- 1 - !!"#!!$! % "&"'""! ""'' ()* + ! "## $ ! " " %& ' '( )'*' # + )'*' ! "# , # - $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (%!$ # + " " '* #" # % ' *& ) &' ) " "# . " &! /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 4=9 0>>/0? =9 ;=?/2 <@ 34/ A?0=7083 050=893 34/ "6257/83 082 0B012 203/2 '* >099/2 =8 # : % ' <@ 34/ :613 :; /8=:1 =C=? "625/ 082 4=330>61!;:194:13D34/1=<680?E$9//F=85/8408A/7/83:;34/ A:7>/8903=:8 % 8G61/2 A?0=7083 05/2 /=543 @/019 7/3 B=34 08 0AA=2/83 :8 &'' 082 4=9 ;034/1 09 0 03610? 6012=08 ;=?/20A?0=7>/3=3=:8A?0=7=85A:7>/8903=:8:; 9&' ) 4/1=<680?1/?=/26>:834/G6257/83=8 - 3 - 1/>:13/2=8 !"#$%&'(51083/2 08 07:683 :; 9% ) 3:B0129 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85 082 0?9: 51083/2 07:6839 682/1 34/ :34/1 4/029 3: 08 /H3/83 :; 9*& ) B=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; -I ;1:7 203/ :; >/3=3=:83=??1/0?=J03=:8 551=/C/2<@34/90=2:12/14/>1/;/11/2080>>/0? =8 B4=A4 =3 =9 A:83/82/2 3403 7=8:1)A?0=7083 96930=8/2 51=/C:69 =8G61=/9 / B09 027=33/2 =8 34/ 4:9>=30? :8 %'' 082 2=9A4015/2 :8 &(' 082 3469 4/ B09 =8>03=/83 ;:1 0 >/1=:2 :; '& 20@9 / ;6134/1 9303/2 3403 7/05/1A:7>/8903=:8B090B012/2682/134/:34/14/029082 8:07:683B0951083/2682/1?:99:;07/8=3=/9:;?=;/?:99:; ?=;//H>/A308A@2=9;=56103=:8:;<:2@082?:99:;0A02/7=A@/01 =8/26A03=:84/:A3:1099/99/234/2=90<=?=3@3:34//H3/83 :;'I3:34/B4:?/<:2@<6334/1=<680?40930F/834/907/ 09(I4691/K6/93/2;:1/8408A/7/83:;A:7>/8903=:8 ' /01234/01567/839;1:7<:349=2/9 /9>:82/83 A:689/?96<7=33/2340334/1=<680?0;3/1A:89=2/1=8534//83=1/ /C=2/8A/:81/A:120B012/2G693A:7>/8903=:8082=38//298: =83/1;/1/8A/ - 4 - - 4/ 0AA=2/83 :AA611/2 :8 &'' 9 >/1 34/ 56=2/?=8/9=996/2<@34/018030F0/50?/1C=A/9634:1=3@34/ =8A:7/:;34/A?0=7083=93:</30F/803 9* )>/17:834 4/A?0=7083B0905/2@/019/8A/34/76?3=>?=/1=9D'E /018/2A:689/?;:134/0>>/??0831/?=/26>:80A=303=:8=834/ A09/ :; ) * + , -** * * . #"!&/0!"!12 /8A/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: A:89=2/1 34/ 8:3=:80? =8A:7/09>/134/A40134/A?0=7083/H07=8/234/:A3:109 0824/9303/2340334/A?0=708340251=/C:693106703=A <10=8 =8G61@ 26/ 3: A:8369=:8 :; ?083=;:17 86A?69 082 A:1:80 102=03/ 09 ;:682 A?=8=A0??@ 082 102=:?:5=A0??@ 082 )6>>/1 082 ?:B/1?=7<9=7>0=1=8534/8:170?>4@9=A0?B:1F=8508268930<?/ 50=30AA:6839082;0A=0?>010?@9=9:8?/;39=2/082=996/2H&) 2=90<?=3@ A/13=;=A03/ 082 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=?=3@ 09 'I 4/ 31=<680? 409 30F/8 %12 :; 34/ 'I =/ (%%I 4=9 :613 ;=8298:1/09:83:=83/1;/1/B=3434/90=2;=82=85 ( 8 34/ 2=90<=?=3@ A/13=;=A03/ 34/ :A3:1 409 9303/2 340334/1/=9/C=2/8A/:;?/;3;0A=0?>010?@9=926/3:B4=A434/1/ =9 2/;:17/2 ?::F :; ;0A/, ?/;3 6>>/1 082 ?:B/1 ?=7<9)>:B/1 =9 - 5 - ))#4@>/11/;?/H=008293=;;8/99:;G:=837:C/7/839?:99:; A::12=803/27:C/7/839?=F/A:7<=85B094=85/3A9>/134/ 9A08 :; 34/ <0=8 94/ 402 4/7:11405=A A:8369=:8 =8 1=543 ?0835=;:17 86A?/69 082 <=?03/10? A:1:80 102=03/ ?015/93 </=85 H - A7 082 9611:682=85 /2/70, ;/B 8:8 4/7:11405=A A:8369=:89B/1/8:3/2=8?/;3A:1:80102=03//8A/34/:A3:1 409:>=8/2340326/3:34/;0A=0?>010?@9=9:8?/;39=2/0AA:6839 :;2=90<=?=3@:;I3:7=H/2A108=0?8/1C/ * /018/2A:689/?;:134/1/9>:82/839303/234034/ =9 8:3 0 31/03/2 :A3:1 09 96A4 ;6361/ >1:9>/A39 A088:3 </ 022/2B4/1/09?/018/2A:689/?;:134/0>>/??0831/?=/26>:80 "6257/83:;34/:8E<?/6>1/7/:613=834/A09/:; , +% . (1$$0!"!$2 B4/1/=8 I :; 34/ =8A:7/ B09 022/2 3:B0129 ;6361/ >1:9>/A39 082 76?3=>?=/1 0>>?=/2 B09 D'E 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 022 I 3:B0129 ;6361/>1:9>/A39/8A/34/?:99:;;6361//018=85A0>0A=3@=9 09682/1 9* )LIM 9 ) 9 )++'+(IM 9%( ) - 6 - & 4/ 31=<680? 0B012/2 0 967 :; 9%*-( ) 3:B0129 7/2=A0? /H>/89/9 082 =3 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8A/ 4/ A?0=7083B094:9>=30?=J/2;:10>/1=:2:;'*20@909>/1H( 4/1/;:1/ 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 0 967 :; 9(' ) 3:B0129 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9' ) 3:B0129 ?:99:;07/8=3=/9082 9% )3:B012931089>:1303=:8/H310 8:61=947/83082033/82083A4015/9=8A/94/B0907=8:15=1? 05/2 /=543 @/019 03 34/ 3=7/ :; 0AA=2/83 94/ 402 ;0A=0? 2=9;=56103=:8 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 51083 0 967 :; 9% ) 3:B0129 ?:99 :; ;6361/ >1:9>/A39 :; 7011=05/ /8A/34/3:30?A:7>/8903=:8=909682/1 ", -./0123-40.564 2745 :99:;;6361//018=85A0>0A=3@ 9%( ) /2=A0?/H>/89/9 9%*-( ) % 0=808296;;/1=859 9(' ) :99:;07/8=3=/9 9' ) ' 1089>:1303=:8 /H310 8:61=947/83 082033/82083A4015/9 9% ) - 6361/7011=05/>1:9>/A39 9% ) 5., 0 8 /018/2A:689/?;:134/896108A/A:7>08@96<7=39 3403 34/ A:7>/8903=:8 07:683 0B012/2 <@ 34/ 31=<680? 409 <//82/>:9=3/2<@34/896108A/A:7>08@</;:1/34/31=<680? AA:12=85?@34/;:??:B=85:12/1 - 7 - ! !=$ 4/0>>/0?=90??:B/2=8>013, !==$ 4/ A?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 3: 3:30? A:7>/8903=:8 :; 9(*( ) 0?:85 B=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; -I >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 34/ 203/ :; 1/0?=J03=:8 09 050=893 9*& )0B012/2<@34/31=<680?, !===$ 4/ 896108A/ A:7>08@ =9 2=1/A3/2 3: 2/>:9=334//8408A/2A:7>/8903=:8:; 9%(*( ) 0?:85 B=34 =83/1/93 B=34=8 :8/ 7:834 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :;34=9:12/1, !=C$ =8A/ =3 =9 9303/2 3403 34/ A?0=7083 409 </A:7/ 70G:1 94/ =9 >/17=33/2 3: B=34210B /83=1/ 07:6830?:85B=34=83/1/930AA16/2:8=3 0/8 ('""!* &! # =93:?:% "