- 1 - !" #$ % % && '%( ) !"# $ % & # ' ( !"# )) * ( !"# $ % ) + ""#" #& Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) #,-%#& ) ) ' ##"."# "# ' ' ) !,- "" ./ !"""" #/ ) ' ) ) ' 0' $ 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?<4556774?< 8@A >@928;2?B <16 CD9B>6?< 4?9 4E4A9 94<69 ##"."# 5433692? @ "#:;<16A2?=25476?2@A2F27 'D9B6 4?9 ' 4?9 992<2@?47 294A 4?9 8@A 6?14?=6>6?<@8=@>56?34<2@? A26884=<376492?B<@8272?B@8<16=742>56<2<2@? 8@A=@>56?34<2@?4A643D?96A - 3 - 14< @? "-"."# <16 4556774?<=742>4?< 47@?B E2<11238A26?9431A4<1E6A65A@=6692?B@?4>@<@A=;=76 :64A2?B A6B23<A4<2@? @-)"" 8A@> 294A <@ 4?94G?4772 16 4556774?<=742>4?< :62?B <16 A296A 4?9 123 8A26?9 E43 52772@? A296A < 4:@D< #""" 5> E16? <16;E6A65A@=6692?B@?4><14?4A@49?64A4><14?4 :A29B6 <16 9A2F6A @8 <16 412?9A4 @>>4?96A '665 :64A2?B A6B23<A4<2@? @- "- =4>6 8A@> 69745DA32962?412B1356694?92?4A4314?9?6B72B6?< >4??6A 4?9 943169 4B42?3< <16 >@<@A=;=76 @8 <16 4556774?<=742>4?< @?36HD6?<7; <16 4556774?<=742>4?< 4?9 <16 52772@? A296A 8677 9@E? 4?9 3D3<42?69 BA26F@D3 2?CDA263 16 4556774?<=742>4?< >496 4 =742> 56<2<2@? 16A2:D?4714343363369=@>56?34<2@?4<3, ,"" E2<12?<6A63<4<<16A4<6@8./56A4??D>16A2:D?47 1679<14<<16A623=@?<A2:D<@A;?6B72B6?=6<@<166I<6?<@8 !"/ @8 <16 =742>4?< E1@ 23 <16 4556774?< 16A62? 4?9 4E4A969 @?7; 3!,- ":62?B<16."/ @843363369 =@>56?34<2@?164556774?<=742>4?<143=14776?B69<16 - 4 - 342982?92?B@8=@?<A2:D<@A;?6B72B6?=6@8<16A2:D?474?9 473@3@DB1<6?14?=6>6?<@8=@>56?34<2@?4396<6A>2?69 :;<16A2:D?47 - 64A9 764A?69 =@D?367 8@A <16 4556774?< 4?9 764A?69=@D?3678@AA635@?96?<@2?3DA4?=6=@>54?; ! 64A?69 =@D?367 8@A <16 4556774?< E@D79 =@?<6?9<14<<16=14AB63166<143:66?82769@?7;4B42?3< <16 9A2F6A @8 <16 @886?92?B F612=76 4?9 <16 =@5; @8 <16 =14AB63166<234<I-16A68@A6<16A6=4??@<:64?; =@?<A2:D<@A; ?6B72B6?=6 @? <16 54A< @8 <16 4556774?<=742>4?< 4?9 <@ <14< 6I<6?< <16 A2:D?47 143 =@>>2<<69 4? 6AA@A 64A?69 =@D?367 8@A <16 4556774?< 8DA<16A =@?<6?93 <14< <16 =@>56?34<2@? 4E4A969 :; <16 A2:D?4723@?<167@E6A3296 64A?69=@D?3678@AA635@?96?<@2?3DA4?=6 =@>54?; E@D79 =@?<6?9 <14< <16 A@49 @? E12=1 <16 4==296?< 143 <4G6? 574=6 23 4 -" 866< E296 3<A42B1< A@49 4?9<16A623?@4776B4<2@?<14<<169A2F6A@8<16@886?92?B - 5 - F612=76 =4>6 @? <16 6I<A6>6 A2B1< 3296 4?9 943169 4B42?3< <16 >@<@A=;=76 @8 <16 =742>4?< 4?9 =@?3296A2?B <16 34>6 <16 A2:D?47 143 A2B1<7; 82I69 =@?<A2:D<@A; ?6B72B6?=6 @? <16 =742>4?< 4< !"/ 6 8DA<16A 3D:>2<3 <14< <16A6 4A6 ?@ BA@D?93 8@A 6?14?=6>6?< @8 =@>56?34<2@? 43 <16 =@>56?34<2@? 4E4A969 23 CD3< =@>56?34<2@? . 4F2?B 164A9 <16 764A?69 =@D?367 8@A <16 54A<263 <123 @DA< 56AD369 <16 2>5DB?69 CD9B>6?< 4?9 A247@DA<A6=@A93 , I- 23 <16 =@5; @8 <16 =14AB63166< 16 =14AB63166< 23 82769 @?7; 4B42?3< <16 9A2F6A @8 <16 @886?92?B F612=76 2<1@D< =@?3296A2?B <16 3429 4356=< <16 A2:D?47 143 6AA69 2? 82I2?B <16 =@?<A2:D<@A; ?6B72B6?=64<!"/@?<164556774?<=742>4?<@?7;@?<16 BA@D?9 <14< <16 4==296?< 143 <4G6? 574=6 @? -" 866< 3<A42B1< A@49 4?9 <16A6 E6A6 ?@ @<16A F612=763 @? <16 A@494<<16<2>6@8<164==296?<16?@?=6<16=14AB6 - 6 - 3166< 23827694B42?3<<169A2F6A @8<16 @886?92?BF612=76 <16A623?@4?;=@?<A2:D<@A;?6B72B6?=6@?<1654A<@8<16 4556774?<=742>4?<8<16A6234?;=@?<A2:D<@A;?6B72B6?=6 @? <16 54A< @8 <16 4556774?<=742>4?< <16 =14AB63166< E@D79 14F6 :66? 82769 4B42?3< 12> 473@ 16A68@A6 <16 82?92?B@8<16A2:D?47<14<<164556774?<143=@?<A2:D<69 ?6B72B6?=6 <@ <16 4==296?< <@ <16 6I<6?< @8 !"/ 143 ?@ :432316A68@A6342982?92?BA6HD2A63<@:636<43296 16 =742>4?< 143 5A@9D=69 123 455@2?<>6?< 76<<6A 4?9 54;37253 4< I3-! -" 4?9 -# A6356=<2F67; 4?9 =@?3296A2?B <16 34>6 <16 A2:D?47 143 <4G6? 123 2?=@>6 4< 3""" 56A >@?<1 4?9 49969 !"/ @8 <16 2?=@>6 <@E4A93 8D<DA6 5A@356=<3 16 A2:D?47 143 473@ <4G6? 2?<@ =@?3296A4<2@? <16 9234:272<; =6A<282=4<6 4< I, 233D69 :; @=<@A E1@ 143 965@369 <14< <169234:272<;@8<16=742>4?<234<!,/@8<16A2B1<72>: @?3296A2?B<1634>6<16A2:D?47143A2B1<7;<4G6?<16 9234:272<;@8<16=742>4?<4</@?3296A2?B<16>692=47 :2773 5A@9D=69 <16 A2:D?47 143 A2B1<7; 4E4A969 >692=47 - 7 - 6I56?363 16 A2:D?47 143 473@ A2B1<7; 4E4A969 7@33 @8 2?=@>69DA2?B<167429D556A2@94<<6?94?=6=14AB634?9 7@33 @8 4>6?2<263 16 A2:D?47 143 A2B1<7; 43363369 =@>56?34<2@? 4< 3, ,"" 16A68@A6 =@?3296A2?B <1634294356=<3 <16A64A6?@BA@D?938@A6?14?=6>6?< @8=@>56?34<2@?434E4A969:;<16A2:D?47 ?F26E@8<1634>6<168@77@E2?B %2& 16 23=6774?6@D3 )2A3< 55647 23 477@E69 2? 54A< %22& 16=@>56?34<2@?43363369:;<16A2:D?472?4 3D>@83, ,""A6>42?3D?47<6A69 %222& 16 82?92?B @8 <16 A2:D?47 A6B4A92?B =@?<A2:D<@A;?6B72B6?=6<@<166I<6?<@8!"/@? <164556774?<=742>4?<2336<43296 %2F& 16 =742>4?<4556774?< 23 6?<2<769 8@A <@<47 =@>56?34<2@? @8 3, ,"" E2<1 2?<6A63< 4< <16A4<6@8./56A4??D>8A@><1694<6@8<16 =742>56<2<2@?<277<1694<6@8A6472J4<2@? - 8 - %F& 635@?96?< @2?3DA4?=6 =@>54?; 31477 965@32< <16 6?<2A6 =@>56?34<2@? 4>@D?< E2<1 2?<6A63<E2<12?456A2@9@862B1<E66G38A@><123 94;84272?BE12=12<23724:76<@54;2?<6A63<4< <16A4<6@8/56A4??D> %F2& 16 4556774?< 23 ?@< 6?<2<769 <@ 2?<6A63< @? <16 6?14?=69 =@>56?34<2@? 26 !"/ @8 3, ,"" 8@A <16 9674;69 56A2@9 @8 94;32?8272?B<164556474356A<16@A96A94<69 ""#" %F22& 16 @A96A A6B4A92?B 965@32< 4?9 A676436 @8 =@>56?34<2@? 543369 :; <16 A2:D?47 A6>42?3 D?923<DA:69 %F222& 882=6 23 92A6=<69 <@ A6<DA? <16 A247 @DA< A6=@A9347@?BE2<14=@5;@8<123CD9B>6?< *+ ' % %( $ 23<@#7@!" CT:VK