Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43098 (KAR)

CHANDAMMA W/O KAREPPA MALLABADI AND ORS v. THE MANAGING DIRECTOR NWKRTC HUBLI

MFA.CROB/200025/2023 · 2025-09-12

Shivashankar Amarannavar

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #$%% $ &%' ( !"# $% !"# $ $ !"# Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % $# !"# & ' ( !"# & ' ( ))%) ) %%###* '+ ) ( , - ) ) * .##!!## ) ) ) ) / - 3 - 012 34522 56783915: 12 ;1<8= 6> 3<?1@?:92 288A1:B 8:0?:38@8:9 5; 35@C8:2?915: ?D?4=8= 1: 7E=B@8:9 ?:= ?D?4= =?98= !## C?228= 1: 5.##! 6> 8:1541F1<E=B8?:= * E==8610?< 08 482C5:=8:9 354C54?915: 0?2 ;1<8= ) 5#.## ?44?>1:B 3<?1@?:92 ?2 482C5:=8:9 52 95%82C5:=8:95295%0?F8;1<8=3452256783915:2 $ 08 ;?392 <8?=1:B 95 ;1<8 3<?1@ C891915: ?48 ?2 E:=84G : #H#!##. 908 =838?28= ?:= 590842 @5F1:B 1: 908E268?41:B5 *)*!"?:=19D?2=41F8:6>192 =41F841:4?20?:=:8B<1B8:9@?::841:01B02C88=?:=19 3?@8:8?4IE?44>5; ?<<?::?14?=?4?990?991@8=41F84 <529 35:945< 5F84 F8013<8 ?:= 2?@8 D?2 ;8<< 1: 908 IE?44> 6821=8 5; 45?= 1: 908 <?:= 5; ?<<?CC? 14?=?4 08 =838?28= 2E29?1:8= 1:7E4182 ?:= 2E33E@68= 95 =8?90?:= 590842E29?1:8=1:7E41828B?<081425;908=838?28=0?F8 ;1<8= 3<?1@ C891915: 08 416E:?< 0?2 ?228228= - 4 - 35@C8:2?915: ?:= C?228= ?D?4= 08 54C54?915: 0?2 30?<<8:B8=9082?1=?D?4=1: )5#.##:908 2?1= ) 908 C4828:9 34522 56783915:2 0?F8 688: ;1<8= 08 2?1= ?CC8?< ;1<8= 6> 908 54C54?915: 0?2 688: =12@1228=5:<1@19?915:6>54=84=?98=##$#$ % 8?4= <8?4:8= 35E:28< ;54 34522 567839542 ?:= <8?4:8=35E:28<;5490854C54?915: 8?4:8= 35E:28< ;54 34522 567839542 D5E<= 35:98:=90?9908?331=8:90?29?A8:C<?381:908>8?4##. ?:= 908 =838?28= D?2 ?B8= % >8?42 ?2 5: 908 =?98 5; ?331=8:908416E:?<0?29?A8:1:35@8?92$###*6E9 ?2 C84 30?49 C48C?48= ;54 =12C52?< 5; 3?282 1: 5A ?=?<?90 908 :5915:?< 1:35@8 ;54 908 >8?4 5; ##. 12 2%###* 8 ;E49084 2E6@192 90?9 35:25491E@ <522 5; 829?98 ?:= ;E:84?< 8JC8:282 ?48 5: <5D84 21=8 190 9082808C4?>295?<<5D908?CC8?< " 8?4:8= 35E:28< ;54 54C54?915: 2E6@192 90?9 908 35@C8:2?915: ?D?4=8= 6> 908 416E:?< 12 7E29 ?:= C45C84 - 5 - . ?F1:B 08?4= <8?4:8= 35E:28<2 9012 5E49 0?2 C84E28= 1@CEB:8= 7E=B@8:9 ?:= 59084 @?9841?<2 C<?38= 5:48354= ! 08 =?98 5; ?331=8:9 ?:= ?B8 5; 908 =838?28= ?48 :59 1: =12CE98 08 ?331=8:9 0?2 9?A8: C<?38 5: #H#!##.?:=?990891@85;?331=8:9908=838?28=D?2 ?B8=%>8?422C8430?49C48C?48=;54=12C52?<5;3?282 1:5A*?=?<?90908:5915:?<1:35@8;54908>8?4##.12 2%###* 5:21=841:B 908 2?@8 1:35@8 9?A8: 6> 908 416E:?< 12 :59 C45C84 08 416E:?< 0?2 :59 ?D?4=8= ;E9E48 C452C839E2 5:21=841:B 908 ?B8 5; 908 =838?28= 3<?1@?:92 ?48 8:919<8= ;E9E48 C452C839E2 ?9 - 0848;5481:F18D5;908?65F8<5225;=8C8:=8:3>12?2 E:=84G )*+ ,-*. . . * - )/* H <?1@?:92 ?48 D1;8 ?:= 90488 301<=48: 5; 908 =838?28= 5:21=841:B 908 2?@8 908> ?48 8:919<8= 35:25491E@?9*.-) /*<?1@?:92 - 6 - ?48 8:919<8= <522 5; 829?98 ?9 ) * ?:= ;E:84?< 8JC8:282?9) *?2?B?1:292####*?D?4=8= 6> 908 416E:?< : F18D 5; 908 ?65F8 3<?1@?:92 ?48 8:919<8=95959?<35@C8:2?915:?2E:=84G 0 ) 123) 456786 ) 5225;=8C8:=8:3> "####* 5:25491E@ "####* $ 5225;829?98 ###* % )E:84?<8JC8:282 ###* 720 * # :F18D5;908?65F83<?1@?:92?488:919<8=959?< 35@C8:2?915: 5; 2.####* ?B?1:29 2$""###* ?2 ?D?4=8=6>908416E:?< :F18D5;908?65F8908;5<<5D1:B 1( 083452256783915:12 11( 4522 567839542 3<?1@?:92 8:919<8= ;54 959?< 35@C8:2?915: ?@5E:9 5; )* &95:11)1;162<=)87>=5)26360>' ?B?1:29 2$""###* ?2 ?D?4=8= 6> 908 - 7 - 416E:?< D190 1:984829 ?9 908 4?98 5; "- C84 ?::E@;45@908=?985;C891915:91<<48?<1K?915: 111( 08 482C5:=8:9 *54C54?915: 12 =148398= 95 =8C5219 35@C8:2?915: ?@5E:9 D1901: #!D88A2 ;45@ 9012 =?> ;?1<1:B D0130 19 12 <1?6<8 95 C?> 1:984829 ?9 908 4?98 5; H- C84 ?::E@ 91<< C?>@8:9 1F( 08 ?CC54915:@8:9 5; 35@C8:2?915: ?:= 54=84 5; =8C5219 5; 35@C8:2?915: ?@5E:9 C?228= 6> 908416E:?<1248@?1:8=E:=129E468= F( 08 3<?1@?:92 ?48 :59 8:919<8= 95 1:984829 ;54 C8415= 5; =8<?> 5; . =?>2 1: ;1<1:B 34522 56783915: 3* &%%' $ 1295<5