.301/60@/:D1E3:>736/0E/0036
.351:.3<>5:.3241/9:/552<353<<365/<0:122314 /9 > ()' 196 :.3 01E3 140> D1E3 :> 73 6/0E/0036 5:3< :.3 631:.
>5 241/9:/55C0 51:.3< 196 43=14 <32<3039:1:/?30 >5 ></=/914 241/9:/55 .1?3 5/436
> )))) 735><3 :./0 >@<: 196 /: D1E3 :> 73 6/0E/0036@2.>46/9=:.3F@6=E39:0210036/9></=/9140@/: 196/95/<0:122314
- 5 -
* .3 D103 >5 :.3 12234419:;241/9:/55 31<4/3< G10 5><71<3/9F@9D:/>9 :D1E3:>736/0E/0036:.1::.3<3/0 D4>@6 >?3< :.3 :/:43 >5 :.3 241/9:/55 196 :.3<35><3
.3 .10 9>G 5/436 1 0@/: 5>< 63D41<1:/>9 196 /9F@9D:/>9 .3 63539619:05/436 @963< <63<(@43"1$A"6$>5 033H/9= <3F3D:/>9 >5 :.3 241/9: >9 :.3 =<>@96 :.1: /: 6>309>:6/0D4>03:.3D1@03>51D:/>91960@/:/071<<3678 41G .3241/9:/55.105/436>7F3D:/>9:>:.301/61224/D1:/>9
( 5:3< .31</9= :.3 21<:/30
:.3 </14 >@<:
144>G36:.301/61224/D1:/>9196<3F3D:36:.3241/9: 3/9= 1==</3?36 78 :.3 01/6 ><63<
:.3 12234419:;241/9:/55 /0 735><3:./0>@<:
31<936 D>@9034 5>< 12234419:;241/9:/55 G>@46 D>9:396 :.1: :.3 241/9: 6/0D4>030 :.3 D1@03 >5 1D:/>9 196 0:1:3E39: /9 :.3 241/9: 6>30 9>: 71< :.3 0@/: .3 /E2@=936><63<D1E3:>73210036>9:.3=<>@96:.1::.3 0@/:/0./:782</9D/243>5
@963<3D:/>9>5 196 :.3<3 /0 71< @963< <63< @43 3
- 6 -
D>9:3960:.1::.301/62</9D/243>5
/063539D3 196 /:<3I@/<30 D>443D:/>9 >53?/639D3 196 >9 :.1:=<>@96 241/9:D199>:73<3F3D:36 90@22><:>5./0D103
431<936 D>@90345><12234419:;241/9:/55.10<34/36@2>9:.363D/0/>9 >5 :.3 >9-743 23J >@<: /9 :.3 D103 >5
/9 ! 35@<:.3<D>9:3960:.1:3?39:>D>90/63<:.1:
71<@963< <63<@43>5
/:<3I@/<30:.33?/639D3 10/:/063539D319601E3/09>:1=<>@965><<3F3D:/>9>5 241/9: 35@<:.3<D>9:3960:.1:/E2@=936><63<.107339 210036 >948 >9 :.3 =<>@96 :.1: :.3 0@/: /0 E19/530:48 ?3J1:/>@0 196 E3</:4300 .3 01/6 1023D: D199>: 73 D>90/63<36 G./43 D>90/63</9= :.3 1224/D1:/>9 5/436 @963< <63<(@43>5 30@7E/:0:.1:241/9:6/0D4>030 :.3 D1@03 >5 1D:/>9 %/:. :./0 .3 2<1836 :> 144>G :.3 122314
- 7 -
) 31<936D>@90345><<302>9639:0G>@46D>9:396 :.1:
31<4/3<0@/:5/43678:.3241/9:/55C051:.3<5><:.3<34/35 >5 /9F@9D:/>9 .10 7339 6/0E/0036 196 /: 1::1/936 5/914/:8 .3<35><3
:.3 2<3039: 0@/: /0 ./: 78 2</9D/243 >5
@963< 3D:/>9 >5 ?39 :.3 51:.3< >5 241/9:/55>@=.::>.1?30>@=.:5><63D41<1:/>9/9:.331<4/3< 0@/: 196 :.3<35><3
:.3<3 /0 71< @963< <63< @43 >5 35@<:.3<0@7E/:0:.1:10:.30@/:/0?3J1:/>@05/436 :> .1<100 :.3 63539619:0
:.3 </14 >@<: .10 </=.:48 210036:.3/E2@=936><63<
1?/9= .31<6 431<936 D>@9034 5>< 7>:. 0/630 :./0 >@<: .10 23<@036 :.3 /E2@=936 ><63< 196 >:.3< E1:3</140241D36>9<3D><6
: /0 9>: /9 6/02@:3 :.1: :.3 0@/: 5/436 78 :.3 241/9:/55C0 51:.3< /9 > )( 5>< :.3 <34/35 >5 23<23:@14/9F@9D:/>9D1E3:>736/0E/0036 .3122314196 03D>96 122314 140> 5/436 78 ./E 1<3 140> 6/0E/0036 .3 01/60@/:G105/4365><:.323<23:@14/9F@9D:/>91962<3039:
- 8 -
0@/: /0 5/436 5>< 63D41<1:/>9 196 /9F@9D:/>9 93 >5 :.3 =<>@960>9G./D.:.3</14>@<:.10210036:.3/E2@=936 ><63</0:.1::.30@/:/071<<36782</9D/243>5
@963<3D:/>9>5
' .3 >9-743 23J >@<: /9 :.3 D103 >5
" $ 1:21<1=<12.0 > 196 .10 .346 10@963<
! "##$%$$&
'(
)) )
* " ##+,
-&
'(#
)
! ! - ! -
'('
! - )
'(. -
! ! +,// +,
- 9 -
0 - ! ! 1 , -
-
) - ! ) )
1 +,
-
! ! ! 0
'(2
0
)
/ /
- ! *"##+, - !
- /
+ ,
3 ) - 4
! -
5 #
)
! ! )
) -
4
$
0
6 4
"
! 7)
8 ! $
" -
$
!)
! -
- 10 -
! "
% $7 )- )
)
7)
-&
(8
"## $%$ - - $ 7! )
)-
! 7 - )
9 -
"##$%$
)
) $
) 8 $ - 7
) :) ; <
)
! =
9 ?/3G >5 :.317>?3
:.3/00@3 >5
D>@469>:.1?3733963D/636>9191224/D1:/>9@963<@43 >5 <63<(>5
5><:.3<310>9:.1::.316F@6/D1:/>9 >9:.3/00@3/9?>4?30D>90/63<1:/>9>5:.324316/9=0/9:.3
- 11 -
31<4/3< 0@/:
:.3 F@6=E39: >5 :.3 </14 >@<: 196 :.3 F@6=E39:>5:.3223441:3>@<:0
.3>:.3<=<>@96>9G./D.:.3</14>@<:.10 210036 :.3 /E2@=936 ><63< /0 :.1: @963< 2<>?/0/>90 >5 <63<@43>5 .3 <63<@432<30D</736 :.1:
:.3 241/9:/55 :> /9D4@63 144 D41/E0 1</0/9= 5<>E :.3 01E3D1@03>51D:/>9/910@/: .331<4/3<0@/:5/43678:.3 241/9:/55C051:.3<G105><71<3/9F@9D:/>91962<3039:0@/:/0 5/436 78 :.3 2<3039: 12234419:;241/9:/55 5>< :.3 <34/35 >5 63D41<1:/>9 196 /9F@9D:/>9 : /0 :.3 D>9:39:/>9 >5 :.3 63539619:0:.1:
241/9:/55>@=.::>.1?3/9D4@636:.3<34/35 >563D41<1:/>9/9:.331<4/3<0@/:
* 9 23<@014 >5 :.3 F@6=E39: 210036 /9 :.3 31<4/3<0@/:
/:6/0D4>030:.1::.3<3G10D4>@6>9:.3:/:43>5 :.3241/9:/55C051:.3< .3<35><3
:.30@/:>571<3/9F@9D:/>9 G10 6/0E/0036 > D>90/63< G.3:.3< :.3 0@/: /0 ./: 78 <63<@43>5
/01E1::3<>5:</14
G./D.<3I@/<30 D>90/63<1:/>9 >5 31<4/3< 24316/9=0 196 F@6=E39:0 210036
- 12 -
78:.3</14>@<:196:.3223441:3>@<:0 9<316/9=>5 :.3 241/9: /96/D1:3 :.1: :.3 D1@03 >5 1D:/>9 1DD<@36 >9 ' ) )1960@/:/05/436>93E>9:.:.3<315:3< #3<348 73D1@03 :.3<3 /0 D43?3< 6<15:/9= >5 D1@03 >5 1D:/>9 :.3 241/9:D199>:73<3F3D:36
( 5:.30@/:/0?3J1:/>@0196E3</:4300
:.3>@<: .10:>5<1E319/00@3/9:.1:<3=1<619615:3<.31</9=:.3 1<=@E39:0
/: .10 :> 63D/63 :.3 01/6 /00@3 .3 241/9: D199>:73<3F3D:36>9:.3710/0>5:.31443=1:/>90E16378 :.3 63539619:0 /9 :.3 G</::39 0:1:3E39: >< /9 19 1224/D1:/>95><<3F3D:/>9>5:.3241/9:
.3</14>@<:.10:><316:.339:/<3241/9:101 G.>43:>5/96>@:G.3:.3</:6/0D4>030D1@03>51D:/>9196 /5 /: /0 5>@96
:.39
:.3 241/9: D199>: 73 <3F3D:36 78 3J3<D/0/9=2>G3<@963< <63<(@43>5 .3<31<3 ?1</>@0<3E36/301?1/41743:>:.363539619:0:>2<>:3D:./0 </=.:0 1=1/90: :.3 ?3J1:/>@0 4/:/=1:/>9 196 :.3 >@<: .10 140>2>G3<@963<96/193914>63:>E33:0@D.3960
- 13 -
>90/63</9= 144 :.303 1023D:0
:.3 /E2@=936 <63< 210036 78 :.3 </14 >@<: >9 > 5/436 @963< <63<(@43>5<3I@/<30:>7303:10/63
) 9:.3<30@4:
:.35>44>G/9=
"/$ .3122314/0144>G36
"//$ .3 /E2@=936 ><63< 61:36 ) ) 210036 /9
> '') 78 :.3 39/></?/4@6=3A#,
/9=10@=@<>9
> 5/436 @963< <63< ( @43 >5 /0.3<37803:10/63
"///$ .3 </14 >@<: 0.144 2<>D336 G/:. :.3 E1::3</91DD><619D3G/:.41G
)& %$!$' #
'
+&