- 1 - !"" ##$#%&" " '"!$($)$$# $!$))! *&+ $!$))! *&+ " # !" #$%& "" " ' #$(& ') ' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ' ' % ' " " ' " * &&& " #+ $% &, " " $ # , !" #$%& "" " ' #$(& ') ' " ' ' % ' " " " ' " * &&& " #+ $$ &, " ' " * "- - 3 - - ". " !(# /0110234356789388:6720$% &, 3260$ &,02&&&;<=>:667=7023? :2705 7@7? A6B: 326 + 7C3<39A5 D05 8>05= E=>: =57;A23?F >:/?37132=720$% &,>3895:D:55:6 ' 0&(% & 326 =>: /?37132= 72 0$$ &, >38 95:D:55:6 ' 0& & 8::G72B :2>32/:1:2=0D=>:/019:283=702 2'0&(% & >: 72CA5:6#/?37132= 1:= 47=> 3//76:2= 02 &$&& ": 8A8=372:6 D53/=A5: 0D 57B>= =7;73 326 D7;A?3 D53/=A5:0D,=>326=>1:=3/3593?;02:D53/=A5:0DA99:556 0D =7;73 326 A99:5 56 ?088 0D =>5:: A99:5 =::=> B57:@0A8 72CA57:8 =0 57B>= G2:: 326 57B>= ?:B B57:@0A8 72CA57:8 =0 H<B013=7/ 35/> A99:5 ?79 326 208: A99:5 =>5:: 72/78058 8:@:5: ?3/:53=702 0D ?04:5 ?79 >: /?37132= 89:2= =40 326 - 4 - >3?D ?3G>8 =043568 1:67/3? :I9:28:8 38 9:5 I ": :I3172:6 =>: 0/=05 >: 0/=05 388:88:6 =>: 6783;7?7=< 3= =0&J=0=>:57B>=?04:5?71;326&=0J=0=>:57B>= A99:5 ?71; A26:5 I ( >78 0A5= D7268 7= 5:38023;?: =0 =3G:=>:6783;7?7=<3=J= 4388=3=:6=>3==>:/?37132= 4386072B13802405G3263B57/A?=A53?405GA=2072/01: 9500D4389506A/:6=0950@:=>:72/01:>:/?37132=1:= 47=>3//76:2=02&$&&89:5=>:BA76:?72:8788A:6;< =>: 3523=3G3 =3=: :B3? :5@7/:8 A=>057=< =>: 20=7023? 72/01:0D=>:/?37132=78=0;:=3G:23=8%&&& #":2/: =>:?0880DDA=A5:72/01:7838A26:5- 8%&&& #+++JK8($&& # , >: =57;A23? >38 34356:6 3 8A1 0D 8$( # =0435681:67/3?:I9:28:83267=2::682072=:5D:5:2/:>78 0A5= /02876:572B =>: 23=A5: 0D 72CA57:8 326 9:5706 0D >0897=3?7H3=702 D7268 7= 5:38023;?: =0 34356 3 8A1 0D 8&&&& # =043568 9372 326 8ADD:572B8 8&&& # =043568 ?088 0D 31:27=7:8 8&&&& # =043568 =5328905=3=702:I=5320A578>1:2=3263==:2632=/>35B:8": 17B>=>3@:20=3==:26:632<405GD053=?:38=D0A5102=>8 - 5 - ":2/: 3 8A1 0D 8$&&& # 8%&&& # + , 102=>8 78 34356:6 A26:5 =>: >:36 0D ?088 0D :35272B 6A572B ?376 A9 9:5706":2/:=>:=0=3?/019:283=7027838A26:5- $, -./012-30.453 1634 0880DDA=A5:72/01: 8($&& # 3723268ADD:572B 8&&&& # 0880D31:27=7:8 8&&& # , 5328905=3=702 :I=53 20A578>1:2= 326 3==:2632= />35B:8 8&&&& # 0880D72/01:6A572B?376A9 9:5706 8$&&& # ( :67/3?:I9:28:8 8$( # 4., 0 2'0& & >78 399:3? 78 D7?:6 ;< =>: /?37132= 3B3728= =>: A6B1:2= 326 34356 63=:6 &&& 9388:6 72 0$$ &, ;< =>: 667=7023? :2705 7@7? A6B: 326 + 7C3<39A53 D05 8>05= E=>: =57;A23?F 8::G72B :2>32/:1:2=0D/019:283=702 ( >: /?37132= 8A8=372:6 D53/=A5: 0D >:36 0D 26 1:=3/3593? 9>3?32B:8 D53/=A5: 0D 57B>= D7;A?3 D53/=A5: 0D 57B>= =7;73 326 D7;A?3 D53/=A5: 0D 72D:5705 5310A8 0D 3;?A2=0 572BB57:@0A872CA57:802?:D==>7B>57B>=?:B3=A99:556326 - 6 - 0257B>=G2::6058A10D57B>=>326>:/?37132=4383B:6 &<:3583264386072B13802405G326:35272B38A10D 8&&& #9:5102=>A=>:>3820=9506A/:632<72/01: 9500D >: /?37132= :I3172:6 0/=05 * >: 0/=05 388:88:6=>:6783;7?7=<0D=>:/?37132=3=&#J=0=>:57B>= ?04:5 ?71; A= =>: =57;A23? >38 02?< /02876:5:6 &J 6783;7?7=< 56 0D J /01:8 =0 J 2 @7:4 0D =>: BA76:?72:8 788A:6 ;< =>: 3523=3G3 =3=: :B3? :5@7/:8 A=>057=< =>: 20=7023? 72/01: 78 =0 ;: =3G:2 3= 8%&&& # 9:5102=>":2/:=>:?0880DDA=A5:72/01:7838A26:5- 8%&&& #+++JK8&,& # % >: =57;A23? B532=:6 3 8A1 0D 8(% $ # =0435681:67/3?:I9:28:8>:831:78/055:/=3262::6820 72=:5D:5:2/: 02876:572B =>: 23=A5: 0D 72CA57:8 9:5706 0D >0897=3?7H3=7020//A93=7020D=>:/?37132=3260=>:55:?:@32= D3/=8 =>78 0A5= D7268 7= 5:38023;?: =0 34356 3 8A1 0D 8&&&& # =043568 9372 326 8ADD:572B8 8&&& # =043568 ?088 0D 31:27=7:8 8&&&& # =043568 =5328905=3=702 :I=53 20A578>1:2= 326 3==:2632= />35B:8 - 7 - >:/?37132=17B>=>3@:20=3==:26:632<0=>:5405GD053= ?:38= D0A5 102=>8 ":2/: >: 78 :2=7=?:6 =0 3 8A1 0D 8$&&& #8%&&& #+,102=>8=043568?0880D72/01: 6A572B ?376 A9 9:5706 ":2/: =>: =0=3? /019:283=702 78 38 A26:5- $, -./0712-30.453 1634 0880DDA=A5:72/01: 8&,& # 3723268ADD:572B 8&&&& # 0880D31:27=7:8 8&&& # , 043568 =5328905=3=702 :I=53 20A578>1:2= 326 3==:2632= />35B:8 8&&&& # 088 0D 72/01: 6A572B ?376 A9 9:5706 8$&&& # ( :67/3?:I9:28:8 8(% $ # 4., 0 $ >: =57;A23? >38 0;8:5@:6 =>3= 872/: =>:5: 438 9:517=@70?3=702=>:728A532/:/01932<438:I02:53=:6D501 =>: ?73;7?7=< 326 675:/=:6 =>: 5:89026:2= 0#042:5 0D =>: @:>7/?:=06:9087==>:310A2= :352:6 /0A28:? D05 =>: /?37132=8 72 ;0=> =>: 399:3?85:?7:8023/7=3=7029388:6;<=>:"02F;?:A95:1: 0A5= 72 =>: /38: 0D 5:905=:672 !"#$$!2@7:40D=>:8376 - 8 - A6B1:2= =>: 28A532/: /01932< 78 675:/=:6 =0 93< =>: /019:283=702 =0 =>: /?37132=8 326 ?3=:5 5:/0@:5 =>: 831: D501=>:042:50D=>:@:>7/?: & //05672B?<=>:D0??0472B- # 3 7 >:399:3?783??04:672935=) 77 >: /?37132= 72 78 :2=7=?:6 =0=3? /019:283=702 0D 8&( # 3?02B 47=> 72=:5:8= 3= =>: 53=: 0D (J 9:5 322A1D501=>:63=:0D9:=7=702=7??=>:63=:0D5:3?7H3=70238 3B3728=8 &( #34356:6;<=>:=57;A23?) 777 >: 28A532/: /01932< 78 675:/=:6 =0 6:9087= :2=75: /019:283=702 3?02B 47=> 72=:5:8= 47=>72 02: 102=> D501=>:63=:0D=>78056:5326?3=:55:/0@:5=>:831:D501 =>:042:50D=>:@:>7/?:;<6A:950/:880D?34) 7@ 2 8A/> 6:9087= =>: /?37132= 78 9:517==:6 =0 47=>6534=>::2=75:310A2=3?02B47=>72=:5:8=3//5A:6027= - 9 - 3 7 >:399:3?783??04:672935=) 77 >: /?37132= 72 78 :2=7=?:6 =0=3? /019:283=702 0D 8& # 3?02B 47=> 72=:5:8= 3= =>: 53=: 0D (J 9:5 322A1D501=>:63=:0D9:=7=702=7??=>:63=:0D5:3?7H3=70238 3B3728=8 & $ #34356:6;<=>:=57;A23?) 777 >: 28A532/: /01932< 78 675:/=:6 =0 6:9087= :2=75: /019:283=702 3?02B 47=> 72=:5:8= 47=>72 02: 102=> D501=>:63=:0D=>78056:5326?3=:55:/0@:5=>:831:D501 =>:042:50D=>:@:>7/?:;<6A:950/:880D?34) 7@ 2 8A/> 6:9087= =>: /?37132= 78 9:517==:6 =0 47=>6534=>::2=75:310A2=3?02B47=>72=:5:8=3//5A:6027= 0/ *)$$#+ (# " 78=0-?0-, -