- 1 - !"!# $%"%% &%' ! " # $%& ' " % ( $) ( # $%& * ( + Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( # ) ( + ( # %%% ! ", ( % %% %', *) ' " %%$ %%" " )% " ' " # % %%% *(%& " ' ' " ( " ' % - "" '+ + . - 3 - +. /0 102323450676572787 39/ 4:62 097; 06<3=0 4>>32200 60160?0520@ AB @@323457; 093?2676 :@3=37; 75@ 0=60276B 39/ 4:62 097; 06<3=0? 4>>32200 7;7A:679305=//7?C3;0@2/3?D63210232345:5@06623=;0? %%$75@%%4C 45?232:23454C5@37607@D32/0=2345)% 4C 6 ?008359 3??:75=0 4C 7 D632 35 2/0 572:60 4C =062346763 24E:7?/ 2/0 46@06@720@ % %%% 17??0@ 35 10=37; 7?0 4 *(%& 45 2/0 C3;0 4C ;07650@ @@323457; 0??345? F:@90 " 72 3F7B71:6 7D76@359 =4>105?72345 4C ? ( 24 07=/ 4C 2/0 <3=23>? 2/72 3? ' 75@ ' % D/4 760 7667B0@ 7? 60?145@0524? *75@)352/3?10232345 % "7=2?4C2/0=7?035A630C3?2/72710=37; 7?0 4 *(%& =7>0 24 A0 6093?2060@ 79735?2 60?145@052 4 % A0359 2/0 7==:?0@ 7;;09359 =4>>3??345 4C4CC05=01:53?/7A;0:5@060=2345?*%*75@$4C 75@:5@060=2345?75@%4C =2%% /0 - 4 - 637; 4:62 /0;@ 2/0 2637; 75@ 17??0@ 2/0 F:@9>052 7=E:322359 2/0 7==:?0@ C46 7;; 2/0 7C460?73@ 4CC05=0? G06=3?359 32? 14D06 :5@06 0=2345 * 4C 6 75@ :;0 % 4C =2 2/0 637; 4:62 7D76@0@ =4>105?72345 4C ? ( 07=/ 24 ' 75@ ' % A03592/0<3=23>? 75@ @360=20@ 2/03?263=2 097;06<3=0? 4>>32200 3F7B1:67 @3?263=2 24 17B 2/0 =4>105?72345 7>4:52 0359799630<0@AB2/0?7>02/00=60276B4C 39/ 4:62 097;06<3=0 4>>32200/7?160C0660@2/3?D632 10232345 * 076@ 63 787 ;07650@ =4:5?0; C46 2/0 1023234506 75@ 63 7>7@76 /7/7A:@@35 ;07650@ 39/ 4:62 4<065>052 ;07@06 C46 60?145@052 4 75@ 106:?0@ 2/0 D63217106? <05 2/4:9/ 60?145@052 4? * 75@)D060?06<0@2/0B60>7350@:560160?0520@ ) 5<30D4C2/0=452052345?:690@AB2/0;07650@ =4:5?0;C46A42/2/0176230?2/0143522/72D4:;@763?0C46 >B=45?3@06723453?+ - 5 - H'/02/062/03>1:950@46@06@720@ % %%% 35 10=37; 7?0 4 *(%& 17??0@ AB 2/0 @@323457; 0??345? :@90 " 72 3F7B71:67 35 60976@ 24 7D76@359 =4>105?72345 3? ;37A;0 24 A0 E:7?/0@ 35<48359 35/06052 14D06 :5@06 623=;0? %%$75@%%4C 45?232:23454C5@37IJ B 75?D06 24 2/0 7A4<0 14352 3? 35 C462/0C4;;4D359+ $ 23?2/0=4520523454C2/0164?0=:23453510=37; 7?0 4 *(%& 2/72 60?145@052 4 % /06035 A0359 2/0 7==:?0@ =4>>3220@ 4CC05=0? 1:53?/7A;0 :5@06 0=2345?*%*75@$4C 75@:5@060=2345?75@% 4C =2 %% 79735?2 60?145@052 4? * 75@ ) /06035 /0 637; 4:62 /0;@ 2/0 2637; D/060 2/0 7==:?0@ @0530@ 2/0 7==:?72345 /0 164?0=:2345 0G7>350@'? 24 75@ 942 >7680@ @4=:>052? G? 24 %) 35 ?:11462 4C 32? =452052345 ==:?0@ @0530@ 7;; 2/0 35=63>3572359 >720637;? 7<73;7A;0 45 60=46@ /0 637; - 6 - 4:627C2062783593524=45?3@06723452/0C7=22/72A42/2/0 <3=23>? 0G7>350@ 7? ' 75@ ' % /7<0 542 ?:114620@ 2/0 =7?0 4C 2/0 164?0=:2345 672/06 2/0B /7<0 2:650@ /4?23;0 7=E:3220@ 2/0 7==:?0@ AB 17??359 2/0 3>1:950@ F:@9>052 @720@ % %%% 4D0<06 D/3;0 7=E:322359 2/07==:?0@2/0637; 4:627=2359:5@060=2345*4C 6 75@:;0%4C =2164=00@0@247D76@ =4>105?72345 4C ? ( 07=/ 24 A42/ 2/0 <3=23>? 0G7>350@ 7? ' 75@ ' % /0 ?73@ 46@06 7D76@359 =4>105?72345 24 <3=23>? 3? :5@06 =/7;;0590 35 2/3? D632 10232345 0=2345*4C 6 @07;?D32/2/03=23> 4>105?72345=/0>0 ?106?:A?0=23454C*4C 6 2/0 2720 4<065>052 35 =446@3572345 D32/ 2/0 05267; 4<065>052 3? 60E:360@ 24 1601760 7 ?=/0>0 C46 164<3@359 C:5@? C46 2/0 1:614?0 4C =4>105?72345 24 2/0 <3=23>? 75@ D/050<06 7 60=4>>05@72345 3? >7@0 AB 2/0 4:62 C46 =4>105?72345 2/0 3?263=2 097; 06<3=0? :2/4632B 46 2/0 2720 097; 06<3=0? :2/4632B 7? 2/0 - 7 - =7?0>7BA0=4:;@@0=3@02/0E:752:>4C=4>105?72345 24A07D76@0@:5@062/0?=/0>060C0660@2435?:A?0=2345 4C0=2345*4C 6 07650@=4:5?0;C462/01023234506/7?164@:=0@ 2/0 423C3=72345 @720@ %% % %* 3??:0@ AB 2/0 4<065>052 4C 76572787 ;7B359 2/0 :;0? C46 7D76@359 =4>105?72345:5@060=2345*4C 6 ;7:?0$4C 2/0 76572787 3=23> 4>105?72345 =/0>0 % 607@? 7?:5@06+ !"# $ % & '( ) * ) + - 8 - , - . ! % / & 760607@3594C2/07A4<0=;7:?0>780?32=;076 2/72 C46 2/0 1:614?0 4C 9022359 =4>105?72345 2/0 <3=23>(=;73>752 ?/7;; =44106720 D32/ 2/0 14;3=0 @:6359 35<0?23972345 75@ 7;?4 D32/ 2/0 164?0=:2345 @:6359 2637; @>3220@;B352/0160?052=7?0A42/2/0<3=23>?0G7>350@ 7? ' 75@ ' % /7<0 542 ?:114620@ 2/0 =7?0 4C 2/0 164?0=:2345D/3=/60?:;20@357=E:3227;4C2/07==:?0@ 5 ?1320 4C 2/72 2/0 637; 4:62 164=00@0@ 24 17?? 2/0 F:@9>0527D76@359=4>105?723454C? (07=/24 2/0<3=23>?D/3=/3?542106>3??3A;07?1062/0423C3=72345 60C0660@247A4<0 5 94359 2/64:9/ 2/0 F:@9>052 17??0@ AB 2/0 637; 4:62 32 3? 5423=0@ 2/72 2/0 637; 4:62 /7? 542 7??3950@ 75B 607?45 7? 24 D/B 32 3? 7D76@359 - 9 - =4>105?72345 24 2/0 <3=23>? ' 75@ ' % D/05 2/0B 50<06 7??3?20@ 2/0 164?0=:2345 @:6359 2637; 75@ /7<0 =7209463=7;;B ?2720@ 2/72 2/0 7==:?0@ /7? 542 =4>>3220@ 75B=63>357;4CC05=079735?22/0> 5@06?:=/=36=:>?275=0?7>4C2/04135345 2/72 2/0 ?73@ 1462345 4C 2/0 F:@9>052 7D76@359 =4>105?72345 24 ' 75@ ' % D/4 760 7667B0@ 7? 60?145@0524? *75@)/060353?24A0?027?3@0 % ==46@359;B 75?D06 2/0 7A4<0 14352 35 2/0 75@164=00@2417??2/0C4;;4D359+ 3 '63202323453? 33 /0 3>1:950@ F:@9>052 @720@ % %%% 17??0@3510=37; 7?0 4 *(%& AB 2/0 @@323457; 0??345? :@90 " 72 3F7B71:67 D32/ 60?10=2 24 7D76@359=4>105?723454C? (24 07=/4C2/0<3=23>?3 0 ' 75@' %AB - 10 - 2/0 3?263=2 097; 06<3=0? =4>>32200 3F7B71:673?/060AB?027?3@0 () &%%' " 3?24 +;4 +) +