Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43073 (KAR)
BHIMANNA v. KALLAPPA AND ANR
RSA/200005/2025 · 2025-09-02
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43073 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43073 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "# #
$%& '
! "
#! $
! %
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! &
'( )! "
#! * + $
*
*
, & %! ! !! ! % * *
&&
*
! *
&,
- 3 -
-!&
"
./0122314/05/436789.31223441:96353:61:9;! 2<18/:=9;039>10/639.3/?2@=:36;<63<61936%! ! 210036/:!!;! % 789.366/9/;:14/09</A91:6 300/;:0 &@6=3 19 /B1812@<1 C.3<3 @:63< 9.3 /:93</? 1224/A19/;:5/436789.31223441:96353:61:9;!@:63< 3A9/;: ;5 9.3 /?/919/;: A9 033D/:= A;:6;:19/;: ;5 63418 /: 2<353<</:= 9.3 122314 .10 733: 6/0?/0036 1:6 A;:03E@3:9489.3122314A1?39;736/0?/0036! ! 31<6 431<:36 A;@:034 5;< 9.3 1223441:9 1:6 431<:36A;@:0345;<<302;:63:9;!! ! : 02/93 ;5 03<F/A3 ;5 :;9/A3 <302;:63:9 ;! <3?1/:361703:91:6@:<32<303:936! ! 302;:63:9 ;! > 241/:9/55 .10 5/436 1 0@/9 /:
!!;!( 1=1/:091223441:96353:61:9;!1:6 <302;:63:9 ;! 6353:61:9 ;! 5;< 9.3 <34/35 ;5 21<9/9/;:1:60321<1932;00300/;:;5./00.1<3/:5;44;C/:= 0@/92<;23<9/30>
- 4 -
! .3 A103 ;5 9.3 <302;:63:9 ;! > 241/:9/55 735;<3 9.3 </14 ;@<9 C10 9.19 0@/9 2<;23<9/30 1<3 1:A309<14 2<;23<9/30 241/:9/55 1:6 6353:61:90 ;! 1:6 .1F30.1<3/:9.30@/92<;23<9/30! (! 302;:63:9;! 6353:61:9;! 5/436C</993: 09193?3:91:6A;@:93<A41/?16?/99/:=9.3A;:93:9/;:;5 241/:9 21<10 ;! 1:6 1:6 0;@=.9 ./0 0.1<3 /: 9.3 0@/9 2<;23<9/30!.31223441:96353:61:9;!6/6:;9A.;;03 9; 5/43 1:8 C</993: 09193?3:9! .3 </14 ;@<9 5<1?36 /00@30 <3A;<636 3F/63:A3 1:6 63A<336 9.3 0@/9 144;99/:= <6 0.1<30 31A. 9; 9.3 21<9/30 /: 9.3 0@/9 0A.36@43 2<;23<9/30! - 5 -
%! ==</3F36 78 9.3 01/6 B@6=?3:9 1:6 63A<33 210036789.3</14;@<99.31223441:96353:61:9;! .10 5/436 1: 122314 /: !!;! % ! 0 9.3<3 C10 1 63418/:5/4/:=9.3122314.35/436!!;!@:63<3A9/;:
;5 9.3 /?/919/;: A9 033D/:= A;:6;:19/;: ;5 63418 ;5 831<0 % ?;:9.0 /: 2<353<</:= 9.3 122314! .3 01/6 1224/A19/;: .10 733: 0@22;<936 78 9.3 155/61F/9 ;5 9.3 1223441:96353:61:9;!!.3<302;:63:909.3<3/:.1F3 5/436 9.3 ;7B3A9/;:0 9; 9.3 01/6 1224/A19/;: 033D/:= A;:6;:19/;: ;5 63418 63:8/:= 9.3 1F3<?3:90 ;5 9.3 1224/A19/;:1:60@22;<9/:=155/61F/9! '! .3*/<0922344193;@<92;09369.3?1993<5;< 3:E@/<8 ;: !!;!! .3 1223441:9 6353:61:9 ;! 6/6 :;9 12231< 5;< 3:E@/<8 1:6 9.3<31593< 9.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 6<;2236 9.3 3:E@/<8! .3 1223441:9 6353:61:9 ;! 6/6 :;9 12231< 5;< .31</:= ;: 1224/A19/;: 033D/:= A;:6;:19/;: ;5 63418 3F3: /: 02/93 ;5 =/F/:= 0@55/A/3:9 ;22;<9@:/98!.35/<09122344193;@<99;;D9.31<=@?3:90 ;: 9.3 1223441:9G0 0/63 10 :/4 1:6 210036 9.3 ;<63<0 ;: !!;!6/0?/00/:=9.301?31:6A;:03E@3:9486/0?/0036 9.3122314! - 6 -
)! 31<:36 A;@:034 5;< 9.3 1223441:9 6353:61:9 ;!C;@46A;:93:69.19/:9.31703:A3;59.312231<1:A3 ;59.3431<:36A;@:0345;<9.31223441:96353:61:9;! 9.3<3?3685;<9.35/<09122344193;@<9C109;6/0?/009.3 122314/:09316;563A/6/:=9.3122314;:?3</90! ! 31<:36A;@:0345;<<302;:63:9;!241/:9/55 C;@46A;:93:69.19/:02/93;5=/F/:=0@55/A/3:9;22;<9@:/98 431<:36A;@:0345;<9.31223441:96353:61:9;!6/6:;9 12231<735;<39.35/<09122344193;@<91:69.3<35;<39.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 .10 210036 9.3 /?2@=:36 ;<63< <3B3A9/:=9.31224/A19/;:5/436033D/:=A;:6;:19/;:;563418 ;: ?3</90! 3 5@<9.3< 0@7?/90 9.19 *
!;! ' % 5/436 78 <302;:63:9 ;! 241/:9/55 .10 733: 6/02;036 ;5 1:6 5/:1463A<33.10733:6<1C:;: !! ! ! ;:0/63</:= 9.3 17;F3 1023A90 9.3 5;44;C/:= 0@7091:9/14E@309/;:;541C1</0305;<A;:0/63<19/;:> ! ! !
" #$$ % &' # ' ' ! # ( ! $$ )
* +',
-'%.%/
- 7 -
! @43%;5 <63<;5
<316010@:63<>
01 23 ! ! '4 ) ! 5!! ! ! & ) ! $$ $$ 5! ! $$ ' ! ) ! % 6
!! $$ 784$1 ! ! 1 ! $5 ! %
! $$ ! 9 23
1 ! ! $$ $$ ! $ $$ )! $$ ! ! 41$ :
! ;:0/63</:= 9.3 17;F3 2<;F/0; 9.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 A1::;9 63A/63 9.3 122314 ;: ?3</90 5;< 6351@49;512231<1:A3;51223441:9! ! : 9.3 A103 ;: .1:6 9.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 .10 63A/636 !!;! 1:6 A;:03E@3:948 6/0?/0036 9.3 122314!31<:36A;@:0345;<1223441:96353:61:9;!/: 9.35/<09122314.10:;912231<361:6.3<3?1/:361703:9 1:69.3;29/;:5;<9.35/<09122344193;@<9C109;6/0?/00 9.3 122314! .3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 :;9 3?2;C3<36 9; 6/0?/009.3122314;:?3</90! - 8 -
! ;:0/63</:= 9.3 01/6 1023A9 9.3 /?2@=:36 ;<63< 210036 78 9.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 <3E@/<30 9; 73 039>10/631:69.3?1993<<3E@/<309;73<3?1:6369;9.3 5/<09122344193;@<99;63A/639.3!!;!1:6122314/:
1AA;<61:A3C/9.41C! (! 0 9.3 1223441:9 /0 :;9 6/4/=3:9 :3/9.3< 735;<3 9.35/<09122344193;@<9:;<735;<39./0;@<9!.3<3/01 63418 140; /: 5/4/:= 9.3 122314 735;<3 9./0 ;@<9 9.3 1223441:9 6353:61:9 ;! 0166436 C/9. A;090 ;5 0! >21817439;<302;:63:9;!241/:9/55!:F/3C ;59.317;F39.35;44;C/:=+
! .3122314/0144;C36! ! .3 /?2@=:36 ;<63< 61936 %! ! 210036 /:
!!;! % 78 9.3 66/9/;:14 /09</A9 1:6 300/;:0&@6=3/B1812@<1/0039>10/63! ! .3?1993</0<3?/99369;9.35/<09122344193;@<99;
6/02;03 ;5 9.3 !!;! 1:6 122314 /: 1AA;<61:A3 C/9.41C! - 9 -
! .3 1223441:9 1:6 <302;:63:90 1<3 6/<3A936 9; 12231< 735;<3 9.3 5/<09 122344193 ;@<9 ;:
!)! C/9.;@91:9/A/219/;:;51:8;@<9:;9/A3! ! .3 1223441:9 6353:61:9 ;! 0.144 12231< 735;<3 9.35/<09122344193;@<9;:9.301/661931:6C/9.;@9 033D/:=1:816B;@<:?3:92<;A336C/9.9.3122314! ! .31223441:96353:61:9;!9;2189.301/6A;090 9;<302;:63:9;!241/:9/55;<632;0/9/:;@<9;:
;<735;<39.301/66193! : F/3C ;5 9.3 6/02;014 ;5 9.3 ?1/: 122314 9.3 23:6/:= !0! /5 1:8 6; :;9 0@<F/F3 5;< A;:0/63<19/;:
.3:A39.381<3140;6/02;036;5! (% $# #&
"
&& /09;!4;! 9D