- 1 - !"# $% !"# $ & %& ' ( % ) ! # $ &' & * $ +&( %$ ", Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ & & $ +& ",- ' $ &.- & $ % +& ",- ) ! / '%# '!# % + % ( -$, $& %& $ &', & * $ +&( & %$ ) ! # - 3 - ' ( % $ &, & $ + ",- ' $ &. & $ % +& ",- ) ! / *'# . % % 0,'$"!1 % # % 23 % "( - ,& % & & - 4 - !& # 4$ 50 65789 :; <=8 >0?@A>B8 4CDA>;?>98@8B<54>'!#46<=84<4@8=5B780B< !64@ 0=4@< E<=8 B<F# A>9 @4:4 $ 50 65789:;<=8B7A5CA><?>98@ @98@.?7846:85>G AGG@58H89 :; <=8 I?9GC8>< A>9 AJA@9 9A<89 DA0089 :; <=8 8>54@ 5H57 ?9G8 * A>9 6KA7D?@ !64@ 0=4@< E<=8 @5:?>A7F# 5> 4-$, 5>B8 <=8 B=A778>G8 50 <4 <=8 0AC8 I?9GC8>< :4<= <=8 ADD8A7A>9<=8B@4004:I8B<54>A@8B7?::89<4G8<=8@=8A@9 A>9B4CC4>I?9GC8><50:85>GDA0089 AB<0G5H5>G@508<4<=86575>G46<=808BA080:@5867; 0<A<89A@8<=A<4>,A<A:4?<-ACJ=578 <=8B7A5CA><JA0@8<?@>5>G<4=50H577AG8A0D57754>@598@4> C4<4@B;B78 :8A@5>G @8G50<@A<54> 4 "'$",-' J=5B= 50 @5998> :; =A>9@ALA><= J=8> <=8; J8@8 @8AB=89 A7GA<<5H577AG8A<<=A<<5C8<=874@@;:8A@5>G@8G50<@A<54> 4 " $"'. :85>G 9@5H8> :; 5<0 9@5H8@ A< A =5G= - 5 - 0D8895>A@A0=A>9>8G75G8><CA>>8@A>99A0=89<4<=8 C4<4@B;B78 0 A @80?7< 46 <=8 A64@80A59 ABB598>< <=8 B7A5CA><0?0<A5>89G@58H4?05>I?@580A>9JA0=40D5<A75K89 ' =8B7A5CA><65789AD8<5<54>?>98@8B<54>--46 <=8 B< 088L5>G B4CD8>0A<54> < JA0 D78A989 <=A< =8 0D8>< =?G8 AC4?>< <4JA@90 C895BA7 8MD8>080 B4>H8;A>B8B=A@G808<B<JA06?@<=8@D78A989<=A<<=8 ABB598>< 4BB?@@89 D?@87; 4> ABB4?>< 46 <=8 @A0= A>9 >8G75G8><9@5H5>G46<=84668>95>GH8=5B78:;5<09@5H8@ . > 08@H5B8 46 >4<5B8 @80D4>98>< 40 A>9 ADD8A@89 <=@4?G= <=85@ B4?>087 80D4>98>< 4' >0?@A>B84CDA>;ADD8A@89<=@4?G=5<0B4?>087A>965789 J@5<<8> 0<A<8C8>< 98>;5>G <=8 AH8@C8><0 CA98 5> <=8 B7A5CD8<5<54> > <=8 :A050 46 <=8 D78A95>G0 46 <=8 DA@<580 <=8 7A5C0@5:?>A76@AC89<=8500?80A>9<=8@8A6<8@@8B4@989 <=8 8H598>B8 =8 B7A5CA>< 5> 4@98@ <4 D@4H8 <=8 BA08 B7A5CA><8MAC5>89=5C0876A0%"A>9@AH5=5HA@A; JA08MAC5>89A0%A>9G4<CA@L8994B?C8><0>AC87; - 6 - M <4 M- > :8=A76 46 @80D4>98><0 >85<=8@ A99?B89 A>; 8H598>B8 >4@ G4< CA@L89 A>; 94B?C8><0 =8 7A5C0 @5:?>A7 :; <=8 5CD?G>89 I?9GC8>< 5><8@ A75A=879<=A<<=8ABB598><<44LD7AB84>ABB4?><46@A0= A>9>8G75G8><9@5H5>G46<=84668>95>GH8=5B78:;5<09@5H8@ A0A@80?7<46J=5B=<=8B7A5CA><0?0<A5>895>I?@580=8 @5:?>A7 6?@<=8@ =879 <=A< <=8 B7A5CA>< 50 8><5<789 <4 A B4CD8>0A<54>460.,- $"A74>GJ5<=5><8@80<A<<=8 @A<8 46 -3 DA A>9 95@8B<89 <=8 @80D4>98>< 4'" >0?@A>B8 4CDA>; <4 98D405< <=8 B4CD8>0A<54> AC4?>< A74>GJ5<=5><8@80<85>GAGG@58H89:;<=8I?9GC8><A>9 AJA@9<=8ADD8A7A>9B@400"4:I8B<54>=AH8:88>65789 - 8A@>89 B4?>087 @5?:=A0= A77AD?@ ADD8A@5>G 64@ <=8 @80D4>98><">0?@A>B8 4CDA>; =A0 @A5089 <=8 64774J5>GB4><8><54>0/ A# 5@0<7; 9?8 <4 <=8 ABB598>< <=8 B7A5CA>< =A0 0?668@89C5>4@5>I?@580A>9=8=A08MAC5>89<=894B<4@A0 % J=8@85> =8 =A0 98D4089 5> =50 8H598>B8 <=A< <=8 B7A5CA><=A00?668@89950A:575<;46.,3<4<=8J=478:49; - 7 - A>9 A0080089 <=8 75C: 950A:575<; A< .,3 % 94B<4@ 50 >4< A <@8A<89 94B<4@ A>9 A0080089 <=8 950A:575<; 46 <=A< DA@<5B?7A@ 75C: A< .,3 A>9 $'@9 46 <=8 0AC8 B4C80 <4 -3 8>B8 <=8 0AC8 >8890 <4 :8 @89?B89 8 A704 0?:C5<0<=A<<=8AJA@946B4CD8>0A<54><4JA@90C895BA7 8MD8>08050>4<D@4D8@ :# ?@<=8@ =8 B4><8><89 <=A< 9?8 <4 <=8 ABB598>< B7A5CA>< =A0 0?668@89 <=@88 6@AB<?@80 B4>0598@5>G <=8 C895BA7 @8B4@90 A>9 J4?>9 B8@<565BA<8 <=8 4H8@A77 B4CD8>0A<54> AJA@989 :; <=8 @5:?>A7 50 4> =5G=8@ 0598 8>B8=804?G=<64@@89?B<54>46<=8B4CD8>0A<54> 8@ B4><@A 78A@>89 B4?>087 ADD8A@5>G 64@ <=8 B7A5CA><=A0B4><8><89<=A<A<<=8<5C846<=8ABB598><=8 JA0 8A@>5>G 0$" <4 0'$" D8@ A>>?C =8@5:?>A7=A0A0080089>4<54>A75>B4C846<=8B7A5CA>< A<0 $"D8@C4><=J=5B=504><=874J8@0598 A# 8B4>97; =8 B4><8>989 <=A< 9?8 <4 <=8 ABB598>< B7A5CA>< =A0 0?668@89 <=@88 CAI4@ 6@AB<?@80 A>9 A704 8MAC5>89<=894B<4@A0%=894B<4@5>=508H598>B8 - 8 - 98D4089 <=A< <=8 B7A5CA>< =A0 0?668@89 75C: 950A:575<; <4 <=88M<8><46.,3=8@5:?>A7=A0@5G=<7;B4>0598@89<=8 75C:950A:575<;A<.,3 :#=5@97;9?8<4<=8ABB598><B7A5CA><=A00?668@89 G@58H4?0 5>I?@580 =8 4B<4@ A0080089 <=8 J=478 :49; 950A:575<; A< .,3 4>0598@5>G <=8 J4?>9 B8@<565BA<8 A>9 950A:575<; B8@<565BA<8 <=8 B4CD8>0A<54> AJA@989 :; <=8 @5:?>A7?>98@<=8=8A9046DA5>A>90?668@5>G0A>94<=8@ 5>B598><A78MD8>080A@8A774><=874J8@0598=8@5:?>A7 =A0 6A5789 <4 G@A>< A>; B4CD8>0A<54> 64@ E7400 46 AC8>5<580FE7400465>B4C89?@5>G<=87A59?DD8@549F , 8A@9 <=8 78A@>89 B4?>087 64@ <=8 DA@<580 A>9 D8@?089<=8I?9GC8><A>9AJA@946<=8@5:?>A7 <50>4<5>950D?<8<=A<<=8B7A5CA><=A00?668@89 5>I?@5805>A@4A9<@A665BABB598><4BB?@@894>, 9?8<4@A0=A>9>8G75G8><9@5H5>G469@5H8@4674@@;:8A@5>G @8G50<@A<54> 4 " $"'. ?8 <4 <=8 ABB598>< B7A5CA><=A00?668@89<=864774J5>G5>I?@580& - 9 - • • • • • !"# $ % & 8=A08MAC5>89<=894B<4@A0%=894B<4@ 5>=508H598>B80<A<89<=A<<=8B7A5CA><=A00?668@89.,3 950A:575<;<4<=8J=478:49;A>9=8=A0A0080089<=875C: 950A:575<; <4 .,3 4>0598@5>G <=8 950A:575<; J4?>9 B8@<565BA<8 AG8 A>9 AH4BA<54> 46 <=8 B7A5CA>< J8 A@8 46 <=84D5>54><=A<J=478:49;950A:575<;=A0<4:8A0080089 A<E3F H8> <=4?G= B7A5CA>< =A0 B7A5C89 <=A< =8 JA0 8A@>5>G0$"<40'$"D8@A>>?C:?<=8 =A0 >4< D@49?B89 A>; 94B?C8><0 <4 D@4H8 =50 5>B4C8 =8@864@8 5> <=8 A:08>B8 46 D@446 46 5>B4C8 >4<54>A7 5>B4C8=A0<4:8A0080089A0D8@<=8G?59875>80500?89:; A@>A<ALA <A<8 8GA7 8@H5B8 ?<=4@5<; 64@ <=8 ABB598>< <AL8>D7AB85><=8;8A@=8>4<54>A75>B4C8=A0<4 :8<AL8>A<0$"DC=8C?7<5D758@ADD7589<4=50 - 10 - AG8 G@4?D 50 E-F =8 0AC8 50 @8<A5>89 =?0 <=8 B7A5CA>< 50 8><5<789 64@ B4CD8>0A<54> 46 0. $" !0NN-N3# 4> ABB4?>< 46 7400 46 6?<?@8 5>B4C8 @5:?>A7 =A0 AJA@989 0,. $" <4JA@90 C895BA7 8MD8>080 A>9 <=8 0AC8 A@8 4> <=8 :A050 46 :5770 D@49?B89 =8@864@8 <=8@8 J4?79 :8 >4 0B4D8 64@ 8>=A>B8C8>< ' 4>0598@5>G <=8 A:4H8 CA<8@5A70 J8 A@8 46 <=8 4D5>54> <=A< <=8 B4CD8>0A<54> AJA@989 :; <=8 @5:?>A7 ?>98@<=8=8A946EDA5>A>90?668@5>G0F=A0<4:88>=A>B89 6@4C0$"<40$"?@<=8@<=8B7A5CA><50 8><5<789 64@ 0$" ?>98@ <=8 =8A9 46 E7400 46 AC8>5<580F . =8 >A<?@8 465>I?@580 0?GG80<0 <=A< <=8 B7A5CA>< C?0<=AH8:88>?>98@@80<A>9<@8A<C8><64@AD8@54946 <=@88 C4><=0 =8@864@8 <=8 B7A5CA>< 50 8><5<789 64@ B4CD8>0A<54> 46 0'$" !0$" M ' C4><=0# ?>98@<=8=8A9E7400465>B4C89?@5>G7A59?DD8@549F - 11 - 4>0598@5>G <=8 >A<?@8 46 5>I?@580 <=8 B4CD8>0A<54>AJA@989:;<=8@5:?>A7?>98@4<=8@=8A90 50I?0<A>9@8A04>A:78 - =?0 <=8 B7A5CA>< 50 8><5<789 <4 <=8 64774J5>G B4CD8>0A<54>& !"#$%&'($)$*#+ *(#+#$'#&*% !)$'($ ,%- 400466?<?@85>B4C8 . $" 895BA78MD8>080 ,. $" A5>A>90?668@5>G $" 400465>B4C89?@5>G 7A59?DD8@549 '$" 40046AC8>5<580 $" <<8>9A><A>9 <@A>0D4@<A<54>B=A@G80 $" MD8>08064@958<A>9 >4?@50=C8>< $" '&. //0 ><=8@80?7<<=864774J5>G4@98@50DA0089& - 12 - A =8ADD8A765789:;<=8>0?@A>B84CDA>; 50 : =8@400"4:I8B<54>65789:;<=8B7A5CA><50 B =8 I?9GC8>< 46 <=8 7A5C0 @5:?>A7 50 C4956589A064774J0 9 =8 B7A5CA>< 50 8><5<789 <4 A <4<A7 B4CD8>0A<54> 46 % //0 A0 AGA5>0< 0.,- $" AJA@989 :; <=8 @5:?>A7 8 =8 >0?@A>B8 4CDA>; 50 95@8B<89 <4 98D405< <=8 B4CD8>0A<54> AC4?>< A74>G J5<= 5><8@80< 2 -3 DA 6@4C <=8 9A<8 46 6575>G 46 <=8 B7A5C D8<5<54> <577 <=8 9A<8 46 @8A75KA<54> J5<=5> A D8@549 46 05M J88L0 - 13 - 6@4C <=8 9A<8 46 @8B85D< 46 B4D; 46 <=50 I?9GC8>< 6 C4?>< 5> 98D405< 50 <@A>068@@89 <4 <=8 @5:?>A7 1*0 , 21- 1*0 , 3453- 50<4&74& &