Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43134 (KAR)
BHEEMARAYA AND ORS v. AYUB AND ORS
MFA/200079/2024 · 2025-10-14
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43134 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43134 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#! $ %!#! $ %!"%& "
! !##
'&( )* ! !## +,
'&( ! !##
'&( ! !##
'&(
)
*
!""
#
!""
$
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
!""
&
#' %
!$!$'"
!'('
) )
%
!$!$'"
!'('
!( ) )!** %%
' %
%% !'"**+"
#
)
%
!,!"
!'('
- 3 -
&
%
% % +
%
$((
%
-+*#**#! -$'****! . % ) !*!*
)/
'"*"
+,)
*
!""
#
!""
$
%
!""
- 4 -
&
#' %
!$!$'"
!'('
) )
%
!$!$'"
!'('
!( ) )!** %%
' %
%% !'"**+"
#
)
%
!,!"
!'('
&
%
- 5 -
% % +
%
$((
%
-*#! -#'****! .
% ) !*!*
)/
''*"
)
*
!( ) )!** %%
' %
%% !'"**+"
&
#
'
- 6 -
*
!""
0'('*
#
#' %
!$!$'"
!'('*
' ) )
%
!$!$'"
!'('*
"
)
%
!,!"
!'('*
&
%
% % +
%
) **
'"*"
)
- 7 -
)
*
!( ) )!** %%
' %
%% !'"**+"
&
#
'
*
!""
0'('*
#
( %
!$!$'"
- 8 -
!'('*
' ) )
%
!$!$'"
!'('*
"
)
%
!,!"
!'('*
&
%
% % +
%
) **
''*"
) %
) 1 )
1 ) )
- 9 -
% 1 )
%2***(*#345%2***+$*#367 89:75 ;< =>7 ?:39@34=- % 2*''(*# 345 % 2*'"*# 367 89:75 ;< =>7 4-A634?7 2@B34< A45767?=924+28=>72=267>9?:7-?=826->26= C=>7 ?=D ;794E 3EE697F75 ;< =>7 GA5E@74= 345 3H365 53=75**B3--75;<=>7559=9243:749269F9: )A5E73453:3;A63E9942''*"?:A;;75 H9=> 2'"*" 94?7 =>7 ?>3::74E7 9- =2 =>7 -3@7 GA5E@74= 3:: =>7 3BB73:- 367 ?:A;;75 =2E7=>76 >7365345?2@@24GA5E@74=9-;794EB3--75
%3?=- E9F94E 69-7 =2 =>7 89:94E 28 =>7 3BB73:- ;6978:<-=3=75367=>3=24*+*(*'3=3;2A=*B@ =>7 57?73-75 3-3BB3 H3- B62?77594E 24 3 @2=26?<?:7 ;73694E 67E9-=63=924 2!,!" 3:24E H9=> >9- -24 @7746755<862@A6F9::3E7=2 35E9693-3BB33-3 B9::924 69576 345 >9- -24 @7746755< H3- 3 69576 28 =>7 @2=26?<?:7 >74 ;2=> 367 E294E =2H365- 35E969 @394
- 10 -
6235 H>74 =>7< H767 4736 3@343BA63 ?62-- 3= =>3= =9@7 =>7 569F76 28 ->2I3 7<:345 266< ;73694E 67E9-=63=9242!$!$'"H>9?>H3-;794E569F74943 63-> 345 47E:9E74= @34476 ?3@7 862@ =>7 2BB2-9=7-957 34553->75=2=>7@2=26?<?:7-367-A:=28=>738267-395 3??9574= ;2=> 367 -A-=39475 E697F2A- 94GA697- 345 -A??A@;75 =2 =>7 94GA697- 345 3-3BB3 5975 3= =>7 -B2= 345@7746755<24=>7H3<=2>2-B9=3:
>7?:39@34=-89:753B7=9=924A45767?=924"" 28=>7?=-77I94E?2@B74-3=9243:24EH9=>94=767-=826=>7 573=>2838267-39557?73-75
# 4 -76F9?7 28 -A@@24- =>7 67-B24574= 2- 345 367 3BB73675 =>62AE> =>796 ?2A4-7: 345 89:75 2;G7?=924- 574<94E =>7 3F76@74=- @357 94 =>7 ?:39@ B7=9=924>767-B24574=259542=3BB736;78267=>7 69;A43:94-B9=728-76F9?72842=9?7345>74?7H3-B:3?75 7J!B36=7
- 11 -
' 4=>7;3-9-28=>7B:73594E-28=>7B36=97-=>7 :39@-69;A43:863@75=>79--A7-345=>76738=7667?26575 =>77F9574?7>7?:39@34=-9426576=2B62F7=>796?3-7 7J3@9475 ?:39@34= 2 >9@-7:8 7J3@9475 3- ! 345 E2= 7J>9;9=75 52?A@74=- 43@7:< J =2 J(
4 ;7>3:82867-B24574=2247H9=47--H3-7J3@94753- !
345 E2= 7J>9;9=75 52?A@74=- 43@7:< J 345 J >7 :39@- 69;A43: ;< =>7 9@BAE475 GA5E@74= 94=763:93>7:5=>3==>73??9574==22IB:3?7243??2A4=28 63-> 34547E:9E74= 569F94E 28 =>7 28874594E F7>9?:7 ;< 9=- 569F76 3- 3 67-A:= 28 H>9?> =>7 57?73-75 -A-=39475 94GA697- 345 -A??A@;75 =2 =>7 94GA697- >7 69;A43:
8A6=>76 >7:5 =>3= =>7 ?:39@34=- 367 74=9=:75 =2 3 ?2@B74-3=924 28 -+*#**#! 826 =>7 573=> 28 @7746755< 345 ?2@B74-3=924 28 -*#! 826 =>7 573=> 28 3-3BB3 3:24E H9=> 94=767-= 3= =>7 63=7 28 $. B3 345 5967?=75 =>7 94-A634?7 ?2@B34< =2 57B2-9= =>7 ?2@B74-3=924 3@2A4= 3:24E H9=> 94=767-= 794E 3EE697F75=>7-73BB73:->3F7;77489:75
- 12 -
" >7:736475?2A4-7:826=>74-A634?72@B34< >3-639-75=>782::2H94E?24=74=924- 3 %96-=:< >7 ?24=74=75 =>3= =H2 ?:39@ B7=9=924- >3F7 ;774 89:75 826 573=> 28 83=>76 345 ;62=>76 28 =>7 ?:39@34=- >7 ?:39@34=- 94 2''*" 367 =>7 ?>9:5674 28 =>7 57?73-75 3-3BB3 94?7 ?:39@34=- 367 ?:39@75 =>3= =>7< 367 57B74594E 24 =>7 94?2@7 28 =>796 83=>76 345 3:-2 =>7< H767 ?:39@75 =>3= =>7< 367 42= 57B74594E 24 =>7 94?2@7 28 =>796 ;62=>76 @7746755< >7 69;A43: >3- E634=75 ?2@B74-3=924 94 67-B7?= 28 =>7 ?:39@34=-94;2=>=>7?3-7-367?24=636<=2:3H
; 7?245:< >7 ?24=74=75 =>3= 94?3-7 28 573=> 28 ;62=>76!@7746755< 9- ?24?76475 =>7 ?:39@34=- ?34 ?:39@75=>3=:2--2857B74574?<9-6528=>794?2@728 =>7 57?73-75 345 =>7 69;A43: >3- ?24-957675 '*. 9- A4-A-=3943;:7
? 3-=:< 94 F97H 28 =>7 9F9-924 74?> 57?9-924 28 =>9-2A6=94=>7?3-728
- 13 -
! "# $%
&'=>7 63=72894=767-==2;73H3657524=>7?2@B74-3=9242AE>= =2 >3F7 ;774 ". B3 H>7673- 94 =>7 ?3-7 24 >345 =>7 69;A43: >3- 3H36575 94=767-= 3= =>7 63=7 28 $. B3 H>9?>9-24=>7>9E>76-95774?7>7-2AE>=8263::2H94E =>73BB73:89:75;<=>794-A634?7?2@B34<;<675A?94E=>7 ?2@B74-3=924
+>7:736475?2A4-7:3BB73694E826=>7?:39@34=- >3-639-75=>782::2H94E?24=74=924-
3%96-=:<>7?24=74575=>3=94=>7?3-728573=>28 3-3BB3=>7344A3:94?2@73--7--75;<=>769;A43:9-24 :2H76-957>7678267>78A6=>76?24=74575=>3=3-B76=>7 GA5E@74= 28 =>7 24D;:7 AB67@7 2A6= 94 =>7 ?3-7 28 ( () $* ) * +
,' 73?> 28 =>7 ?:39@34=- 367 74=9=:75 826 ?2@B74-3=924 28 -#****! A4576 =>7 >735 28 C:2-- 28 :2F73453887?=924345?24-26=9A@D
- 14 -
;7?245:<>7>3-?24=74=75=>3=94?3-728573=> 28@7746755<9-?24?76475?:39@34=2-345367=>7 <2A4E76;62=>76345<2A4E76-9-=76345=>7<36774=967:< 57B74594E AB24 =>7 94?2@7 28 =>796 57?73-75 83=>76 345 =>796 ;62=>76 >7678267 =>7 69;A43: >3- 3--7--75 =>3= =>7?:39@34=-36774=9=:7524:<'*.28=>794?2@728=>7 57?73-75 9- 24 ?24=636< =2 B62F9-924- 28 2=26 7>9?:7- ?=
?
>965:< >7 ?24=74=75 =>3= =>7 @24=>:< 94?2@7 3--7--75;<=>769;A43:9467-B7?=28@7746755<9-3:-2 24:2H76-957
53-=:<>7?24=74=75=>3=7F7494?3-728573=>28 @7746755< 9- ?24?76475 =>7 ?:39@34=- 367 74=9=:75 826 ?2@B74-3=92428 -#****!73?>A4576=>7>73528:2-- 28:2F73453887?=924345?24-26=9A@74?7>7-2AE>=826 3::2H94E =>7 3BB73: 89:75 ;< =>7 ?:39@34=- ;< 74>34?94E =>7?2@B74-3=924
- 15 -
( 7365 =>7 :736475 ?2A4-7: 826 =>7 B36=97- 345 B76A-75=>767?265-
$=9-42=9459-BA=7=>3=3-3BB3345@7746755< 59759436235=63889?3??9574=24*+*(*'5A7=263-> 345 47E:9E74= 569F94E 28569F76 28 28874594E 266<;73694E 2!$!$'"
*467-B7?=28?:39@B7=9=92489:75;<:7E3:>796-28 3-3BB3942''*"
>7?2@B74-3=9243H36575;<=>769;A43:A4576=>7 >735 :2-- 28 57B74574?< 9- GA-= 345 B62B76 345 -3@7 9- 42=59-=A6;75467-B7?=282=>76>735-9-?24?7647597 ?2@B74-3=924 3H36575 ;< =>7 69;A43: =2H365- :2-- 28 7-=3=7 9= >3- =2 ;7 675A?75 =2 -'***! 862@ -*"*! 345 :9I7H9-7 ?2@B74-3=924 =2H365- 8A4763:
7JB74-7- >3- =2 ;7 675A?75 =2 -'***! 862@ -*"*!94F97H28=>7GA5E@74=28=>7B7J2A6=
4 F97H 28 =>7 :3H :395 52H4 ;< =>7 AB67@7 2A6=94=>7?3-728-./0.(1213.4$2563.2718-AB63
- 16 -
?:39@34= 2- =2 ;794E =>7 ?>9:5674 28 57?73-75 3-3BB336774=9=:75826 -#****!73?>A4576=>7>735 28C:2--28B3674=3:?24-26=9A@D
>A-=>7?:39@34=-36774=9=:75=2=>782::2H94E ?2@B74-3=924 -./012340506/7 64/7/03/261 -50340 '1( 2--2857B74574?< *#****! %A4763:7JB74-7- '***! 2--287-=3=7 '***! 2--283674=3:?24-26=9A@ ****! 328 ,)
467-B7?=28?:39@B7=9=92489:75;<:7E3:>796-28 @7746755<942'"*"
>7 ?2@B74-3=924 3H36575 ;< =>7 69;A43: A4576 =>7 >735 :2-- 28 57B74574?< 9- K@2598975 345 57=76@9475 3- -*$"**! -(***L#*.JJ(J'*. 4 67-B7?= 28 2=>76 >735- 9- ?24?76475 97 ?2@B74-3=924 3H36575 ;< =>7 69;A43: =2H365- :2-- 28 7-=3=7 9= >3- =2 ;7 675A?75 =2 -'***! 862@ -*"*! 345 :9I7H9-7 ?2@B74-3=924 =2H365- 8A4763: K2667?=75F9572A6=2657653=75*#*'
- 17 -
7JB74-7- >3- =2 ;7 675A?75 =2 -'***! 862@ -*"*!94F97H28=>7GA5E@74=28=>7B7J2A6=
# 4 F97H 28 =>7 :3H :395 52H4 ;< =>7 AB67@7 2A6=94=>7?3-728-./0.(1213.4$2563.2718-AB63 ?:39@34= 2- =2 ;794E =>7 ;62=>76 28 ?:39@34=- 367 74=9=:75 826 -#****! 73?> A4576 =>7 >735 28 C:2-- 28 89:93:?24-26=9A@D
' >A-=>7?:39@34=-36774=9=:75=2=>782::2H94E ?2@B74-3=924 -./012340506/7 64/7/03/261 -50340 '1( 2--2857B74574?< K*$"**! %A4763:7JB74-7- '***! 2--287-=3=7 '***! 2--283674=3:?24-26=9A@ ****! 328 9,
)
" 4=>767-A:==>782::2H94E265769-B3--75
3 >73BB73:-3679:5; 519 K2667?=75F9572A6=2657653=75*#*'
- 18 -
;
>7 GA5E@74= 345 3H365 28 =>7 :39@-69;A43:9-@2598975 ? >7 ?:39@34=- 94 % 2***+$*#
2''*" 367 74=9=:75 =2 3 =2=3: ?2@B74-3=924 28 -$****! 3- 3E394-= -*#! 3H36575;<=>769;A43: 5 >7 ?:39@34=- 94 % 2***(*#
2'"*" 367 74=9=:75 =2 3 =2=3: ?2@B74-3=924 28 K -'$"**! 3- 3E394-= -+*#**#!
3H36575;<=>769;A43: 7 4 F97H 28 GA5E@74= 94
' =>7 63=7 28 94=767-= 3H36575 ;< =>7 69;A43: 24 =>7 ?2@B74-3=924 3= $. B76 344A@9-675A?75=2".B76344A@ 8 >7 67-B24574= 2 ! 4-A634?7 2@B34< 9- 5967?=75 =2 57B2-9= =>7 74=967 K2667?=75F9572A6=2657653=75*#*'
- 19 -
?2@B74-3=9243@2A4=94=>73BB73:-89:75;<=>7 ?:39@34=-3:24EH9=>94=767-=3=".B3862@=>7 53=72889:94E28=>7?:39@B7=9=924=9::=>753=728 673:9M3=924H9=>943B7692528-9JH77I-862@=>7 53=72867?79B=28?2B<28=>9-GA5E@74= E >7 59-;A6-7@74= 57B2-9= 345 67:73-7->3::;73-B76=>72657628=>769;A43: > >7 3@2A4= 94 57B2-9= @357 94 =>7 3BB73:-89:75;<=>794-A634?7?2@B34<->3::;7 =634-@9==75=2=>769;A43:82659-;A6-7@74=
!6) '#!( %
!6) '"%& "( %
9-=2:2#