- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ $ %$"" & ! " # Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ % & ' ' '" ( $ # ) ! ! " - 3 - " # & # & $ "" - 4 - #) ' $ ' * +, -#(#! + & "+ -#!!! " $ + . & -#(#! $ - 5 - #) % & / -#(#" # % & / -#(#! + & "+ -#!!! * +0 # + + + )' + + + 1 ( ! & ! ( '+ ! +$ + & 2$ 2$ + - 6 - 2$ 345 67889: 45 ;4589< =>: >:<9:5 97:< 839 ?>@A59; 7BB97:4AC =>: 839 B98484>A9:5 75 D9;; 75 ?>@A59; =>: :95B>A<9A85 39 ?>@A59; =>: 839 ?>A896A>: E:>@C38 A>84?9 >= 8345 >@:8 8> 839 >:<9: <789< ( ! B7:84?@;7:;F B7:7C:7B3 A> D39:94A 7A >E59:G784>A 45 67<9 EF ;97:A9< 4AC;9 $@<C9 8378 7=89: 839 D>:H5 D9:9 @A<9:87H9A 48 45 A>D =>@A<8378E9F>A<!7?:95>=;7A<839:95B>A<9A8/7@83>:48495 7:9B:>?99<4AC8>=>:67:>7<D34?3D>@;<9A?>6B75595A97:;F "! 7?:95 >= ;7A< 4A 7<<484>A 8> D378 D75 >:4C4A7;;F B;7AA9< A769;F ! 7?:95 39:9=>:9 839 B98484>A9:5 37G9 C4G9A :9B:959A8784>A7A<;97:A9< 4AC;9$@<C97;5>37G4AC?>A54<9:9< 8396789:47;>A:9?>:<4AB7:7C:7B3A>67<97A>E59:G784>A D483 7 5B9?4=4? <4:9?84>A :95B>A<9A8 - 9B@8F >664554>A9: 9AC7;@:@8>87H9A>89>=839C:49G7A?9>=839B98484>A9:57A< ?>A54<9:8394::9B:959A8784>A58:9788345696>:7A<@6>=D:48 B98484>A 75 >A9 6>:9 :9B:959A8784>A C4G9A EF 839 B98484>A9:5 B755 A9?9557:F >:<9:5 =>: 455@7A?9 >= 7?I@45484>A A>84=4?784>A - 7 - 7A<8>B:>?99<4A7??>:<7A?9D483;7D399A84:99J9:?459537;; E9 ?>6B;989< 75 9JB9<484>@5;F 75 B>554E;9 7A< 78 7AF :789 D4834A 7 B9:4>< >= 83:99 6>A835 =:>6 839 <789 >= :9?94B8 >= ?9:84=49<?>BF>=8345>:<9: " AB7:7C:7B3A>#7;5>C4G9A7<4:9?84>A837848D75 7;5> E:>@C38 8> A>84?9 >= 8345 >@:8 8378 7;83>@C3 349= AC4A99:7;7E@:7C437<:9?>669A<9<455@7A?9>=A>84=4?784>A =>:7?I@45484>A4A:95B9?8>=!7?:95>=;7A<3>D9G9:9G9A4A :95B9?8 >= 574< ! 7?:95 >= ;7A< 7?I@45484>A A>84=4?784>A 37G9 A>8 E99A 455@9< 75 F98 39:9=>:9 839 :95B>A<9A8/7@83>:48495 7:9 <4:9?89< 8> 455@9 7?I@45484>A A>84=4?784>A 4A :95B9?8 >= ! 7?:95 >= ;7A< 75 :9?>669A<9< EF 349= AC4A99: >66@A4?784>A 7A< @4;<4AC5 >:83/758 @E;4? &>:H5 9B7:869A8 7;7E@:7C4 7;>AC D483 >839: ;7A<5 =>: D34?3 <4:9?84>A537G9E99A455@9<EF8345>@:8 39 ?>A896B8 B98484>A9: 4A 839 B98484>A D>@;< ?>A89A< 8378 839 <4:9?84>A 375 A>8 E99A ?>6B;49< 7A< 4A :95B>A59 8> 8345 ?>A896B8 B98484>A 7A 7==4<7G48 45 =4;9< EF 839 :95B>A<9A8 <789< !" ! # 7A< 4A 839 ?>6B;47A?9 :9B>:8 :9=9::4AC839>:<9:75D9;;75?>BF>=B:>B>57;75 AA9J@:9/ - 8 - 7A< 7;5> 48 45 58789< 8378 8345 B:>B>57; D75 =>:D7:<9< 8> 839 >==4?98> 554587A8>664554>A9:7;7E@:7C4>A!!" ! #=>: A9?9557:F 589B5 39 ?>BF >= 839 ;9889: <789< !!" ! # 45 7;5> 9A?;>59< 75 AA9J@:9/ A 839 5769 <7F 839 <:7=8 A>84=4?784>A D75 455@9< EF 839 >==4?9 >= 839 554587A8 >664554>A9:7;7E@:7C47A<839<:7=8A>84=4?784>A7;5>=4;9<75 AA9J@:9/"7A<7;5>E:>@C388>839A>84?9>=8345>@:88378 839 5769 D75 7BB:>G9< >A 839 5769 <7F 7A< 839 5769 45 67:H9< 75 AA9J@:9/ 7A< 39A?9 67<9 48 ?;97: 8378 A>84=4?784>A@A<9: 9?84>A>=8394C388>+74:>6B9A5784>A 7A< :7A5B7:9A?F 4A 7A< ?I@45484>A 937E4;48784>A 7A< 95988;969A8 ?8 !" D75 455@9< >A !'!" ! # 75 AA9J@:9/#84558789<8378!)7?:95"C@A875>=;7A<D75 A>84=49< 7A< 8378 45 839 7:97 D34?3 839F 37G9 @84;4K9< =>: 839 =>:6784>A>=839:>7< # 7G4AC ?>A54<9:9< 839 5@E64554>A >= 839 ?>@A59; 7BB97:4AC =>: 839 B98484>A9:5 75 D9;; 75 839 ?>@A59; =>: 839 :95B>A<9A85 7A< 87H4AC A>89 >= 839 <4:9?84>A 455@9< EF 839 ;97:A9< 4AC;9 $@<C9 4A B7:7C:7B3 A>5 7A< # 7A< 7;5> 839 ?>6B;47A?9E9=>:98345>@:84845G9:F?;97:8378>A;F!)7?:95 - 9 - " C@A875 >= ;7A<D75 7?I@4:9< 7A< 8> 8378 9==9?8 A>84=4?784>A D75 7;5> 455@9< &39A 5@?3 E94AC 839 ?759 839 ?>6B;47A?9 7==4<7G48457??9B89<54A?9:95B>A<9A8537G987H9A<9?454>A8> A>84=F>A;F!)7?:95"C@A875>=;7A< &39A 839:9 45 ?>6B;47A?9 839:9 45 A> A99< =>: 4A484784AC ?>A896B8 B:>?99<4AC5 7C74A58 839 :95B>A<9A85 9A?9 839 ?>A896B8 B:>?99<4AC5 7:9 <:>BB9< = B98484>A9: 37G9 7AF >839: C:49G7A?95 5769 ?7A E9 B9:5@7<9< 599H4AC 7BB:>B:4789:969<495 ' 39 ?>6B;74A7A8 ?>@A59; 5@E6485 8378 839 7:97 D34?34553>DA45;9559:837AD378839F37G9@84;4K9<7A<39A?9 ;4E9:8F 45 C4G9A 8> 839 B98484>A9:5 8> B@:5@9 839 7BB:>B:4789 :969<F4=48456>:9837A8397:97D34?3839F37G9@84;4K9< '( )"* '( )$* 458> ;>'