- 1 - !" #$% %% &'( ) ! " #$ %&'' #%(%$ $ ) #%(%' " $* '$'+$'$$ ! "" , " ! " ! $%'$'$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' $'& " ! - - . $ /01 233425 01 60547 282091: :/4 2;2<7 =6 :/4 <0>?925 09 =' $'& 72:47 $%'$'$ 321147 >@ :/4 770:0=925 490=< 0A05 ?784 297 2: 252>?<280 6=< 1/=<:B:/4<0>?925C $ 9D?<47 E520F29: 2847 $( @42<1 ;=<G098 21 2 E49:4<098E==50429752>=?<E=9:<2E:=<F4:;0:/292EE0749:=9 $$'%$'&297605472E520F34:0:0=9E520F098E=F34912:0=9=6 1,%'''' #/4<0>?92526:4<E=91074<09849:0<44A0749E4 =9<4E=<78<29:47292F=?9:=61+,%' #;0:/09:4<41:2: :/4 <2:4 =6 +H 34< 299?F 6<=F :/4 72:4 =6 34:0:0=9 :055 <425012:0=9 88<04A47>@:/41207=<74<:/423345529:3<464<<47 29 233425 297 F2095@ E=9:49:47 :/2: /4 ;21 42<9098 1%''' #34< F=9:/ 297 7?4 := :/4 2EE0749: /4 1?1:20947 I'H7012>050:@:=:/4;/=54>=7@?::/4<0>?925/21:2G49 - 3 - :/4 12F4 21 'H 4 4J2F0947 :/4 =E:=< 21 !$ 297 /4 011?47:/47012>050:@E4<:060E2:4?974<J'90:0255@/4;21 27F0::47 09 :/4 /=130:25 6=< % 72@1 297 251= ?974<8=94 1?<84<@ 297 28209 /4 ;21 27F0::47 09 :/4 /=130:25 6?<:/4< F=<4 72@1 :/?1 /4 ;21 /=130:250K47 6=< $% 72@1 09 :=:25 /4<46=<4<4L?41:476=<49/29E4F49:=6:/4E=F34912:0=9 I 42<7:/42<8?F49:1=6>=:/10741 % 1 :/4 34:0:0=94< 620547 := 3<=A4 /01 09E=F4 :/4 <0>?925 /21 <08/:5@ :2G49 :/4 9=:0=925 09E=F4 =6 1$%' # 21 34< :/4 E/2<: 3<432<47 >@ :/4 2<92:2G2 :2:4 4825 4<A0E41 ?:/=<0:@ 1 /4 F4: ;0:/ 29 2EE0749: 09 :/4 @42< $'&297/4;212847$(@42<12134<J+:/4F?5:03504< ;21:2G49,J,01:/4;=?97E4<:060E2:4297J'01:/4 7012>050:@ E4<:060E2:4 011?47 >@ :/4 =E:=< 1 34< ;=?97 E4<:060E2:4 :/4 23345529: 1?1:20947 7443 ! =A4< 546: G944 %J 2><210=9 =A4< <08/: 2>7=F49 297 <08/: 45>=; ! =A4< 546: 6==: IJ EF :4974< 4J3=147 297 6<2E:?<4 =6 546: 64F?< ;/0E/ 2<4 8<04A=?1 09 92:?<4 =E:=< 1:2:47 :/2: :/4<4 01 =57 F25?90:47 1?3<2E=97@52< 6<2E:?<4 =6 546: 64F?< ;0:/ 09:4<E=97@52< 4J:4910=9 ;0:/ 7@1:<=3/0E E25E060E2:0=9 2<=?97 - 4 - 701:25 64F?< ;0:/ 0F3529: 09 10:? 297 /4 1?8841:47 :/2: :/4 23345529:<4L?0<4129=:/4<1?<84<@6=<<4F=A25=60F3529:1297 41:0F2:47 :/4 233<=J0F2:4 2F=?9: 6=< 0: 2: 1+'''' # 297 21141147:/47012>050:@=6:/4546:5=;4<50F>21I'H297:/2:=6 :/4;/=54>=7@21I'H/4<0>?925/21:2G49 <7=6:/4 12F404$$H10:012E214=6F25#?90:476<2E:?<4:/01 =?<: 60971 0: <421=92>54 := :2G4 :/4 7012>050:@ 21 B%HC EE=<70985@:/45=11=66?:?<442<9098E232E0:@E=F41:=- $%'J$J,J%HMI'%I%' + /4 <0>?925 8<29:47 29 2F=?9: =6 1$$+%' # 2134<J$297J#470E25>0551/4<46=<4:/01=?<: 609719=<421=9:=09:4<64<4;0:/:/41207=<74< , 3345529:;21/=130:250K476=<234<0=7=6,72@109 :=:25 297 /4 ;21 27A0147 := <41: 6=< $ F=<4 F=9:/1 /49E4 E=91074<098 :/4 92:?<4 =6 09D?<@ 34<0=7 =6 /=130:25012:0=9 /01 =EE?32:0=9 284 297 =:/4< <454A29: 62E:=<1 :/01 =?<: 60971 0: <421=92>54 := 8<29: 29 2F=?9: =6 1+'''' # 6=< 3209 297 1?664<0981'''' #6=<5=11=62F490:0412971'''' #6=< :<2913=<:2:0=94J:<29=?<01/F49:2972::49729:E/2<841 - 5 - ( 4F08/:9=:/2A42::4974729@=:/4<;=<G2:5421: 6=< 2 34<0=7 =6 6=?< F=9:/1 :/4<46=<4 1%''' # $%' J I 01 2;2<747 ?974< 5=11 =6 09E=F4 7?<098 5207 ?3 34<0=7 297 /4 01 251= 49:0:547 6=< 29 2F=?9: =6 1I'''' # :=;2<716?:?<4F470E254J3491416=<<4F=A25=6:/40F3529:1 & 9 255 :/4 :=:25 E=F34912:0=9 E=F41 := 1(I$'' #;0:/09:4<41:2::/4<2:4=6+H34<299?F6<=F :/472:4=634:0:0=9:055<4250K2:0=9 ' /4 2;2<7 321147 >@ :/4 <0>?925 01 F=706041 21 ?974<- *+,- ./0120- =11=66?:?<409E=F4 I'%I%' # $2092971?664<098 +'''' # =11=62F490:041 '''' # I470E254J349141 $$+%' # %<2913=<:2:0=9 4J:<2 9=?<01/F49: 2972::49729:E/2<841 '''' # + =11 =6 42<9098 7?<098 5207 ?3 34<0=76=<IF=9:/1 %''' # ,"?:?<4F470E254J349141 I'''' # 1+3 " " 4 - 6 - EE=<70985@ :/4 23345529: 01 49:0:547 6=< 2 :=:25 E=F34912:0=9=6-" " 421282091:1+,%' #/4 E520F29: 01 49:0:547 6=< 29 49/29E47 E=F34912:0=9 =6 - " " 4 9:/4<41?5::/46=55=;098=<74<01321147- 0 /423342501 00 /4E520F29: 0149:0:5476=<2949/29E47 E=F34912:0=9 =6 1,',%' # ;0:/ 09:4<41: 2: :/4 <2:4 =6 +H 34< 299?F 6<=F:/472:4=634:0:0=9:055<4250K2:0=9 000 413=9749: =$ # 91?<29E4 E=F329@ /21 25<427@ 743=10:47 :/4 2F=?9: 2;2<747 >@ :/4 <0>?925 :/4<46=<4 <413=9749: =$ 01 70<4E:47 := 743=10: :/4 49/29E47 E=F34912:0=9 =6 1,',%' #;0:/09:4<41:2:<2:4=6+H ;0:/09 =94 F=9:/ 6<=F :/4 72:4 =6 :/01 =<74< - 7 - 0A 9 1?E/ 743=10: :/4 23345529: 01 34<F0::47:=;0:/7<2;:/449:0<42F=?9: 25=98;0:/09:4<41:2EE<?47=90: -,4 &%( $ 01:=-5=-I -