- 1 - !" ## $%& ' ! " # $ % Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ! && & $ ' !( " # &) (( % & & #% & *!! %& % & $ (( +!( &&$ &,(!(( & - % & & % & & &$ . & $ / - 3 - " #/0 $ &% 12, 344536 2, 72658 9: ;15 <632=3>; 3445663>; 3?32>,;;15@A8?=5>;3>83B3C883;58((2> D+!(43,,589:;15882;2D>365>2DC2E26$A8?5 3>8 3; 3639AC3?2 #7DC ,1DC; F C29A>36-% ,55G2>? 7DC5>13><5=5>;D7;15<D=45>,3;2D> 15 83;5 D7 3<<285>; 2>ED6E5=5>; D7 ;15 E512<65 853;1 D7 362C3= 3;1D8 3>8 ;15 6239262;: D7 ;15 >,AC3><5 D=43>: ;D 43: ;15 <D=45>,3;2D> 3C5 >D; 2> 82,4A;5) ;15 D>6: 82,4A;5 2, 2> C5,45<; D7 2>385HA3;5 <D=45>,3;2D>3B3C8589:;15 C29A>36 53C8 C2 3?3C3@ 3;26 653C>58 <DA>,56 34453C2>? 7DC ;15 3445663>;,<632=3>;, 3>8 =; C55;2 3;26 56GA>82 653C>58 <DA>,56 34453C2>? 7DC ;15 C5,4D>85>;D285DC85C83;58((>D;2<5;D C5,4D>85>;D2,82,45>,58B2;1 C2 3?3C3@ 3;26 653C>58 <DA>,56 7DC ;15 3445663>;, B2;1 366 E515=5><5 ,A9=2;;58 ;13; ;15 - 4 - 85<53,58B3,3>3?C2<A6;AC2,;13E2>?=DC5;13>3<C5,D7 63>8 3>8 B3, 53C>2>? =DC5 ;13> ,((((( 45C 3>>A= 1DA?1;15C53C55I;C3<;,D7 ,;D,1DB;13; ;15 85<53,58 B3, 13E2>? 3<C5, D7 63>8 ;15 C29A>36 5CC582>;3G2>?;152><D=5D>6:3;,( 2>;5C=,D7 ;15 2><D=5 72I58 9: ;15 5?36 5CE2<5, A;1DC2;: 7DC ;15 :53C(2>C5,45<;D7A>,G26658639DAC 1545C,D>B1D B3,1D682>?;1563>8D73<C5,<3>>D;955HA3;58;D3> A>,G26658 639DAC <<DC82>?6: 15 ,DA?1; ;D ;3G5 ;15 2><D=53;653,;3;;15C3;5D7,(((( 45C=D>;15 13,7AC;15C,A9=2;;58;13;;15 C29A>3613,>D;<D>,285C58 ;15<3,5D7;153445663>;,7DC3B3C82>?(J5,<363;2D>D> ;15 <D=45>,3;2D> 3B3C858 A>85C ;15 <D>E5>;2D>36 1538, 2>;5C=,D763B63288DB>9:;15D>096545IDAC;2>;15 <3,5D7 1 <<DC82>?6: 15 ,DA?1; ;D 366DB ;15 344536 3>8 =D827258;153B3C83>85>13><5;15<D=45>,3;2D> 1 2009 ACJ 1298 - 5 - 57A;2>?;15,A9=2,,2D>,D7;15653C>58<DA>,56 34453C2>?7DC;153445663>;=;C55;23;2656GA>82B2;1 366 E515=5><5 ,A9=2;;58 ;13; ;15 C29A>36 13, 344CD4C23;56:;3G5>;152><D=53;,( 2>;5C=,D7 <13C;4C543C589:;155?365CE2<5A;1DC2;:B12<18D5, >D;<3667DC3>:2>;5C75C5><52>;1539,5><5D73>:4CDD7D7 2><D=5 4CD8A<58 9: ;15 3445663>;, 5C5 4CD8A<2>? ;15 5I;C3<;,B266>D;<D=5;D;15328D7;153445663>;,;D ,55G;152><D=512?15C;13>;152><D=572I589:;155?36 5CE2<5, A;1DC2;: 7DC ;15 :53C ( 15 C29A>36 13, <D>,285C58 ;15 <3,5 D7 ;15 <632=3>;,3445663>;, 3B3C82>? <D=45>,3;2D> A>85C 366 ;15 1538, B12<1 2, @A,; 3>8 4CD45C3>88D5,>D;<3667DC3>:2>;5C75C5><5<<DC82>?6: ,15,DA?1;;D82,=2,,;15344536 + 3E2>? 153C8 ;15 653C>58 <DA>,56 7DC ;15 43C;25, 45CA,58 ;15 5>;2C5 344536 4345C, ;15 D>6: HA5,;2D>;13;BDA683C2,57DC<D>,285C3;2D>D7;12,DAC;2,/ - 6 - KB15;15C;15<D=45>,3;2D>3B3C8589: ;15 C29A>369572;B2;12>;155I4C5,,2D> D7 @A,; <D=45>,3;2D> 27 ;15 3>,B5C 2, D;15CB2,5 B15;15C 3>: 2>;5C75C5><5 3; ;15 13>8, D7 ;12, <DAC; 2, C5HA2C58 ;D 5>13><5;15<D=45>,3;2D>LK >,B5C ;D ;15 39DE5 4D2>; 7DC <D>,285C3;2D> 2, F43C;6:2>3772C=3;2E5-7DC;157D66DB2>?/ ; 2, >D; 2> 82,4A;5 ;13; ;15 85<53,58 B3, 3> 3?C2<A6;AC2,;13E2>?3<C5,D763>83,45CI,!3>8* 1DA?1 >D 2><D=5 4CDD7 2, 4CD8A<58 1DB5E5C 3 45C,D> B1D 2, 13E2>? 3> 3?C2<A6;AC36 63>8 =53,AC2>? 3<C5, <3>>D;955HA3;58B2;13>A>,G26658639DACDB5E5C2> ;1539,5><5D73>:4CDD7D72><D=52;2,@A,;3>84CD45C;D ;3G5 ;15 2><D=5 3; ;15 C3;5 D7 ,(( B12<1 BDA68 =55;5>8,D7@A,;2<5>;5C=,D7;1563B63288DB>9:;15 D>0965 45I DAC; 2> ;15 3445663>;,3C55>;2;6587DC5,<363;2D>3;;15C3;5D7(JD> ;15 <D>E5>;2D>36 1538, 3>8 ;3G2>? ;15 2><D=5 D7 ;15 85<53,58 3, ,(( ;15 <D=45>,3;2D> 3B3C858 9: - 7 - ;15 C29A>36 C5HA2C5, C5 85;5C=2>3;2D> 3>8 C5 <D>,285C3;2D> ! 3E2>? <D>,285C58 ;15 2><D=5 3; ,(( 45C=D>;1;3G2>?;153?5D785<53,5895;B55>;153?5D7 ( ( :53C, J 2, ;D 95 38858 ;DB3C8, &A;AC5 CD,45<;A, 2; <D=5, ;D ,* 3E2>? <D>,285C58 ;15 ,3=5 25 ,* 9: 858A<;2>? ;1 ;DB3C8, 45C,D>365I45>,5,3>8;3G2>?=A6;24625C3,F-;156D,,D7 8545>85><:BDA68<D=5,;D,++! M#,(( NJ%IIIO% * 3E2>? <D>,285C58 ;15 73<; ;13; ;15C5 3C5 7DAC 8545>83>;, ;15 6D,, D7 <D>,DC;2A= BDA68 <D=5, ;D ,+(((( #,(((( I % 43C; 7CD= ;13; ,((( 53<1 2, 3B3C858 ;DB3C8, 6D,, D7 5,;3;5 3>8 7A>5C365I45>,5,(J5,<363;2D>2,C5HA2C58;D9538858 D>;153=DA>;3B3C858A>85C<D>E5>;2D>361538, ( 1A,2>366;153445663>;,<632=3>;,3C55>;2;658 7DC5>13><58<D=45>,3;2D>3,7D66DB,/ - 8 - D,,545>85><: , ++! D,, D7 D>,DC;2A= #,4DA,5 N 726236% , +(((( D,, D7 ,;3;5 P &A>5C36 I45>,5, , (((( (J 5,<363;2D> #7DC ;5C= D7 ;1C55:53C,% , *((( ( ))* 15 ;D;36 <D=45>,3;2D> C5 85;5C=2>589: ;12, DAC; BDA68 BDCG, DA; ;D ( ))* 3, 3?32>,; ,(( 3B3C858 9: ;15 C29A>36 15 3445663>;,<632=3>;, 3C5 5>;2;658 7DC 3> 3882;2D>36 <D=45>,3;2D> D7 (+ ,)* B12<1 2, CDA>858 D77 ;D (+ *36D>?B2;12>;5C5,;3;+J45C3>>A=7CD= ;1583;5D77262>?D7;1545;2;2D>;266C5362Q3;2D> &DC ;15 7DC5?D2>? C53,D>, ;12, DAC; 4CD<558, ;D43,,;157D66DB2>?/ 2% 153445362,--./0123456) - 9 - 22% 15 @A8?=5>; 3>8 3B3C8 43,,58 9: ;15 C29A>362>3B3C883;58((2> D+!( 43,,58 9: ;15 882;2D>365>2DC2E26$A8?53>8 3; 3639AC3?22,=D827258) 222% 15 3445663>;, R <632=3>;, 3C5 5>;2;658 7DC 3> 3882;2D>36 <D=45>,3;2D> D7 (+ ,) B12<1 2, CDA>858 D77 ;D (+ * B2;1 2>;5C5,; 3; +J 43 7CD=;1583;5D745;2;2D>;266C5362Q3;2D> 2E% 15 C5,4D>85>; D R >,AC3><5 D=43>: ,1366 854D,2; 5>;2C5 5>13><58 <D=45>,3;2D> 36D>? B2;1 3<<CA58 2>;5C5,; ,;3;58957DC5;15<D><5C>58 C29A>36 B2;12>,2IB55G,7CD=;1583;5D7C5<524;D7 3<D4:D7;12,DC85C) E% 44DC;2D>=5>;3>882,9AC,5=5>;2,3, 45C;15DC85CD7;15 C29A>36 E2% DDC85C3,;D<D,; 0* $& " 2,;D/6D/( /$