Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43110 (KAR)
PEER MOHAMMED S/O MOHAMMAD RAFI v. MOHAMMED RAFI S/O PEER MOHAMMED AND ANR
MFA/200928/2017 · 2025-08-22
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43110 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43110 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
!!#"
$ %""&"&
""''
(&) *
! !"
! #
$%
! &'('#)
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! ! ! *'('#) $+%%+,#)#',-# ! ###))#$#)#))#'
!. #
! "
#+, #" ! ##))#-
!#,()#- ! /#$%%%%%*
0
! - 3 -
1
! ! %! 23/4556473/83769/66:3;<6;24;=6>6;?@8=@>56;/4?3@; 4/4A4B9693;CD9<>6;?4;94A4B994?69##))#-54//69 3; !@#,()#- EF ?26 764B;69 6;3@B 3G37 D9<6 4;9 4?23??45DB
) 64B9 ?26 764B;69 =@D;/67 8@B ?26 4556774;? * =743>4;?4;9764B;69=@D;/678@BB6/5@;96;?@&3;/DB4;=6 =@>54;F
), 64B;69 =@D;/67 8@B ?26 4556774;? A@D79 =@;?6;9 ?24? ?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ 4 9357@>4 2@796B 4;9 26 3/ 4 /678*6>57@F694;9<6??3;<>@B63;=@>626B3ED;4724/6BB69 3; ?4:3;< ?26 3;=@>6 4? /-)))* 56B >@;?2 6 8DB?26B /DE>3?/ ?24? ?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 24/ /D/?43;69 ?2B66 8B4=?DB6/4;92624/E66;@56B4?69?A3=64?3B4C4;926A4/ 49>3??693;?262@/53?478@B#)94F/269@=?@BA2@6H4>3;69 23>24/3//D6993/4E373?F=6B?383=4?64/56BH#,/?4?3;<?24? - 4 -
?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 24/ /D/?43;69 ''I 56B>4;6;? 93/4E373?F ?@ ?26 A2@76 E@9F 26 B3ED;47 24/ 6BB69 3; ?4:3;< ?26 93/4E373?F 4? #(I 26 B3ED;47 24/ ;@? 4A4B969 =@>56;/4?3@; ?@A4B9/ 7@// @8 4>6;3?36/ 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? A4/ D;>4BB369 4;9 ?26B6 3/ 7@// @8 5B@/56=?/ @8 23/ >4BB34<69D6?@?26/4394==396;?264>@D;?@8=@>56;/4?3@; 4A4B9698@B7@//@83;=@>69DB3;<?267439D556B3@93/@;7@A6B /3963?2?26/6265B4F/?@477@A?264556474;96;24;=6?26 =@>56;/4?3@;4/4A4B969EF?26B3ED;47
)$ 64B;69 =@D;/67 8@B B6/5@;96;? @ & 3;/DB4;=6 =@>54;F =@;?6;969 ?24? ?26 =743>4;? 24/ ;@? 5B@9D=69 4;F 9@=D>6;?/?@/2@A?24?263/49357@>42@796B4;9263//678* 6>57@F69 @;/396B3;< ?26 /4>6 ?26 B3ED;47 24/ ?4:6; ?26 3;=@>6 @8 ?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 4? /-)))* 56B >@;?2 A23=2 3/ 5B@56B 4;9 =@BB6=? 6 /DE>3?/ ?24? ?26 9@=?@B A2@ 3//D69 ?26 93/4E373?F 3/ ;@? 4 ?B64?69 9@=?@B 26B68@B6 ?26 93/4E373?F 4? #(I 3/ 5B@56B 4;9 =@BB6=? 6 /DE>3?/ ?24? ?26 =@>56;/4?3@;4A4B969EF?26B3ED;473/5B@56B4;9=@BB6=? - 5 -
)' 4G3;<264B9?26764B;69=@D;/678@B?264556774;? & =743>4;? 4;9 B6/5@;96;? @ & 3;/DB4;=6 =@>54;F ?23/ @DB? 56BD/69 ?26 3>5D<;69 CD9<>6;? 4A4B9 4;9 ?26 B347 @DB?B6=@B9/
)- 2694?6@84==396;?734E373?F@8B6/5@;96;?@& 3;/DB4;=6=@>54;F4;94<6@8?264556774;?&=743>4;?4B6;@? 3;93/5D?6264==396;?24/?4:6;574=6@;+)+)#'4??24? ?3>6?264556774;?&=743>4;?A4/4<69@8#F64B/
;@B96B?@ /2@A ?24? ?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? A4/ 9357@>4 2@796B ;@ 9@=D>6;?/24/E66;5B@9D=69EF?264556774;?&=743>4;?/ ;@3;=@>65B@@83/5B@9D=69?263;=@>624/?@E6?4:6;E4/69 @; ?26 =24B? 5B654B69 8@B /6??76>6;? @8 93/5D?6 3; ?26 @:* 9474?226;@?3@;473;=@>68@B?26F64B)#'4/56B?26=24B? 3//()))*56B>@;?2
)+ 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 24/ /D/?43;69 ?2B66 8B4=?DB6/ 4;9 26 D;96BA6;? @56B4?3@; ?A3=6 4;9 26 24/ E66;
49>3??69 3; ?26 2@/53?47 8@B #) 94F/ * 9@=?@B A2@ 24/ 4 69 ?26 93/4E373?F 4;9 3//D69 H#, ?26 93/4E373?F =6B?383=4?624//?4?69?24??2693/4E373?F@8?26A2@76E@9F @8 ?26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ ''I 26 B3ED;47 24/ ?4:6;
- 6 -
?2693/4E373?F4?#(I4;93?3/@;?267@A6B/396&9@=?@B A2@ 24/ 3//D69 H#, & 93/4E373?F =6B?383=4?6 3; 23/ 6G396;=6 /?4?69?24??264556774;?&=743>4;?3/D;4E76?@/JD4?/3?=B@// ?2676<D;4E76?@A47:7@;<93/?4;=6D;4E76?@738??26A63<2? A3?2768?24;94;9768?24;9<B353/A64:
)( @;/396B3;< ?26/6 4/56=?/ ?26 93/4E373?F ?4:6; EF ?26 B3ED;47 4? #(I 3/ @; ?26 7@A6B /396 @;/396B3;< ?26/6 4/56=?/?2693/4E373?F3/?@E6?4:6;4?'I?@?26A2@76E@9F
)% 26 B3ED;47 24/ B3<2?7F 4557369 ?26 >D7?35736B 4?
K#(0
#) ; G36A @8 ?26 4E@G6 ?26 7@// @8 8D?DB6 3;=@>6 3/ /()))*H#H#(H'IL/$,)))*
## 26B3ED;4724/B3<2?7F4A4B969?26=@>56;/4?3@;
?@A4B9/ 543; 4;9 /D886B3;< 4? /+')))* ?@A4B9/ >693=47 6H56;/6/4?/##)))*?@A4B9/936?4;94??6;94;?=24B<6/ 4? /#))))* 4;9 ?@A4B9/ 8D?DB6 >693=47 6H56;/6/ 4? /))))*
- 7 -
# 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? A4/ 49>3??69 3; ?26 2@/53?478@B#)94F/4;926D;96BA6;?@56B4?3@;?A3=64;926 24/ E66; 49G3/69 B6/? 26B68@B6 26 3/ 6;?3?769 8@B =@>56;/4?3@; ?@A4B9/ ?26 7@// @8 3;=@>6 9DB3;< ?26 7439 D5 56B3@9 8@B ), >@;?2/ 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ 6;?3?769 8@B =@>56;/4?3@;?@A4B9/7@//@83;=@>69DB3;<?267439D556B3@9 3;4/D>/()))*H,L/$)))*
#, 264556774;?&=743>4;?A4/4<69#F64B/4;926 A4/ D;>4BB369 D6 ?@ ?26 /439 4==396;? 26 24/ /D886B69 ), 8B4=?DB6/4;9D;96BA6;?@56B4?3@;?A3=64;9/D886B6993/4E373?F 26 /4>6 24/ 4886=?69 23/ >4BB34<6 5B@/56=?/ 26B68@B6 ?26 4556774;?&=743>4;?3/6;?3?7698@B=@>56;/4?3@;?@A4B9/7@// @8 4>6;3?36/ 4;9 7@// @8 5B@/56=?/ @8 >4BB34<6 3; 4 /D> @8 /#)))))*
#$ @;/396B3;< ?26 4E@G6 4/56=?/ ?26 4556774;? * =743>4;?3/6;?3?769?@=@>56;/4?3@;4/D;96B*
- 8 -
"+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74 # @A4B9/ 7@// @8 8D?DB6 3;=@>6 /$,)))*
@A4B9/ 543; 4;9 /D886B3;< /+')))* , @A4B9/ >693=47 6H56;/6/ /##)))* $ @A4B9/ 4??6;94;?0/ =24B<6/ /#))))* ' @A4B9/ 8D?DB6 >693=47 6H56;/6/ /))))* - @A4B9/ 7@// @8 3;=@>6 9DB3;<?267439D556B3@9 /$)))* + @A4B9/ 7@// @8 4>6;3?36/ 4;9 5B@/56=?/ @8>4BB34<6 /#)))))*
4-+ / <
#' 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ 6;?3?769 ?@ ?@?47 =@>56;/4?3@; @8 /+()))* 4/ 4<43;/? /$+$,))* 4/4A4B969EF?26B3ED;47
#- ;G36A@8?264E@G6?268@77@A3;<. - 9 -
! 264556473/477@A693;54B? 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ 6;?3?769 ?@ ?@?47 =@>56;/4?3@; @8 /+()))* 4/ 4<43;/? /$+$,))*4/4A4B969EF?26B3ED;47
26B4?6@83;?6B6/?4;9?26@B96B@8965@/3?54//69 EF?26B3ED;47B6>43;69D;47?6B69
! 26 B6/5@;96;? @ * 3;/DB4;=6 =@>54;F /2477 965@/3??26=@>56;/4?3@;4>@D;?A3?23;456B3@9@8 )( A66:/ 8B@> ?23/ 94F 84373;< A23=2 3? 3/ 734E76 ?@ 54F3;?6B6/?4??26B4?6@8%I54?37754F>6;? ! 26 4556774;? & =743>4;? 3/ 6;?3?769 8@B B6764/6 @8 6;?3B6=@>56;/4?3@;4>@D;? ".< ("&"&) %! 3/?@# 7@$# ?.!: