- 1 - ! " " #$ " #$ "" %&' () "" ( ) !" #$% #& " # $'( # % !! ) ) *% " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " +$ ** ("((% (%'%'(( , ,- ) , ! (%'%'(( ("((% , , ) & , . ( ) !" #$$ #& " # $'( # % !! ) ) *% - 3 - " +$ ** ("((% , - ) , ! (%%(( ("((% , - ) ! ! , . , ! # # /, /, $ # /, 0($+("((1231456789:5;<6 0($%+"(( 12 31456 78 9:5 =4;1>;<9 =:;445<?1<? 9:5 @A6?>5<9;<6;B;C66;956(%%((D;22561<0 ("((% 78 664 5<10C 1E14 ,A6?5 ;<6 , ;<6 - 4 - 661910<;4 );4;7AC;?1 :5C51<;395C C535CC56 90 ;2 F9C17A<;4G 09: 9:525 ;DD5;42 ;C5 0< 9:5 HA;<9A> 03 =0>D5<2;910< ( 5;C6 45;C<56 =0A<254 30C 9:5 ;DD544;<9 ;<6 45;C<56=0A<25430C9:5C52D0<65<9 $ :5 =0<95<910< 03 9:5 ;<;?1<? 1C5=90C 1< 9:51C ;DD5;4 12 9:;9 9:5 9C17A<;4 :;2 9;I5< J 612;714198 5E5< 9:0A?: 9:5 60=90C :;2 65D0256 612;714198 90 B:045 7068 ;9 +J 5 B0A46 ;420 =0<95<6 9:;99C17A<;45CC561<=0<2165C1<?3A9AC5DC02D5=92;<69:;9 "$C6612;7141982:0A46:;E5755<=0<2165C56 % < 9:5 09:5C :;<6 9:5 45;C<56 =0A<254 ;DD5;C1<? 30C 9:5 =4;1>;<9 1< :12 ;DD5;4 B0A46 =0<95<6 9:;9 9:5 9C17A<;4 =0>>19956 ;< 5CC0C 1< ;B;C61<? 45225C =0>D5<2;910< A<65C 9:5 :5;6 03 D;1< ;<6 2A335C1<? ;<6 ;420 A<65C 9:5 :5;6 03 4022 03 ;>5<19152 AC9:5C <0 =0>D5<2;910<:;2755<;B;C65690B;C623A9AC5;995<6;<9 =:;C?52 9:0A?: 9:5 1<@AC56 12 2A335C1<? 3C0> ;C;D45?1; - 5 - ;<6C5HA1C52;<;995<6;<99:C0A?:0A9:1241355<=59:5 ;B;C6C5HA1C521<95C35C5<=5789:120AC9 ;E1<? :5;C6 709: 45;C<56 =0A<254 9:5 30440B1<?D01<92;C12530C=0<2165C;910<039:120AC9# !:59:5C 9:5 9C17A<;4 =0>>19956 ;< 5CC0C 1< =0<2165C1<? J 612;7141985E5< 9:0A?: 9:5 60=90C:;265D02569:;99:5612;714198;9+JK ( !:59:5C 9:5 9C17A<;4 :;2 =0>>19956 ;< 5CC0C 1< <09;B;C61<?@A29;<6C5;20<;745=0>D5<2;910<K !:59:5C 9:5 ;B;C6 C5HA1C52 1<95C35C5<=5 78 9:12 0AC9K $ !:;90C65CK L "*+, +- :5 >;1< =0<95<910< 03 9:5 12 9:;9 9:0A?: 9:5 60=90C B:0 B;2 5M;>1<56 7530C59:59C17A<;465D02569:;99:5612;71419812+J90 9:5 B:045 7068 ;<6 9:5 9C17A<;4 =0>>19956 ;< 5CC0C 1< 9;I1<?9:5612;714198;2J + :12 =0<95<910< =;<<09 75 ;==5D956 30C 9:5 C5;20<9:;99:5=4;1>;<9122A335C1<?3C0>;C;D45?1;:5 - 6 - 5E165<=5039:560=90C12E5C8=45;C9:;96A5903C;=9AC503 90 ;<6 L ;<6 + 9:5 =4;1>;<9 12 2A335C1<? 3C0> ;C;D45?1; ;<6 :;2 4029 =0<9C04 0E5C 709: 40B5C 41>72 ;2 B544;20<9:5290>;=:!:5<2A=:5E165<=512?1E5<;<6 ;420 B:5< 2A??52910< B;2 >;65 19 12 =;95?0C1=;448 65D0256 9:;9 =:;<=52 03 C5=0E5C8 ;C5 C;C5 ;<6 9:5 =4;1>;<912A<;7459060;<8I1<603B0CI9:5=0<95<910< 039:59:;99:59C17A<;45CC561<9;I1<?612;714198;9 J125CC0<50A2=;<<0975;==5D956:50AC9:;290 9;I5<095039:53A<=910<;4612;714198039:5D5C20<!:5<; D5C20< 12 A<;745 90 60 ;<8 B0CI ;<6 12 D5C>;<5<948 2A335C1<? 3C0> ;C;D45?1; :;E1<? 4029 =0<9C04 0E5C 9:5 40B5C 41>72 19 =;<<09 75 5MD5=956 9:;9 :5 =;< 60 ;<8 B0CI1<3A9AC5:5C530C51<2A=:;=;259:5=0<95<910<03 9:5;DD544;<99:;99:59C17A<;4=0>>19956;<5CC0C=;<<09 75 ;==5D956 < ; =;25 03 ;C;D45?1; 9:5 HA52910< 03 C5=0E5C86052<09;C125!:5<D;C91=A4;C489:53C;=9AC503 9:5 90 ;<6 L ;<6 + 12 ; D5C>;<5<9 612;714198 A<65C 9:5 =1C=A>29;<=52 B5 60 <09 31<6 ;<8 30C=5 1< 9:5 - 7 - =0<95<910<039:5=0A<254;DD5;C1<?30C9:5:5C5 12 <0 1<31C>198 1< =0<2165C1<? 9:5 J 612;714198 ;<6 :5<=5D01<9012;<2B5C561<9:5<5?;91E5 * "*+, :545;C<56=0A<254;DD5;C1<?30C 9:5 =4;1>;<9 =0<95<656 9:;9 9:5 9C17A<;4 =0>>19956 ;< 5CC0C 1< ;B;C61<? =0>D5<2;910< 03 "' A<65C 9:5 :5;603D;1<;<62A335C1<?:5C51230C=51<9:5=0<95<910< 039:545;C<56=0A<25430C9:5=4;1>;<99:;99:5=4;1>;<912 ;?56;70A9$$85;C2;<62A335C56?C15E0A21<@AC1522A=:;2 2D1<;4 1<@AC152 ;<6 ;420 A<65CB5<9 :02D19;41N;910< 30C (L 6;82 !:5< 2A=: 751<? 9:5 =;25 19 12 ;DDC0DC1;95 90 5<:;<=59:52;>590("';2;?;1<29"' :5 09:5C =0<95<910< 03 9:5 45;C<56 =0A<254 12 9:;90<48"':;2755<;B;C656A<65C9:5:5;603 4022 03 ;>5<19152 ;E1<? =0<2165C56 9:;9 9:5 =4;1>;<9 12 ;?56;70A9$$85;C212D5C>;<5<948612;7456;<6:;290 41E5B19:J3A<=910<;4612;71419830C9:5C529034135;<6 ;420 =0<2165C1<? 9:5 612=0>30C9 19 12 ;DDC0DC1;95 90 5<:;<=59:52;>590("';2;?;1<29"' - 8 - 0B =0>1<? 90 9:5 ;2D5=9 03 <0<';B;C61<? 03 ;<8=0>D5<2;910<90B;C62;995<6;<9=:;C?529:50<G745 D5M 0AC9 1< 9:5 =;25 03 C5D0C956 1< B:5C51< 30C LJ 612;714198 9:5 0<G745 D5M 0AC9 900I612;714198;9J <9:;9=;2503;C;D45?1;0<G745 D5M 0AC9 ;B;C656 ;995<6;<9 =:;C?52 ;9 "' D5C >0<9: B:1=: =0>52 90 L"' D5C ;<<A> ;E1<? =0<2165C56 9:5 >A491D415C 03 * ;661910<;4 =0>D5<2;910< A<65C 9:12 :5;6 =;>5 90 *"' 0B5E5C 1< 9:12 =;25 :;E1<? =0<2165C56 9:5 >A491D415C 03 L 21<=5 9:5 =4;1>;<912;?56$$85;C219=0>5290L"' AC9:5C <0 =0>D5<2;910< :;2 755< ;B;C656 90B;C62 3A9AC5 >561=;4 5MD5<252 78 9:5 9C17A<;4 < 2ADC; =;25 30C LJ 612;714198 B19: =0?<191E5 1>D;1C>5<99:50<G745D5M0AC9;B;C656$"' =0<2165C1<? C5=ACC1<? >561=;4 9C5;9>5<9 < 9:5 =;25 0< :;<6 ;420 9:5 =4;1>;<9 12 2A335C1<? 3C0> D;C;D45?1; B19: J 612;714198 ;<6 :;2 90 A<65C?0 C5=ACC1<? >561=;4 - 9 - 9C5;9>5<9 9:C0A?:0A9 :12 4135 5<=5 19 12 ;DDC0DC1;95 90 ;B;C6 $"' 90B;C62 3A9AC5 >561=;4 5MD5<252 0>D5<2;910< A<65C ;44 09:5C :5;62 ;C5 A<612DA956 0B5E5C :5 12 <09 5<919456 30C ;<8 =0>D5<2;910< A<65C 9:5:5;6034022031<=0>56AC1<?4;16ADD5C1061<E15B03 9;I1<?612;714198;9J ( ==0C61<?48 1< ;44 9:5 =4;1>;<9 12 5<919456 30C 5<:;<=56 =0>D5<2;910< 03 2+%"' 5<=5 B5 ;<2B5C9:5D01<9<0(D;C9481<;331C>;91E5 $ 0>D5<2;910< C5';2252256 78 9:12 0AC9 12 ;2 30440B2# 5;62 B;C6039C17A<;4 B;C6 03 9:12 0AC9 022 03 3A9AC5 1<=0>5 2%$("' 2%$("' ;1<;<6A335C1<? 2"' 2("' 022 03 1<=0>5 6AC1<?4;16ADD5C106 2("' 14 995<6;<9 =:;C?52 9C;<2D0C9;910< ;<6 >12=544;<50A2 5MD5<252 2"' 2L"' - 10 - 022 03 ;>5<19152 ;<6<A9C1910<;43006 2"' 2("' 561=;471442 2(("' 2(("' A9AC5 >561=;4 5MD5<252 14 2$"' ,./ 0 ( 0 -( % < E15B 03 9:5 612=A2210<2 >;65 ;70E5 B5 DC0=55690D;229:530440B1<?# 1 0($+("((31456789:5 12 612>12256 ;<6 0($%+"(( 31456789:5=4;1>;<912;440B561<D;C978 >061381<? 9:5 @A6?>5<9 ;<6 ;B;C6 6;956 (%%((D;22561<0("((% 78 664 5<10C 1E14 ,A6?5 ;<6 , ;<6 661910<;4 );4;7AC;?1 78 5<:;<=1<? 9:5 =0>D5<2;910< 90 2+%"';2;?;1<292%((%"' 11 :5 ;>0A<9 1< 65D0219 2:;44 75 9C;<2>19956909C17A<;430C9:B19: 111 <91C5 =0>D5<2;910< ;>0A<9 2:;44 75 65D021956 ;40<? B19: 1<95C529 ;9 9:5 C;95 - 11 - 03 LJ D5C ;<<A> 3C0> 9:5 6;95 03 D591910< 9144 C5;41N;910< 78 9:5 7530C5 9:5 =0<=5C<56 9C17A<;4 B19:1< ; D5C1060321MB55I23C0>9:120C65C 1( %" ' $ 1( %' $ , 1290#40# #