Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43067 (KAR)
THE MANAGER LEGAL TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., v. SUMITRABAI AND ORS
MFA/202336/2024 · 2025-11-25
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43067 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43067 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%! & '!%! & '!"'# " ! !%%
(#) *+ ! !%%
! !%%
! !%%
*
+
! "
#
$ %&
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
$%
'%
%
$ %( %
$ %#& %
)
$ %*# %
$%
'%
%
+
$ %,# %
$%
'%
%
(
$ , % $%
#
! # +- ("
- 3 -
#,!#"
.*.#.)
,&,$. '
*
+
! "
#
$ %( %
$%
'%
%
$ %#, %
$
- 4 -
%#+ %
)
$ %# %
+
$ %## %
+
#
$ $%
'
%
(
$ %*# %
$%
'
%
,
$ %,# %
$%
'%
%
*
$
- 5 -
, % $%
#
! # ,-! +
$ #" *"
#,!#"
.*.#.)
,&($. '
*
+
#
$ %& %
$%
'%
% /+*(##&
$ %( %
$ %#& %
- 6 -
)
$ %*# %
$%
'%
% /+*(##&
+
$ %,# %
$%
'%
%
! "
#
$ , % $%
# /+*(##,
/+*(#.#
! #-
"
#,!#"
.*.#.) ,&,$. - 7 -
(,),+$
0
'
*
+
#
$ %( %
$%
'%
%
$ %#, %
$ %#+ %
)
$ %# %
+
$ %## %
+
# $ $%
- 8 -
'
%
(
$ %*#
%
$%
'
%
,
$ %,# %
$%
'%
%
! "
#
$ , % $%
# /+*(##,
! #-
"
- 9 -
#,!#"
.*.#.) ,&($. *...$
0
'
0
%
% 1
1
' ! %1
"
2.($.) 34 53678 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: @=8 2.)*($.) 34 53678 9: ;<7 A6@3B@=;492;<@?343=D2>;252,&,$. 3E7F347 2.)$.) 34 53678 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: @=82.,#$.)34536789:;<7A6@3B@=;4@?343=D 2>; 25 2,&($. <747 52>? @CC7@64 @?7 53678 >=87? 7A;32=#,!#"25;<72;2?7<3A674A;#&**!52? - 10 -
4<2?; G;<7 A;0" 973=D @DD?37H78 9: ;<7 A2BB2= I>8DB7=; @=8 @F@?8 8@;78 .*.#.) C@44789: ;<7 883;32=@6
7=32?3H36>8D7@=83I@:@C>?@!52? 4<2?; G;<7 ?39>=@60"
3=A7 ;<7 @CC7@64 @?347 2>; 25 ;<7 4@B7@AA387=;;<2>D<47C@?@;7A6@3BC7;3;32=4F7?753678 @66 ;<7 @CC7@64 @?7 <7@?8 ;2D7;<7? @=8 @ A2BB2= I>8DB7=;34973=DC@4478
@A;4 D3H3=D ?347 ;2 ;<7 5363=D 25 ;<7 @CC7@64 9?3756: 4;@;78 @?7 ;<@; 2= .). @; @92>; +%.. ;<7 87A7@478 3= 2,&($. @?@B@=@=8 @=8 ;<7 87A7@478 3= 2,&,$. 3?>C@;3 F7?7 ;?@H763=D 5?2B 3I@:@C>?
;2 <@?@;@D3 2# 2= @ B2;2?A:A67 97@?3=D 7D2*$*#+)@?@B@=@=8F@4?383=D;<7 B2;2?A:A67 @=8 3?>C@;3 F@4 @ C36632= ?387? 25 ;<7 4@38 B2;2?A:A67@;;<@;;3B72=7A@?97@?3=D 7D2*$ # A@B7 5?2B 3I@:@C>? 4387 C?2A7783=D ;2F@?84 26@C>?8?3H7=9:3;48?3H7?3=H7?:<3D<4C778?@4<@=8 =7D63D7=; B@==7? @=8 8@4<78 ;2 ;<73? B2;2?A:A67 @=8 A@>478;<7@AA387=;>7;2;<7@AA387=;92;<576682F=
- 11 -
2=;<7D?2>=8@=84>4;@3=78D?37H2>43=I>?374@=83?>C@;3 4>AA>B978 ;2 ;<7 3=I>?374 2= ;<7 4C2; 3;4765 <7?7@4 @?@B@=@=8 F@4 4<35;78 ;2 ;<7 34;?3A; <24C3;@6 3I@:@C>?@ F<7?7 <7 4>AA>B978 ;2 ;<7 3=I>?374 2= ;<7 4@B78@:
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
- 12 -
7J@B3=78@4 #@=8553A7?25;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:
F@47J@B3=78@4 @=8D2;B@?E78J #;2 )<7 6@3B4 ?39>=@6 9: ;<7 3BC>D=78 I>8DB7=;
<768 ;<@; ;<7 @AA387=; ;22E C6@A7 2= @AA2>=; 25?@4< @=8 =7D63D7=; 8?3H3=D 25 ;<7 2557=83=D A@? 9: 3;4 8?3H7? @4 @ ?74>6; 25 F<3A< ;<7 87A7@478 4>4;@3=78 3=I>?374 @=8 4>AA>B978;2;<73=I>?374 ( <7 ?39>=@6 <768 ;<@; ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 3= 2,&($. @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 @ A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4(,*...$@62=DF3;<3=;7?74;@;;<7?@;725(KC@ @=8 ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 3= 2,&,$. @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 @ A2BC7=4@;32=25 4#,++,+$@62=DF3;<3=;7?74;@;;<7 ?@;725(KC@@=883?7A;78?74C2=87=;2=4>?@=A7 2BC@=:;287C243;;<7A2BC7=4@;32=@B2>=;@62=DF3;< 3=;7?74;73=D@DD?37H78;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:@=8;<7 A6@3B@=;4<@H753678;<747@CC7@64 ,
7@?=78A2>=47652?;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:<@4 ?@3478;<752662F3=DA2=;7=;32=4%
- 13 -
@" 3?4;6:;<7@AA387=;2AA>??782=.).@;
+%.. 5;7? ;<7 @AA387=; ;<7 2F=7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67C@38;<7C?7B3>B@;#.%#+2=.).<7 C263A: F@4 344>78 ;2 97 7557A;3H7 5?2B B38=3D<; 25 .).- 3; 4;@?;4 5?2B ..%.. <2>?4 2= .). <7?752?7 <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; @4 2= ;<7 8@;7 25 ;<7 @AA387=; ;<7 C263A: F@4 =2; 3= 52?A7 @=8 ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: 34 =2; 63@967 ;2 C@: ;<7 A2BC7=4@;32= <7 ?39>=@6 <@4 7??78 3= 5@4;7=3=D ;<7 63@9363;: 2= ;<7 =4>?@=A72BC@=: 9" = 4>CC2?; 25 <34 A2=;7=;32= <7 ?76378 2= ;<7 I>8DB7=; 25 ;<34 2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 25
3= 2.#(&*$.#, 834C2478252=#).&. A" 7A2=86:7H7=;<2>D<;<7A6@3B@=;4A6@3B;<@;
;<7 87A7@478 @?@B@=@=8 F@4 7@?=3=D 4....$ C7?
B2=;< @=8 ;<7 87A7@478 3?>C@;<3 F@4 @642 7@?=3=D 4....$C7?B2=;<;<74@B734=2;74;@9634<789:;<7 A6@3B@=;4 9: C?28>A3=D 4>CC2?;3=D 82A>B7=;4 <7
- 14 -
?39>=@6<@4@4474478;<73=A2B72592;<;<787A7@478@; 4#),+.$F<3A<342=;<7<3D<7?4387 8"
@4;6: <7 A2=;7=878 ;<@; A2=4387?3=D ;<7 @D7 @=8 @H2A@;32= 25 ;<7 87A7@478 3= 92;< A@474 ;<7 2H7?@66 A2BC7=4@;32= @F@?878 9: ;<7 ?39>=@6 34 2= ;<7 <3D<7? 4387 @=8 ?7L>3?78 ;2 97 ?78>A78 7=A7 <7 42>D<; 52? @662F3=D;<7@CC7@64536789:;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:@=8 834B3443=D;<7@CC7@64536789:;<7A6@3B@=;4 *
7@?=78A2>=476@CC7@?3=D52?;<72F=7?25;<7 2557=83=DA@?<@4A2=;7=878;<@;;<7C?7B3>BF@4C@382= .). @=8 ;<@; ;<7 C263A: A2H7?4 ;<7 H7<3A67 5?2B ..%.. <2>?4 2= .). 3;4765
3=A7 ;<7 @AA387=;
2AA>??78 @; .+%.. 2= .). ;<7 H7<3A67 F@4 A2H7?78 9: ;<7 3=4>?@=A7 C263A: @=8 ;<7?752?7 ;<7 =4>?@=A72BC@=:3463@967;2C@:;<7A2BC7=4@;32= & = 4>CC2?; 25 <34 A2=;7=;32= <7 ?76378 2= ;<7 I>8DB7=; 25 ;<72=0967 C7J2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 ! "#$ % & ' 3=3H36
- 15 -
CC7@6 2+.)$.. 834C2478 25 2= ,.*.#. @=8 3= ;<7 A@47 25 ! "#$
% &
( 3= 2()+#$.. $F 2(.+$..834C2478252=#.#..& #. 7@?=78 A2>=476 52? ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 <@4 ?@3478 ;<752662F3=DA2=;7=;32=4% @" 3?4;6: 3= H37F 25 ;<7 I>8DB7=; 25;<7 2=0967 >C?7B72>?;3=;<7A@4725)*"#$
% +,- # . / 0 1& 7@A< 25 ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 @?7 7=;3;678 52? A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ >=87? ;<7<7@825 G6244 2562H7 @=8 @557A;32= @=8A2=42?;3>B03=92;<;<7A@474 9" @4;6:A2=4387?3=D;<7@D7@=8@H2A@;32=25;<7 87A7@4783=92;<A@474;<72H7?@66A2BC7=4@;32=@F@?878 9:;<7?39>=@6342=;<762F7?43877=A7<7C?@:452? @662F3=D;<7@CC7@64536789:;<7A6@3B@=;4 ## 7@?8 ;<7 67@?=78 A2>=476 52? ;<7 C@?;374 @=8 C7?>478;<7I>8DB7=;@=8@F@?825;<7?39>=@6
- 16 -
# ; 34 =2; 3= 834C>;7 ;<@; 87A7@478 @?@B@=@=8 @=83?>C@;<383783=;<7?2@8;?@553A@AA387=;2AA>??782= .).8>7;2?@4<@=8=7D63D7=;8?3H3=D25;<78?3H7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67 37 ?;3D@ A@? 97@?3=D 7D2 *$# = ;<747 @CC7@64 ;<7 2=6: 344>7 ;2 97 A2=4387?78 34 F<7;<7? 63@9363;: 4<2>68 97 5@4;7=78 2= ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: 2? 2= ;<7 2F=7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67 ; 34 @642 =2; 3= 834C>;7 ;<@; ;<7 2F=7? C@38 ;<7 C?7B3>B 52? ;<7 3=4>?@=A7 C263A: @; #.%#+ 2= .). <7 @AA387=; 2AA>??78 @; .+%.. 2= .). <7?7 F@4 =2 3=4>?@=A7 C263A: 52? ;<7 C?7H32>4 :7@? 3=A7 ;<7 @B2>=; F@4 C@38 @; #.%#+ ;<7 C263A: F@4 344>78 ;2 A2H7? ;<7 C7?328 97D3==3=D @;
..%..<2>?42=.).<>4;<7C263A:838=2;A2H7? ;<7@AA387=;;<@;2AA>??782=.).@;+%..
<34 2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 25 !4>C?@" 52662F3=D ;<7 I>8DB7=; 25 ;<7 2=0967 C7J 2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 25
!"#$ $% &#$
- 17 -
'' #"())*'2947?H78;<@;3=2?87?;2 A>?9;<34F3874C?7@8B34A<37525D7;;3=D3=4>?@=A7C263A374 @5;7? @AA387=;4 3; 34 @9426>;76: 3BC7?@;3H7 ;2 A67@?6: <268 ;<@; 7557A;3H7=744 25 3=4>?@=A7 C263A: F2>68 4;@?; 5?2B ;3B7 @=8 8@;7 4C7A353A@66: 3=A2?C2?@;78 3= C263A: @=8 =2; 5?2B@=7@?637?C23=;25;3B7 # = ;<7 A@474 2= <@=8 ;<7 C263A: 34 @CC63A@967 5?2B ..%.. <2>?4 2= .). <7 @AA387=; 2AA>??78 2=.).@;+%..<7?752?7;<7H7<3A67F@4=2;
A2H7?78 9: ;<7 3=4>?@=A7 C263A: 2= ;<7 8@;7 25 ;<7 @AA387=; H7= ;<7 I>8DB7=; ?76378 >C2= 9: ;<7 67@?=78 A2>=476 52? ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67 34 =2; <76C5>6 ;2 ;<7 2F=7? 25 ;<7 H7<3A67 = 5@A; ;<7 2=0967 C7J 2>?; 3= 3H36 CC7@6 2+.)$.. <768 ;<@; ;<7 A<7L>7 52? ;<7 C?7B3>B@B2>=;F@4?7A73H789:;<7A2BC@=:9752?7;<7 @AA387=; F@4 2AA>??78 = 2()+#$.. $F 2(.+$.. ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: <@4 =2;
- 18 -
74;@9634<78 ;<7 C?7B3>B F@4 C@38 4>947L>7=; ;2 ;<7 @AA387=;
#) = ;<7 C?747=; A@47 ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: <@474;@9634<78;<@;;<7C?7B3>B52?;<73=4>?@=A7C263A:
F@4 C@38 @; #.%#+ 2= .). F<7?7@4 ;<7 @AA387=;2AA>??782=.).@;@92>;+%.. 3=A7 ;<7C263A:F@4=2;3=52?A7@;;<7;3B725;<7@AA387=;;<7 =4>?@=A72BC@=:34=2;63@967;2C@:A2BC7=4@;32=2 ;<@;7J;7=;;<753=83=D25;<7?39>=@63447;@4387 %! =2,&($.% #+ <7 ?39>=@6 <@4 ?3D<;6: @4474478 ;<7 =2;32=@6 3=A2B7 25 ;<7 87A7@478@?@B@=@=8 @; 4#),+.$ C7? B2=;<2;<7@52?74@383=A2B743=A7<7F@4@D78@92>; )#:7@?4@=8F@447657BC62:78+K<@4;297@88782= @AA2>=;255>;>?7C?24C7A;43=H37F25;<76@F6@3882F=9:
;<72=4;3;>;32=7=A<25;<7
>C?7B72>?;3=2! "#$ 34%!!, 54(! - 19 -
/".(661&7<>4;<7B2=;<6:3=A2B7A2B74 ;2 4#*)*$ #(
3=A7 ;<7?7 @?7 ., 87C7=87=;4 #$+;< 25 ;<7 3=A2B7 34 ;2 97 878>A;78 ;2F@?84 <34 C7?42=@6 7JC7=474 @=8?7B@3=3=D@B2>=;<@4;297;@E7=@4<34A2=;?39>;32= ;2;<75@B36:<787A7@478F@4@D78@92>;)#:7@?4@;
;<7 ;3B7 25 ;<7 @AA387=; @=8 B>6;3C637? @CC63A@967 ;2 <34 @D7 D?2>C 34 G#)0 <>4 ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4),*.(,$ ! 4#*)*M#M#)M)$+" 2=@AA2>=;25G62442587C7=87=A:0 #, = @883;32= ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32=25 4#(+..$2=@AA2>=;25G62442574;@;70 @=8 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4#(+..$ 2= @AA2>=; 25 G5>=7?@6 7JC7=4740 #* = H37F 25 ;<7 6@F 6@38 82F= 9: ;<7
>C?7B7 2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 25 2) * "#$
% &7 !4>C?@" A6@3B@=; 2# F357 34 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244 25
- 20 -
4C2>4@6A2=42?;3>B06@3B@=;24;2+A<368?7=25;<7 87A7@478 @?7 7=;3;678 52? A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ 7@A< >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244 25 C@?7=;@6 A2=42?;3>B0 @=8 A6@3B@=;24(@=8,C@?7=;425;<787A7@478@?77=;3;678 52?
A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ 7@A< >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244255363@6A2=42?;3>B0 #& <>4;<7A6@3B@=;4@?77=;3;678;2;<752662F3=D A2BC7=4@;32=% ,-./0123/4/5.6 53.6./2.150 ,4/23/ (0)
2442587C7=87=A: ),*.(, >=7?@67JC7=474 #(+.. 2442574;@;7 #(+.. 244254C2>4@6 A2=42?;3>B ))... 24425C@?7=;@6 A2=42?;3>B #,(... 244255363@6A2=42?;3>B **... 217
$8$
- 21 -
=2,&,$.% . <7 ?39>=@6 <@4 ?3D<;6: @4474478 ;<7 =2;32=@6 3=A2B7 25 ;<7 87A7@4783?>C@;<3 @; 4#),+.$ C7? B2=;<2;<7@52?74@383=A2B743=A7<7F@4@D78@92>; +:7@?4@=8F@447657BC62:78#.K<@4;297@88782= @AA2>=;255>;>?7C?24C7A;43=H37F25;<76@F6@3882F=9:
;<7 2=4;3;>;32= 7=A< 25 ;<7
>C?7B7 2>?; 3= 54 (! !4>C?@" <>4 ;<7 B2=;<6: 3=A2B7 A2B74 ;2 4#(+$ #
3=A7 ;<7?7 @?7 .+ 87C7=87=;4 #$);< 25 ;<7 3=A2B7 34 ;2 97 878>A;78 ;2F@?84 <34 C7?42=@6 7JC7=474 @=8?7B@3=3=D@B2>=;<@4;297;@E7=@4<34A2=;?39>;32= ;2;<75@B36:<787A7@478F@4@D78@92>;+:7@?4@;
;<7 ;3B7 25 ;<7 @AA387=; @=8 B>6;3C637? @CC63A@967 ;2 <34 @D7 D?2>C 34 G##0 <>4 ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4#(.(,+$ ! 4#(+M#M##M$)" 2=@AA2>=;25G62442587C7=87=A:0 = @883;32= ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 @?7 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32=25 4#(+..$2=@AA2>=;25G62442574;@;70
- 22 -
@=8 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4#(+..$ 2= @AA2>=; 25 G5>=7?@6 7JC7=4740 = H37F 25 ;<7 6@F 6@38 82F= 9: ;<7
>C?7B7 2>?; 3= ;<7 A@47 25 2) * "#$
% &7 !4>C?@" A6@3B@=; 2# F357 34 7=;3;678 ;2 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244 25 4C2>4@6 A2=42?;3>B0 6@3B@=; 24 @=8 A<368?7= 25 ;<787A7@478@?77=;3;67852?A2BC7=4@;32=25 4))...$ 7@A< >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244 25 C@?7=;@6 A2=42?;3>B0 @=8 A6@3B@=;24)@=8+C@?7=;425;<787A7@478@?77=;3;678 52? A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4))...$ 7@A< >=87? ;<7 <7@8 25 G6244255363@6A2=42?;3>B0
) <>4;<7A6@3B@=;4@?77=;3;678;2;<752662F3=D A2BC7=4@;32=% ,-./0123/4/5.6 53.6./2.150 ,4/23/ (0)
2442587C7=87=A: #(.(,+ >=7?@67JC7=474 #(+.. 2442574;@;7 #(+.. - 23 -
244254C2>4@6 A2=42?;3>B ))... 24425C@?7=;@6 A2=42?;3>B **... 244255363@6A2=42?;3>B **... 217 $8$
+ =;<7?74>6;;<752662F3=D2?87?34C@4478%
@" <7 @CC7@6 53678 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=:3=2.($.)@=8 2.)$.)@?7@662F78 9" <7 @CC7@6 53678 9: ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 3=
2.)*($.) @=8
2.,#$.)@?7@662F783=C@?;
A" <7I>8DB7=;25;<76@3B4?39>=@634 B2835378 8" <7A6@3B@=;43=2,&($.@?7 7=;3;678 ;2 @ ;2;@6 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4*#&.(,$ @4 @D@3=4; 4(,*...$ @F@?878 9: ;<7 ?39>=@6
- 24 -
7" <7A6@3B@=;43=2,&,$.@?7 7=;3;678 ;2 @ ;2;@6 A2BC7=4@;32= 25 4#*+&,+$ @4 @D@3=4; 4#,++,+$ @F@?878 9: ;<7 ?39>=@6 5" <7 2F=7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67 34 83?7A;78 ;2 87C243; ;<7 A2BC7=4@;32= @B2>=;@62=DF3;<3=;7?74;@;(KC@ 5?2B ;<7 8@;7 25 5363=D 25 ;<7 A6@3B C7;3;32= ;366 ;<7 8@;7 25 ?7@63N@;32= 3= 92;< ;<7 A@474 F3;<3= @ C7?328 25 43J F77E45?2B;<78@;725?7A73C;25A2C: 25;<34I>8DB7=;
D" <7 @CC2?;32=B7=; 87C243; @=8 ?767@47 25 @B2>=; 4<@66 97 B@87 3= ;7?B425;<7@F@?825;<7?39>=@6 <" B2>=;35@=:87C243;789:;<72F=7? 25 ;<7 2557=83=D H7<3A67 34 83?7A;78 ;2 97;?@=4B3;;78;2;<7?39>=@6 3" B2>=; 87C243;78 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=: 73;<7? 9752?7 ;<34 2>?; 2?
9752?7 ;<7 ?39>=@6 34 83?7A;78 ;2 97 ?75>=878;2;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:
- 25 -
I" 5 ;<7 A6@3B@=;4 <@H7 F3;<8?@F= ;<7 @B2>=; 87C243;78 9: ;<7 =4>?@=A7 2BC@=:;<7=4>?@=A72BC@=:34@;
6397?;: ;2 ?7A2H7? ;<7 4@B7 5?2B ;<7 2F=7?25;<72557=83=DH7<3A67
!5* (%!) '
!5* ("'# ") '
34;2%#
62%+