- 1 - ! " #!$!%!! !!%% &' ( )* !!%% ++ &' ( ) * !" #$ % & ' '( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) * ## # !" #$ ' #+++, % & '- '+++ *( &( ' * * ++ '$+$ ' # ++) * ' #,++, ) ' - 3 - #,++, % & '( # #$+ ) ) * ## # #$+ % & ' '- - )# '( - 4 - &( ' * ++ ' $+$ ' # * ' . $ /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 4/9/ 0>>/0?9 01/ ;=?/2 050=893 34/ @6257/83 082 0A012 203/2 ++ >099/2 <B 34/ /8=:1 =C=? 625/082#025=1=8':$:;+$ 4/ ;0D39 :; 34/ D09/ 01/ 3403 :8 E++$ A4=?/ 34/ 2/D/09/2 401080770 082 :34/19 A/1/ >1:D//2=85=8063:</01=85/5=93103=:8: ## ;1:7 08/F0? 3: 050?0>61 :8 05010<0820#025=1 70=8 1:0234/21=C/1:;34/90=2063:21:C/=3=84=549>//2082 1094 082 8/5?=5/83 7088/1 082 34/1/<B 34/ 063: 3618/2 3613?/ 09 0 1/96?3 :; A4=D4 401080770 96930=8/2 - 5 - 51=/C:69 =8@61=/9 082 96DD67</2 3: 34/ 907/ 261=85 31/037/83 ) 4/1/;:1/ 4/1 469<082 082 D4=?21/8 ;=?/2 0 D?0=7 >/3=3=:8 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680? D?0=7=85 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9+++++# 4/ 1=<680? D:89=2/1=85 34/ /83=1/ /C=2/8D/ :8 1/D:12 51083/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9++++#A=34=83/1/9303,G>0;1:734/203/:; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=903=:8 082 2=1/D3/2 1/9>:82/83 :# 896108D/:7>08B34/1/=83:2/>:9=334/907/ 551=/C/2<B34/90=2@6257/830820A01234/ D?0=70839 40C/ >1/;/11/2 :+++ D40??/85=85 34/ H608367 :; D:7>/8903=:8 082 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B 409 >1/;/11/2 :+++ 2=9>63=8534/?=0<=?=3B , /018/2 D:689/? ;:1 34/ D?0=70839 D:83/82/2 340334/=8D:7/:;34/2/D/09/2=994:A8099+++# >/17:834<6334/1=<680?/11:8/:69?B30F/84/1=8D:7/ 099$+++#>/17:83408234/07:68351083/23:A0129 - 6 - ?:99 :; ?:C/ 082 0;;/D3=:8 =9 7/051/ 082 0?9: 34/ D:7>/8903=:8 51083/2 3:A0129 ;68/10? /I>/89/9 082 ?:99 :; D:89:13=67 =9 :8 ?:A/1 9=2/ 4/ 1=<680? 409 022/2 G:;34/=8D:7/3:A0129;6361/>1:9>/D3908234/907/ =93:<//8408D/24/1/;:1/1/H6/93/2;:1/8408D/7/83 :;D:7>/8903=:8 /1 D:8310 ?/018/2 D:689/? ;:1 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B 96<7=33/23403 34/1/ A09 8: 21=C=85 ?=D/8D/ 3: 34/ 21=C/1 :; 34/ C/4=D?/ 4015/ 94//3 682/1 I A09 ;=?/2 050=893 34/ 21=C/1 ;:1 34/ :;;/8D/9 >68=940<?/ 682/1 /D3=:89 082 $ :; 34/ :3:1 '/4=D?/9 D3 <63 34/ 1=<680?:<9/1C/2340334/>:?=DBA09 =8/I=93/8D/09:8 34/203/ :;0DD=2/83 082 ;=I/2 34/ ?=0<=?=3B :8 1/9>:82/83 :#896108D/:7>08B3=9;6134/19303/2340334/1/=9 >/17=3C=:?03=:834/>?0D/:;0DD=2/83=9F70A0B;1:7 025=1082>/17=3?=7=3:;34/063:=9A=34=8$F7?=7=39:; 025=1 09 >/1 I 9 4/ C=:?03/2 34/ 3/179 :; 34/ =896108D/ >:?=DB 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B =9 8:3 ?=0<?/ 3: >0B34/D:7>/8903=:8 - 7 - $ 4/ :A8/1 2=2 8:3 3618 6> 082 4/ 1/70=8/2 </;:1/34/1=<680? E ) 4/ 2/D/09/2 A09 05/2 ) B/019 09 >/1 34/ :93 :13/7 1/>:13 082 34/ 76?3=>?=/1 =9 1=543?B 30F/8 09 ) 4:654 =3 =9 9303/2 3403 34/ 2/D/09/2 A09 /018=85 9+++#>/17:83434/0>>/??083940C/8:3;=?/208B =8D:7/ >1::; 4/1/;:1/ 0994/ 7/3 A=34 08 0DD=2/83 :8 E++$09>/134/56=2/?=8/9:;34/ 018030F0 303/ /50? /1C=D/9 634:1=3B 4/1 =8D:7/ =9 3: </ 30F/8 03 9+#>/17:834 + 4/ :8J<?/ >/I :613 =8 34/ 2=D367 :; ! "# 4/?2 3403 34/ ;6361/ >1:9>/D39 :; =8D:7/ :; 34/ 9/?;#/7>?:B/2 2/D/09/2 940?? 0?9: </ =8D?62/2 =8 2/3/17=803=:8:;34/D:7>/8903=:8469D:89=2/1=8534/ 05/:;34/2/D/09/2G:;34/=8D:7/4093:</022/2 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 - 8 - 3:A0129 ;6361/ >1:9>/D39 082 3469 34/ 07:683 A:6?2 </D:7/9),$$#>/17:834&+KE$( 9>/134/56=2/?=8/9:;34/:8J<?/>/I:613 =8 2=D367 :; " $# % &12:;34/=8D:7/:;34/2/D/09/2=93:</ 2/26D3/2 3:A0129 4/1 >/19:80? /I>/89/9 469 34/ =8D:7/:;34/2/D/09/20;3/12/26D3=85>/19:80?/I>/89/9 D:7/93:9EE#>/17:834&),$$#)$E,(4/1/;:1/ 34/?:99:;2/>/82/8DBA:6?2</9,)+,#&EEI I)( 6134/1 34/ :8J<?/ 6>1/7/ :613 <B 1/=3/103=85 34/ D:7>1/4/89=C/ =83/1>1/303=:8 :; LD:89:13=67J 5=C/8 =8 34/ 0634:1=3B :; ' ( ) * ## * + #, 082 =8 34/ 0634:1=3B </3A//8 - ) 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 - 9 - "./"0. #1;:13=;=/2 340334/07:6839;:1?:99:;D:89:13=67940??</0A012/2 3: 34/ D4=?21/8 A4: ?:9/ 34/ D01/ 082 >1:3/D3=:8 :; 34/=1 >01/839 09 L>01/830? D:89:13=67J 3: 34/ >01/839 09 L;=?=0? D:89:13=67J ;:1 34/ ?:99 :; 34/=1 51:A8#6> D4=?21/8 3: D:7>/8903/ 34/=1 05:8B ?:C/ 082 0;;/D3=:8 D01/ 082 D:7>08=:894=> :; 2/D/09/2 D4=?21/8 082 3: 34/ 961C=C=85 9>:69/09L9>:690?D:89:13=67J;:1?:99:;34/=1D:7>08B 0;;/D3=:8 082 0=2 :; 34/ :34/1 DD:12=85?B =3 =9 @693 082 1/09:80<?/3:0A0129)++++#3:D?0=7083:3:A0129 ?:99 :; 9>:690? D:89:13=67 9)++++# /0D4 3: D?0=7083 :90823:A0129>01/830?D:89:13=67 4/B =9 0?9: /83=3?/2 ;:1 08 07:683 :; 9++++# 682/1 34/ D:8C/83=:80? 4/029 =/ ?:99 :; /9303/082;68/10?/I>/89/909>/134/D=303=:8=834/D09/ :; ! "# 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 10 - ) /8D/ 34/ D:7>/8903=:8 =9 1/099/99/2 09 682/1 :99:;2/>/82/8DB 9,)+,# :99:;D:89:13=67&9)++++I( 9++++# :8C/83=:80?4/029 9++++# :30? /990A012/2<B34/1=<680? 9E+,# 9++++# 8408D/2D:7>/8903=:8 9,)+,# 469 34/ D?0=70839 01/ /83=3?/2 ;:1 /8408D/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,)+,# A=34 =83/1/93 03 ,G >0 ;1:734/203/:;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=M03=:808234/1/;:1/34/ 0>>/0?2/9/1C/93:</0??:A/2=8>013 ++) 8 34=9 0>>/0? 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B 70=8?B 2=9>63/234/?=0<=?=3B:834/51:682340334/1/=98:21=C=85 ?=D/8D/ , 9>/134/56=2/?=8/9:;34/:8J<?/>/I:613 =8 2=D367 :; ! 2# ) . 3 #4 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: 5 (2018) 3 SCC 208 - 11 - 2=1/D3 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B 3: ;=193 >0B 34/ D:7>/8903=:807:68308234/81/D:C/134/907/;1:734/ :A8/1:;34/C/4=D?/4/1/;:1/34/0>>/0?2/9/1C/93:</ 0??:A/2=8>013 834/1/96?334/;:??:A=85:12/1=9>099/2 &=( :3434/0>>/0?901/0??:A/2=8>013 &==( 4/ 0>>/??0839 =8 :+++ # D?0=70839 01/ /83=3?/2 ;:1 /8408D/2 D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9,)+,#0?:85A=34=83/1/9303,G>0;1:734/203/ :;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=M03=:8 &===( 9 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B 409 0?9: >1/;/11/2 34/0>>/0?34/B40C/8:32/>:9=3/208B07:683/8D/ 34/B 01/ 2=1/D3/2 3: >0B 34/ /83=1/ D:7>/8903=:8 :; 9E+,#A=34=83/1/9303,G>0;1:734/203/:; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=M03=:8 :A/C/1 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B =9 03 ?=</13B 3: 1/D:C/1 34/ 907/ ;1:7 1/9>:82/83 : </;:1/34/1=<680?#:A8/1:;34/C/4=D?/<B26/>1:D/99 :;?0A - 12 - &=C( 896D42/>:9=334/D?0=7083901/>/17=33/23: A=34210A34//83=1/07:6830?:85A=34=83/1/930DD16/2:8 =309>/134/0>>:13=:87/83702/<B34/1=<680? &C( 4/ 896108D/ :7>08B 940?? 2/>:9=3 34/ D:7>/8903=:8 A=34=8 :8/ 7:834 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; 34=9 @6257/83 &C=( 4/ 07:683 2/>:9=3/2 <B 34/ 896108D/ :7>08B </;:1/ 34=9 :613 940?? </ 310897=33/2 3: 34/ 1=<680?;:12=9<619/7/83 ,-) &%!! ( $ =93: ?:$E