- 1 - !! ""#$"%! ! &! #'#(##" # #(( )*+ # #(( )*"+ ! " !" # ! $% # &' ($()!(!! ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *% +,, - !,(%!(, (!()!(, "*!($ ! " "% %&$,$)( ! %% % % ) !+ - 3 - $ !* " !$ * * , * .* , + $% # &$,$%%( !%()!(!) " ' ($()!(!! + ' * , *% +,, - !,(%!(, (!()!(, %(!($ - - 4 - /- '" /- 01 2345678 97::1; 7 <.==.6 .2;12 36 .:%(!($ 76; "*!($ .!(,%!(, 3: >381; 7?736:@ @01 A5;?=16@ 76; 7B72; 97::1; 36 ."*!($76; .!(,)!(,3:>381;7?736:@@01 A5;?=16@ 76; 7B72; 97::1; 36 .%(!($ 4C @01 .@.2 103<81 <<3;16@ 873=: 2345678 5=6747; >.2 :0.2@ D@01 2345678E .@0 @01:1 799178: 721 >381; 4C @01 ;3:95@36?@01F576@5=.><.=916:7@3.6 ! 0.5?06.@3<1B7:3::51;@.21:9.6;16@ .36 .!(,%!(, 01 07: 6.@ 7991721; 41>.21 @03: .52@ % , )* + 61 23 7:03= 070 7?1; !( C172: =1@ B3@0 76 7<<3;16@ .6 !*!() 76; ;31; ;51 @. @01 36A521: 3: - 5 - 81?780132:31>7@01242.@012:76;:3:@12:07G1>381;<873= 91@3@3.6 :11H36? <.=916:7@3.6 .> :!((((((& 78.6? B3@0 36@121:@ 7@ @01 27@1 .> !I 01 2345678 7>@12 <.6:3;1236?@0116@3211G3;16<1.621<.2;7B72;1;7:5= .>:()*(((&78.6?B3@036@121:@7@@0127@1.>"I912 7665=>2.=@01;7@1.>91@3@3.6@388@01;7@1.>21783J7@3.6 ??231G1;4C@01:73;A5;?=16@76;7B72;@0179918876@ K 07: 921>1221; @01 921:16@ 799178 76; =7368C <.6@16;1; @07@42.@012: 76; :3:@12: .> @01 ;1<17:1; 721 =7A.2:76;@01C7216.@;1916;16@.6@01;1<17:1;76; @01 2345678 07: 1221; 36 ;1;5<@36? )@0 @.B72;: 03: 912:.6781L916:1:36:@17;.>$(I7:01B7:56=72231; 1 >52@012 :54=3@@1; @07@ @01 <873=76@: 721 16@3@81; >.2 .68C8.::.>1:@7@176;>5612781L916:1: ) .6:3;1236? @01 7?1 .> @01 ;1<17:1; @01 234567807:@7H16@01=58@3983127:,B03<03:A5:@76; 92.912 3: 36<.=1 B7: @7H16 7: :"(((& 912 =.6@0 5@ 7: 912 @01 ?53;18361: 3::51; 4C @01 7267@7H7@7@1 - 6 - 1?7812G3<1:5@0.23@C@0136<.=1.>@01;1<17:1;07: @.41@7H167@:*$((&912=.6@0 $ 01 .6E481 91L .52@ 36 @01 ;3<@5= .> 018; @07@ @01 >5@521 92.:91<@: .> 36<.=1 .> @01 :18>&1=98.C1; ;1<17:1; :0788 78:. 41 36<85;1; 36 ;1@12=367@3.6.>@01<.=916:7@3.605:<.6:3;1236?@01 7?1.>@01;1<17:1;)(I.>@0136<.=107:@.417;;1; @.B72;:>5@52192.:91<@:76;7:912@01?53;18361:.>@01 .6E481 91L .52@ 36;3<@5= .> $(I .> @01 36<.=1 .> @01 ;1<17:1;3:@.41;1;5<@1;@.B72;:03:912:.6781L916:1: 16<1 @01 8.:: .> ;1916;16<C B.58; <.=1 @. :"(((&M)(I&$(IN!N,O:+(*!((& " 873=76@ .3:@01>7@012.>@01;1<17:1;6 G31B.>@01<3@7@3.6.>@01.6E48191L .52@219.2@1;36 @01 75@0.23@C .> ! 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 7 - " # $ # % & 76; 36 @01 75@0.23@C .> ' " ( ) * ( +013:16@3@81>.27:5=.>:)((((& @.B72;:8.::.>>38378<.6:.2@35= * 13:78:.16@3@81;>.2767=.56@.>:%((((& 56;12 @01 <.6G16@3.678 017;: 31 8.:: .> 1:@7@1 76; >561278 1L916:1: 7: 912 @01 <3@7@3.6 36 @01 <7:1 .> , 05: @01 @.@78 <.=916:7@3.6 B.58; 41 7: 56;12 8 . 17;: .> <.=916:7@3.6 =.56@ .::.>;1916;16<C :+(*!((& ! .::.><.6:.2@35= :)((((& % .6G16@3.678017;: :%((((& -./ 01$$ 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 8 - + 0121>.21 @01 <.=916:7@3.6 7B72;1; 4C @01 23456787@:()*(((&3:21;5<1;@.:+**!((& 6 :5<0;19.:3@@01<873=76@:721912=3@@1;@.B3@0;27B@01 16@3217=.56@78.6?B3@036@121:@7<<251;@0121.6 ( , )* $ + 01 36A521; <873=76@ 7?1; !% C172: >381; 7 <873= 91@3@3.6 41>.21 @01 2345678 <873=36? <.=916:7@3.6 .> :%*(((((& 01 2345678 <.6:3;1236? @01 16@321 1G3;16<1 .6 21<.2; ?276@1; <.=916:7@3.6 .> :+!,%%%& B3@0 36@121:@ 7@ "I 97 >2.= @01 ;7@1 .> 91@3@3.6 @388 21783:7@3.6 5@ 7: @0121 B7: <.6@2345@.2C 61?83?16<14.@0.6@01972@.>@01;23G12.>@01=.@.2<C<81 76; @01 45: @01 <.6@2345@.2C 61?83?16<1 B7: >3L1; 59.6 @01 <873=76@ 7: !(I 76; ,(I .6 @01 <.29.27@3.6 76; ;321<@1;21:9.6;16@ .!& .29.27@3.6@.;19.:3@@01,(I .>@01:73;<.=916:7@3.6 ??231G1;4C@01:73;A5;?=16@76;7B72;@01 .29.27@3.6 07: 921>1221; @03: 799178 76; =7368C - 9 - <.6@16;1; @07@ @01 ;3:74383@C B7: B2.6?8C @7H16 4C @01 23456787@!!I ! 01 <873=76@ 07: 1L7=361; @B. ;.<@.2: 01 ;3:74383@CB7:7::1::1;7@!+I@.@01B0.814.;C4C.61 ;.<@.276;76.@012;.<@.27::1::1;@01;3:74383@C7@)I .6:3;1236? @01 :7=1 @03: .52@ >36;: 3@ 217:.67481 @. @7H1@01;3:74383@C7:%2;.>)I31%I .6:3;1236? @01 7?1 .> @01 <873=76@ 7: !! C172: @01 =58@398312 B7: 23?0@8C@7H167:,76;@01234567807:23?0@8C@7H16@01 36<.=17@:"(((&912=.6@0 0121>.21 @01 8.:: .> >5@521 36<.=1 <.=1: @. :"(((L!L,L%IO:",),(& % 03: .52@>36;:6.217:.6@.36@12>121B3@0@01 .@012017;:?276@1;4C@012345678 ) 05: @01 @.@78 <.=916:7@3.6 B.58; 41 7: 56;12 73676;:5>>1236? :((((& 1;3<781L916:1: :"((*%& @@16;76@ <072?1: >..; 76; :!!$((& - 10 - <.6G1C76<1 .::.>>5@521172636?: :",),(& .::.>7=163@31: :((((& -./ 0 1 0121>.21@01<.=916:7@3.67B72;1;4C@012345678 7@:+!,%%%&3:21;5<1;@.:,"+%& $ <<.2;36?8C 4.@0 @01 799178: ;1:12G1 @. 41 788.B1; " 6@0121:58@@01>.88.B36?.2;123:97::1; 3 .@0@01799178:721788.B1; 33 01 <.=916:7@3.6 7B72;1; 4C @01 2345678 36 .%(!($ 7@ :()*(((& 3:21;5<1;@.:+**!((& 333 01 <.=916:7@3.6 7B72;1; 4C @01 234567836 ."*!($7@:+!,%%%&3: 21;5<1;@.:,"+%& 3G 0179918876@& .29.27@3.607:78217;C ;19.:3@1; ,(I .> @01 <.=916:7@3.6 7=.56@ - 11 - 7B72;1;4C@01234567876;@01C72116@3@81;>.2 21>56;.>1L<1::7=.56@3>76C G 01 :@7@5@.2C ;19.:3@ =7;1 4C @01 79918876@ 41>.21 @03: .52@ :0788 41 @276:=3@@1; @.@012345678 #2 )(##"+ '" 3:@ . 8 . !+